Khail v RTA Gove Pty Ltd & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

CITATION:Khail v RTA Gove Pty Ltd & Anor [2024] NTSC 9

PARTIES:KHAIL, Sayed

v

RTA GOVE PTY LTD

(ACN 000 453 663)

and

CONTITECH AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ABN 97 000 468 780)

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION: IN THE MATTER of an appeal under Section 116 of the Return to Work Act

FILE NO:2023-01466-SC

DELIVERED:  5 March 2024

HEARING DATES:  26 & 27 September 2023

JUDGMENT OF:  Kelly J

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL – Section 116 of the Return to Work Act – appeal against decision of the Work Health Court – appeal on questions of law

Whether the trial judge erred in determining that the appellant was not suffering any loss of earning capacity at the time of the cancellation notice –insufficient findings on the extent of the appellant’s incapacity to work amounted to an error of law – matter remitted to the trial judge

Whether s 69 notice can be relied on by an employer to deny liability for a previously accepted injury – whether s 69 notice can only be used to cancel or reduce benefits because of a change in circumstances – trial judge erred in limiting the application of s 69 notice – s 69 can be used for any lawful reason to cancel payments – invalid s 69 notice – employer entitled to commence proceedings for a declaration that the worker does not suffer from a compensable injury regardless of whether notice under s 69 has been validly given – cross-appeal allowed

Whether the finding that the appellant did not suffer a compensable mental injury was vitiated by errors of law – whether the appellant was denied procedural fairness – trial judge did not err in applying the onus of proof – judge is entitled to take into account matters on which she has formed the view that a witness has lied when assessing whether to believe other parts of the witness’s evidence – grounds 4, 5 and 6 of appeal are dismissed.

Return to Work Act 1986 (NT), s 65, s 65(2), s 65(2)(a), s 65(2)(b)(i), s 65(2)(b)(ii), s 69, s 69(1), s 69(1)(b)(i), s 69(2), s 69(2)(D), s 85(3), s 89, s 116, s 116(1), Subdivision B of Division 3 of Part 5

Alexander v Gorey & Cole Holdings Pty Ltd (2002) 117 FLR 31; Australian Gas Light Company v Valuer-General (1940) 40 SR (NSW) 126; Azzopardi v Tasman UEB Industries Ltd (1985) 4 NSWLR 139; Carlsen v AAT Kings Tours Pty Ltd 8 NTLR 114; Disability Services of Central Australia v Regan (1998) 8 NTLR 73; Edwards v R (1993) 178 CLR 193; Gauci v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1975) 135 CLR 81; Hardy v Your Tabs Pty Ltd [2000] NSWCA 150; Lee v MacMahon Contractors Pty Ltd (2018) 41 NTLR 168; Millar v ABC Marketing and Sales Pty Ltd [2012] NTSC 21; Morrissey v Conaust Ltd (1991) 1 NTLR 183; Northern Territory of Australia v Noaks

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Khail v RTA Gove Pty Ltd & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NTSC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Khail v RTA Gove Pty Ltd & Anor, the appellant, Mr Khail, an individual who had a traumatic past including fleeing his war-torn home country of Afghanistan, appealed against decisions of the Work Health Court. The court had delivered reasons on 31 March 2023 concerning matters stemming from decisions made on 14 and 18 November 2022. Mr Khail's appeal was pursuant to s 116 of the Return to Work Act 1986 (NT). The appellant had been employed by the second respondent, Contitech, which had a contract with the first respondent, RTA, to provide belt splicing services at the Gove mine site. The appellant suffered a back injury on 5 September 2019, while working for Contitech, and was subsequently flown to Mackay to undertake light duties. He alleged that he was subjected to inappropriate behaviour by his supervisor on 19 November 2019, which he claimed caused a mental injury, and he has not worked since that date. RTA served a notice to cancel Mr Khail's benefits pursuant to s 69 of the Act on 22 May 2020, followed by a similar notice from Contitech on 22 July 2020.

The court was tasked with determining a number of legal issues, including whether the s 69 notices served by RTA and Contitech were valid, whether Mr Khail's back injury continued to cause an incapacity to work, if his back injury led to an adjustment disorder or PTSD, and whether the psychological sequelae arising from the back injury resulted in Mr Khail being totally incapacitated for work. The court also had to consider whether the incident on 19 November 2019 caused Mr Khail's PTSD or aggravated his pre-existing PTSD, and if Mr Khail continued to be incapacitated for work, what his most profitable employment was and whether he had a limited or any ability to earn. The trial judge found that the s 69 notice served by RTA was valid, but the notice from Contitech did not comply with the requirements of s 69 and was not valid as a notice to cancel benefits. The court also found that Mr Khail was not totally incapacitated for work and had the ability to work full time as a car park attendant. The court was not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that Mr Khail suffered an adjustment disorder arising from his physical injury or that the psychological sequelae arising from the back injury resulted in him continuing to be totally incapacitated for work. Given the unfavourable findings in relation to Mr Khail's credit, the court could not be satisfied on the balance of probabilities that he was truthful in his report of his symptoms of mental health and back pain, or that he continued to suffer PTSD as a result of the work incident on 19 November 2019.

Ultimately, the Work Health Court dismissed Mr Khail's claims for declarations, arrears and continuing benefits, and s 89 interest, and made various declarations in relation to the respondents' counterclaims. The court found that Mr Khail did not suffer any loss of earning capacity and his claim against RTA must fail. The court also certified the matter as fit for senior counsel. In summary, the appeal was dismissed and the findings of the Work Health Court were upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal pursuant to s 116 of the Return to Work Act 1986 (NT) (“the Act”) against decisions of the Work Health Court made on 14 and 18 November 2022 with reasons delivered on 31 March 2023.Background These background facts are taken from the judgment of the Work Health Court. Mr Khail (“the appellant”) was born in war-torn Afghanistan and among other traumas, he saw his father’s body after he was shot by the Taliban in front of his house. The appellant fled that country when he was 17 years old, travelling through Pakistan, Malaysia and Indonesia, and finally making his way to Australia, by boat. It took him three attempts by boat from Indonesia before he was successful in reaching Australia. He was detained at the Christmas Island, Port Hedland and the Baxter detention centres over a period of four years. He obtained his release in Perth and immediately commenced employment. Before his back injury the appellant had worked as a belt splicer and rubber technician working on industrial conveyor belts mainly in the mining industry, obtaining work mostly through labour hire companies. Leading up to his present claim, the appellant has had other claims arising out of work injuries and an assault in 2014. From 2014 to the present day, the appellant has consulted with many doctors and psychologists with varying opinions and treatment regimens for his physical injury and mental health condition. Relevant to this proceeding, the appellant suffered an injury to his back on 5 September 2019 while in the employment of the second respondent (“Contitech”). At the time of the injury, Contitech had contracted with the first respondent (“RTA”) to provide belt splicing services at the Gove mine site. The back injury occurred when the appellant and a co-worker were pulling 80-100 kilos of rubber belt off the back of a ute, and the appellant felt a sharp pain to the left hand side of his back which radiated down through his buttocks and left leg. His claim for compensation for that back injury was accepted by RTA. After his back injury, the appellant was flown to Mackay to undertake light duties in the office of Contitech and to be closer to services for treatment on his back. On 19 November 2019 while undertaking light duties at the Mackay office, the appellant was subjected to inappropriate behaviour by his supervisor which he claims caused him a mental injury and he has not worked since that date. The appellant’s claim for mental injury was originally accepted by Contitech with the proviso that they were accepting a claim for an aggravation of the appellant’s post-traumatic stress disorder (“PTSD”) but not his pre-existing PTSD nor for any psychological sequelae, for example adjustment disorder, or depression and anxiety, arising out of the original back injury. On 22 May 2020 RTA served on the appellant a notice pursuant to s 69 of the Act cancelling his benefits. That notice was supported by a certificate of Dr Frederick Phillips. Dr Phillips certified that the appellant was no longer incapacitated for work arising out of his back injury. That notice was followed by a letter and a s 69 notice from Contitech on 22 July 2020 cancelling the appellant’s benefits attributable to his psychiatric claim.Proceedings in the Work Health Court

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The trial judge identified the following issues raised for determination on the pleadings in the Work Health Court.(a)Is the s 69 notice served by RTA valid and effective?(b)Is the notice served by Contitech valid and effective?(c)Does the appellant’s back injury continue to cause an incapacity to work?(d)Did the appellant’s back injury lead to an adjustment disorder or PTSD?(e)Do the psychological sequelae arising from the back injury result in the appellant continuing to be totally incapacitated for work?(f)Did the incident on 19 November 2019 cause the appellant’s PTSD or aggravate his pre-existing PTSD?(g)If the appellant continues to be incapacitated for work what is his most profitable employment and does he have a limited or any ability to earn?Decision of the Work Health Court The trial judge found:(a)The s 69 notice served by RTA was valid.[1](b)The notice from Contitech to the appellant does not comply with the requirements of s 69 and is not valid as a notice to cancel benefits.[2](c)In relation to the physical injury, the appellant is not totally incapacitated for work and has the ability to work full time as a car park attendant.[3](d)The Court was not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the appellant suffered an adjustment disorder arising from his physical injury.[4](e)The psychological sequelae arising from the back injury did not result in the appellant continuing to be totally incapacitated for work.(f)In circumstances where the Court had made an unfavourable finding in relation to the appellant’s credit, the Court could not be satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the appellant was being truthful in his report of his symptoms of mental health and back pain; or that he continued to suffer PTSD as a result of the work incident on 19 November 2019; or that he suffered a reoccurrence or aggravation of a pre-existing PTSD at all.(g)Accepting RTA’s calculation of the worker’s normal weekly earnings (“NWE”) and the evidence of the weekly income from the identified job of a car park attendant, the appellant does not suffer any loss of earning capacity and his claim against RTA must fail (subject to any finding of a psychological injury arising out of the events of 19 November 2019).[5] The Work Health Court made the following orders:1.The appellant’s application for orders contained in 26.1 and 26.2 of his Further Amended Statement of claim is dismissed. (These were claims for declarations that the appellant suffered a compensable mental injury – either Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder[6] or Adjustment Disorder with mixed Anxiety and Depression.[7])2.The appellant’s application for declarations in 26.3.1 and 26.3.2 is dismissed. (These were claims for declarations that, as at the date of the 25 May 2020 notice of decision,[8] the appellant had not ceased to be incapacitated by the original injury and/ or the adjustment disorder;[9] and that, at the date of the 10 July 2020 notice of decision,[10] the appellant had not ceased to be incapacitated by the PTSD injury.[11])3.The appellant’s application for arrears and continuing benefits pursuant to s 65 is dismissed.4.The appellant’s application for s 89 interest is dismissed.5.A declaration on RTA’s counterclaim that there are no compensable psychological sequelae.6.Contitech’s counterclaim 35(b) is dismissed. (This was an application for a declaration that Contitech had validly disputed any further liability for the PTSD mental injury claim by the s 69 Notice on 10 July 2020.)7.Contitech’s counterclaim in paragraphs 35(a) and 35(c) is granted. (These were claims for a declaration that the appellant did not suffer a compensable mental injury from his employment with Contitech in November 2019, and a declaration that the appellant is not entitled to any or any further compensation with respect to the mental injury claim.)8.The matter is certified fit for senior counsel.The appeal

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.