Alexander v Gorey & Cole Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

Alexander v Gorey [2002] NTCA 7

PARTIES:RICHARD ALEXANDER

v

GOREY & COLE HOLDINGS PTY LTD

TITLE OF COURT:  COURT OF APPEAL OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  CIVIL APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT EXERCISING TERRITORY JURISDICTION

FILE NO:AP10 2001

DELIVERED:  2 October 2002

HEARING DATES:  19 March & 17 August 2002

JUDGMENT OF:  MARTIN CJ, MILDREN & BAILEY JJ

CATCHWORDS:

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant:JB Waters QC

Respondent:  PM Barr

Solicitors:

Appellant:Caroline Scicluna

Respondent:  Hunt & Hunt

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:  

Number of pages:  18

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Alexander v Gorey [2002] NTCA 7

No. AP10 of 2001

BETWEEN:

RICHARD ALEXANDER

Appellant

AND:

GOREY & COLE HOLDINGS PTY LTD

Respondent

CORAM:    MARTIN CJ, MILDREN & BAILEY JJ

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 2 October 2002)

THE COURT:

  1. The appellant commenced employment with the respondent in July 1993.  He was employed as a driller's offsider.  In August 1993, the appellant sustained an injury to his lower back whilst in the course of his employment with the respondent.  The appellant made a claim for compensation in accordance with the provisions of the Work Health Act (the Act) in September 1993.  The appellant's claim was accepted by the respondent and the appellant was paid compensation on the basis that he was totally unfit for any employment.

  2. On 6 May 1997, the appellant recommenced employment with the respondent under a workplace based return to work program established pursuant to s 75B of the Act.  On 27 May 1997, the appellant advised the respondent's representative that he would not continue with that program.  On the same day, the employer's insurer served on the appellant a Form 5 Notice in purported compliance with s 69(1)(a) of the Act, cancelling the appellant's weekly benefits on the basis that the appellant was no longer totally incapacitated for work as the result of his injury, and on the further basis that the appellant had unreasonably failed to participate in the work based return to work program which would have enabled him to return to fulltime duties.

  3. Thereafter, the appellant commenced proceedings in the Work Health Court (proceeding No 9714757) appealing the respondent's decision to cancel his benefit.  The respondent filed an answer to the worker's appeal as well as a "cross–application" in which the respondent sought an order that the appellant ceased to be totally incapacitated for work since at least May 1996, a declaration that the service of the Form 5 Notice "was a valid cessation of weekly payments" and an order to the effect that the appellant ceased to be entitled to payments of compensation "at least at the time of service of the Form 5 Notice dated 27 May 1997". 

  4. On 19 April 1999, the appellant's application was amended but did not raise any new issues.  On 2 June 1998, the respondent filed an amended answer and an amended cross–application.  In the amended answer and proposed amended cross–application, the respondent sought to raise the failure of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alexander v Gorey & Cole Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] NTCA 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Alexander, has appealed a decision made by the learned Magistrate in proceeding 9916566, which involved the cancellation of weekly compensation payments by the respondent, Gorey & Cole Holdings Pty Ltd. The dispute centred on whether the order cancelling the payments could relate back to a time earlier than the date of the judgment. The appellant argued that the order did not, in its terms, relate back to a time prior to the date of the judgment. The respondent did not provide a notice of contention, and the learned Magistrate did not discuss this issue in her reasons for judgment.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether an order cancelling workers' compensation payments could have effect from a time earlier than the date of the order. The court considered the provisions of the statutory scheme, which provided for workers' compensation entitlements, and whether these provisions allowed for retrospective orders. The appellant's counsel contended that the Act required any order cancelling payments to be effective only from the date of the order or the date of the hearing. The respondent argued that the order could relate back to the time when the entitlement to weekly compensation ceased, as determined by the court.

The court examined the statutory framework and previous case law, noting that courts often make orders that have effect from a time earlier than the date of judgment. However, the appellant argued that the specific provisions of the Act in question limited the court's ability to make retrospective orders. The court concluded that the order could indeed relate back to the time when the court was satisfied that the entitlement to weekly compensation ceased, as long as the order was made within the scope of the statutory scheme. The court found that the decision of Riley J, who held that the worker's appeal should not have been dismissed, was correct in this respect.

The court thus upheld the respondent's right to cancel the payments of compensation, allowing the order to relate back to the time when the entitlement to weekly compensation ceased. This decision aligns with the statutory scheme and the authority of previous case law, ensuring that the retrospective effect of the order is valid within the confines of the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant has appealed to this Court on a number of grounds, not all of which were pursued on the hearing of the appeal. We note for the record that no notice of contention was given by the respondent.Did the order of the learned Magistrate in proceeding 9916566 relate back to a time earlier than the date of judgment? The contention of the appellant was that the order (which had not been taken out) was not, in its terms, an order that related back to a time earlier than the date of judgment. Notwithstanding the spirited argument of counsel for the apellant, the question of whether or not this was a possible outcome was plainly raised by the appellant's pleading in paragraph 15 of the Answer. There is no discussion of this issue by the learned Magistrate in her reasons for judgments. That is not surprising given her Worship's decision in proceeding 9714757. The effect of the latter decision was that the respondent was entitled to cancel the worker's weekly payments following due service of the Form 5 Notice and it was not in contention that the respondent had paid compensation during the fourteen day period following the service of the Notice, as required by s 69(1)(a) of the Act. Riley J drew the inference that, because her Worship found that the compensation payable was nil, her Worship must have found that the respondent was entitled to cancel payments of compensation at the stage that compensation was in fact cancelled. However, the finding that the compensation payable was nil was inevitable given the finding she made in proceeding 9714757. We consider that it would have been erroneous to conclude that that is what her Worship intended. Clearly her order did not address the point because it was unnecessary for her to do so. Nevertheless, the matter was addressed by Riley J in the light of his Honour's decision that the worker's appeal should not have been dismissed. His Honour found that such an order can relate back to the date when the Court is satisfied that the entitlement to weekly compensation ceased. It is necessary to see if his Honour was right in the conclusion he reached that the order could relate back in time.Can an order cancelling payments relate back to a time earlier than the date of the order? This may seem to be a strange question to be asked. It is usual for courts to decide questions by reference to a state of facts existing well before the date of any order consequential upon a contested hearing. It is not unusual for courts to make orders having effect from a time earlier than the date of judgment, or even earlier than the date of commencement of proceedings and relating back to the day following the date of the injury: see for example, the discussion in Works Social Club – Katherine Inc. v Rozycki (1998) 143 FLR 224 at 227. However, in this case, the appellant relies upon the provisions of the statutory scheme providing for workers' entitlements to compensation. Mr Waters QC, for the appellant, submitted that on the true construction of the Act, an order cancelling payments could only be made effective from the date of the order, or the date of the hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.