Key Logic Pty Ltd v Blue Groper Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Key Logic Pty Ltd v Blue Groper Investments Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 63

File number(s): QUD 605 of 2016
Judge(s): DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 7 February 2019
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – misleading and deceptive conduct – form of comparative advertising – misleading statements about competitor’s product – injunctions, declarations and corrective action ordered

COPYRIGHT – unauthorised use of photographs in comparative advertising – photographs given by one respondent to another for such use – personal liability of company directors for breach by company – authorisation of infringement by one respondent of another

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2, Australian Consumer Law ss 18, 29(1)(a), 29(1)(g), 232, 247

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 36, 36(1A), 115(2), 115(3)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 21, 37M, 37N

Cases cited:

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564

Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd v Tolbush Pty Ltd [1986] 2 Qd R 146

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v GO Drew Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 1246

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Online Dealz Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 732

Bailey v Broadsword Marine Contractors Pty Ltd (2017) 353 ALR 45

Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67

Comité Interprofessionel du Vin de Champagne v Powell (2015) 330 ALR 67

Flexopack SA Plastics Industry v Flexopack Australia Pty Ltd (2016) 118 IPR 239

Forster v Jododex Australia Pty Ltd (1972) 127 CLR 421

Insight Radiology Pty Ltd v Insight Clinical Imaging Pty Ltd (2016) 122 IPR 232

Keller v LED Technologies Pty Ltd (2010) 185 FCR 449

RAIA Insurance Brokers Ltd v FAI General Insurance Co Ltd (1993) 41 FCR 164

REA Group Ltd v Fairfax Media Ltd [2017] FCA 91

Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Ltd (2012) 248 CLR 42

Stefanovski v Digital Central Australia (Assets) Pty Ltd [2018] FCAFC 31

Truong Giang Corp v Quach (2015) 114 IPR 498

University of New South Wales v Moorhouse (1975) 133 CLR 1

Date of hearing: 30 & 31 July 2018
Date of last submissions: 1 August 2018
Registry: Queensland
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Copyright and Industrial Designs
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 167
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr P Travis
Solicitor for the Applicants: Bennett & Philp
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr BJ McEniery
Solicitor for the Respondents: Plastiras Lawyers

ORDERS

QUD 605 of 2016
BETWEEN:

KEY LOGIC PTY LTD ACN 099 244 078

First Applicant

KEY WHOLESALERS PTY LTD ACN 106 776 130

Second Applicant

AND:

BLUE GROPER INVESTMENTS PTY LTD ACN 083 191 548

First Respondent

KYM JOHN BIDE SCUTTER

Second Respondent

IAN REGINALD FRY (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

DERRINGTON J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 FEBRUARY 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.On or before 14 February 2019 the applicants file and serve:

(a)short minutes of the orders which they claim should be made in light of the reasons published today; and

(b)related submissions of not more than five pages in support…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Key Logic Pty Ltd v Blue Groper Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Key Logic Pty Ltd v Blue Groper Investments Pty Ltd, the primary issue before the court was whether the respondents, Blue Groper Investments Pty Ltd and Mr Scutter, engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) by distributing a document that contained inaccurate comparisons between their solar bollard products and those of the applicants. The court also considered whether the respondents had infringed copyright by using photographs in their comparative advertising without authorisation.

The legal issues included whether the Evaluation Document, which compared the Sun Wizard product with the applicants’ solar bollards, constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under s 18 of the ACL. Furthermore, the court had to determine if there was an unauthorised use of photographs in the Evaluation Document, which would constitute a breach of copyright under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), and whether the directors of the respondent companies were personally liable for the company’s actions.

The court found that the Evaluation Document contained misleading statements that compared the respondents’ solar bollard with an outdated version of the applicants’ bollard, thereby engaging in misleading or deceptive conduct. The document was circulated to potential customers, thereby impacting trade and commerce. The court held that the respondents were liable for the misleading conduct and ordered them to provide injunctions, declarations, and corrective actions. Additionally, the court ruled that the use of photographs in the Evaluation Document constituted an unauthorised use of copyrighted material, and the directors were held personally liable for the breach of copyright by their companies.

The final orders included the requirement for the applicants to file and serve their proposed orders by a specified date, with an opportunity for the respondents to respond. If the parties could not reach an agreement, the matter was to be listed for a further hearing. Costs were reserved for later determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On or before 14 February 2019 the applicants file and serve:

(a) short minutes of the orders which they claim should be made in light of the reasons published today; and

(b) related submissions of not more than five pages in support of the proposed orders.

2. In default of the respondents signifying their agreement to the proposed minutes of orders by signing a consent order:

(a) on or before 21 February 2019 the respondents file and serve:

(i) short minutes of the orders which they claim should be made in light of the reasons published today; and

(ii) related submissions of not more than five pages in support of the proposed orders.

(b) the proceedings be listed for a further hearing on 27 February 2019 at 9:30am.

3. Costs reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The action has had a somewhat tortured history during its interlocutory phases. It appears that underlying acrimony between the parties and business competition has meant that neither sought to engage in this matter in a way which was consistent with ss 37M and 37N of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). It was only shortly prior to and during the trial that the parties, now represented by Counsel, were prepared to make appropriate concessions.BACKGROUND AND CLAIMSBackground facts Key Wholesalers trades under the name “Solar Bollard Lighting”, and operates an established business of designing, manufacturing and distributing solar bollard products for outdoor lighting. Its market is both domestic and international. In the years since 2005, Key Wholesalers, and another company Exlites Pty Ltd (Exlites), have sold various iterations of the applicants’ solar bollard lighting towers. The product consists of a solar powered light mounted on a fabricated steel tower. The towers were of various heights, although those which were most regularly referred to in this matter were about one metre tall. From December 2005, Key Wholesalers and Exlites at various times designed, manufactured and sold several versions of their solar bollard light. From 2005 it was the “Gen 1” bollards. Since mid-2012, it was the “EXSB (first model) 2012” (Model 1), from 2013, the “XSB upgrade (second model) 2013” (Model 2) and, from 2014, the “SBL series (third model) 2014” (Model 3). It is to be noted that Exlites was placed into administration on 15 November 2013 and sometime prior to that it had ceased its involvement in the business. Mr Fry, who is now a director and shareholder of Karmic, had been engaged by Exlites in around late 2009. He accepted the offer of Mr Arieni, who has variously been a director of each of the applicant companies and Exlites, to join Exlites for the purpose of overseeing the physical production of the solar lighting bollard tower product which Exlites had been developing. In January 2010, he was appointed as a director of Exlites and assumed the role of managing production, assembly and logistics for its business. During the course of his employment and directorship of Exlites, Mr Fry worked mainly on the solar bollard towers, but familiarised himself with all aspects of Exlites’ solar lighting systems in order to streamline and improve the assembly process. During the early years of his directorship Exlites produced the Model 1 version of the bollard. In or around 2012, Mr Fry and Mr Arieni, who at the time were both directors of Exlites, passed a resolution adopting and approving a business plan which had been first produced in 2011. That plan envisaged the company group structure would include Exlites and a separate IP/R&D company, which was to hold all relevant intellectual property rights and engage in research and development work. By around mid-2012, Exlites had fully developed the Model 1 bollard and had commenced selling it. In the second half of that year, Mr Arieni began developing the idea of integrating the bollard’s power control module (PCM) into the circuitry of the printed circuit board (PCB). Naturally enough Mr Fry was aware of this development.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It was not suggested and nor could it be that the misrepresentations were not made in the course of trade or commerce. Blue Groper and Mr Scutter made the representations in the course of their business dealings and in an attempt to promote the sale of Blue Groper’s solar bollard in preference to the solar lighting bollards sold by the applicants.Conclusions on misleading or deceptive conduct It follows that, by producing and circulating the Evaluation Document, Blue Groper and Mr Scutter engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in the course of trade and commerce in contravention to s 18 of the ACL. That misleading or deceptive conduct was engaged in predominantly by the sending of the Evaluation Document to Mr Brownrigg. That action by the first and second respondents must have had the most impact because it was in response to a query from Mr Brownrigg and related to a project in respect of which Mr Brownrigg and Broadspectrum were interested. The sending of the Evaluation Document to Mr Brownrigg occurred via email from Mr Scutter and Blue Groper. It is apparent that Mr Brownrigg forwarded that email to other persons being Mr Stephen Smith of Broadspectrum Australia, RAAF Base Darwin and Tara Kay from Aurecon Engineering Consultants in Darwin. Mr Scutter also acknowledged that he gave the Evaluation Document to three other people. He claimed that he did so via the provision of it on a USB stick. Those three people were Mr Mark Sullivan of Combined Electrical, Mr Sam Hatzizaisamis of the Darwin Waterfront Corporation, and Mr Ryan Annear of Combined Electrical Services. He claimed that he had not circulated it to any other persons. His actions in providing the document on a USB stick to other persons was done in the course of the performance of his duties as a director of Blue Groper and, therefore, an act of the company as well. This conduct was a further breach of s 18. Once the applicants had remonstrated with Mr Scutter about the inaccuracies in the Evaluation Document, he says that he has asked his contacts who did receive it to dispose of it and not to circulate it to any other person under any circumstances. It cannot be denied that it was to the advantage of Blue Groper and Mr Scutter to disseminate the Evaluation Document. It provided a comparison of the Sun Wizard solar bollard with an old version of the applicants’ bollard, which was both out of date and out of production as well as being superseded by a new and improved product. It misleadingly identified that the applicants’ bollard, which was then current, was substantially inferior to Blue Groper’s bollard in certain respects and, indeed, that it had the attributes identified in the comparison. It must be acknowledged that the impact of the misleading conduct on persons other than those familiar with the situation at the RAAF Base might have been relatively less serious as it is not apparent that they were immediately seeking to acquire solar bollard lights. Nevertheless, that was not entirely so and the Evaluation Document can be read as a general comparison of the Sun Wizard product with the applicants’ current bollard. Contravention of s 29(1)(a) and (g)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The defence of Karmic and Mr Fry largely mirrored that of Blue Groper and Mr Scutter. Some additional matters were initially raised concerning the previous relationship between Mr Fry and Mr Arieni, however, by trial those matters had dissipated.CONSIDERATION OF THE CAUSES OF ACTIONThe misleading and deceptive conduct claim As mentioned, the applicants’ claim founded upon misleading or deceptive conduct arose by reason of the assertions in the Evaluation Document as to the qualities of the second generation Model 2 and 3 solar bollards supplied by the applicants. In effect, the Evaluation Document purported to make a comparison between the Sun Wizard product and the applicants’ current bollards but in doing so incorrectly identified the Model 1 bollards as being “the current bollards” whereas the current bollards were the Model 3 lights which had substantial improvements and did not have the deficiencies alleged in the document. It was acknowledged by the applicants that their first generation and Model 1 solar bollards had deficiencies when compared to subsequent models and, in particular, because the protection of the PCM from environmental factors was limited. In effect the PCM was separate to the PCB and located outside of the head of the bollard. The Model 2 and Model 3 bollards were constructed with the PCM in the bollard head and, indeed, encased in epoxy so as to be impervious to water, moisture and ants. At the time of the creation and publication of the Evaluation Document the Model 3 bollards had already been installed at the RAAF Base in Darwin and the Model 1 bollards were not being sold. The applicants’ complaint is that the Evaluation Document represented the Model 1 bollards, replete with their deficiencies, as the model then being manufactured and supplied by the applicants as at the time of the creation of the document. In order to consider the applicants’ claim it is appropriate to set out in detail the manner in which the Sun Wizard evaluation document came about.The creation of the Sun Wizard Evaluation Document The circumstances leading to the making of the misrepresentations in the Evaluation Document in April 2016 commenced some years prior to its preparation. The first relevant event occurred on 14 August 2013 when Mr Arieni, a director and/or employee of Key Wholesalers and Exlites, took photographs of a damaged Model 1 Bollard. The photographs were taken for the purposes of assessing a warranty claim in relation to a unit which had been submerged in flood waters. Two of these photographs are the first and third photographs replicated in paragraph 10 of the 2FASC. On 21 August 2013, Mr Arieni sent an email to Exlites’ distributors attaching the two photographs. In it Mr Arieni, inter alia, explained to the distributors that the units were not designed to be submerged in water and that damage caused in that way was not covered by any warranty. In early 2014, Key Wholesalers began the production and sale of the Model 3 Bollard, which had substantial design improvements over the earlier models, including the housing of the PCM in the polyurethane base cap.