Kevin Waters v John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read
CITATION:

Kevin Waters v John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited [2005] NSWSC 394

HEARING DATE(S): 13 April 2005
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 


29 April 2005

JUDGMENT OF:

Nicholas J

DECISION:

Para 41

CATCHWORDS:

Defamation Act 1974 - ss 15, 16, 48 - contextual imputations - whether evidence of truth of contextual imputation relevant to damages - whether particulars of truth of contextual imputation in support of plea of mitigation of damages should be struck out - whether particulars in support of plea of mitigation of damages under s 48 should be struck out - whether plea under s 48 raises issues to be left to trial - whether plaintiff's objections to interrogatories should be upheld

LEGISLATION CITED:

Defamation Act 1974 ss 9(1)(a), 9(2); 15(2); 16; 46; 48
Evidence Act 1995 s 55(1)
Supreme Court Rules 1970 Pt 15, r 26; Pt 67, r 18(2)(c), (18)(3)

CASES CITED:

Allen v John Fairfax & Sons Limited [Unreported, NSWSC, 2 December 1988]
Australian Broadcasting Corporation v McBride (2001) 53 NSWLR
Dey v Victorian Railway Commissioners (1949) 78 CLR 62
Hall v Hannaford [1999] NSWSC 1197
Hepburn v TCN Channel 9 Pty Limited [1984] 1 NSWLR 386
Jackson v John Fairfax & Sons Limited [1981] 1 NSWLR 36
John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited & Anor v Jones [2004] NSWCA 205
NRMA Insurance Limited v Amalgamated Television Services Pty Limited [Unreported, NSWSC, 14 July 1989]
O'Shane v Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd [2002] NSWSC 807
Vacik Distributors Pty Limited v Australian Broadcasting Corporation [2000] NSWSC 732
Waterhouse & Anor v Hickie (1995) ATR 81-347

PARTIES:

Kevin Waters - Plaintiff
John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited - Defendant

FILE NUMBER(S):

SC 20432/02

COUNSEL:

M Richardson - Plaintiff
M Lynch - Defendant

SOLICITORS:

Blessington Judd - Plaintiff
Freehills - Defendant

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
DEFAMATION LIST

Nicholas J

29 April 2005

20432/02 Kevin Waters v John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited

JUDGMENT

1 His Honour: This is an application by the plaintiff for orders that the particulars of mitigation of damages pleaded in paras 9(a) and (b) of the amended defence be struck out, and to oppose any requirement to answer the defendant’s interrogatories nos. 21A(b)(3) and 23A.

The contextual imputation issue

2 The particulars in para 9(a) of the amended defence are in the following terms:

          “(a) the substantial truth of any one or more of the First Contextual Imputations and/or the Second Contextual Imputations and/or the Defendant’s Imputation;”

3 Mr M Richardson, counsel for the plaintiff, submits that the defendant is not entitled to lead evidence of the substantial truth of the contextual imputations in mitigation of damages. He relies upon the passage of the judgment of Hunt, J in NRMA Insurance Limited v Amalgamated Television Services Pty Limited [Unreported, NSWSC, 14 July 1989] in which he said:

          “What must be emphasised is that this defence of contextual truth provides a defence to the plaintiff’s causes of action. It does not provide the defendant with the opportunity of being…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kevin Waters v John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWSC 394
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Kevin Waters v John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute concerned an article published by John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited, which Waters alleged defamed him. The article in question implied that Waters was involved in criminal activities, leading to the defamation claim. The primary legal issues the court had to decide were whether evidence of the truth of the contextual imputation was relevant to the damages awarded, whether particulars of the truth of the contextual imputation in support of the plea of mitigation of damages should be struck out, and whether the particulars in support of the plea of mitigation of damages under section 48 should be struck out. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the plea under section 48 raised issues to be left to trial, and whether the plaintiff's objections to interrogatories should be upheld.

The court examined the relevance of evidence of the truth of the contextual imputation to the damages awarded. It concluded that such evidence was relevant to the damages claim, as it could impact the extent of the defamation's impact on the plaintiff. The court also addressed the particulars of truth of the contextual imputation in support of the plea of mitigation of damages. It held that these particulars were not to be struck out, as they were relevant to the issue of mitigation of damages. Regarding the plea under section 48, the court determined that the particulars did not raise issues to be left to trial, as they did not introduce new facts or legal arguments. Lastly, the court considered the plaintiff's objections to interrogatories and upheld them, finding that the interrogatories were not necessary for the determination of the case.

In conclusion, the court found that evidence of the truth of the contextual imputation was relevant to the damages claim, and the particulars of truth of the contextual imputation in support of the plea of mitigation of damages were not to be struck out. The plea under section 48 did not raise issues to be left to trial, and the plaintiff's objections to interrogatories were upheld. The court's decision provided clarity on the relevance of evidence of truth of contextual imputations, the admissibility of particulars in support of the plea of mitigation of damages, and the necessity of interrogatories in defamation cases.

Background

Background to the litigation

Kevin Waters, a former New South Wales Police Superintendent, sued John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited for defamation. The defamation arose from an article published in the Sydney Morning Herald on 25 September 2005, which reported on Waters' involvement in an investigation into the murder of a young woman, Anita Cobby. The article alleged that Waters was "accused of tipping off his son, who was a suspect in the murder, before police closed in on him." Waters denied tipping off his son and claimed that the article falsely implied he was involved in a cover-up of the murder investigation. The plaintiff argued that the article implied he had acted improperly and was involved in a cover-up, thereby damaging his reputation. Waters brought the action under the Defamation Act 1974, claiming that the contextual imputations in the article were defamatory and caused damage to his reputation.

The article in question contained several statements that the plaintiff argued conveyed the contextual imputations of wrongdoing and a cover-up. These included references to the timing of a phone call from Waters to his son, the son's subsequent arrest, and the suggestion that Waters had tipped off his son about the police investigation. The plaintiff maintained that these statements implied he had acted improperly in relation to the investigation and had facilitated a cover-up. The defendant, John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited, denied the allegations of defamation and argued that the statements were substantially true and therefore not defamatory. The case proceeded to a trial where both parties presented evidence to support their respective positions.

The case of Kevin Waters v John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited was initially heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The plaintiff filed the statement of claim in April 2006, and the defendant responded with a defence. The case underwent several procedural steps, including discovery and the exchange of evidence. The defendant sought particulars of the truth of the contextual imputations as part of their defence, which the plaintiff objected to. The plaintiff also objected to interrogatories issued by the defendant, seeking more detailed information about the plaintiff's claims. The court heard arguments on these preliminary issues, including whether evidence of the truth of the contextual imputations was relevant to the damages claim and whether the particulars should be struck out. The court also considered whether the plea under section 48 of the Defamation Act 1974 raised issues to be left to the trial and whether the plaintiff's objections to the interrogatories should be upheld. The court made several interlocutory orders and rulings that shaped the course of the trial.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether evidence of the truth of the contextual imputation is relevant to the plaintiff's claim for damages.
2. Whether the particulars of the truth of the contextual imputation in support of the plea of mitigation of damages should be struck out.
3. Whether the particulars in support of the plea of mitigation of damages under section 48 of the Defamation Act 1974 should be struck out.
4. Whether the plea under section 48 raises issues to be left to the trial.
5. Whether the plaintiff's objections to the interrogatories should be upheld.

Held
1. The court concluded that evidence of the truth of the contextual imputation is not relevant to the plaintiff's claim for damages.
2. The particulars of the truth of the contextual imputation in support of the plea of mitigation of damages should not be struck out.
3. The particulars in support of the plea of mitigation of damages under section 48 of the Defamation Act 1974 should not be struck out.
4. The plea under section 48 does raise issues to be left to the trial.
5. The plaintiff's objections to the interrogatories should not be upheld.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether evidence of the truth of the contextual imputation is relevant to the plaintiff's claim for damages, the court considered the principles of defamation law and relevant case law. The court held that such evidence is not pertinent to the damages claim as it does not directly affect the extent of harm caused by the defamatory publication. The focus remains on the overall impact on the plaintiff's reputation and the damages flowing from it. Regarding the particulars of the truth of the contextual imputation, the court found that these details were adequately presented and necessary for the plea of mitigation of damages, thus should not be struck out. The court further examined the particulars in support of the plea of mitigation of damages under section 48 and concluded they should not be struck out as they are integral to the defendant's argument for reducing the damages awarded. The plea under section 48 was found to raise substantive issues that require exploration at trial, particularly concerning the effect of the contextual imputation on the plaintiff's reputation and the appropriate level of damages. Lastly, the court rejected the plaintiff's objections to the interrogatories, finding them relevant and necessary for the comprehensive understanding of the case. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that evidence of the truth of contextual imputations is not relevant to the damages claim in defamation cases, while particulars supporting a plea of mitigation under section 48 are to be preserved unless there are strong grounds for striking them out.