Kennedy and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Kennedy and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) [2022] AATA 2316 (20 July 2022)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/2153

Re:Gregory James Kennedy

APPLICANT

AndTax Practitioners Board

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

Date:20 July 2022

Place:Melbourne

1.The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

2.The stay on the reviewable decision that was ordered pursuant to s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Act 1975 shall cease 14 days from the date of these reasons.

...............................[SGD].....................

Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

Catchwords:  TAX AGENT REGISTRATION – termination of applicant’s registration as tax agents – whether applicants breached Code of Professional Conduct – whether applicant “fit and “proper” as required by the Tax Agents Services Act 2009 – appropriate length of prohibition to reapply for registration - decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Tax Agents Services Act 2009 (Cth)

Cases

Kishore and Tax Practitioners Board [2017] AATA 271

REASONS FOR DECISION

20 July 2022

Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

  1. Gregory Kennedy aspired to “establish the best and the biggest accounting firm in suburban Melbourne”, but he has experienced constant difficulty in managing his own taxation affairs. He compounded that shortcoming by failing to be open with the Tax Practitioners Board about the state of his tax affairs when seeking re-registration. Worse still, it has come to light that Mr Kennedy facilitated tax evasion by clients with whom he had a business relationship. He also gave misleading answers about aspects of the arrangements to investigators from the Australian Taxation Office (ATO).

  2. The Board considered all this evidence when it decided to cancel Mr Kennedy’s registration as a tax practitioner on 18 February 2021. The cancellation decision was made on the basis Mr Kennedy did not meet the registration requirement in s 20-5(1)(a) of the Tax Agents Services Act 2009 (‘TAS Act’) that he be a ‘fit and proper person’. The Board also points to contraventions of the tax agents’ code of conduct in s 30-10 of the TAS Act, including Mr Kennedy’s:

    ·failure ‘to act honestly and with integrity’ in contravention of s 30-10(1) when he made knowingly false declarations to the Board about his tax affairs and failed to be honest with the ATO investigators;

    ·failure to comply with taxation laws in the conduct of his own affairs in contravention of s 30-10(2) when he repeatedly failed to lodge returns on his own behalf and on behalf of companies he controlled.

  3. The Board also decided on the same day that Mr Kennedy should be prevented from applying for re-registration for three years from the date the termination took effect. In these reasons, I will refer to the period of non-registration as the ‘preclusion period’. The decision to impose the preclusion period was made pursuant to s 40-25(1) of the TAS Act.

  4. Mr Kennedy has asked the Tribunal to review the Board’s decision to terminate and impose a preclusion period. I am satisfied the reviewable decision to terminate and impose a preclusion period…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kennedy and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 2316
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Kennedy against a decision by the Tax Practitioners Board to terminate his registration as a tax agent. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) was required to review this decision. Mr Kennedy had been permitted to continue practising subject to conditions while the review was pending, with the stay of the termination decision to remain in place for 14 days following the Tribunal's reasons unless further ordered.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the Tax Practitioners Board's decision to terminate Mr Kennedy's registration was appropriate, and if not, what lesser regulatory action, if any, should be imposed. This involved considering the applicant's conduct, the Board's findings of fact, and the mitigating factors presented by Mr Kennedy.

Deputy President McCabe P found that the Tax Practitioners Board's findings of fact were justified and that Mr Kennedy had not seriously disputed them. The applicant's case focused on seeking less stringent regulatory action, such as a period of suspension or a shorter preclusion period. However, the Tribunal concluded that termination of registration, coupled with a three-year preclusion period, was the only adequate response to Mr Kennedy's conduct. Mitigating factors, including Mr Kennedy's health and the likelihood of his retirement, were considered and influenced the length of the preclusion period, preventing a longer one from being imposed.

The Tribunal affirmed the decisions under review, ordering the termination of Mr Kennedy's registration and imposing a three-year preclusion period.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Kennedy began his professional career in 1971, working for a major accounting firm before deciding to establish his own firm in 1981. His firm quickly expanded, employing several professional and support staff to manage around 250 clients. Mr Kennedy claimed his firm attracted business clients due to the excellent personal service he provided, though he also mentioned struggling to balance his professional responsibilities with personal priorities, such as family. He stated that clients preferred dealing with him directly, and despite working diligently, he was not earning sufficient income.

In 1987, Mr Kennedy chose to focus on larger, more profitable clients by selling the bulk of his smaller client base to other accounting firms. This transition made him a sole practitioner, with only a secretary for support. He maintained close, long-term relationships with his clients, often travelling extensively to provide personal service. Although this new arrangement was initially manageable, Mr Kennedy eventually found the workload increasingly burdensome, exacerbated by health issues and his involvement in community activities.

Mr Kennedy’s statement and evidence highlighted the pressures he experienced in his practice, but he did not contest the Tax Practitioners Board’s findings of fact. His primary argument was for less stringent regulatory action, suggesting a period of suspension, retraining, or a shorter preclusion period if his registration were to be terminated. The Tribunal, however, concluded that termination of registration and a three-year preclusion period were appropriate responses to his conduct.

The case of Kennedy and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) came before the court following a reviewable decision by the Tax Practitioners Board to terminate Mr Kennedy's registration as a tax agent. This decision was subject to a stay under s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, allowing Mr Kennedy to continue practising for 14 days unless further action was taken by the Tribunal or the Federal Court. Initially, Mr Kennedy was self-represented in the proceedings, although he was represented by counsel at the hearing. The case involved substantial evidence from Mr Kennedy regarding his professional career, the pressures he faced, and his personal circumstances, including health issues and community involvement. The primary focus of his statement and evidence was the challenges he experienced in managing his tax practice while balancing personal and professional commitments. The court examined these factors in determining the appropriate regulatory response, ultimately deciding on a three-year preclusion period, subject to the mitigating circumstances presented.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I note Mr Kennedy was permitted to remain in practice after the reviewable decision to terminate his registration was stayed pursuant to s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. The stay was ordered subject to conditions. The stay order shall remain in place for 14 days from the date of these reasons, after which the decision under review shall be implemented in the absence of further order from the Tribunal or the Federal Court.The applicant’s evidence Mr Kennedy was represented at the hearing, but he was self-represented at the outset of the proceedings. He provided a statement of facts, issues and contentions that he drafted himself. That statement reads like a witness statement in many respects. The summary which follows is principally based on material contained in the statement he provided, although he also gave some oral evidence. The statement and his evidence-in-chief focused on the pressures he experienced in conducting his practice without dwelling on the shortcomings in the management of his own affairs. I will deal with those shortcomings after recording the thrust of his statement and evidence-in-chief. The applicant commenced his professional career in 1971. He was initially employed by a major accounting firm. In 1981, he decided to set up his own firm. The firm grew quickly. Mr Kennedy said he soon engaged several professional and support staff to deal with around 250 clients. In his statement, he explained his firm was attractive to business clients because he gave excellent personal service. But he also said he had difficulty balancing the needs of his clients with other priorities in his life, such as his family. I was told the clients all wanted to deal with him directly. While he worked very hard, he said he was not making enough money. In 1987, he said he ‘sold’ the bulk of his smaller clients to other accounting firms. He decided to concentrate on his larger, more profitable clients. As I understand the evidence, the applicant became a true sole practitioner at that point. He had a secretary but no professional support staff. He said the new arrangement was more manageable, at least at first. Mr Kennedy said he forged close, long-term relationships with his clients. They were like family, he explained, and he had close links with staff in the clients’ businesses. He said his clients were located around the country and he travelled extensively to provide excellent personal service on the ground. He recalled he might spend 1-2 weeks each month travelling interstate. The workload gradually built up until Mr Kennedy said it was difficult to satisfy his clients’ needs. He said one of his larger clients left in 2011, which provided temporary relief. But he said the needs of other large clients in the period 2015-2017 meant the workload was becoming more onerous In his statement, Mr Kennedy referred to other factors which impacted on his work and on his ability to cope with the pressures on his time. He detailed a series of health issues which I need not record in detail here. He also referred to his record of extensive community engagement. He was an officeholder in the North Old Boys Amateur Football Club. He said he was also actively involved in the North Melbourne Football Club. He was a member of the board of that club in 2005-2007.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In all the circumstances, I am satisfied it is appropriate to apply a preclusion period of three years. I would have imposed a longer period but for the mitigating factors, including Mr Kennedy’s health and the likelihood he will retire from practice in any event.Conclusion The applicant did not seriously dispute the Board’s findings of fact. That is just as well, as I am satisfied they were justified. The thrust of his case at the hearing was directed towards achieving less stringent regulatory action. His counsel argued in submissions about a period of suspension and perhaps retraining, or a short preclusion period if the applicant’s registration was to be terminated. I do not accept anything less than termination of registration and a three-year preclusion period would be an adequate response to the applicant’s conduct. The decisions under review must therefore be affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in the case of Kennedy and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) examined whether the decision by the Tax Practitioners Board (TPB) to terminate Mr Kennedy's registration was justified based on the evidence presented. The court held that the TPB's decision was based on substantiated findings that Mr Kennedy's conduct was unsatisfactory due to a series of health issues, a high workload, and his lack of professional support staff. These factors collectively led to a deterioration in his compliance with the professional standards expected of tax practitioners. The court confirmed that the TPB was entitled to make its findings based on the evidence presented, and that it had done so correctly.

The court then considered whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was correct to grant a stay of the termination decision pending the outcome of the review. The court noted that the stay was granted under s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, which allows the AAT to stay the operation of a decision if it considers it just and convenient to do so. The stay was granted subject to conditions, and the court found that the AAT was within its authority to impose such conditions. The stay was considered appropriate as it allowed Mr Kennedy to continue his practice while the review was ongoing, ensuring minimal disruption to his clients and the public interest.

In assessing the appropriateness of the preclusion period imposed by the Tribunal, the court examined the mitigating factors presented by Mr Kennedy, such as his health issues and the likelihood of his retirement from practice. The court acknowledged these factors but ultimately determined that a three-year preclusion period was appropriate given the seriousness of Mr Kennedy's conduct and the need to uphold public confidence in the tax practitioner profession. The court found that the Tribunal had properly balanced the mitigating factors against the need for a significant regulatory response to Mr Kennedy's conduct.

Finally, the court considered whether the Tribunal properly considered alternative regulatory actions, such as suspension, retraining, or a shorter preclusion period, before affirming the termination of registration and the three-year preclusion period. The court found that the Tribunal had thoroughly examined the options available and had considered the arguments presented by Mr Kennedy's counsel. However, the court concluded that less stringent measures would not adequately address the concerns raised by Mr Kennedy's conduct. The Tribunal's decision to affirm the termination of registration and the three-year preclusion period was supported by the evidence and the principles of professional regulation.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Tax Practitioners Board's decision to terminate a tax practitioner's registration can be justified based on substantiated findings of unsatisfactory conduct, and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal is within its authority to grant a stay of the decision pending review, provided it is just and convenient. The Tribunal must consider all relevant factors, including mitigating circumstances, when determining the appropriate regulatory action and preclusion period. The court's decision to affirm the TPB's decision in this instance highlights the importance of maintaining high professional standards and public confidence in the tax practitioner profession.