TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Trade mark application number 2258808 (classes 36, 39, 41 & 43) – BRILLIANT TRAVELS - in the name of Kelsian Group Limited
Delegate:
Tracey Berger
Representation:
Applicant: Sam Hallahan of Counsel instructed by Wallmans Lawyers
Decision:
2023 ATMO 126
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – request to be heard under s 33(4) – s 41 considered – no inherent adaptation to distinguish – evidence of use insufficient – trade mark application rejected
Background
1. This decision follows from an ex parte hearing at the request of Kelsian Group Limited (‘Applicant’) pursuant to s 33 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)[1] in relation to trade mark application number 2258808 (‘Application’) filed on 25 March 2022 (‘Relevant Date’) for the trade mark shown below:
[1] Unless otherwise stated, each reference to a section or regulation is a reference to a section of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) or regulation of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘Regulations’).
Trade Mark: BRILLIANT TRAVELS (‘Trade Mark’)
Services: Class 36: Agency services for arranging travel insurance
Class 39: Agency services for arranging travel; Advisory services relating to travel; Arrangement of travel; Booking of tickets for travel; Computerised reservation services for travel; Information services relating to travel; Organisation of travel; Booking and reservation services for transportation for travel tours; Boat transport; Bus transport; Ferry-boat transport; Vehicle transport services; Booking of vehicle rental; Arranging of transportation for travel tours; Agency services for arranging transportation for tours; Arranging of sightseeing tours (not guided); Travel cruises; Arranging of cruises
Class 41: Booking services for guided tours; Conducting guided sightseeing tours; Organising guided tours; Arranging of exhibitions for entertainment purposes; Organisation of exhibitions for cultural or educational purposes
Class 43: Reservation of places at holiday resorts; Hotel information; Hotels; Travel agency services for making hotel reservations; Provision of carry-out foods and beverages; Provision of conference facilities; Provision of facilities for exhibitions; Cafes; Bar services; Holiday camp services (lodging); Booking of restaurant places; Provision of information relating to restaurants; Restaurant services; Arranging hotel accommodation; Booking of accommodation for travellers; Booking of hotel accommodation; Resort accommodation; Travel agency services for booking accommodation; Agency services for booking hotel accommodation; Hotel accommodation services
(‘Services’)
2. The Application was examined as required by s 31 and grounds for rejection were raised under s 41 and s 44.
3. In relation to the s 41 objection, the Examiner referred to the Macquarie Dictionary meaning of BRILLIANT as ‘illustrious’ and concluded that the ordinary meaning of the Trade Mark was travel related services that are illustrious. Hence other traders are likely to wish to use the Trade Mark in relation to their similar goods or services for its descriptive meaning.
4. In response to the objections, the Applicant filed letters of consent from the owners of the cited marks,[2] submissions and a declaration of Philip Boyle, General Manager (National Marketing) for the Applicant, made on 11 August 2022 with…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelsian Group Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] ATMO 126
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the delegate was whether the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" was capable of distinguishing Kelsian Group Limited's services from those of other persons, as required by section 41 of the Act. This involved determining whether the mark was inherently adapted to distinguish the services and, if not, whether its use had acquired distinctiveness by the filing date of the application. The delegate was required to consider the ordinary signification of the mark and the likelihood that other traders would legitimately wish to use it for similar services.
The delegate reasoned that the ordinary signification of "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" to consumers of travel services is "distinguished" or "excellent" travel, which is directly descriptive of the services offered. Applying the test from *Clark Equipment Co v Registrar of Trade Marks*, the delegate found that other traders would likely wish to use the mark or a similar mark in relation to their own travel-related services. Consequently, the delegate concluded that the trade mark was not inherently adapted to distinguish the services. Furthermore, the delegate was not satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the extent of use of the trade mark by Kelsian Group Limited prior to the application date had resulted in it actually distinguishing the services as being those of the applicant.
Accordingly, the delegate found that a ground for rejection existed under section 41(3) of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth) because the trade mark was not inherently adapted to distinguish the designated services and had not acquired distinctiveness through use. Therefore, the application for registration of the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" was refused.
Background
Background to the litigation
Kelsian launched the BRILLIANT TRAVELS brand on 12 November 2019 as a central brand linking its marine and tourism businesses. The company has since used the brand across its various subsidiaries and services, including SeaLink, Captain Cook Cruises, and Kangaroo Island Odysseys, among others. It also rebranded its 'Australian Holiday Centre' travel agency to BRILLIANT TRAVELS on 1 July 2020 and promoted the brand through various channels such as its website, social media, and print media. Despite these efforts, the company did not meet the two-year period of use before filing the application. The evidence showed that while the Group Businesses generated substantial revenue, the use of the BRILLIANT TRAVELS brand was limited, and the brand did not achieve significant distinctiveness in the market.
The delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks considered the objections and submissions from Kelsian. The delegate found that the trade mark BRILLIANT TRAVELS had no inherent adaptation to distinguish Kelsian's services from those of other traders. Furthermore, the evidence of use did not establish that the trade mark was distinctive at the time of filing. Consequently, the delegate rejected the trade mark application under section 41(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995, concluding that a ground for rejection existed and that the trade mark did not meet the criteria for registration.
The matter came before the court as an appeal against the decision of a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Tracey Berger, who rejected the trade mark application number 2258808 for the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" filed by Kelsian Group Limited. The Applicant, represented by Sam Hallahan of Counsel, requested a hearing under section 33 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. Following an examination under section 31, objections were raised under sections 41 and 44 of the Act. In response, the Applicant submitted letters of consent, declarations, and other evidence attesting to the use of the trade mark since 12 November 2019. Despite this, the delegate upheld the objection under section 41, finding that the trade mark had no inherent adaptation to distinguish the Applicant's services from those of other traders and that the evidence of use was insufficient to establish distinctiveness. The Applicant subsequently appealed this decision.
The appeal hearing was conducted via videoconference, with the Applicant presenting written and oral submissions. The Applicant argued that the trade mark had some inherent adaptation to distinguish and that its extensive use across various marketing channels and businesses established distinctiveness. The Applicant also relied on Google search results and other evidence to support its contention that "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" was an uncommon phrase unlikely to be used by other traders. However, the delegate found that the ordinary signification of the trade mark was descriptive of the services and that other traders were likely to wish to use it or a similar mark for their travel-related services. Additionally, the delegate was not satisfied that the Applicant had used the trade mark to such an extent that it was distinctive of the services at the relevant date. Therefore, the delegate upheld the objection under section 41(3) and rejected the trade mark application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" have any inherent adaptation to distinguish the Applicant's services from those of other traders?
2. Has the Applicant used the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" to such an extent before the Relevant Date that the mark did in fact distinguish the services at the time of filing the application?
3. Does the evidence of use provided by the Applicant establish that the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" distinguished the Applicant's services as being those of the Applicant at the Relevant Date?
4. Are there any other circumstances that would lead to the conclusion that the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" is capable of distinguishing the Applicant's services from those of other traders?
Held
1. Does the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" have any inherent adaptation to distinguish the Applicant's services from those of other traders?
The court concluded that the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" does not have any inherent adaptation to distinguish the Applicant's services from those of other traders. As a result, a ground for rejection exists under s 41(3).
2. Has the Applicant used the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" to such an extent before the Relevant Date that the mark did in fact distinguish the services at the time of filing the application?
The court concluded that the Applicant had not used the trade mark to such an extent before the Relevant Date that the trade mark was distinctive of the services at the time of filing the application.
3. Does the evidence of use provided by the Applicant establish that the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" distinguished the Applicant's services as being those of the Applicant at the Relevant Date?
The court concluded that the evidence of use provided by the Applicant did not establish that the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" distinguished the Applicant's services at the Relevant Date.
4. Are there any other circumstances that would lead to the conclusion that the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" is capable of distinguishing the Applicant's services from those of other traders?
The court concluded that there were no other circumstances that would lead to the conclusion that the trade mark "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" is capable of distinguishing the Applicant's services from those of other traders.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Tracey Berger, considered the trade mark application for "BRILLIANT TRAVELS" in light of the statutory provisions and case law. The primary issue was whether the trade mark had any inherent adaptation to distinguish the Applicant's services from those of other traders, and if not, whether the Applicant had used the trade mark sufficiently before the Relevant Date to establish distinctiveness. The Delegate found that the trade mark had no inherent adaptation to distinguish the services as it was descriptive of the services and other traders were likely to wish to use it. Additionally, the evidence of use was insufficient to establish that the trade mark had distinctiveness at the Relevant Date.
To determine if the trade mark had any inherent adaptation to distinguish, the Delegate applied the test established in Clark Equipment Co v Registrar of Trade Marks. The Delegate considered the ordinary signification of the trade mark, which was found to be distinguished or excellent travel, and found that other traders would likely wish to use the trade mark for its descriptive meaning. This satisfied the first limb of s 41(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995, that the trade mark is not inherently adapted to distinguish. The Delegate also considered the evidence of use provided by the Applicant, including the extensive promotional activities, but found that the use was not sufficient to establish distinctiveness at the Relevant Date. The Applicant's evidence demonstrated that the trade mark had been used across various Group Businesses and the Travel Agency, but the Delegate found that the use was not extensive enough to establish distinctiveness. The Delegate was not satisfied that the trade mark was distinctive of the Applicant's services at the Relevant Date.
In reaching this decision, the Delegate distinguished the case of J & P Coats Ltd’s Application and Austereo Pty Ltd v DMG Radio (Australia) Pty Ltd, which found that certain descriptive terms could have some inherent adaptation to distinguish if they were not the only or natural words for the purpose. However, the Delegate found that the term "BRILLIANT" was a common English word with a well-understood meaning that directly described the services, and hence, did not have the necessary inherent adaptation to distinguish.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a trade mark that is entirely descriptive of the services and does not have any inherent adaptation to distinguish, and for which there is insufficient evidence of use to establish distinctiveness, will be rejected under s 41(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The Delegate's decision followed the established test for determining whether a trade mark has inherent adaptation to distinguish, as set out in Clark Equipment Co v Registrar of Trade Marks, and applied it to the specific facts of the case. The Delegate also considered the evidence of use in light of the statutory requirements and found it to be insufficient to establish distinctiveness at the Relevant Date.