Kelly v Northern Meat Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

REGISTRY:  TOWNSVILLE

NUMBER: S40 of 1996

[2001] QSC 014

Plaintiff:  JAMES FRANCIS KELLY

AND

First Defendant:  NORTHERN MEAT HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED

formerly known as

INNISFAIL BUTCHERING COMPANY PTY LTD

AND

Defendant-by-Election:       WORKCOVER QUEENSLAND

DECISION - CULLINANE J.

DELIVERED THE  FIRST DAY OF FEBRUARY 2001

The Plaintiff claims damages for personal injury alleged to have been sustained by him as a result of the negligence and/or breach of duty of the Defendant, his former employer.  The personal injury is wholly psychiatric in nature.

The Plaintiff’s employment with the Defendant ceased on 2 July 1993 in circumstances which will be described more fully below.  The Writ of Summons was issued on 6 March 1996.  In the defence the Statute of Limitations has been
pleaded in respect of any injury the Plaintiff sustained more than three years prior to the issue of the Writ.  The consequence is that the Plaintiff’s right to recover damages if he establishes negligence or breach of duty is limited to the consequences of such negligence or breach of duty of the Defendant suffered by him after that date.

The Defendant conducts an abbatoir.  The Plaintiff first commenced working at those works (then under different ownership) in 1976.  He left and returned in 1980.  At that time the operations were in the nature of a small shed and the numbers of beasts processed were relatively small.  The Plaintiff had been working as a slaughterman and was promoted to foreman in mid 1982.  He became responsible for supervising the workings of the slaughtering area as well as continuing to perform his duties as a slaughterman.  The number of employees under the Plaintiff’s supervision were about 15. 

The abattoirs were purchased by the  Defendant in the late 1980s and thereafter the operations increased in size.  Cattle were killed for export.  This involved complying with certain additional requirements and as time went on it would seem that some of these became more complex.  In the years prior to the Plaintiff’s ceasing work, the Plaintiff had become involved in overseeing certain quality controls.  He had received some training for this.  It appears that it was necessary to meet requirements of three bodies, Austmeat, the Department of Primary Industries and the Defendant. 

The Plaintiff on the evidence which I have heard would appear to have coped reasonably well although with increasing difficulty until the latter part of 1992.

He had, as a child, suffered polio which left him with some disability of the shoulder.  During 1992 he also suffered symptoms in the right wrist, the spine and in the leg.  It would seem with the benefit of hindsight that some of the increased symptomatology which he complained of in relation to those may have been somatic in origin but it appears that both the shoulder and the spinal complaint have some organic basis.

In the latter part of 1992 the Plaintiff commenced to suffer from a number of symptoms which he describes in his statement (Exhibit 1), and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelly v Northern Meat Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QSC 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Kelly v Northern Meat Holdings Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, James Francis Kelly, sought damages for psychiatric injury he alleged was caused by the negligence and/or breach of duty of the defendant, his former employer. The court had to determine whether the defendant's actions contributed to the plaintiff's psychiatric injury and whether any such breach of duty was the cause of the plaintiff's current condition. The court found that the defendant had failed to take reasonable care for the plaintiff's safety by either refusing the plaintiff the time off work certified by his doctor or seeking to persuade the plaintiff not to take the time off. This constituted a breach of the defendant's duty to the plaintiff. The court also found that the defendant's negligence was causative of the plaintiff's current condition, which includes a major depressive disorder and considerable anxiety. The court assessed the plaintiff's general damages at $55,000, with $25,000 attributed to the past. Past economic loss was calculated at $180,000, reduced by $45,000 for disability support pension and WorkCover payments. Future economic loss was assessed at $235,321, with a small earning capacity taken into account. The court also awarded damages for past and future care and assistance, special damages, and future counselling and pharmaceutical expenses. Judgment was entered in favour of the plaintiff against the defendant-by-election in the sum of $550,904.12.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established