Kelly v Austwide Consumer Products Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Overflow FNQ Pty Ltd (in liquidation); Kelly & Ors v Austwide Consumer Products Pty Ltd [2017] QSC 76

PARTIES:

In the matter of OVERFLOW FNQ PTY LTD
ACN 101 890 831 (in liquidation)
TODD WILLIAM KELLY and
GERALD THOMAS COLLINS

(First Applicants)
and
OVERFLOW FNQ PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)
ACN 101 890 831
(Second Applicant)

v
AUSTWIDE CONSUMER PRODUCTS PTY LTD
ACN 009 438 153

(Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 143 of 2017

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

9 May 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Cairns

HEARING DATE:

28 April 2017

JUDGE:

Henry J

ORDERS:

1. It is declared that the interest of the respondent, Austwide Consumer Products Pty Ltd as chargee pursuant to an agreement titled “Business application form in terms of trade” dated 16 August 2010 (and the subject of PPSA registration number 201511100062557) has vested in the second applicant.

2.       The respondent pay the first and second applicants’ costs of the application.

CATCHWORDS:

SECURITIES — CORPORATIONS ACT 2001 (CTH) –CHAPTER 5 – EXTERNAL ADMINISTRATION –PART 5.7B – RECOVERING PROPERTY OR COMPENSATION FOR THE BENEFIT OF CREDITORS OF INSOLVENT COMPANY (ss 588D–588Z) – 588FL – Vesting of PPSA security interests if collateral not registered within time – Where court considered time limitations – Where security interest not registered within time

Acts Interpretation Act 1901(Cth) ss 36(1), 22(1)(b), 23(b), 22(1)(g)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 5C, 51, 105, 511, 513B, 513C, 588FL(2), 588FL(2)(a), 588FL(2)(b), 588FL(4), 588FL(7)

Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 160(1)

Prowse v McIntyre (1961) 111 CLR 264, cited

Dodds v Walker [1981] 1 WLR 1027, cited

Re Weston Application (2009) 255 ALR 362, cited

Carrafa (as liquidators of Relux Commercial Pty Ltd) (in liq) v Doka Formwork Pty Ltd (2014) 104 ASCR 163, distinguished

COUNSEL:

No appearances, application heard on the papers

SOLICITORS:

Miller Harris Lawyers for the applicants

Metaxas & Hager for the respondent

  1. The first applicants are liquidators of Overflow FNQ Pty Ltd (“Overflow”).  They have realised its assets.  They seek a declaration that the respondent’s security interest under its terms of trade agreement with Overflow has vested in Overflow. 

  2. The issue on which the application turns is whether the respondent registered its security interest sufficiently long before administration began, so as to avoid the interest being statutorily deemed to have vested in Overflow.

    Background

  3. After the first ranking secured creditor, NAB, the respondent asserts an entitlement as second ranking secured creditor in respect of sale proceeds of company property said to be the subject of a security interest of the respondent.  That interest allegedly arises out of a document styled “Business application form and terms of trade” submitted to the respondent by Overflow.  That document’s terms provided that “[b]y way of security against future unpaid accounts”, ownership of goods supplied to Overflow by the respondent would not pass, even if paid for in full, until on sold.[1]

    [1]     Affidavit of Todd William Kelly filed 24 March 2017 Ex…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelly v Austwide Consumer Products Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QSC 76
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Kelly v Austwide Consumer Products Pty Ltd, the applicant, as liquidator of the insolvent company Overflow, sought a declaration that a security interest held by the respondent, Austwide Consumer Products Pty Ltd, vested in Overflow. The respondent claimed to hold a security interest over the property of Overflow pursuant to a document titled “Business application form and terms of trade”. This interest was registered on 10 November 2015, and Overflow was placed into administration on 10 May 2016. The issue was whether the respondent's security interest was registered within the six-month period before the critical time, as required by s 588FL(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

The court had to determine whether the respondent's security interest was registered within six months before the critical time, which was defined as 8.00 am on 10 May 2016. Section 588FL(2) of the Corporations Act provides that a PPSA security interest is covered if it is perfected by registration and the registration time for the collateral is after the latest of six months before the critical time. The court found that the registration time was 4.18 pm on 10 November 2015, which was less than six months before the critical time. Therefore, the respondent's security interest vested in Overflow. The court granted the applicant's request for a declaration to that effect and ordered the respondent to pay the applicants' costs of the application.

The court concluded that the security interest held by the respondent did vest in Overflow, as it was not registered within the six-month period before the critical time. The court's reasoning was based on the statutory provisions of the Corporations Act and the fact that the registration time was too late to avoid the application of s 588FL. The court's decision was consistent with the legislative intent to protect unsecured creditors in the event of a company's insolvency. The court's orders provided clarity to the parties and resolved the dispute over the security interest.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. It is declared that the interest of the respondent, Austwide Consumer Products Pty Ltd as chargee pursuant to an agreement titled “Business application form in terms of trade” dated 16 August 2010 (and the subject of PPSA registration number 201511100062557) has vested in the second applicant.

2. The respondent pay the first and second applicants’ costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issue on which the application turns is whether the respondent registered its security interest sufficiently long before administration began, so as to avoid the interest being statutorily deemed to have vested in Overflow.Background After the first ranking secured creditor, NAB, the respondent asserts an entitlement as second ranking secured creditor in respect of sale proceeds of company property said to be the subject of a security interest of the respondent. That interest allegedly arises out of a document styled “Business application form and terms of trade” submitted to the respondent by Overflow. That document’s terms provided that “[b]y way of security against future unpaid accounts”, ownership of goods supplied to Overflow by the respondent would not pass, even if paid for in full, until on sold.[1][1] Affidavit of Todd William Kelly filed 24 March 2017 Ex p 13. The interest sought to be secured is a security interest within the meaning of the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (“PPSA”)[2] and, pursuant to s 51 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“Corporations Act”), is a PPSA security interest within the meaning of the Corporations Act. For present purposes, s 588FL(4) Corporations Act has the practical effect that a PPSA security interest granted by a company to which an administrator is subsequently appointed is deemed to have vested in the company from immediately before the appointment of the administrator if it is a PPSA security interest covered by s 588FL(2). Section 588FL(2) relevantly provides:[2] See in particular PPSA s 12.“This subsection covers a PPSA security interest if:(a) at the critical time, or, if the security interest arises after the critical time, when the security interest arises:(i)the security interest is enforceable against third parties under the law of Australia; and(ii)the security interest is perfected by registration, and by no other means; and(b) the registration time for the collateral is after the latest of the following times:(i)six months before the critical time; …” (emphasis added) It is not disputed that s 588FL(2)(a) applies. The controversy lies in whether s 588FL(2)(b) applies, that is, whether “the registration time” in this case was “after … six months before the critical time”. Section 588FL(7) defines the “critical time”:“In this section:critical time, in relation to a company, means:(a) if the company is being wound up – when, on a day, the event occurs by virtue of which the winding-up is taken to have begun or commenced on that day under section 513A or 513B; or(b) in any other case – when, on a day, the event occurs by virtue of which the day is the section 513C day for the company.” The first applicant liquidators commenced in that role when, on 14 June 2016 a resolution was passed for Overflow to enter liquidation. However, the company was already in administration, the first applicants having been appointed as voluntary administrators of Overflow at 8.00 am on 10 May 2016. This has the consequence, pursuant to ss 513B and 513C of the Corporations Act, that the critical time within the meaning of s 588FL(7) was the day of 10 May 2016 or, more specifically, 8.00 am on that day.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is unnecessary to determine that question, which was not argued, because even applying such a reckoning the registration time was too late to avoid the application of s 588FL. Ignoring the above mentioned statutory provisions about days and months, and reckoning by reference to times of day, the point in time six months before the critical time of 8.00 am on 10 May 2016 would have been the moment immediately before 8.00 am on 10 November 2015. On any view that was much earlier in the day than the 4.18 pm registration time. It follows, even if reckoning the period in question by reference to times of day, the registration time of 4.18 pm on 10 November 2015 was less than six months before, and thus occurred after six months before, the critical time. Conclusion For all of these reasons it is clear s 588FL(2) does cover the security interest. The security interest therefore vested in Overflow. The applicants seek a declaration to that effect. Such a declaration will adequately answer the question which has arisen for consideration pursuant to s 511 of the Corporations Act. Costs should follow the event.Orders My orders are:1. It is declared that the interest of the respondent, Austwide Consumer Products Pty Ltd as chargee pursuant to an agreement title “Business application form in terms of trade” dated 16 August 2010 (and the subject of PPSA registration number 201511100062557), has vested in the second applicant.2. The respondent pay the first and second applicants’ costs of the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.