CITATION: Kelleher v Commissioner, Department of Corrective Services [1999] NSWSC 86 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Administrative Law FILE NUMBER(S): 30024/98 HEARING DATE(S): 30/11/98 JUDGMENT DATE:
3 March 1999PARTIES :
David John Kelleher v Commissioner, Department of Corrective ServicesJUDGMENT OF: McInerney J at 1
COUNSEL : Mr. M. Thangaraj (Plaintiff)
Ms. R.M. Henderson (Defendant)SOLICITORS:
I.V. Knight (Defendant)CATCHWORDS: DECISION: Summons dismissed
21THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW DIVISIONMcINERNEY J
Wednesday, 3 March 1999
30024/98 - DAVID JOHN KELLEHER v COMMISSIONER, DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIVE SERVICESJUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: This matter has a long history. The plaintiff, David John Kelleher, is serving a sentence for conspiracy to import heroin. He was originally sentenced to life imprisonment on 21 September 1988. On 18 July 1996 his sentence was redetermined and a non-parole period of 13 years was substituted. He is due for release on parole on 20 September 2001. The head sentence of life imprisonment remains.
2 The plaintiff sought permission from the Department of Corrective Services (the Department) to have certain tattoos removed outside the prison environment. In fact, he had one treatment which resulted in the partial removal of some tattoos and it was anticipated that he would have further treatments. However, after the first treatment, in a policy statement dated October 1997 the Department denied the right of inmates to private medical treatment for removal of tattoos.
3 At about the same time, the plaintiff sought permission to have plastic surgery but that was refused. There was no urgency in either of these procedures which could be performed on his release from prison.
4 By way of Summons filed on 19 March 1998 the plaintiff seeks:
“1(i) A declaration that the prohibition of access by inmates to private medical practitioners for tattoo removal is invalid.
(ii) An order quashing the decision of the defendant to prohibit the plaintiff having his tattoos removed.
(iii) An order that the plaintiff be entitled to complete the tattoo removal procedure.
(iv) Alternatively to (iii), an order that the matter be remitted to the defendant.
2(i) A declaration that the prohibition of access by inmates to private medical practitioners for cosmetic surgery which has no medical need is invalid.
(ii) An order quashing the decision of the defendant to prohibit the plaintiff having the cosmetic surgery.
(iii) An order that the plaintiff be entitled to undergo the cosmetic surgery.
(iv) Alternatively to (iii), an order that the matter be remitted to the defendant.
3(i) An order quashing the decision of the defendant to deny the plaintiff a Metropolitan Warrant.
(ii) An order that the plaintiff be entitled to a Metropolitan Warrant.
(iii) Alternatively to (ii), an order that the matter be remitted to the defendant.
4(i) An order quashing the decision of the defendant to deny the plaintiff a Complex Warrant.
(ii) An order that the plaintiff be entitled to a Complex Warrant.
(iii) Alternatively to (ii), an order that the matter be remitted to the defendant.
5. Such…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelleher v Commissioner, Department of Corrective Services and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [1999] NSWSC 86
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In the Supreme Court of New South Wales, Administrative Law Division, McInerney J delivered a judgment dismissing David John Kelleher's summons against the Commissioner, Department of Corrective Services. Kelleher, serving a life sentence for conspiracy to import heroin, sought judicial review of several decisions made by the Department concerning his access to private medical treatment and warrants for employment. The court found that the Department had the discretion to deny Kelleher access to private medical treatment for tattoo removal and cosmetic surgery, as these decisions involved matters of security and prison management, areas typically beyond judicial review. The court also held that it lacked jurisdiction to review the Department's decisions regarding Kelleher's requests for Metropolitan and Complex warrants, as these decisions were within the purview of the Serious Offenders Review Council, an expert body established to determine rehabilitation programs for serious offenders.
The court examined the principles governing judicial review of correctional authorities' decisions, emphasizing that such review is limited and confined. The court noted that while prisoners are not barred from seeking judicial review, the scope of such review is generally restrictive, particularly where prison legislation is silent on the rights of prisoners. The court further held that the Department's policy decision to disallow inmates from accessing private medical practitioners for tattoo removal was an administrative decision, not subject to judicial review. Similarly, the decisions regarding Kelleher's requests for warrants were found to be within the discretion of the Commissioner and the Council, and thus not open to judicial scrutiny.
The court examined the principles governing judicial review of correctional authorities' decisions, emphasizing that such review is limited and confined. The court noted that while prisoners are not barred from seeking judicial review, the scope of such review is generally restrictive, particularly where prison legislation is silent on the rights of prisoners. The court further held that the Department's policy decision to disallow inmates from accessing private medical practitioners for tattoo removal was an administrative decision, not subject to judicial review. Similarly, the decisions regarding Kelleher's requests for warrants were found to be within the discretion of the Commissioner and the Council, and thus not open to judicial scrutiny.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi