JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: KEITH -v- VERGE [2009] WASC 338
CORAM: MASTER SANDERSON
HEARD: 4 AUGUST 2009
DELIVERED : 19 NOVEMBER 2009
FILE NO/S: COR 110 of 2009
BETWEEN: MALCOLM KEITH
Plaintiff
AND
EVAN VERGE
Defendant
Catchwords:
Corporation law - Appeal against refusal liquidator to assign potential insolvent trading action to creditor - Whether assignment possible
Legislation:
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 509, s 558FF, s 588FH, s 588FI, s 588M, s 1321
Result:
Application dismissed
Category: A
Representation:
Counsel:
Plaintiff: Mr B P Wheatley
Defendant: In person
Proposed Second Defendant : Mr A F Carles
Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Mossensons
Defendant: In person
Proposed Second Defendant : Carles Solicitors
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
Movitor Pty Ltd (receiver and manager appointed) (in liquidation) v Sims [1996] FCA 1320; (1996) 64 FLR 380
Tosich Construction Pty Ltd and the Corporations Law [1997] FCA 115; (1997) 73 FLR 219
UTSA Pty Ltd (in liq) v Ultra Tune Australia Pty Ltd (1996) 21 ACSR 457
UTSA Pty Ltd (in liq) v Ultra Tune Australia Pty Ltd [1997] 1 VR 667
MASTER SANDERSON: This was the return of two applications. The first in time was the plaintiff's originating process. The application was said to be brought under s 1321 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). This section authorises an appeal against a liquidator's decision. In this case the defendant is the liquidator of Senson Technology Pty Ltd (Senson). The relief claimed by the plaintiff was as follows:
1.The decision of the Defendant to refuse to assign to the Plaintiff any rights which Senson Technology Pty Ltd, or the Defendant (in his capacity as Liquidator), has to recover monies from Richard Martyn or his related entities under the various provisions of the Corporations Act 2001, including without limitation, sections 588FF, 588FH, or 588M of the Corporations Act 2001 ('the Rights'), be set aside.
2.The Defendant assign the Rights to the Plaintiff for a consideration of $2,000.00.
3.The Defendant do pay the Plaintiff's costs of this Originating Process.
The other application was an interlocutory process. Pursuant to that process, Richard Selwyn Martyn (Martyn) applied for the following orders:
1.That Richard Selwyn Martyn be joined as a party as Second Defendant in these proceedings.
2.That pursuant to section 1321 of the Corporations Act the liquidator be given directions as to the extent to which he has any power to assign causes of action to Richard Selwyn Martyn or to the plaintiff, Malcolm Keith, or to any other party.
3.That the Applicant's costs of this application be paid out of the assets of Senson Technology Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) as part of the expenses of the winding up.
At the hearing of the application, the plaintiff and the proposed second defendant, Martyn, appeared by counsel. The defendant appeared in his personal capacity. He advised that Senson was without funds and that he was not in a position to engage legal representation. He indicated he would abide by the decision of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Keith v Verge and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] WASC 338
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the relevant statutory provisions, including sections 588FB, 588FC, 588FF, and 588FI, which pertain to preferences and insolvent trading. The court noted that while some authorities suggested that prospective recoveries were 'property of the company' and could be assigned, other authorities, particularly the decision of Hansen J in UTSA Pty Ltd (in liq) v Ultra Tune Australia Pty Ltd, held that claims under these sections were not assignable and lay solely with the liquidator. The Victorian Court of Appeal had upheld Hansen J’s decision, emphasizing that allowing assignments would undermine the purpose of the preference provisions and the compensation mechanism outlined in the Act. The court concluded that assigning a preference claim or an insolvent trading claim to a creditor would be inconsistent with the statutory objectives of the Act.
In light of the statutory language and the reasoning of the Victorian Court of Appeal, the court found that the liquidator did not have the authority to assign a preference claim or an insolvent trading claim to a creditor. The statutory scheme clearly intended to protect the company and its creditors by ensuring that the preferred creditor could prove in the winding up as if the transaction had not been entered into, and by preventing any circumvention of the compensation process outlined in the Act. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the liquidator's refusal to assign the claim was upheld.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Tosich Construction Pty Ltd and the Corporations Law [1997] FCA 115; (1997) 73 FLR 219 at 235, Lindgren J referred to Movitor and agreed with the proposition that prospective recoveries were 'property of the company' within s 477(2)(c). His Honour commented that 'it was not to the point that only the liquidator had standing to apply for the remedy which would give rise to those recoveries'. On behalf of the proposed second defendant, it was submitted that these two statements of principle were obiter and not determinative of the question. Be that as it may, they represent unqualified statements of principle and should be viewed in that light. The contrary line of authority rests upon the decision of Hansen J in UTSA Pty Ltd (in liq) v Ultra Tune Australia Pty Ltd [1997] 1 VR 667. His Honour was of the view that claims under s 588FB, s 588FC and s 588FF lay with the liquidators and were not assignable: see UTSA (698). On appeal, the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria upheld his Honour's decision: see UTSA Pty Ltd (in liq) v Ultra Tune Australia Pty Ltd (1996) 21 ACSR 457. Hayne JA (464) agreed with the primary judge 'substantially for the reasons that he gives' and found there was no basis for interfering with the exercise of the primary judge's discretion. Brooking JA concurred and wished 'only to add my own expression of admiration for the careful and comprehensive judgment of Hansen J'. Phillips JA agreed. There is no basis upon which the opposing views can be reconciled. However, given that the Victorian Court of Appeal has adopted the approach of Hansen J, I propose to adopt the same approach. The aim of the preference provision is for the preferred creditor to 'put the company in the same position as if the transaction had not been entered into'. That is clear from s 588FI(1)(b). Section 588FI(3) then entitles the preferred creditor to prove in the winding up as if the transaction had not been entered into. If a preference claim could be assigned by a liquidator to a third party and was successfully pursued by the third party, then the company will not have been put back in the same position as if the transaction had not been entered into. The preferred creditor will then have been compelled to pay under the preference claim but will be denied the benefit of proving in the liquidation under s 588FI. On this view, an assignment of a preference claim would be inconsistent with s 588FI. Further, s 588M(3) provides that a creditor aggrieved by alleged insolvent trading 'may, as provided by Subdivision B but not otherwise, recover from the director, as a debt due to the creditor, an amount equal to the amount of the loss or damage'. Subdivision B then provides a procedure whereby the creditor may sue for compensation with the liquidator's consent, following the creditor giving the liquidator notice of intention to sue for compensation. For a creditor to purchase from the liquidator an insolvent trading claim as 'property of the company' would be contrary to the words 'but not otherwise' in s 588M(3). The effect of s 588M(3) is to prevent the assignment of an insolvent trading claim by the liquidator to a creditor.