Kearns and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

Kearns and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2019] AATA 1631 (2 July 2019)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL            )
  )  No: 2016/5014
GENERAL DIVISION  )

Re: Shayne Kearns
Applicant

And: Australian Capital Territory
Respondent

DIRECTION

TRIBUNAL:  Senior Member Linda Kirk

DATE OF CORRIGENDUM:  10 July 2019

PLACE:           Canberra

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the text of the decision in this application as follows:

1.   The name of the Respondent on page 1 be changed from ‘Comcare’ to ‘Australian Capital Territory’ ;

2.   The words ‘(‘the Respondent’)’ be deleted from paragraph 13; and

3.   The words ‘the Respondent’ be changed to ‘Comcare’ at paragraph 26.

...................................................................

Senior Member Linda Kirk

File Numbers: 2016/5014 and 2016/5590

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/5014

2016/5590

Re:Shayne Kearns

APPLICANT

AndComcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Linda Kirk

Date:2 July 2019

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review pursuant to section 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

........................................................................

Senior Member Linda Kirk

Catchwords

WORKERS COMPENSATION – whether the Applicant continues to suffer the effects of an accepted condition – whether the Applicant continues to suffer the effects of a second accepted condition – whether an aggravation or ailment was contributed to in material degree by employment – whether an aggravation or ailment was contributed to in a significant degree by employment – decisions under review affirmed.

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Australian Postal Corporation v Bessey (2001) 32 AAR 508

Comcare v Power [2015] FCA 1502

Comcare v Sahu-Khan [2007] FCA 15; 156 FCR 536

Commonwealth v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369

Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch (1964) 110 CLR 626

Howes v Comcare [2016] FCA 1521

Prain v Comcare [2017] FCAFC 143; 256 FCR 65

Re Blasco and Australian Postal Corporation [2017] AATA 1222

Re Carmel Elizabeth McDonald v Director-General of Social Security (1984) 1 FCR 354

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford (2006) 151 FCR 253

Tippett v Australian Postal Corporation (1998) 27 AAR 40

Trustees Executors & Agency Co Ltd v Reilly [1941] VLR 110

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Linda Kirk

2 July 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Shayne Kearns (‘the Applicant’) was born in 1955. On 29 July 2002 hecommenced work with the ACT Government, Department of Housing (‘the Agency’).  He retired from the Agency on 19 July 2011.

  2. On 20 July 2006, the Applicant lodged a workers’ compensation claim for ‘jarred back back strain’ arising from a workplace incident on 29 June 2006.[1]

    [1] T38.

  3. On 31 July 2006, Comcare accepted liability for ‘lumbar sprain’ under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (‘SRC Act’)[2] (‘first accepted condition’).

    [2] T41.

  4. On 27 July 2010, the Applicant lodged a workers’ compensation claim for ‘reinjured back jarred back aggravated pre-existing back symptoms’ arising from a workplace incident on 16 July 2010.[3]

    [3] T75.

  5. On 6 September 2010, Comcare accepted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kearns and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 1631
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the Applicant, Kearns, against decisions made by the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) regarding workers' compensation. The Applicant had two accepted conditions under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act): a 'lumbar sprain' from 31 July 2006 and an 'aggravation of lumbar sprain' from 6 September 2010. The central dispute revolved around whether the Applicant continued to suffer from the effects of these accepted conditions as at 2 June 2016 and up to the present date, and whether his employment remained a contributing factor to his condition to the requisite degree.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Applicant continued to suffer from the effects of his accepted conditions as at 2 June 2016 and thereafter, and whether any ailment or aggravation of an ailment affecting his lumbar spine was contributed to in a material degree by his employment from 29 June 2006, and to a significant degree by his employment from 16 July 2010. Additionally, the Tribunal was required to consider if the Applicant had obtained reasonable medical treatment, was incapacitated for work, and had unreasonably failed to seek suitable employment or mitigate his loss of income, should his condition not have resolved by 2 June 2016.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the evidence of medical experts, who agreed that prior to the 2006 incident, the Applicant had mild degenerative lumbar spondylosis. They also agreed that the 2006 incident resulted in a lumbar sprain or soft tissue injury, which aggravated the underlying degenerative condition, and that this sprain was contributed to in a material degree by his employment. However, the Respondent's medical experts were unanimous in their opinion that the factors contributing to the Applicant's ongoing back condition were his underlying degenerative condition, constitutional factors, age, weight, and other health conditions, and that the two workplace incidents no longer contributed to his back condition in June 2016 or to date. While one expert maintained the workplace incidents remained significant, the Tribunal found that the Applicant had unreasonably failed to seek suitable employment from July 2011 to the present.

Consequently, the Tribunal found that no compensation was payable by the Respondent to the Applicant under sections 16 and 19 of the Act, and the Reviewable Decisions were affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Their Honours then made the following observations at [87]:Further, reading the Tribunal’s reasons as a whole, we are not persuaded that the Tribunal failed to address the test in s 5B(1) of the SRC Act. Its appraisals of the evidence and relevant determinations show that it understood and applied itself to the statutory question to which s 5B(1) gave rise, namely, whether Mrs Prain’s ailment was contributed to, to a significant degree, by her employment at the Canberra Hospital. The Tribunal specifically acknowledged (at [60]) that, notwithstanding its doubts about some of her evidence, Mrs Prain was ‘entitled to succeed if the compensable factors have nonetheless contributed to that injury to a significant degree’. Whilst the reference to ‘compensable factors’ (as was its reference to ‘novus actus interveniens’ in [70]) were inapt, reading the Tribunal’s reasons as a whole, it is clear that the Tribunal had in mind the contribution made by Mrs Prain’s employment at the Canberra Hospital to her condition after July 2015 and that its reference to ‘factors’ was to this issue and to the factors listed in s 5B(2) that might, in the Tribunal’s direction, be considered in determining the question to which s 5B(1) gave rise and to which the Tribunal directed its attention at [65] and following. The Tribunal’s statement (at [68]) that ‘it seems improbable that one particular stressor – the week-long conflict at the hospital four years previously – should still amount to a significant factor in her ongoing condition’ should be understood as the application of that test. It is in this context that one must understand and read the Tribunal’s further statements (at [70]) that ‘factors which the medical records suggest were agitating Mrs Prain after April 2011’ had ‘the effect of pushing the employment factor further and further into the background’. Taking the evidence as a whole, it is plain enough that the Tribunal’s determination (at [70]) that Mrs Prain’s employment at the Canberra Hospital had ceased to be ‘a significant contributor to Mrs Prain’s adjustment disorder by July 2015’ was reached after considering the case Mrs Prain sought to make and correctly addressing the question to which s 5B gave rise. The Tribunal’s reasoning at this point is also consistent with its appreciation that, under s 5B(3), ‘significant degree’ meant ‘substantially more than material’. Accordingly, we consider that ground 3 is not made out. (emphasis added). Counsel for the Respondent submitted, and the Tribunal accepts, that whereas Prain considered the issue in terms of the ‘significant degree’ evaluative threshold, the analysis by both the Tribunal and the Full Court applies mutatis mutandis, to the ‘material degree’ threshold applicable in this case to the 2006 incident. The Respondent’s medical experts all agree that the factors contributing to the Applicant’s ongoing back condition are the underlying degenerative condition, constitutional factors, his age, weight and other health conditions. They are unanimous in their opinion that the two workplace incidents no longer contributed to his back condition in June 2016 or to date. Dr Eaton agrees that these other factors contributed to the Applicant’s condition in 2016 and presently, but maintains that the two workplace incidents remain significant.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issues for determination are:(1)Whether, as at or before 2 June 2016:(a)the Applicant continued to suffer from the effects of the first accepted condition;(b)the Applicant continued to suffer from the effects of the second accepted condition.(2)Whether, from 2 June 2016 to date:(a)any ailment, or aggravation of such an ailment, affecting the Applicant’s lumbar spine from 29 June 2006 was contributed to, in a material degree, by his employment?(b)any ailment, or any aggravation of such an ailment, affecting the Applicant’s lumbar spine from 16 July 2010 was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his employment?(2)If the Applicant’s ailment or any aggravation of an ailment affecting his lumbar spine had not resolved as at 2 June 2016:(a)Did the Applicant obtain reasonable medical treatment for his ailment or any aggravation of an ailment sustained on 29 June 2006 and/or 16 July 2010?(b)Is the Applicant incapacitated for work as a result of his ailment or aggravation of an ailment sustained on 29 June 2006 and/or 16 July 2010?(c)Did the Applicant unreasonably fail to seek suitable employment?(d)Did the Applicant otherwise fail to mitigate his loss of income?APPLICANT’S EVIDENCE After completing his schooling in 1972 the Applicant joined the Commonwealth Public Service and was employed as an administrative officer. In 1997 he took a redundancy and set up his own landscaping/concrete edging and gardening business.[10] He was self-employed in this business until 2001 when he joined the Agency as a Fencing Officer. His work was mostly out in the field inspecting fences on ACT Housing properties.[11][10] Exhibit A1, para 2.[11] Applicant’s SOFIC at para 3; Transcript of proceedings, 1 August 2018, p25.Previous workplace injury In 1995 the Applicant sustained an injury to his neck in the course of his employment with the Commonwealth Public Service. The injury was an overuse syndrome and primarily caused symptoms to his neck, shoulders and both arms. It sometimes caused referred pain to his whole back which caused his muscles to tighten. Comcare accepted liability for aggravation of a disc lesion at C4-5 on 1 May 1995.[12] [12] T32. Imaging of the Applicant’s back in May 1995 showed no abnormalities of the lumbar spine and the cervical spine was degenerate.[13] These findings were confirmed on MRI in October 1995.[14] In his report dated 2 November 1995, Dr Andrews, Consultant Neurologist, reported that the Applicant has a ‘significant disc lesion at C5-6.’[15] Dr Andrews examined the Applicant in relation to his neck pain and noted in his report dated 3 January 1996 that the CT scan of the Applicant’s cervical spine showed degenerative changes at C4-5, 5-6. He noted that the Applicant has ‘a history of chronic low back pain for two years’.[16] The Applicant was asked about this in cross-examination and denied saying this to Dr Andrews.[17][13] T15[14] T18.[15] T19.[16] T14.[17] Transcript of proceedings, 1 August 2018, p44.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Therefore, the Tribunal finds that no compensation is payable by the Respondent to the Applicant under sections 16 and 19 of the Act.DECISION The Reviewable Decisions are affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the alternative, the Applicant has unreasonably failed to seek suitable employment following his retirement in July 2011 to date.CONSIDERATION AND REASONS The Tribunal has considered the parties’ submissions, the evidence of the witnesses at the hearing, and all the documentary material before it. The Tribunal is satisfied that the parties had an adequate opportunity to be heard by the Tribunal. The Applicant has two accepted conditions under s14 of the SRC Act namely ‘lumbar sprain’ (31 July 2006) and ‘aggravation of lumbar sprain’ (6 September 2010). The central issue for determination is whether the Applicant continued to suffer from the effects of the accepted conditions as at 2 June 2016 and to the present date. The Respondent does not contend that the initial acceptance of liability under s 14 was wrong and it is not argued that the Tribunal revisit the substantive determination relying on the principles expounded in Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford (2006) 151 FCR 253. Rather, this matter, involves, inter alia, the contention by the Respondent that the compensation is no longer payable because of the “ceased effects” of the compensable “injury”. The Tribunal’s role on review is established by section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) which provides that the Tribunal “may exercise all the powers and discretions that are conferred by any relevant enactment on the person who made the decision”. The Tribunal is not reviewing whether compensation should not have been awarded to begin with, but whether the compensation entitlements arising from the accepted conditions should be terminated on the basis that the Applicant’s employment is no longer contributing to his condition to the requisite degree.[157][157] Comcare v Power [2015] FCA 1502, at [63]. In Comcare v Power [2015] FCA 1502 Katzmann J said, at [70]:… I accept that is reasonable to say, as a practical matter, that Comcare would have to persuade the Tribunal of the circumstances which justify a finding that compensation payments should no longer be made… If the Tribunal is unable to decide, on the balance of probabilities, whether the Applicant does or does not continue to suffer the effects of the accepted conditions, the Tribunal is bound to find in the Applicant’s favour.[158] There is no presumption that the reviewable decisions are correct.[159][158] Comcare v Power [2015] FCA 1502, at [71].[159] Re Carmel Elizabeth McDonald v Director-General of Social Security (1984) 1 FCR 354, at 357; [1984] FCA 57. On the basis of the evidence before it, particularly the evidence of the medical experts, the Tribunal makes the following findings in relation to the Applicant’s lumbar spine condition, and whether he continued to suffer from the condition at 2 June 2016 and presently.The Applicant’s back conditionPrior to and following the June 2006 incident The medical experts agree that prior to the June 2006 incident, the Applicant suffered mild degenerative lumbar spondylosis.[160] This was likely associated with some mild pain,[161] although Dr Andrews reported the Applicant in 1996 as suffering chronic back pain. The medical experts also agree that on 29 June 2006 the Applicant sustained a ‘lumbar sprain or soft tissue injury of the lumbar spine’,[162] otherwise described as ‘musculoligamentous strain’,[163] resulting in an ‘aggravation’[164] or ‘exacerbation’[165] of the underlying degenerative condition in his lumbar spine. They further agree that the sprain suffered by the Applicant as a consequence of the 2006 incident was contributed to, in a material degree, by his employment.[166][160] Transcript of proceedings, 7 May 2019, Dr Burke at 16; Dr Eaton at 16; Dr Allen at 44; Professor Youssef at 60.[161] Transcript of proceedings, 7 May 2019, Dr Burke at 16[162] Transcript of proceedings, 7 May 2019, Dr Burke at 16.[163] Transcript of proceedings, 7 May 2019, Dr Eaton at 16; Professor Youssef at 60.[164] Transcript of proceedings, 7 May 2019, Dr Eaton at16.[165] Transcript of proceedings, 7 May 2019, Dr Allen at 44.[166] Transcript of proceedings, 7 May 2019, Dr Burke at 17; Dr Eaton at 17; Dr Allen at 45.