Kanesamoorthy v Brisbane City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT OF
COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Kanesamoorthy & Anor v Brisbane City Council

[2016] QPEC 42

PARTIES:

DUSHYANDAN KANESAMOORTHY

&

HARJASLEEN SINGH

(Appellants)

v

BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL

(Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

2544/2016

DIVISION:

Planning & Environment

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning & Environment of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

1 September 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

27 June 2016, 28 June 2016

JUDGE:

Searles DCJ

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed.1.   

CATCHWORDS:

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING – DEVELOPMENT CONTROL –  APPLICATIONS – OBJECTIONS ­– where the Appellant made a development application for preliminary approval to carry out building work (demolition of  pre-1946 house in the Traditional Building Character Overlay) – where the development application was refused by the Respondent Council – where the subject Dwelling has been altered –  where the subject dwelling is accepted to represent traditional building character – where the development application is to be assessed against the Traditional Building Character (Demolition) Overlay Code under City Plan 2014 – whether Performance Outcome PO5(c) is satisfied – whether Acceptable AO5(c) is satisfied– whether Acceptable Outcome AO5(d) is satisfied.

Brisbane City Plan 2014

Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld) ss 313, 324, 326, 461(1)(a), 495

Hamilton v Brisbane City Council [2016] QPEC 28

Leach v Brisbane City Council [2011] QPELR 609

Lonie v Brisbane City Council & Ors [1998] QPELR 209

Lucas v Brisbane City Council [2015] QPEC 25

Marriott v Brisbane City Council [2015] QPEC 45

Se Ayr Projects Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2016] QPELR 223

Unterweger v Brisbane City Council [2012] QPELR 335; [2011] QPEC 134

Westfield Management Ltd v Pine Rivers Shire Council & Anor [2004] QPELR 338

COUNSEL: 

S Ure for the Appellant

N Kefford for the Respondent

SOLICITORS:

HWL Ebsworth for the Appellant

Brisbane City Legal Practice for the Respondent

Appeal

  1. By Notice of Appeal dated 25 June 2015, the Appellant appealed[1] the decision of the Respondent Council (‘Council’) refusing a development application for a preliminary approval to carry out building work (demolition of a pre-1946 house in the Traditional building character overlay) (‘Application’) on land located at 80 Kent Street, Hamilton and more particularly described as Lots 103 and 104 on RP33641 (‘Land’).

    [1]Pursuant to section 461(1)(a) of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld).

Subject Site

  1. The Land has a site area of approximately 810m2 and is identified within the Low-medium density residential zone (2 or 3 storey mixed zone precinct), the Racecourse Precinct Neighbourhood Plan and the Traditional Building Character Overlay of the Brisbane City Plan 2014 (‘City Plan 2014’). The Land is currently improved by a single detached dwelling house (‘Dwelling’).

Application

  1. On or about 28 April 2015, the DTS Group Qld Pty Ltd (‘DTS’), lodged the Application on behalf of the Appellants which was accepted by the Council as properly made on 8 May 2015. Pursuant to section 313 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld) (‘SPA’), the Application required code assessment. There were…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kanesamoorthy v Brisbane City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QPEC 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kanesamoorthy v Brisbane City Council, the appellant sought preliminary approval for a development application to demolish a pre-1946 house within a Traditional Building Character Overlay. The Brisbane City Council refused the application, leading to the appellant's appeal to the court. The central issue before the court was whether the appellant's development application satisfied the criteria outlined in the Traditional Building Character (Demolition) Overlay Code under City Plan 2014. Specifically, the court had to determine whether Performance Outcome PO5(c) and Acceptable Outcomes AO5(c) and AO5(d) were met.

The court examined the legal framework provided by the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld) and the applicable Demolition Code under City Plan 2014. It was acknowledged that only Performance Outcome PO5 was relevant to the appeal, as the other outcomes were inapplicable to the circumstances of the case. The court assessed the evidence presented by the parties, including expert reports from heritage architects, which confirmed the building's traditional character and the absence of substantial alterations. The court applied the principles of interpretation as outlined in Westfield Management Ltd v Pine Rivers Shire Council & Anor, ensuring that its decision did not conflict with the Demolition Code. After thorough consideration, the court found that the appellant had not satisfied the relevant Performance and Acceptable Outcomes, leading to the dismissal of the appeal.

Consequently, the court upheld the decision of the Brisbane City Council and dismissed the appellant's appeal. This decision underscores the importance of adhering to the criteria set forth in the applicable planning codes when seeking development approval, particularly in areas designated for the preservation of traditional building character.

ORDERS:
Appeal dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed.1.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Appendix A hereto contains the Council’s reasons for refusal (‘Decision Notice’) and details conflicts with the following provisions of the Demolition Code: The relevant provisions of the Demolition Code in respect of this appeal are reproduced below: The Appellant appeals pursuant to section 461 of SPA and bears the onus of establishing that the appeal ought to be allowed and the Application approved.[3] Pursuant to section 495 of SPA, the appeal is by way of a hearing anew to the intent the Court stands in the shoes of the original assessment manager, and must to the relevant extent, assess and determine the Application.[3]Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld), section 493(1). The Application required code assessment pursuant to section 313 of SPA. Section 313(2)(c) of SPA requires that the assessment is to be carried out against applicable codes. It is not in dispute between the parties that the Demolition Code under City Plan 2014 is the applicable code for the purposes of the appeal.[4] Nor is it in dispute that Performance Outcomes PO1 to PO4 and PO6 to P10 (inclusive) of the Demolition Code are not applicable. Performance Outcome PO5 (extracted above) is the only relevant Performance Outcome.[5][4]Submissions of the Appellant, paragraph 5; Submission on behalf of the Respondent, paragraph 21.[5]Joint Report of Expert Heritage Architects, paragraph 7. In Westfield Management Ltd v Pine Rivers Shire Council & Anor[6], Britton SC DCJ set out the various principles with respect to the interpretation of planning schemes. His Honour noted, The appeal is to be decided in accordance with ss 324 and 326 of SPA. Section 324 of SPA relevantly provides: Section 326 provides; Under section 326 of SPA, a ‘relevant instrument’ includes applicable codes under City Plan 2014. Hence, pursuant to section 326(1)(b) of SPA, the decision of this Court must not conflict with the Demolition Code. The Appellants have not raised any ‘sufficient grounds’ to warrant approval of the Application in the event conflict with City Plan 2014 is found. The Appellant relies on the following grounds of appeal (‘Grounds of Appeal’): The Appellants accept that Performance Outcomes (‘PO’) 5(a) and (b) and Acceptable Outcomes (‘AO’) 5(a) and (b) of the Demolition Code set out above are not relevant and acknowledge the building represents traditional building character, has not been substantially altered, lacks the appearance of construction pre-1946, or is structurally unsound and incapable of structural repair. [8] [8]Submissions of the Appellant, paragraph 9. That is consistent with the evidence of the heritage experts in their joint report (‘Joint Report of Expert Heritage Architects’).[9] Council agrees that only the following provisions of the Demolition Code require consideration:[9]Joint Report of Expert Heritage Architects page 2, paragraphs 8-9. It can be seen that the provisions of Performance Outcome 5 impose alternative, rather than cumulative requirements. Further, section 5.3.3 of City Plan 2014 relevantly provides:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.