JW v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read
CITATION: JW v Director of Public Prosecutions [1999] NSWSC 1244
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Common Law
FILE NUMBER(S): 30065/99
HEARING DATE(S): 20 October 1999
JUDGMENT DATE:
16 December 1999

PARTIES :


JW - Plaintiff
Director of Public Prosecutions - Defendant
JUDGMENT OF: Simpson J at 1
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Children's Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S) :
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
COUNSEL : P Lakatos - Plaintiff
F Corsaro - Defendant
SOLICITORS: T A Murphy - Plaintiff
S E O'Connor - Defendant
CATCHWORDS:
ACTS CITED: Crimes Act 1900
Supreme Court Act 1970
Evidence Act 1995
Justices Act 1902
CASES CITED: Ex parte Hebburn Limited; re Kearsley Shire Council (1947) 47 SR (NSW) 416
Saffron v DPP (1989) 16 NSWLR 397
Hanna v Kearney; Mileshkin v Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions, unreported, 28 May 1998 per Studdert J.
Director of Public Proseccutions v Losurdo (1998) 44 NSWLR 618
DECISION: Declaration that, on 2 July 1999, the second defendant erred in rejecting applications for the attendance at committal proceedings of witnesses pursuant to s 48E of the ustices Act 1902; Order that the second defendant reconsider the application according to law.

THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW DIVISION

SIMPSON J

16 December 1999

30065/99
JW v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

      JUDGMENT
      HER HONOUR :

1 The plaintiff, JW, who was born on 29 September 1981 and who is now eighteen years of age, is charged with one count of break enter and steal in circumstances of aggravation (under s 112(3) of the Crimes Act 1900) and with the murder of Ralph Terrence Mason. Both offences are alleged to have been committed on the same day, 11 January 1999, at Berkeley. Committal proceedings under the Justices Act 1902 (“the Act”) to take place in 2000 involve both the plaintiff and another juvenile, TP, jointly charged with the plaintiff. A broad overview of the prosecution case is to be found in a police fact sheet. Put shortly, the prosecution case is that, a little after midnight on 11 January, the plaintiff, with a number of other young men, went to Mr Mason’s house with the intention of stealing a video recorder. They were wearing balaclavas. The plaintiff was armed with a knife. A struggle took place during which Mr Mason was stabbed a number of times as a result of which he died. Crown witnesses assert that it was the plaintiff who stabbed Mr Mason and that he also hit Mr Mason on the head a number of times with a steel bar.

2    During the course of the present proceedings I was told that the plaintiff had participated in an electronically recorded interview in which he admitted to having been present at or about the time of the death.

3 Pursuant Pt 4, Division 1, Sub-Division 7A of the Act, the prosecution has served on the plaintiff a number of statements of witnesses whom it proposes to call at a trial in the event that the plaintiff is committed for trial. The plaintiff’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JW v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWSC 1244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of JW v Director of Public Prosecutions involves the plaintiff, JW, who is charged with break enter and steal in circumstances of aggravation and the murder of Ralph Terrence Mason. JW's legal representatives sought directions under s 48E(2)(b) of the Justices Act 1902 for ten witnesses to attend for cross-examination at committal proceedings. The magistrate, the second defendant, granted the application for only one witness, CP, the brother of JW's co-accused, TP. JW challenges this decision by the magistrate, seeking a declaration that the magistrate erred in rejecting the applications for the other witnesses, and an order for the magistrate to reconsider the applications according to law.

The legal issue before the court was whether the magistrate applied an incorrect test in deciding whether there were substantial reasons for the witnesses to attend for cross-examination. The court considered whether the magistrate gave individual consideration to the witness statements and the purposes of the cross-examination outlined by JW's counsel, and whether the magistrate applied an excessively difficult test by requiring the cross-examination to have a "critical effect" or relate to a "key issue".

The court found that the magistrate did give individual consideration to the witness statements and purposes of the cross-examination. However, the magistrate applied an incorrect test by requiring the cross-examination to have a "critical effect" or relate to a "key issue". The court held that there are many legitimate purposes for cross-examination that fall short of meeting these tests. Accordingly, the magistrate erroneously directed himself in relation to the task permitted by s 48E(2)(b) of the Justices Act 1902.

The court made a declaration that the magistrate erred in rejecting the applications for the witnesses to attend for cross-examination and ordered the magistrate to reconsider the applications according to law.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff, JW, is an eighteen-year-old charged with the break and enter and steal of a video recorder under aggravated circumstances, and the murder of Ralph Terrence Mason. The charges relate to an incident on 11 January 1999 at Berkeley. According to the prosecution, JW and several other young men went to Mason's house intending to steal a video recorder. JW was armed with a knife, and a struggle ensued during which Mason was stabbed multiple times, resulting in his death. JW allegedly stabbed Mason and hit him on the head with a steel bar. JW admitted to being present during the incident in an electronically recorded interview. The case involves joint charges against JW and another juvenile, TP. The prosecution has served several witness statements on JW under the Justices Act 1902. JW's legal representatives sought directions for the attendance of ten witnesses for cross-examination. The magistrate, the second defendant, directed the attendance of only one witness, CP, the brother of TP. JW challenges this decision, seeking a declaration that the magistrate erred and an order for reconsideration.

JW filed a summons on 8 September 1999 challenging the magistrate's decision to reject the applications for witness attendance. The matter came before Simpson J in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, Administrative Law Division. The plaintiff argues that the magistrate failed to give individual consideration to the witness statements and the objectives outlined in the submissions for cross-examination. The defendant contends that the magistrate did consider the statements and arguments individually. Simpson J reviewed the magistrate's reasons and concluded that while individual consideration was given, the magistrate applied an incorrect test in making his decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the magistrate fail to give individual attention to the witness statements and the objectives for cross-examination as outlined in the submissions?
2. Did the magistrate apply an incorrect test in making his decision regarding the attendance of witnesses for cross-examination?

Held
1. The court held that the magistrate did not fail to give individual attention to the witness statements and the objectives for cross-examination as outlined in the submissions. The court found that the magistrate did give appropriate consideration to the statements of each of the witnesses.
2. The court held that the magistrate applied an incorrect test in making his decision regarding the attendance of witnesses for cross-examination. The court found that the magistrate erroneously directed himself in relation to the task permitted to him by s 48E(2)(b) of the Justices Act 1902.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the arguments of both parties regarding the magistrate's decision to reject applications for the attendance of witnesses at committal proceedings. The plaintiff argued that the magistrate failed to give individual attention to the witness statements and the stated objectives of cross-examining the witnesses. The Director argued that the magistrate did not fail to consider the statements or the argument in relation to each witness individually. The court examined the magistrate's reasons and found that he did give individual consideration to the statements of each of the witnesses. However, the court found that the magistrate applied an incorrect test in making his decision. The magistrate's test included factors such as whether cross-examination was likely to result in the discharge of the defendant or to establish grounds for a no bill application, which went beyond the legitimate purposes of cross-examination permitted by s 48E(2)(b) of the Justices Act 1902. The court noted that the test should not be limited to situations where cross-examination is likely to result in the discharge of the defendant, but rather should consider other legitimate purposes such as testing the reliability of evidence and exploring the strength and weaknesses of the evidence. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a magistrate must consider the legitimate purposes of cross-examination permitted by s 48E(2)(b) of the Justices Act 1902 and not apply an excessively difficult test to the disadvantage of the defendant.