Justin Anthony Firth Complainant AND :JBM Defendant

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

CITATION:Justin Anthony Firth v JBM [2018] NTLC034

PARTIES:Justin Anthony FIRTH

v

JBM

TITLE OF COURT:  Local Court

JURISDICTION:  Criminal

FILE NO(s):21744064, 21758768, 21759965

DELIVERED ON:  30 July 2018

DELIVERED AT:  Darwin

HEARING DATE(s):  27 February 2018

JUDGMENT OF:  Chief Judge Lowndes

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – MENTAL IMPAIRMENT DEFENCE – DISMISSAL

PROCESS UNDER SECTION 77 OF THE MENTAL HEALTH AND RELATED

SERVICES ACT – LACK OF KNOWLEDGE THAT CONDUCT WAS WRONG

Mental Health and Related Services Act s 77

O’Neill v Lockeyer [2012] NTSC 10 followed

R v Porter (1933) 55 CLR 182 followed

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Complainant:  Mr D Dalrymple

Defendant:Ms M Chen

Solicitors:

Complainant:  DPP

Defendant:NTLAC

Judgment category classification:       B

Judgment ID number:  [2018] NTLC 34

Number of paragraphs:  150      

IN THE LOCAL COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 21744064, 21758768, 21759965

BETWEEN:

Justin Anthony Firth

Complainant

AND:

JBM

Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 30 July 2018)

CHIEF JUDGE LOWNDES

INTRODUCTION

  1. The defendant was charged with the following offences:

    ·Three counts of engaging in conduct that contravenes a domestic violence order (file number 21744064);

    ·One count of damage to property (file number 21758768); and

    ·One count of breach of bail, one count of drive unregistered, one count of drive uninsured and one count of failing to produce a licence on request (file number 21759965).

  2. The defendant sought to have all the charges dismissed pursuant to s 77 of the Mental Health and Related Services Act (MHRSA). To that end certificates pursuant to s 77(2) of the MHRSA were requested and in due course provided to the Court.

  3. The Chief Health Officer, Dr Heggie, provided a s 77 certificate in relation to each of the three criminal files. In accordance with s 77(3) of the Act those certificates were issued on the basis of advice from a designated mental health practitioner, Mr Tim Jacobs.

  4. In relation to file numbers 217444064 and 21758768 Dr Heggie certified that:

    (a)the defendant was suffering from a mental illness or mental disturbance at the time of carrying out the conduct constituting the alleged offences and

    (b)that the mental illness or mental disturbance was likely to have materially contributed to the conduct.

  5. With respect to file number 21759965 Dr Heggie certified that although the defendant was suffering from a mental illness or mental disturbance at the time of carrying out the conduct constituting the alleged offences, that mental illness or mental disturbance was not likely to have materially contributed to the conduct.

  6. The advice from Mr Jacobs, which took the form of a report, supported the above certifications as well as documenting the reasons for the opinions he had formed (Exhibit 2).

  7. The application for dismissal of charges was heard by the Court on 27 February 2018. The only witness called to give evidence at the hearing was Mr Jacobs.

    THE DISMISSAL PROCESS UNDER SECTION 77 OF THE ACT

  8. The process for dismissal of charges under s 77 of the MHRSA begins with a request made by the Court to the Chief…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Justin Anthony Firth Complainant AND :JBM Defendant and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NTLC 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Justin Anthony Firth v JBM involved a dispute over the admissibility of medical certificates and the defendant's mental impairment as a defence. The Local Court of the Northern Territory was tasked with deciding whether the defendant's mental illness could be used as a defence for the alleged criminal offences. The primary legal issue was whether the defendant's mental impairment at the time of the offences could be considered a valid defence under the applicable criminal law.

The court examined the evidence provided by the defendant's mental health practitioner, Mr. Jacobs, who held various qualifications and had assessed the defendant's mental state. Mr. Jacobs provided reports stating that the defendant was suffering from a mental illness or disturbance at the time of the alleged offences, and in some cases, this condition likely contributed to the conduct constituting the offences. However, the court found that the medical certificates in question did not meet the necessary preconditions for admissibility under section 79 of the relevant Act. Even if they had been admissible, the court determined that they should be given no weight.

The court also considered the oral and documentary evidence given by Mr. Jacobs during the hearing of the application. The court assessed the credibility and relevance of this evidence in determining the defendant's mental state and its potential impact on the alleged offences. Ultimately, the court found that while the defendant likely suffered from a mental illness, it did not absolve him of criminal responsibility for the offences in question. The court dismissed the charges for two of the alleged offences but declined to dismiss the charges for the third offence.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the charges related to file numbers 21744064 and 21758768 but did not dismiss the charges for file number 21759965. The court's decision hinged on the assessment of the defendant's mental state and its relevance to the alleged criminal conduct, ultimately finding that the defendant's mental impairment did not sufficiently negate his criminal responsibility for the offences.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

These preconditions have not been satisfied, and therefore the certificates are not admissible under s 79 of the Act as an exception to s76 which establishes the “opinion rule” – which operates to exclude evidence of an opinion which a party seeks to use in order “to prove the existence of a fact about the existence of which the opinion was expressed”.[7] However, even if the certificates were admissible under s79(1) of the Act they should be given no weight.·Mr Jacobs’ Evidence It remains to consider the evidence given by Mr Jacobs - both documentary and oral. This evidence is constituted by the written advice/report he gave to the Chief Health Officer as well as the evidence he gave at the hearing of the s 77 application on 27 February 2018. It is proposed to first set out in detail Mr Jacobs’ evidence. That will be followed by a consideration of the admissibility of his evidence and the weight, if any, to be accorded to that evidence. ·Mr Jacobs’ Advice/Report to the Chief Health Officer By way of preamble to his advice, Mr Jacobs listed the following qualifications:Designated Mental Health Practitioner(DMHP) since May 2016 and a member of the Top End Health Service Forensic Team (FMHT) since 21 April 2016 – registered nurse with the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency – academic qualifications Batchelor of Nursing (University of Tasmania 2000); Graduate Diploma in Nursing (Flinders University 2004); and Masters in Forensic Mental Health (Griffith University 2014) – currently undertaking a Batchelor of Behavioural Studies Psychology through Swinburne University. In his advice to the Chief Heath Officer Mr Jacobs formed the following opinions:1. In relation to file numbers 21744064 and 21758768 he expressed the opinion that the defendant was suffering from a mental illness or mental disturbance at the time of the alleged offences and that his mental illness or disturbance was likely to have materially contributed to the conduct constituting the offences.2. In relation to file number 217599965 he expressed the opinion that although the defendant was suffering from a mental illness or mental disturbance at the time of the alleged offences his mental illness or disturbance was not likely to have materially contributed to the conduct constituting the offences. In reaching these opinions, Mr Jacobs relied upon the following information.1. The defendant was involuntarily admitted to the Top End Mental Health Services (TEMHS) inpatient psychiatric facility from 4 to 8 August 2017 (which was during the same month as the offences alleged on file number 21744064). The Discharge Summary completed by Dr Sarah Elbelassi (resident medical officer) stated that the diagnosis was “Relapse Schizophrenia due to non -compliance (likely substance use may be contributing)”. It was also reported that the defendant had experienced suicidal ideation, and was suffering from paranoid delusions that his former girlfriend (Ms Ricki Killeen, the victim in the matter) was involved with outlaw motor cycle gangs and that they had been injecting him with methamphetamines without his consent. 2. On 10 August 2017, 3 days prior to the alleged offences on file number 21744064, the defendant was assessed at his place of residence by Dr Rajiv Weerasundera (psychiatrist) who reported that he was “anxious and paranoid”, presenting with “persecutory delusions of being poisoned”. The psychiatrist also noted “schizophrenia, early signs of relapse” plus high risk of deterioration.3. On 21 August 2107, two days following the third alleged offence on file 21744064, the defendant was assessed by a social worker, Ms Sophie Smith, who noted that the defendant’s thought content included: “ paranoid and persecutory delusions, continues to voice concerns about being poisoned and his ex - girlfriend having revenge on him having injected him with drugs”. When she subsequently assessed the defendant on 29 August 2017 the social worker recorded that he was experiencing: “ongoing paranoid and persecutory delusions, these seen to have diminished slightly (sitting under the surface) still believes that there was a revenge attack against him and people were injecting his feet with drugs at night”.4. On 13 September 2017, the defendant was again assessed by the social worker, it being noted that he “continued to be preoccupied discussing the ‘revenge attack’ that he felt had happened to him. It was difficult to interrupt [the defendant] when he was discussing this and he spoke over [his] CM (case- manager) to continue this conversation. [The defendant] spoke about this at some length”.5. On 28 September 2017 the defendant was again assessed by the psychiatrist (Dr Rajiv Weerasundera) when “paranoid and persecutory delusions” were noted.6. On 11 October 2017, about 12 days prior to the alleged offence associated with file number 21758768, the defendant was once again reviewed by the social worker. It was recorded that ongoing paranoid and persecutory delusions remained, including the defendant’s belief that he had been previously assaulted by his former girlfriend (“revenge attack”).7. On 30 October 2017, about 7 days after the alleged offence associated with file number 21758768, the defendant was again reviewed by the social worker, with the following being noted: “ ongoing paranoid and persecutory delusions remain, and this included [the defendant’s] belief that he was previously assaulted by his ex-girlfriend: revenge attack”. 8. On 15 November 2017, Dr Gregory Spicer (psychiatric registrar) assessed the defendant, recording that he had stated that the mafia might have been involved in his girlfriend injecting him with drugs previously. The defendant was assessed as being “delusional, potentially experiencing perceptual disturbances, and requiring inpatient psychiatric assessment and admission”. 9. On 15 November up until 20 December 2017, the defendant was admitted to the TEMHS inpatient psychiatric facility.[8] According to the discharge summary completed by the resident medical officer, Dr Emma Martin, the defendant’s admission was due to “…relapse of his condition (chronic schizophrenia secondary to medication non-compliance and substance use – THC and ice”. It was reported that the defendant’s “thought content included the mafia sending him messages, attempting to recruit him” Auditory hallucinations and lack of insight into his mental health symptoms were also recorded. It was further recorded that over the course of his admission his auditory hallucinations resolved; however, the mental state examination conducted at the time of his discharge revealed “ongoing symptomology, yet of a reduced intensity”. His “persistent paranoid/persecutory delusions regarding the mafia” were also recorded.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In conclusion I turn to the alleged offending on file number 21759965. Although I accept that the defendant is likely to have been suffering from a mental illness at the material time, I am not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that he did not know that the conduct constituting the offences was wrong. DECISION I dismiss the charges laid on file numbers 21744064 and 21758768, but decline to dismiss the charges on file number 21759965.Dated 30 July 2018………………………………..Dr John LowndesChief Judge of the Local Court of the Northern Territory

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established