Justelle Nominees Pty Ltd v Martin [No 3]

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   JUSTELLE NOMINEES PTY LTD -v- MARTIN [No 3] [2009] WASC 264

CORAM:   BLAXELL J

HEARD:   16, 17 & 23 FEBRUARY, 23 & 29 APRIL 2009

DELIVERED          :   17 SEPTEMBER 2009

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1861 of 2006

BETWEEN:   JUSTELLE NOMINEES PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

GAVIN WILLIAM MARTIN
NATALIE MARTIN
Defendants

Catchwords:

Landlord and tenant - Purported termination of lease for non-payment of rent - Action by landlord for possession, arrears of rent and damages - Counterclaim for damages for landlord's breach of repair covenant - Extent of landlord's obligation to repair - Whether lease validly terminated by service of writ - Causal nexus between non-payment of rent and landlord's breach of repair covenant - Surrender of lease by operation of law

Legislation:

Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 14
Property Law Act 1969 (WA), s 81

Result:

Judgment to plaintiff for arrears of rent
Judgment to defendants for nominal damages

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr D J Morris

Defendants:     In person

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Bruce Havilah & Associates

Defendants:     In person

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Andrews v Hogan (1952) 86 CLR 223

Clowes v Bentley Pty Ltd (1970) WAR 24

Dare v Pulham (1982) 148 CLR 658

Dickinson v St Aubyn (1944) 1 All ER 370

DTR Nominees Pty Ltd v Mona Homes (1978) 138 CLR 423

Emhill Pty Ltd v Bonsoc Pty Ltd (No 2) [2007] VSCA 108

Granada Theatres Ltd v Freehold Investment (Leytonstone) Ltd (1958) 2 All ER 551

Idameneo Pty Ltd v Ticco Pty Ltd [2004] NSWCA 329

McCarrick v Liverpool Corporation [1947] AC 219

Morris v Baron & Co [1918] AC 1

Oastler v Henderson (1877) 2 QBD 575

Roadshow Entertainment Pty Ltd v CEL Home Video Pty Ltd [1997] 42 NSWLR 462

Rosa Investments Pty Ltd v Spencer Shier Pty Ltd [1965] VR 97

Sharp v O'Driscoll (Unreported, Library No 970111, 21 March 1997)

Tomlinson v Cut Price Deli Pty Ltd (1992) 38 FCR 490

Wheeler v Keeble Ltd [1920] 1 Ch 57

  1. BLAXELL J:  The present proceedings arise from a lease of the hotel premises at Lot 4 Great Eastern Highway, Bindoon known as the Bindoon Country Inn (the property). 

  2. At all material times prior to July 2002, the registered proprietor of the property was Mr Ian Henry, and he was also the licensee and owner of the business of the inn.  On 22 July 2002 the freehold in the property was sold to the plaintiff, but Mr Henry continued to occupy the premises as licensee, and as lessee of the inn for a term of 15 years.

  3. On 20 February 2004 Mr Henry sold the business of the Inn to the defendants, and they entered into occupation of the property as assignees of the lease for the balance of the term.  Thereafter, disputes arose between the parties over various matters including arrears of rent, non-payment of rates, and responsibility for repair of damage caused by termites.  Notices of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Justelle Nominees Pty Ltd v Martin [No 3] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] WASC 264
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Justelle Nominees Pty Ltd v Martin [No 3] involved a dispute between a landlord and tenant over the termination of a lease, arrears of rent, damages, and a counterclaim for damages by the landlord for the tenant's alleged breach of repair covenant. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The central legal issues before the court were the extent of the landlord's obligation to repair, whether the lease was validly terminated by the service of the writ, and if there was a causal nexus between the non-payment of rent and the landlord's breach of repair covenant.

The court found that all of the damage caused by the termites constituted 'items of damage in respect of the leased premises which are not specifically the responsibility of the lessee'. Therefore, the landlord was required to repair this damage under clause 12.3 of the lease. However, the obligation under clause 12.3 only arose when the landlord became aware of the termite damage, which was some months prior to September 2005 in this case. The court also found that the tenant failed to clean gutters, service equipment, and maintain the premises in a clean condition, thereby breaching the full terms of clause 7.1 of the lease. Additionally, the court found that the landlord was responsible for certain repairs as per clauses 7.1, 11.1, and other terms of the lease.

The court held that the tenant was at least 14 days in arrears in payment of rent after 9 April 2005, allowing the landlord to re-enter the leased premises without notice or terminate the lease forthwith under clause 14.3.1. The court noted that the landlord was not required to serve a notice of default before exercising this right. However, the landlord had served an erroneous notice of default on 21 June 2006, which did not affect their right to terminate the lease. The court found that the landlord must rely on the service of the writ of summons on 17 August 2006 to bring the lease to an end, as per Rosa Investments Pty Ltd v Spencer Shier Pty Ltd [1965] VR 97.

The final orders of the court were that judgment was to be entered in favour of the landlord for arrears of rent, and in favour of the tenant for nominal damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgment to plaintiff for arrears of rent

Judgment to defendants for nominal damages

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

All of the damage caused by the termites constituted 'items of damage in respect of the leased premises which are not specifically the responsibility of the lessee'. It follows that cl 12.3 required that the plaintiff repair this damage. However, given that the termite damage was latent and unobservable at the time of commencement of the lease, the obligation under cl 12.3 only arose when the plaintiff became aware of its existence (McCarrick v Liverpool Corporation [1947] AC 219, 231 ‑ 232). On the facts as found, the plaintiff was well aware of the termite damage some months prior to September 2005. To the extent that the defendants failed to clean gutters, service equipment and maintain the premises in a clean condition, I find that they were in breach of the full terms of cl 7.1 of the lease. I also find that pursuant to cl 7.1, cl 11.1 and other terms of the lease, the plaintiffs were responsible for the following repairs (and two additional items) the subject of the claim by the plaintiffs: For the reasons summarised below, I am not satisfied that the defendants were obliged to carry out the following repair items which are the subject of specific claims by the plaintiff: c)Supply of electrical items by Zenelec ($1,272.75): the invoice for this item would seem to relate to the accommodation units, and to work which became necessary as a result of the termite damage.f)Replace fuses at hotel and site meeting with Western Power Inspect ‑ Foresthills Electrics Pty Ltd ($132.00): these costs seem to relate to the repair of damage in the accommodation units.h)Bin hire ‑ Bullsbrook Hiab ($330.00): it is my understanding that the bins were required for debris from the accommodation units.m)Repair to urinal and damage to mens toilet ‑ Eddy's Plumbing & Gas, MST and Pekka Korhonen ($3,844.95): the evidence from Mr Faigen's report establishes that this damage was the result of movement of the stonework wall. It was consequential upon the plaintiff's failure to maintain the wall in a sound structural condition. At all material times after 9 April 2005, the defendants were at least 14 days in arrears in payment of rent. Accordingly, cl 14.3.1 allowed the plaintiff to re‑enter the leased premises without notice or to terminate the lease forthwith. The plaintiff was under no obligation to serve a notice of default before exercising this right, given that s 81 of the Property Law Act 1969 (WA) does not affect the law relating to re‑entry in case of non‑payment of rent (see subs 81(9)). Likewise, cl 14.2 of the lease did not make such a notice mandatory. Nevertheless, the plaintiff served on the defendants a notice of default dated 21 June 2006 (exhibit 10) which erroneously overstated the arrears of rent which were then outstanding. Quite obviously, this defect (in what was an unnecessary notice) did not affect the plaintiff's continuing right under cl 14.3.1 to terminate the lease forthwith. However the plaintiff did not at any time serve a further notice terminating the lease, and in these circumstances, the plaintiff must necessarily rely upon service of its writ of summons (on or about 17 August 2006) as having brought the lease to an end. In Rosa Investments Pty Ltd v Spencer Shier Pty Ltd [1965] VR 97, Sholl J held (at 105) that:Unless on the construction of the lease, or otherwise, there is a dispensation with the requirement of re-entry, a lessor must still, I think, in order to take advantage of a forfeiture which requires him to exercise it by re-entry, either proceed by an action for possession in the Supreme Court (which by a long course of authority is held equivalent to re-entry) or do something amounting to a demand on the demised premises, on the lessee or the person in possession, for immediate possession thereof, whether by verbal request or by service of clear written notice. (See also Wheeler v Keeble Ltd [1920] 1 Ch 57, and Tomlinson v Cut Price Deli Pty Ltd (1992) 38 FCR 490.)