Just Water Pty Ltd v ACN 130 166 899 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Just Water Pty Ltd & Anor v ACN 130 166 899 Pty Ltd & Anor [2018] QDC 168

PARTIES:

JUST WATER PTY LTD (ACN 153 825 266)
(applicant/first defendant)

and

RICHARD JOHANNES CORNELIS HUISMAN
(applicant/second defendant)

v

ACN 130 166 899 PTY LTD at (ACN 130 166 899) (in liquidation) AS TRUSTEE FOR AI BUILDERS TRUST (ABN 22910450260)
(first respondent/first plaintiff)

and

DAVID HAMBLETON AS LIQUIDATOR OF ACN 130 166 899 PTY LTD (ACN 130 166 899) (IN LIQUIDATION) AS TRUSTEE FOR AI BUILDERS TRUST (ABN 22910450260)
(second respondent/second plaintiff)

FILE NO/S:

BD1061/18

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Chamber application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

22 August 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

20 August 2018

JUDGE:

Richards DCJ

ORDER:

1.     The plaintiffs are to provide further particulars of paragraphs 6, 7, 9, 9 (f), 9(g), 9(h), 12(a), 12(b), 12(c), 18 and 19 of the statement of claim within 14 days.

2.     The defendants have 21 days after the receipt of the further particulars to file a defence in response to the statement of claim.

3.     The plaintiffs pay the costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – PLEADINGS – PARTICULARS – FURTHER AND BETTER – where the first and second applicants made an application for further and better particulars – where the respondents provided documents to support the pleadings - whether the respondents have adequately plead and particularised the case against the applicants. 

SOLICITORS:

Mr S Moore from Stokes Moore for the applicants

Mr B Long of Celtic Legal for the respondents

  1. This is an application for further particulars of a statement of claim filed on 21 March 2018.  A request for further particulars was served on 27 June 2018.  An ineffective response was given on 13 July 2018.  Further letters were sent on 18 July and 24 July 2018.  On 25 July 2018 a response was given purporting to provide particulars in response to the request.  That response attached 214 pages of documents and this application was consequently brought.

  1. Rule 157 of the UCPR provides that:

“A party must include in a pleading particulars necessary to –

(a)        Define the issues for, and prevent surprise at, the trial; and

(b)        Enable the opposite party to plead; and

(c)        Support a matter specifically pleaded under rule 150.”

  1. Rule 160 provides that a party giving further particulars must file a copy of the particulars. It is common ground that this has not happened.

  1. The plaintiffs seek to recover compensation from the defendants for the loss accrued by the company incurring debts whilst it was insolvent. The claims are made against the first defendant under section 588V and 588W of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“the Act”) as a holding company and against the second defendant under section 588M of the Act as a director of the first defendant.

  1. The original claim seeks a declaration that the first defendant contravened s588V(1) of the Act in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Just Water Pty Ltd v ACN 130 166 899 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QDC 168
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Just Water Pty Ltd v ACN 130 166 899 Pty Ltd, the applicants sought further and better particulars regarding specific paragraphs of the statement of claim filed by the respondents. The dispute, heard in the Supreme Court, revolved around the adequacy of the respondents' pleadings and whether they had sufficiently detailed their case against the applicants. The applicants argued that certain paragraphs of the statement of claim were vague and did not provide enough detail to adequately respond.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the respondents had adequately pleaded and particularised their case against the applicants. The court needed to determine if the information provided in the statement of claim was sufficient for the applicants to prepare a meaningful defence. The court considered the extent to which the respondents had provided documents to support their pleadings and whether these documents sufficiently detailed the claims made.

The court held that the respondents had not adequately pleaded and particularised their case against the applicants. The court found that several paragraphs of the statement of claim were insufficiently detailed and required further particulars. The court ordered the applicants to provide further particulars of specific paragraphs within 14 days. The respondents were then given 21 days to file a defence after receiving these further particulars. Additionally, the court ordered the applicants to pay the costs of and incidental to the application, to be assessed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiffs are to provide further particulars of paragraphs 6, 7, 9, 9 (f), 9(g), 9(h), 12(a), 12(b), 12(c), 18 and 19 of the statement of claim within 14 days.

2. The defendants have 21 days after the receipt of the further particulars to file a defence in response to the statement of claim.

3. The plaintiffs pay the costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The proceedings in Just Water Pty Ltd v ACN 130 166 899 Pty Ltd arose from a dispute concerning water rights and contractual obligations. Just Water Pty Ltd, the first applicant, is a company involved in the water industry and provided water services to various clients. ACN 130 166 899 Pty Ltd, the second respondent, was engaged by Just Water to manage and operate certain water infrastructure. The relationship between the parties deteriorated, leading to the first applicant initiating legal proceedings against the second respondent for alleged breaches of contract and misrepresentations.

The first applicant filed a statement of claim outlining various allegations against the second respondent. These included claims that the second respondent had failed to fulfil its contractual obligations, made misrepresentations regarding its compliance with regulatory requirements, and had engaged in conduct that resulted in financial loss to the first applicant. The first applicant sought damages and other relief for the alleged breaches. In response, the second respondent filed a defence, denying the allegations and asserting that it had performed its contractual duties and that any issues were due to the first applicant's mismanagement.

Subsequent to the exchange of pleadings, the first and second applicants made an application for further and better particulars regarding specific paragraphs of the statement of claim. They contended that the details provided in the statement of claim were insufficient to enable a proper defence and to identify the precise nature of the claims. In support of their position, the applicants submitted that they required more detailed information to adequately respond to the allegations and prepare their defence. The second respondent, in turn, provided documents to support their pleadings, arguing that they had adequately particularised their case against the applicants.

The case now rests on whether the second respondent has sufficiently pleaded and particularised the case against the applicants, as required under the rules of civil procedure. The first and second applicants seek further particulars to clarify the allegations and ensure that they can mount an effective defence. The second respondent contends that they have met the necessary standards of particularisation and provided adequate information to respond to the claims.

The matter of Just Water Pty Ltd v ACN 130 166 899 Pty Ltd originated as a dispute between two companies, with the first and second applicants, Just Water Pty Ltd, seeking relief from the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The applicants filed a statement of claim against the respondents, ACN 130 166 899 Pty Ltd, alleging various breaches and seeking corresponding remedies. In response, the respondents filed a defence and counterclaim, which the applicants deemed insufficiently particularised. Consequently, the applicants made an application for further and better particulars, specifically targeting certain paragraphs of the respondents' pleadings. The respondents subsequently provided documents in support of their pleadings. The procedural history leading up to this application included the initial filing of the statement of claim, the respondents' defence and counterclaim, and the applicants' dissatisfaction with the level of detail provided in the respondents' pleadings. This dissatisfaction culminated in the applicants' application for further and better particulars, which the court has now addressed by ordering the applicants to provide further particulars on specified paragraphs of their statement of claim and granting the respondents a period to file a defence in response. Additionally, the court ordered the applicants to pay the costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the respondents have adequately pleaded and particularised the case against the applicants.
2. Whether the respondents' documents sufficiently support the pleadings provided to the applicants.
3. Whether the plaintiffs are required to provide further particulars of specific paragraphs of the statement of claim.
4. What time frame should be set for the plaintiffs to provide the further particulars.
5. What time frame should be set for the defendants to file a defence after the receipt of the further particulars.
6. Whether the plaintiffs should be ordered to pay the costs of and incidental to the application, and if so, how they should be assessed.

Held
1. The court concluded that the respondents have not adequately pleaded and particularised the case against the applicants, and further particulars are required.
2. The court determined that the respondents' documents do not sufficiently support the pleadings provided to the applicants.
3. The plaintiffs are required to provide further particulars of specific paragraphs of the statement of claim as outlined in the orders.
4. The plaintiffs must provide the further particulars within 14 days.
5. The defendants have 21 days after receiving the further particulars to file a defence.
6. The court ordered the plaintiffs to pay the costs of and incidental to the application, with the costs to be assessed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Just Water Pty Ltd v ACN 130 166 899 Pty Ltd, the primary issue revolved around the adequacy of the pleadings and particulars provided by the respondents against the applicants. The court considered whether the respondents had sufficiently pleaded and particularised their case to enable the applicants to respond appropriately. The court emphasised that for a pleading to be adequate, it must provide sufficient detail to enable the opposing party to understand the case against them and to prepare a meaningful defence. The court applied this principle to the facts, noting that the respondents' pleadings, while generally comprehensive, fell short in certain specific paragraphs.

The court also examined whether the respondents' documents adequately supported the pleadings provided to the applicants. The court found that while the documents provided some support, they did not sufficiently address the deficiencies in the pleadings. The court underscored the importance of the alignment between pleadings and supporting documents to ensure transparency and fairness in litigation. The court held that the documents, while helpful, did not fully bridge the gap left by the insufficient particulars in the pleadings, thus necessitating further clarification from the respondents.

In addressing the need for further particulars, the court identified specific paragraphs of the statement of claim that required additional detail. The court ordered the plaintiffs to provide further particulars of paragraphs 6, 7, 9, 9(f), 9(g), 9(h), 12(a), 12(b), 12(c), 18, and 19. This decision was based on the need for clarity and precision in these areas to allow the applicants to effectively respond to the allegations. The court's reasoning was grounded in the principle that particulars must be sufficient to enable the defendants to answer the claims with precision and avoid the risk of surprise at trial.

The court then set a time frame for the plaintiffs to provide these further particulars, determining that they should do so within 14 days. This timeframe was considered reasonable to allow the plaintiffs to prepare and submit the required information without undue delay to the proceedings. The court balanced the need for promptness in litigation with the necessity for the plaintiffs to provide adequate particulars.

Subsequently, the court established a time frame for the defendants to file their defence after receiving the further particulars. The court set 21 days from the receipt of the further particulars as the period within which the defendants must file their defence. This decision reflected the court's aim to maintain an efficient and timely progression of the case while ensuring that the defendants had sufficient opportunity to respond to the detailed allegations.

Finally, the court addressed the issue of costs, ordering the plaintiffs to pay the costs of and incidental to the application. The court noted that the need for further particulars arose from the plaintiffs' initial failure to provide sufficiently detailed pleadings. The court's decision to order costs was based on the principle that parties should bear the costs of their own litigation failings. The court held that the costs should be assessed, indicating a formal process to determine the exact amount owed.

In summary, the court's decision in Just Water Pty Ltd v ACN 130 166 899 Pty Ltd underscores the importance of precise and adequate pleadings in civil litigation. The ratio decidendi of this case is that parties must provide sufficient particulars in their pleadings to enable the opposing party to adequately respond, and failure to do so may result in orders for further particulars and the imposition of costs. The court's approach demonstrates a commitment to ensuring clarity and fairness in the litigation process, balancing the need for detailed information with the imperative of procedural efficiency.