Lenard's Pty Ltd v. Gow Pty Ltd and Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Lenard’s Pty Ltd v Gow Pty Ltd and Ors [2007] QSC 377

PARTIES:

LENARD’S PTY LTD
ACN  010 711 145
(First plaintiff)
THE POULTRY SHOP LEASING (NSW) PTY LTD
ACN 060 545 440
(Second plaintiff)
v
SAM GOW PTY LTD
ACN 105 809 825
(First defendant)
SAMANTHA CATHERINE GOW
(Second defendant)
LINDA JANE GOW
(Third defendant)
GREG SALMON
(Fourth defendant)
MARKETING MASTERS (QLD) PTY LTD
ACN 092 109 389
(Fifth defendant)

FILE NO:

SC No 11002 of 2004

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

COURT:

Supreme Court

DELIVERED ON:

20 November 2007

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

20 November 2007

JUDGE:

Fryberg J

ORDER:

1.  Paragraph 10 of the further and better particulars filed 17 September 2007, including all sub-paragraphs thereof, be struck out;

2.  The time for compliance by the first, second and third defendants with the order of Justice Chesterman, dated 11 September 2007 be extended to 4 December 2007;

3.  Any further amended defence and counterclaim be filed and delivered by the first, second and third defendants no later than 31 January 2008;

4.  Any request for further disclosure on the part of the plaintiffs be made by the first, second and third defendants in the form of a particularised letter to be delivered no later than 31 January 2008;

5.  The parties have liberty to apply on at least two business days notice to the other parties;

6.  The first, second and third defendants pay the first and second plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to this application on the indemnity basis.

CATCHWORDS:

Procedure – Supreme Court procedure – Queensland – Procedure under rules of court – Pleading – Particulars – Purpose of particulars – Duty of drawer to assist parties and the court

COUNSEL:

Plaintiffs:  S Farrell
Defendants:  M Hall

SOLICITORS:

Plaintiff: Hall Lawyers
Defendants: DLA Phillips Fox

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CIVIL JURISDICTION

[2007] QSC 377

FRYBERG J

No 11002 of 2004

LENARD'S PTY LTD
(ACN 010 711 145)
First Plaintiff

and

THE POULTRY SHOP LEASING (NSW) PTY LTD
(ACN 060 545 440)
Second Plaintiff

and

SAM GOW PTY LTD
(ACN 105 809 825)
First Defendant

and

SAMANTHA CATHERINE GOW Second Defendant

and

LINDA JANE GOW Third Defendant

and

GREG SALMON Fourth Defendant

and

MARKETING MASTERS (QLD) PTY LTD
(ACN 092 109 389)
Fifth Defendant

BRISBANE

..DATE 20/11/2007

ORDER

HIS HONOUR:  This is an application by the plaintiffs for an order that a subparagraph of the amended counter-claim be struck out for non-compliance with an order of the Court.  On the 11th of September, Chesterman J ordered the defendants to provide further and better particulars in response to, among other things, paragraph 10 of the plaintiff's request for particulars dated 16 March 2006.  This was not the first time that particulars had been ordered.  An earlier order made by Philippides J had not resulted in a satisfactory outcome.

The plaintiffs seek orders now, because although the defendants purported to comply with Chesterman J's order, they submit that the particulars provided are not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lenard's Pty Ltd v. Gow Pty Ltd and Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] QSC 377
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Lenard's Pty Ltd v. Gow Pty Ltd and Ors, the dispute centred on the adequacy of particulars provided in the proceedings before the Supreme Court of Queensland. The plaintiffs sought to have certain particulars struck out, alleging they were overly broad and vague, which impeded the defendants' ability to prepare a proper defence. The defendants, in turn, argued that the particulars were necessary for the fair administration of the case and were within the permissible scope.

The court was tasked with determining whether the particulars provided by the plaintiffs were sufficiently detailed to assist the defendants in preparing their defence and counterclaim. Additionally, the court had to decide whether the plaintiffs' application to strike out certain particulars was justified and whether any extensions of time were warranted for the defendants to comply with the order and prepare their amended defence and counterclaim.

In its reasoning, the court found that the particulars in question were indeed too broad and lacked the necessary specificity. The court held that the duty of the party who drafted the particulars was to assist both the opposing parties and the court in understanding the claims and the basis of the action. The court acknowledged the need for flexibility in pleading but emphasised that particulars must not be oppressive or vague. The court granted the plaintiffs' application to strike out the contentious particulars, extended the time for compliance with the previous order, and set new deadlines for the filing of amended defences and counterclaims, along with any requests for further disclosure. The defendants were also ordered to pay the plaintiffs' costs on an indemnity basis.

The final orders of the court included the striking out of specific paragraphs of the particulars, an extension of time for compliance with a previous order, a set deadline for filing amended defences and counterclaims, a requirement for particularised letters for further disclosure requests, liberty for the parties to apply for further orders, and an order for the defendants to pay the plaintiffs' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Paragraph 10 of the further and better particulars filed 17 September 2007, including all sub-paragraphs thereof, be struck out;

2. The time for compliance by the first, second and third defendants with the order of Justice Chesterman, dated 11 September 2007 be extended to 4 December 2007;

3. Any further amended defence and counterclaim be filed and delivered by the first, second and third defendants no later than 31 January 2008;

4. Any request for further disclosure on the part of the plaintiffs be made by the first, second and third defendants in the form of a particularised letter to be delivered no later than 31 January 2008;

5. The parties have liberty to apply on at least two business days notice to the other parties;

6. The first, second and third defendants pay the first and second plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to this application on the indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Lenard's Pty Ltd initiated legal proceedings against Gow Pty Ltd and others, alleging breaches of contract and seeking damages. The defendants filed a defence and counterclaim, to which Lenard's Pty Ltd sought further and better particulars. The defendants subsequently filed the requested particulars on 17 September 2007. Lenard's Pty Ltd then made an application to strike out certain portions of these particulars, arguing they were irrelevant and oppressive. The application also sought an extension of time for the defendants to comply with an earlier order, as well as directions for further particulars and disclosure.

The matter initially came before the court on an application by Lenard's Pty Ltd to strike out parts of the further and better particulars filed by the defendants. This was following an earlier order by Justice Chesterman on 11 September 2007, which the defendants had not complied with. The application was heard on its merits, and the court considered the submissions of both parties regarding the propriety of the particulars and the need for any extensions of time or further directions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether paragraph 10 of the further and better particulars filed on 17 September 2007, including all sub-paragraphs thereof, should be struck out.
2. Whether the time for compliance by the first, second, and third defendants with the order of Justice Chesterman, dated 11 September 2007, should be extended.
3. Whether directions should be made for any further amended defence and counterclaim to be filed by the first, second, and third defendants.
4. Whether directions should be made for any request for further disclosure on the part of the plaintiffs to be made by the first, second, and third defendants.
5. Whether the parties should have liberty to apply on at least two business days notice to the other parties.
6. Whether the first, second, and third defendants should pay the first and second plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to this application on the indemnity basis.

Held
1. Paragraph 10 of the further and better particulars filed on 17 September 2007, including all sub-paragraphs thereof, should be struck out.
2. The time for compliance by the first, second, and third defendants with the order of Justice Chesterman, dated 11 September 2007, should be extended to 4 December 2007.
3. Any further amended defence and counterclaim should be filed and delivered by the first, second, and third defendants no later than 31 January 2008.
4. Any request for further disclosure on the part of the plaintiffs should be made by the first, second, and third defendants in the form of a particularised letter to be delivered no later than 31 January 2008.
5. The parties should have liberty to apply on at least two business days notice to the other parties.
6. The first, second, and third defendants should pay the first and second plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to this application on the indemnity basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Lenard's Pty Ltd v. Gow Pty Ltd and Ors, the court examined the procedural aspects of the case, particularly focusing on the compliance with procedural orders and the content of the pleadings. Firstly, the court found that paragraph 10 of the further and better particulars was struck out because it contained information that was not relevant to the case and was potentially prejudicial. The court emphasised the duty of the party drafting the particulars to provide information that assists both the parties and the court in understanding the case clearly and fairly.

Secondly, regarding the extension of time for compliance with the previous order, the court noted the procedural delays and considered the reasons provided by the defendants. It was held that an extension was warranted to ensure that the defendants could properly comply with the order and to avoid further unnecessary delays. The court set a specific deadline of 4 December 2007 for compliance.

Thirdly, the court ordered that any further amended defence and counterclaim be filed by the defendants by 31 January 2008. The court stressed the importance of finalising the pleadings to allow the case to proceed efficiently and without further interruptions.

Fourthly, the court directed that any request for further disclosure from the plaintiffs should be made by a particularised letter by the same deadline. This was to ensure that the defendants could make targeted requests for information necessary for their defence, thereby streamlining the discovery process.

Fifthly, the court granted the parties the liberty to apply to each other with at least two business days’ notice. This was to facilitate efficient communication and procedural fairness between the parties.

Finally, the court ordered the defendants to pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the application on an indemnity basis. The court found that the defendants' actions contributed to the need for the application and the subsequent orders, justifying the indemnity costs order.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that parties must adhere to procedural rules and provide relevant information in their pleadings. The court will intervene to ensure that the case progresses fairly and efficiently, striking out irrelevant or prejudicial content and setting clear deadlines for compliance and further amendments. The court also has the authority to order costs on an indemnity basis where a party’s conduct necessitates additional procedural steps.