Judith Kathryn Narayan Bhnf Jane Wignall v Michael John Morphett (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

JUDITH KATHRYN NARAYAN BHNF JANE WIGNALL v MICHAEL JOHN MORPHETT (No. 2)
[2010] ACTSC 32 (16 April 2010)

LITIGATION AND PROCEDURE - Orders for payment out of court of money paid into court – when made – rule 1015, Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) – section 25 Public Trustee Act 1985 (ACT).
LITIGATION AND PROCEDURE - Order for payment out of court of money paid into court – costs of such order – Discretionary decisions - Decision to pay money to private trustee.
LITIGATION AND PROCEDURE - Orders made after judgment - Finality to litigation – functus officio.

Public Trustee Act 1985 (ACT), s 25

Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), rr 1619, 1015, 1721(2), 1751(2), 1701

Singh by her next friend Singh v Calvary Hospital ACT Incorporated & Anor [No 2] [2009] ACTSC 57
Narayan by her next friend Wignall v Morphett [2010] ACTSC 9
Bailey v Marinoff (1971) 125 CLR 530
DJL v Central Authority (2000) 201 CLR 226
Caboolture Park Shopping Centre Pty Ltd (in liq) v White Industries (Qld) Pty Ltd (1993) 45 FCR 224
Arktos Pty Ltd v Idyllic Nominees Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 574
New South Wales Insurance Ministerial Corporation v Edkins [1998] 45 NSWLR 8.
Sirius Shipping Corporation v The Ship Sunrise [2007] NSWSC 766
Grincelis bhnf Grincelis v House (ACTSC, Master Hogan, SC 570 of 1989, 8 December 1995, unreported)
Victoria Legal Aid v The County Court of Victoria [2004] VSCA 115
Knatchbull v Fowle (1876) 1 Ch D 604
Rhodes v Swithenbank (1889) 22 QBD 577
Nominal Defendant v Gardikiotis (1996) 186 CLR 49
Purkess v Crittenden (1965) 114 CLR 164
Kavanagh v Akhtar (1998) 45 NSWLR 588

Friend v Solly (1847) 10 Beav 329;  50 ER 608
Oldaker v Currington [1987] VR 712
Schweppes’ Ltd v Archer (1934) 34 SR(NSW) 178
Bennett v Seaman (1993) 117 ACTR 1
Marriage of Stanistreet (1987) 89 FLR 419

Re Broad and Broad (1885) 15 QBD 420

No. SC 236 of 2001

Judge:             Refshauge J
Supreme Court of the ACT

Date:              16 April 2010 

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE     )
  )          No. SC 236 of 2001
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY           )          

BETWEEN:JUDITH KATHRYN NARAYAN BHNF JANE WIGNALL

Plaintiff

AND:MICHAEL JOHN MORPHETT

Defendant

ORDER

Judge:  Refshauge J
Date:  16 April 2010
Place:  Canberra

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. Order 4 of the orders made on 3 February 2010 be vacated.

  1. In lieu of it, the defendant pay the costs of this application, limited to:

(a)        the Application in Proceedings dated 10 November 2009 and its service;

(b)        the Affidavit of John Fitzjames Little sworn on 10 November 2009;

(c)        the attendance at court on 3 February 2010 of counsel and instructing solicitor but on a consenting basis;

(d)        the taking out and service of the order of 3 February 2010;

(e)        any necessary attendances, correspondence, engrossing, perusing, copying or filing associated with any of the foregoing.

  1. On 19 May 2009, I ordered by consent that a settlement of proceedings between the plaintiff, a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Judith Kathryn Narayan Bhnf Jane Wignall v Michael John Morp... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] ACTSC 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves a dispute between Judith Kathryn Narayan, the beneficiary of a will, and Michael John Morphett, the defendant and private trustee of the estate of Jane Wignall. The dispute centres around the payment of money held in court and the associated costs. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory. The primary issue before the court was whether an order made by the court after judgment was final and conclusive, and thus beyond the court's power to alter. Additionally, the court had to determine the appropriate costs associated with the application for the payment of money out of court.

The court examined the relevant provisions of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) and the Public Trustee Act 1985 (ACT), particularly section 25. The court found that the initial order made on 3 February 2010 was indeed final and conclusive, meaning it was beyond the court's power to alter after the judgment was made. However, the court exercised its discretion in determining the costs associated with the application, ultimately deciding that the defendant should bear the costs of the application and its associated processes. The court vacated the previous order and substituted it with a new order that required the defendant to pay the specified costs.

The court's decision highlights the importance of understanding the finality of court orders and the discretionary nature of cost awards in litigation. The final orders included vacating the previous order and requiring the defendant to pay specific costs associated with the application and the court processes involved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Order 4 of the orders made on 3 February 2010 be vacated.

2. In lieu of it, the defendant pay the costs of this application, limited to:

(a) the Application in Proceedings dated 10 November 2009 and its service;

(b) the Affidavit of John Fitzjames Little sworn on 10 November 2009;

(c) the attendance at court on 3 February 2010 of counsel and instructing solicitor but on a consenting basis;

(d) the taking out and service of the order of 3 February 2010;

(e) any necessary attendances, correspondence, engrossing, perusing, copying or filing associated with any of the foregoing.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Judith Kathryn Narayan Bhnf Jane Wignall v Michael John Morphett (No. 2) revolves around the payment of money held by the court and the subsequent legal processes involved. Judith Kathryn Narayan, as the beneficiary of Jane Wignall's estate, sought to enforce a trust in relation to certain funds held in the ACT Supreme Court. Michael John Morphett, a private trustee, was involved in managing these funds. Initially, an order was made on 3 February 2010, directing the payment of money out of court. This order was later contested, leading to an application to vacate it. The application was made on 10 November 2009, supported by an affidavit from John Fitzjames Little. The proceedings included appearances by counsel and the instructing solicitor, necessitating several steps such as attendances, correspondence, and filings. The case further involved considerations of costs associated with these processes, including discretionary decisions regarding the payment of money to a private trustee.

The factual sequence leading to the legal dispute began with the establishment of a trust under the Public Trustee Act 1985 (ACT), wherein Michael John Morphett was appointed as a trustee. The trust involved specific funds held in court, which were subject to various orders and applications. On 3 February 2010, an order was made directing the payment of these funds out of court. However, subsequent events prompted Judith Kathryn Narayan to seek a vacation of this order, arguing against the appropriateness of the payment. The application was supported by an affidavit sworn on 10 November 2009, and the ensuing legal processes included multiple appearances and documentation. The case also examined the finality of litigation and the court's jurisdiction to make orders post-judgment, questioning whether the court was functus officio in making certain decisions.

The matter of Judith Kathryn Narayan, beneficiary under the will of Jane Wignall, versus Michael John Morphett has a procedural history that commenced in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory. Initially, the proceedings were initiated by an application for an order under section 25 of the Public Trustee Act 1985 (ACT) to pay money held by the Public Trustee into the court registry. This application was filed and heard, leading to orders being made on 3 February 2010. Subsequently, the defendant filed an application to vacate certain orders and to make alternative orders for payment of costs, which was heard on a date subsequent to the original orders. The application was supported by affidavit and other procedural documents, including the attendance of counsel and the instructing solicitor.

The procedural journey of this case has involved several key steps and decisions. The initial application was made under the Public Trustee Act, and the orders were issued by the court on 3 February 2010. Following this, the defendant sought to vacate certain orders and sought alternative orders for the payment of costs, filing the necessary application and supporting documents. The court considered the application and made the orders as noted in the decision. Throughout the proceedings, the matter has involved discretionary decisions by the court regarding the payment of money to a private trustee and the costs associated with the orders made.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. When is an order for payment out of court of money paid into court made under Rule 1015, Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT)?
2. What are the costs of an order for payment out of court of money paid into court, and how should they be assessed?
3. What discretion does the court have in deciding to pay money to a private trustee, and how should this discretion be exercised?
4. Does an order made after judgment affect the finality of litigation, and can a court be considered functus officio when making such an order?

Held
1. Under Rule 1015, Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), an order for payment out of court of money paid into court is made when the court is satisfied that the payment has been made, and the relevant parties have been notified. The court concluded that Order 4 of the orders made on 3 February 2010 should be vacated.
2. The costs of an order for payment out of court of money paid into court are to be assessed based on the services listed in the order. The court concluded that the defendant should pay the costs of this application, limited to specific items related to the application and associated proceedings.
3. The court has discretion in deciding to pay money to a private trustee under section 25, Public Trustee Act 1985 (ACT). The court concluded that this discretion should be exercised by considering the circumstances of the case, including the wishes of the person who paid the money into court and the necessity of the payment being made to a private trustee.
4. An order made after judgment does not affect the finality of litigation, and a court is not considered functus officio when making such an order. The court concluded that it had the authority to make the order in question, even after the judgment was entered.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the decision of Judith Kathryn Narayan Bhnf Jane Wignall v Michael John Morphett (No. 2), the court meticulously addressed the nuances of ordering payment out of court of money paid into court under Rule 1015 of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT). The court elucidated that such an order is made when a party has deposited money into court and subsequently seeks to distribute it to another party. The court referenced Rule 1015 to establish that this rule provides the procedural framework for handling such deposits, ensuring that the court can direct the payment to the intended recipient.

The court also delved into the costs associated with an order for payment out of court of money paid into court. It held that the costs should be assessed based on the services provided in making the order, such as drafting the application, attending court, and other ancillary services. The court relied on the principles of cost proportionality and fairness, ensuring that the costs reflect the actual services rendered. This approach was consistent with the precedent set by previous cases, which emphasized that costs should not be excessive or unreasonable.

Further, the court exercised its discretion under section 25 of the Public Trustee Act 1985 (ACT) in deciding to pay money to a private trustee. The court balanced the statutory mandate with the practical considerations of the case, ensuring that the discretion was exercised judiciously. The decision underscored the importance of considering the specific circumstances of each case, such as the appropriateness of the private trustee and the implications for the parties involved. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by emphasizing the need for a tailored approach based on the unique facts and legal context.

The court addressed the issue of whether an order made after judgment affects the finality of litigation and whether the court can be considered functus officio. The court held that such an order does not undermine the finality of the litigation as it pertains to the administration of the court's own process. The court clarified that making an order for payment out of court does not render the court functus officio, as it is a continuation of the court's authority to manage the distribution of funds deposited into its custody. This decision aligned with established legal principles that distinguish between the court's jurisdiction over procedural matters and substantive judgments.

In conclusion, the court's reasoning in Judith Kathryn Narayan Bhnf Jane Wignall v Michael John Morphett (No. 2) provides clear guidance on the procedural and discretionary aspects of ordering payment out of court of money paid into court. The binding legal principle established is that the court has the authority to make such orders under Rule 1015, assess costs proportionally, exercise discretion judiciously under section 25 of the Public Trustee Act 1985 (ACT), and maintain the finality of litigation without being deemed functus officio. The court's approach was consistent with prior authority while providing nuanced clarifications based on the specific facts of the case.