Joseph R & Judith P Hlubucek -v- Arthur & Elizabeth Sinodinos

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Joseph R & Judith P Hlubucek -v- Arthur & Elizabeth Sinodinos  ACTRTT12 [2007]
Arthur & Elizabeth Sinodinos -v- Dr & Mrs Hlubucek

CATCHWORDS
End of lease – Compensation to lessor - “Fair wear and tear”

LEGISLATION
Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT)
Sections 29, 30, 31(a) and 38 
Clauses 63 and 64 Standard Residential Terms

CASE LAW

CASE REFERENCE NUMBER:    RT 88 of 2007
Joseph R & Judith P Hlubucek -v- Arthur & Elizabeth Sinodinos           
RE: Premises at 14 Kareelah Vista, O’Malley, ACT 2606

CASE REFERENCE NUMBER:    RT 159 of 2007
Arthur & Elizabeth Sinodinos -v- Dr & Mrs Hlubucek
RE: Premises at 14 Kareelah Vista, O’Malley, ACT 2606

DECISION

ORDERS

1That the tenants pay $500 to the lessors as compensation for the damage to the garage door to be deducted from the bond and released to the lessors on production to the Tribunal by the lessors of a receipt or receipts for the cost of the replacement or repair of the garage door.

2That the tenants pay to the lessors the sum of $50 for the cost of the replacement or repair of both controllers to be deducted from the bond and released to the lessors on production to the Tribunal by the lessors of a receipt or receipts for the cost of the replacement or repair of both controllers. 

3That the tenants pay the sum of $136.75 being for gas consumed on the premises to be deducted from the bond and paid to the lessors.

4That the tenants to pay compensation to the lessors in the sum of $363.00 for the removal of the satellite dish and associated wiring on production to the Tribunal by the lessors of a receipt or receipts for the cost of the removal of the dish and associated wiring.

5That the Office of rental Bonds is to release the balance of the bond in accordance with this Order. 

i.The lessors are to produce the receipts referred to in Orders 1-4 above to the Tribunal within 21 days. 

ii.If no receipts are so produced, the Tribunal Registry is to notify the Office of Rental Bonds to release the full balance of the bond to the tenants. 

iii.If receipts are produced for a lesser amount than set out in Orders 1-4 above, the Tribunal Registry is to notify the Office of Rental Bonds to release an amount representing the total of the receipts so produced to the lessors and to release the remaining balance of the bond to the tenants.  

6That the balance of the lessors’ claim is dismissed.

Member:           Jennifer David
Date:               26 April 2007

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

1.    Being in the nature of cross-actions, these matters were joined at the hearing on 13 March 2007. 

2. The four-year, fixed term tenancy of the premises at 14 Kareelah Vista, O’Malley in the ACT having ended; the Final Inspection took place on 11 December 2006. The lessors advised the tenants by letter dated 21 December 2006 that they intended to deduct from the bond the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Joseph R & Judith P Hlubucek -v- Arthur & Elizabeth Sinodino... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ACTRTT 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute between the Hlubucek's and the Sinodinos' involved claims and counter-claims regarding compensation for damages to the leased premises at 14 Kareelah Vista, O'Malley. The lessors, Arthur and Elizabeth Sinodinos, claimed $2,535.25 from the tenants, Joseph and Judith Hlubucek, for various damages and missing items, while the tenants sought a return of their bond. The legal issues focused on determining whether the damages and missing items were beyond fair wear and tear, whether they could have been reasonably avoided, and if the lessors were entitled to compensation under the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT).

The Tribunal examined the evidence and found that some items were indeed damaged beyond fair wear and tear, while others were within the tenants' rights. For instance, the Tribunal ordered the tenants to pay $500 for the garage door damage and $50 for the replacement of the garage door remote controls. However, it dismissed claims for damages to the window drapes, carpet stains, and other items as these were either within fair wear and tear or could not be attributed to the tenants. Additionally, the Tribunal ruled that the tenants should compensate the lessors $363.00 for the removal of an unauthorized satellite dish and wiring. The balance of the lessors' claim was dismissed, and the Tribunal ordered the release of the remaining bond to the tenants.

The final orders required the tenants to pay specific amounts for certain damages, with receipts to be provided by the lessors, and directed the Office of Rental Bonds to release the remaining bond to the tenants if the lessors failed to produce the required receipts within 21 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established