HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Barwick C.J..
JOOS v. COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
25 July 1972
Patents
Patents—Application—Invention—Process for improving strength and elasticity of human hair and nails—Whether process capable of being subject of patent—Treatment of human body—Medical treatment—Commercial application—Whether necessary that process be employed in trade and commerce—Function of Patents Tribunal—Patents Act 1952-1966 (Cth), ss. 6 "invention"*, 35, 52.
Decision
July 25
BARWICK C.J. delivered the following written judgment : -
On 15th June, 1964, Bernhard Joos of Zurich, Switzerland, lodged with the Commissioner for Patents of the Commonwealth, pursuant to s. 34 of the Patents Act 1952-1966 (Cth) (the Act), an application for the grant of letters patent for an invention entitled "Process for improving strenght and elasticity of keratinous material". With the application he lodged a complete specification. The process there described is one for the treatment of keratinous material, such as hair and nails, with a solution or a suspension of a reaction product of thiourea and formaldehyde. It is said in the specification that human hair treated by the process has improved elasticity and is better "dressable", that the loss of original properties of the hair, especially those related to elasticity, caused by former treatments such as bleachin, permanent waving, dyeing or the like, is partially compensated, and that naturally weak hair may be strengthened. It is further said that the process makes use of compositions which are free of substances which may produce undesirable side effects. (at p614)
2. Having regard to the issue raised before me in this appeal, I have no need to go into the chemistry of the described process. All the claims of the original complete specification were for a process claimed to improve the strength and elasticity of keratinous material, especially human hair and nails, which process involved wetting the surface of the keratinous material with a slightly acidic fluid composition containing dimethylol thiourea in a liquid diluent. It is clear that the principal application of the process is for use on human hair on the head and human nails, both finger nails and toe nails. (at p615)
3. The examiner reported adversely on the specification whereupon the applicant, pursuant to s. 49 of the Act, filed a first statement of proposed amendments. Broadly, the statements proposed to amend the specification so as to make its claims relate to a composition rathe than to a process. The claim would then be for compositions when used for treating keratinous material to improve its strength and elasticity. But, again, it was quite clear that the treatment was to include, and have its principal use in, the application of the composition to human nails and human hair growing on the head. (at p615)
4. However, the Deputy Commissioner of Patents, on 18th April 1969, informed the applicant that the proposed amendments did not remove the objections. In the result, the Deputy Commissioner decided that the application should not proceed because it claimed as an invention a process for the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Joos v Commissioner of Patents and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1972] HCA 38
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the claimed invention, a method for producing a plastic film, constituted a "manner of manufacture" for the purposes of patentability. This required the Court to consider the scope of patentable subject matter in Australia, particularly in relation to processes and the distinction between a mere discovery or abstract idea and a practical application that produces a vendible product or a useful result.
Barwick C.J. applied the established principles for determining whether an invention is a manner of manufacture, drawing on precedent from both Australian and English case law. His Honour emphasised that a patentable invention must involve an "art, process, or method" that results in a tangible product or a useful effect. The Court found that the applicant's method, which involved specific steps to alter the physical properties of a plastic film, did not merely describe a scientific principle or an abstract concept. Instead, it was a practical process that produced a film with altered characteristics, thereby falling within the definition of a manner of manufacture. The appeal was allowed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi