Jones and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 1142 (14 May 2024)
Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION
File Number(s): 2022/3064
Re:Joshua Jones
APPLICANT
AndNational Disability Insurance Agency
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Deputy President Mischin
Date:14 May 2024
Place:Perth
The Tribunal:
1.Refuses the Applicant’s request that it issue a summons to produce documents directed to HWL Ebsworth Lawyers;
2.Grants the Applicant’s request to issue a summons to produce documents directed to Nollamara Medical Centre;
3.Refuses the Applicant’s request that it issue a summons to produce documents directed to Royal Perth Bentley Group;
4.Refuses the Applicant’s request that it issue a summons to produce documents directed to Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital.
....................... [Sgd].................................................
Deputy President Mischin
CATCHWORDS
PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – interlocutory application – summons to produce – objection to request by Applicant to issue summons to produce documents directed to Respondent’s lawyers – objection to request by Applicant to issue summonses to produce documents directed to medical, hospital and allied health service providers
LEGISLATION
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), sections 37, 38AA, 40A(1)(b), 40A(2)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth), section 21CASES
Associated Dominions Assurance Society Pty Ltd v John Fairfax & Sons Pty Ltd (1952) 72 WN (NSW) 250
Bird and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2006] AATA 109
Caltex Refining Co Pty Ltd v The Amalgamated Metal Workers’ Union (6 December 1990 unreported) BC9003718
Comcare v Maganga [2008] FCA 285
Cosco Holdings Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner ofTaxation[1997] FCA 1504; (1997) 37 ATR 432, BC9707273
Fried v National Australia Bank (2000) 175 ALR 194
Interchase Corporation Ltd (in liq) v Grosvenor Hill (Queensland) Pty Ltd (No 1) [1999] 1 Qd R 141
Marnotta Pty Ltd and Secretary, Department of Health and Ageing [2004] AATA 800
Treasurer of the Commonwealth of Australia v Canwest Global Communications Corp & Ors [1997] FCA 578, BC9702863
ML Ubase Holdings Co Ltd v Trigem Computer Inc (2007) 69 NSWLR 577REASONS FOR DECISION
Deputy President Mischin
14 May 2024
The Applicant in this matter, Mr Jones, has applied to the Tribunal for a review of an internal decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA or the Respondent) on 19 April 2022. The Application for review by the Tribunal of that internal decision was filed later that same day. In issue is whether the Applicant should be given access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Scheme).
The Applicant sought access to the Scheme by reason of impairments arising from several conditions. The Respondent accepted that the Applicant has a disability attributable to impairments arising from lumbar spine degeneration, cervical spine stenosis, asthma, and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). The NDIA did not accept that the Applicant’s Type-2 diabetes, hypertension and chronic kidney failure gave rise to a disability.
The NDIA, although satisfied that certain of the Applicant’s conditions met the criteria for access to the Scheme, was not satisfied that the impairments:
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Jones and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] AATA 1142
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether it should grant the applicant's requests to issue summonses to the respondent's lawyers and to the medical and hospital providers. This involved considering the principles governing the exercise of the Tribunal's discretion to issue summonses, particularly in relation to relevance, legitimate forensic purpose, and the avoidance of "fishing expeditions."
The Tribunal applied the general principles applicable to the issue of subpoenas by courts to the issuance of summonses by the Tribunal under section 40A(1)(b) of the *Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975* (Cth). It affirmed that the fundamental criterion for issuing a summons is relevance to the issues to be determined, meaning the documents must have a real possibility of assisting in the resolution of the proceedings or reasonably be expected to throw light on those issues. A legitimate forensic purpose, which could include use in cross-examination, is also required, and summonses should not be issued for improper purposes such as a "fishing expedition."
The Tribunal refused the request for a summons directed to the respondent's legal representative. It also refused the requests for summonses directed to the Royal Perth Bentley Group and Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital as presently framed, finding them too broadly drafted and including material already produced. However, the Tribunal indicated it would grant a summons to the Nollamara Medical Centre, and would consider issuing a summons to the Royal Perth Bentley Group if the request were refined.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Respondent further submits that the Tribunal should refuse the Applicant’s request to issue summonses to the Nollamara Medical Centre, Royal Perth Bentley Group, and Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital, on the bases that: (a)the evidence before the Tribunal is voluminous and already summonsed material exceeds approximately 6,150 pages;[12](b)the scope of documents requested in the summonses is broad and: (i)is not directly relevant to the treatment of the Applicant’s conditions or impairments being relied on for access to the Scheme;[13] and/or(ii)will be unlikely to throw light on the substantive issues to be determined by the Tribunal.[14] [12] Ibid at [21].[13] Ibid at [22(a)]. [14] Ibid at [22(b)].CONSIDERATION The general principles that apply to the issue of subpoenas by a Court also apply to the issue of summonses to produce documents or things by the Tribunal. Section 40A(1)(b) of the AAT Act empowers the Tribunal, for the purposes of a proceedings before the Tribunal, to summon a person to produce any document or other thing specified in the summons. The Tribunal may refuse a request to summon a person: section 40A(2). The basis upon which the discretion to issue a summons to produce should be exercised has been expressed in a variety of ways, but the fundamental touchstone is relevance to the issue or issues to be determined in the proceedings. The test of relevance is:…whether the documents relate to the proceedings such that there is a real possibility that they may assist in the resolution of issues in the proceedings.[15]or …that the material sought could reasonably be expected to throw light on some of the issues in the principal proceedings.[16] [15] Comcare v Maganga [2008] FCA 285 (Maganga) at [37].[16] Cosco Holdings Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner ofTaxation[1997] FCA 1504, (1997) 37 ATR 432, BC9707273 (Cosco) at 11; Marnotta Pty Ltd and Secretary, Department of Health and Ageing [2004] AATA 800 at [42]. There should be a legitimate forensic purpose in seeking the relevant documents which ‘must be identifiable, and likely to facilitate the conduct of the proceeding, not merely to oppress a party or witness’.[17] Such legitimate forensic purpose is not limited to admission into evidence, but use in cross-examination, and includes cross-examination going to the question of credit of a witness.[18][17] Maganga (n 15) at [32], citing Fried v National Australia Bank (2000) 175 ALR 194 at [29].[18] Ibid at [32], [34], [36], [38]. However, a summons should not be issued if it serves an improper purpose, such as a “fishing expedition”.[19] The expression ‘fishing expedition’ has traditionally been a metaphor used in the law to describe where ‘a person who has no evidence that fish of a particular kind are in a pool desires to be at liberty to drag it for the purpose of finding out whether there are any there or not’[20] or, to put it another way:It is not a question of looking at the documents to see if the documents might permit a case to be made.[21][19] Maganga (n 15) at [33]-[34]; Cosco (n 16). [20] Cosco (n 16) at 12, citing Associated Dominions Assurance Society Pty Ltd v John Fairfax & Sons Pty Ltd (1952) 72 WN (NSW) 250 at 254.[21] Cosco (n 16) at 11.