Johnson v South Metropolitan Health Service

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   JOHNSON -v- SOUTH METROPOLITAN HEALTH SERVICE [2023] WADC 125

CORAM:   GETHING DCJ

HEARD:   17 OCTOBER 2023

DELIVERED          :   24 OCTOBER 2023

FILE NO/S:   CIVO 120 of 2023

BETWEEN:   SUSAN JOHNSON

Applicant

AND

SOUTH METROPOLITAN HEALTH SERVICE

Respondent


Catchwords:

Tort - Personal injury - Medical negligence - Limitation period - Application to extend time to bring proceedings - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Limitation Act 2005 (WA), s 39, s 55

Result:

Limitation period extended

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Mr K S Pratt
Respondent : Ms D M Templeman

Solicitors:

Applicant : Bradley Bayly Legal
Respondent : Gilchrist Connell

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

AME Hospitals Pty Ltd v Dixon [2015] WASCA 63

Clarke v Natalwala [2022] WASC 261

Mullaley v The State of Western Australia [2020] FCA 13

GETHING DCJ:

Introduction

  1. By application filed 2 August 2023 (Application), Susan Johnson (Applicant), seeks leave to commence an action for damages against the South Metropolitan Health Service (Respondent).  The action is for damages for personal injuries the Applicant says she suffered as a result of negligent medical treatment by the Respondent from 14 January 2018.  The extension is sought until 21 November 2023.

  2. The application is made pursuant to Limitation Act 2005 (WA) s 39.[1]

    [1] Unless otherwise noted, all statutory references are to provisions of the Limitation Act 2005 (WA).

  3. In support of the Application, the Applicant swore an affidavit dated 27 July 2023 (Applicant's Affidavit).  She also relies on an affidavit sworn on 4 October 2023 by Kaivan Nathanial Jafari, a solicitor employed by her lawyers. 

  4. The Respondent has entered an appearance and opposes the Application.  It relies on an affidavit sworn on 7 September 2023 by Janet Barron, a solicitor employed by the Respondent's lawyers (Barron Affidavit).

  5. Both parties filed written submissions.

  6. For the reasons which follow, the Application should be granted in the terms sought.

Factual background

  1. On 29 December 2017, the Applicant fractured her left femur whilst on a cruise ship near Taiwan.  She underwent surgical fixation of her left femur at a hospital in Taiwan on or about 2 January 2018.  She arrived back in Perth on or around 14 January 2018.

  2. On 14 January 2018, the Applicant attended the emergency department at Rockingham General Hospital (RGH) due to pain and swelling in her left leg.

  3. On 18 January 2018 she was taken by ambulance to Fiona Stanley Hospital (FSH) due to rectal bleeding and was admitted.  During this stay she underwent revision surgery on her left femur on 23 January 2018.  She was discharged on 2 February 2018.

  4. On 24 February 2018, the Applicant was readmitted to FSH.  On 25 February, she underwent surgical debridement of her left femoral wound.  Swabs taken during the surgery grew enterococcus faecalis, and she was subsequently administered antibiotics.

  5. Between 11 March 2018 and 12 February 2020 the Applicant attended RGH amd FSH numerous times.  She underwent six further surgeries in relation to her infected, fractured femur.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Johnson v South Metropolitan Health Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WADC 125
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Johnson v South Metropolitan Health Service, the plaintiffs sought damages for alleged medical negligence by the defendant, a health service provider. The primary dispute centred around the plaintiffs' claim that the defendant's negligence caused significant personal injuries, including loss of vision and hearing, and the defendant's argument that the plaintiffs' claims were time-barred under the Limitation Act. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The key legal issues the court had to resolve were whether the plaintiffs were aware of the cause of their injuries and the identity of the responsible party at the time the limitation period expired, and whether there were any grounds to extend the time to bring proceedings. The court needed to determine if the plaintiffs were conscious of the three specified matters by the date the limitation period expired, and whether the plaintiffs had discharged the burden of proving they were not aware of these matters.

The court found that the plaintiffs had not proven that they were not aware of the physical cause of their injuries, the attribution of their injuries to the defendant's conduct, and the identity of the responsible party by the time the limitation period expired. The court emphasised that the plaintiffs had not provided any explanation to support their claim of unawareness. Specifically, the court placed significant weight on a complaint letter sent by the plaintiffs' legal representative in May 2013, which indicated their belief that the police were responsible for the injuries. The court concluded that the plaintiffs' strong views about the police's responsibility and their awareness of the mental health injuries arising from the events suggested that they were consciously aware that their injuries were attributable to the conduct of a person, namely the police officers. Consequently, the court held that there was no discretion to extend the time to bring the proceedings.

In summary, the court dismissed the plaintiffs' application for an extension of time, finding that the plaintiffs had not established the necessary negative proposition that they were not aware of the specified matters by the expiry of the limitation period. As a result, the plaintiffs' claims were time-barred, and the defendant's motion for summary dismissal was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The second question was 'whether as at the date of accrual the applicant was consciously aware of the three specified matters, namely (a) the physical cause of the injury; (b) that the injury was attributable to the conduct of a person; and (c) after reasonable inquiry the identity of that person'.[37] His Honour held that the applicants had not proven that they were not aware of these matters. Among other evidence, his Honour placed weight on a complaint letter which ALS had sent on behalf of the applicants in May 2013. Specifically, Colvin J concluded:[38]On the evidence as a whole, the proper inference is that by the time the limitation period expired, namely 17 December 2018 in the case of Mr Mullaley and 7 February 2017 in the case of Ms Mullaley, they each remained of the view that the police officers were responsible for the death of the baby and they were aware that they had suffered significant mental health injuries by reason of those events. Given the force with which views about the responsibilities of the police officers had been expressed by each of them and the actual awareness of their mental health injuries arising from those events that arose when they were diagnosed, in the absence of some explanation from the applicants, the necessary inference was that they were consciously aware that their injuries were attributable to the conduct of a person, namely the police officers.On an application for an extension of time, the applicants had an obligation to prove the negative proposition that they were not aware that their mental health injuries were attributable to the conduct of the police officers by the expiry of the limitation period. On the evidence, that negative proposition has not been established and therefore there is no discretion to extend time.Evidence as to paras (a) and (c) of s 39(3)The evidence as to what was actually known to Mr Mullaley and Ms Mullaley at the expiry of the limitation period was to the effect that they did not know who the police officers were who were involved in the events of 19 and 20 March 2013. However, it is not enough to show a lack of actual knowledge. What must be shown is that the person was unable to establish the identity of the person to whom the prospective claimant was aware the injury was attributable. If it was the case that the applicants were aware that their mental health injuries were attributable to conduct of the police officers (rather than grief because of the death of the baby) then reasonable inquiry would have revealed their identity. So much is demonstrated by the affidavit of Mr Smith which deposed to the fact that if he had been asked to identify the officers involved he would have done so. It was accepted for the applicants that they were aware of the physical cause of their injury. That is to say, they knew in general terms of the conduct of the police officers. This is made evident by the terms of the letter of complaint sent by ALS.[37] Mullaley [61].[38] Mullaley [109] - [111].

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicant and her partner responded to the Patient and Family Liaison Officer by email dated 31 January 2021, attaching a letter of that date. Again, given the significance of this letter to the Respondent's position, it is necessary to quote it in detail:[3][3] Barron Affidavit, pages 6 - 9.31 January 2020For the attention of the Patient Liaison TeamDear Sir or Madam,Susan has been receiving care since 2018 by the Orthopaedic and Infectious Diseases Teams following surgery in Taiwan for a femur fracture and subsequent infection. Susan has undergone numerous surgical procedures by the Orthopaedic Team and has been prescribed a range of antibiotics to combat osteomyelitis by the Infectious Diseases Team. These have been delivered intravenously, through a PIC line, orally by tablet and by suspension. She has been admitted on several occasions to FSH and Rockingham Hospital with vomiting, diarrhoea and dehydration thought to be associated with the antibiotics.On 12 December 2020 Susan suddenly lost significant vision in both eyes. She attended a local Optometrist to have an immediate assessment of her condition and currently prescribed glasses. After a series of tests the Optometrist advised Susan to immediately attend Accident & Emergency at Sir Charles Gardiner [sic] Hospital. An extensive range of tests was carried out and the doctor advised Susan and her partner Dave that the nerve at the back of her left eye had died and sight would not be recovered in this eye. Sight is also significantly impaired in her right eye.The doctor arranged an urgent referral to the Eye Clinic at Fremantle Hospital. After another range of tests which included CT scans, an MRI, a brain scan, chest X‑rays, a carotid artery scan, blood tests and a lumbar puncture, received both as an In- and Outpatient, Susan and Dave have still not been provided with a diagnosis.On 15 December 2020, Susan awoke to sudden significant hearing loss in both ears, resulting in her being unable to effectively communicate in a normal fashion. A GP arranged an audiology appointment and a referral to an ENT Consultant. Another hearing test was undertaken and Susan and Dave were advised that Susan would require Hearing Aids. Once again, no diagnosis was provided explaining the reasons for the sudden hearing loss.To date the opinions that were provided have included:•Stroke.•Brain Tumour.•Small blood clots firing behind the eye and hearing centres.•Significant toxic reaction to antibiotics.Stroke, brain tumour and clots were ruled by blood tests and x-rays and the lack of other associated symptoms.Amongst other antibiotics, Susan was prescribed Linezolid which was being taken in suspension form. Susan was on Linezolid for many months and at no time was she or Dave advised of any potential side effects of this medication. She had a full range of blood tests during this period to monitor infection markers amongst other things. Susan was last advised of her infection levels in May 2020 and at no time was she advised of any negative impact from Linezolid.The first time Susan and Dave were advised that Linezolid can cause significant sight and hearing loss was through a Registrar at FSH A & E a long time after the onset of symptoms.Other than a telephone appointment with Infectious Diseases in November 2020 and a brief visit by Dr Hui whilst Susan was an inpatient at Rockingham Hospital, receiving treatment for a UTI, care from the Infectious Diseases team has been conspicuous by its absence. Even in the face of significant hearing and sight loss the first appointment with Infectious Diseases after the above episodes is set for 3 February 2021.In a telephone call to Dave on 18 January 2021, Dr Hui discussed Susan's sudden loss of sight and hearing and confirmed that Linezolid was the probable cause and that Susan should stop taking it (Susan had already stopped taking Linezolid following advice received at FSH A&E (see above)). Dr Hui apologised for her condition.Dr Hui also confirmed that Susan's Linezolid levels were last checked in May 2020, which is why we were able to specify that date above.With side effects as significant as those experienced by Susan, it would seem extremely disturbing that levels were not monitored on a regular basis.In terms of her treatment by the Orthopaedic team at FSH, whilst being told that Susan's case was highly complex, she often had to ask to see the latest x‑rays. On several occasions doctors were not familiar with the case background and as such she and Dave were required to recount the long and complex case history, adding greatly to the significant emotional trauma they were both already dealing with. In terms of the Orthopaedic Team, Susan and Dave were seen by a different doctor each time they attended a clinic appointment. On Monday 18 January 2021, Susan had to insist on seeing Mr Prosser, the Consultant in charge of Susan's orthopaedic treatment: He proposed three surgical alternatives and confirmed that surgery would take place within two weeks. Mr Prosser also apologised for Susan's sight and hearing loss.Mr Prosser advised that he would discuss Susan's case at Grand Rounds on the Thursday prior to admission.On Thursday 28 January, Dave received a phone call from a member of the Orthopaedic Team which confirmed that Susan's case had not been discussed at Grand Rounds and that surgery would be put back by another two weeks.…Areas of Concern and Conclusion•At no time were Susan and Dave advised of the potential negative impact of the continued use of Linezolid on sight and hearing. Susan has had numerous blood tests since May 2020 but was not advised what the blood tests were for and had no knowledge that Linezolid levels had not been checked since May 2020.•The fact that Linezolid levels were not checked between May 2020 and the present is highly alarming.•In light of the complexity of Susan's condition, it would seem remiss that she has been "shuffled' through a range of doctors unfamiliar with her condition. These doctors displayed a negative understanding of care, compassion and empathy.•It would seem unnecessary that a patient should have to undergo the trauma that she had to insist to see the specialist in charge of her treatment.•It is now 31 January 2021 and to date Susan and Dave have not received a diagnosis relating to her sight and hearing loss. While many blood tests have been taken, we have not been advised of the outcome of these other than 'we are treating the really bad stuff with steroids'.•Susan and Dave have received conflicting opinions by medical staff as to whether Susan's sight and hearing will improve. or deteriorate.•The lack of care, compassion and empathy has been reflected by both Orthopaedic and Infectious Diseases Teams.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.