John Rogers and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL              )

)         No: 2014/0170

General Division  )

Re: John Rogers
Applicant

And: Linfox Australia Pty Ltd
Respondent

DIRECTION

TRIBUNAL:              Senior Member CR Walsh

DATE:   9 February 2016

PLACE:                    Perth

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the text of the decision in relation to application 2014/0170 as follows:

  • Pursuant to s 67(8) of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“the SRC Act”), the costs of the proceeding incurred by the applicant be paid by the respondent in accordance with Section 6.9 of the Tribunal’s Guide to the Workers’ Compensation Jurisdiction. 

...................................................................
  Senior Member

Rogers and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2015] AATA 673 (4 September 2015)

Division

 GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

 2014/0170 & 2014/2992

Re

 John Rogers

APPLICANT

And

Linfox Australia Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal

Senior Member CR Walsh

Date 4 September 2015
Place Perth

The Tribunal:

(i)        in No. 2014/0170, sets aside the decision under review and substitutes that decision with the decision that Mr Rogers is entitled to incapacity payments under s 19 of the Safety Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988 from 20 December 2013; and

(ii)       in No. 2014/2992, affirms the decision under review.

....(Sgd) CR Walsh...................................................................

Senior Member CR Walsh

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION- liability for incapacity payments for accepted right shoulder injury sustained by the applicant in the course of his employment as a truck driver – Tribunal’s jurisdiction - liability for pulmonary embolism attributed to treatment for accepted right shoulder injury – decision under review in No. 2014/0170 set aside and substituted – decision under review in No. 2014/2992 affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act- s 4(3) - s 14 – s 16 - s 19 – s 36(3) - s 61- s 62 - s 64

CASES

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford [2006] FCAFC 87

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member CR Walsh

4 September 2015

introduction

  1. On 4 April 2013, Mr Rogers sustained an injury to his right shoulder in the course of his employment as a truck driver for Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Linfox).

  2. Mr Rogers seeks a review of the following two decisions of Linfox’s insurer, CGU Self Insurance Services (CGU):

    (i)a decision, dated 3 January 2014, that Linfox had no present liability to pay Mr Rogers compensation for incapacity payments for his accepted right shoulder condition under s 19 of the Safety Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act) (No. 2014/0170); and

    (ii)a decision, dated 5 June 2014, denying liability for Mr Rogers’ “pulmonary embolism (caused by a blood clot)”[1] condition, attributed to treatment received for the accepted right shoulder condition, namely shoulder surgery on 26 May 2013 and a steroid injection on 8 October 2013, pursuant to s 14 of the SRC Act (No. 2014/2992).[2]

    [1] This decision affirmed an earlier determination of Linfox, dated 20 December 2013

    [2] This decision affirmed an earlier determination of Linfox, dated 15 May 2014.

    FactUAL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Rogers and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 673
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of John Rogers and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd, the Federal Circuit Court of Australia was asked to determine the liability of Linfox for incapacity payments for an accepted right shoulder injury sustained by Mr Rogers during his employment as a truck driver. The court also considered the liability for a pulmonary embolism attributed to the treatment for the accepted right shoulder injury. The case involved two determinations: No. 2014/0170 and No. 2014/2992. The primary legal issues were whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to revisit the acceptance of liability by Linfox and whether Linfox could argue that it should never have accepted liability for Mr Rogers' right superior and postero-superior labral tear, as per the decision in Telstra Corporation v Hannaford.

The court found that the Tribunal had jurisdiction to revisit the acceptance of liability where the later decision was dependent on that acceptance, consistent with the Full Federal Court's decision in Telstra v Hannaford. The court held that Telstra v Hannaford did not prevent the Tribunal from making findings of fact inconsistent with earlier findings if the facts related to the current claim. The court also found that Linfox's argument that it should never have accepted liability for Mr Rogers' shoulder injury was not applicable in this case. As a result, the court set aside the decision under review in No. 2014/0170 and substituted it with a decision that Mr Rogers is entitled to incapacity payments from 20 December 2013. The decision under review in No. 2014/2992 was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal:

(i) in No. 2014/0170, sets aside the decision under review and substitutes that decision with the decision that Mr Rogers is entitled to incapacity payments under s 19 of the Safety Rehabilitation & Compensation Act 1988 from 20 December 2013; and

(ii) in No. 2014/2992, affirms the decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 3 January 2014, CGU (on behalf of Linfox) reconsidered and affirmed the Right Shoulder Condition Determination (under s 62 of the SRC Act) on the basis that it had:No present liability to pay compensation under section 19 of the SRC Act for [Mr Rogers’] incapacity benefits. [Right Shoulder Condition Decision] On 10 January 2014, Mr Rogers applied to the Tribunal for a review of the Right Shoulder Condition Decision (under s 64 of the SRC Act). Mr Rogers’ stated “Reasons for Application” are:The Applicant is incapacitated as a result of his injury of 4 April 2013 sustained during the course of his employment.The Applicant continues to require medical treatment as a result of his work related injury.The decision of the Respondent dated 20 December 2013 is wrong. On 15 January 2014, Clinical Associate Professor Marcel Goodman, Vascular Surgeon, provided a report for CGU, wherein he diagnosed Mr Rogers as suffering from a:pulmonary embolus affecting the subsegmental branch of the left pulmonary artery. In his report dated 15 January 2014, Professor Goodman also stated:……The operation and initial pathology was many months from the time of presentation of chest pain at the end of October and presumably the onset of the episode of pulmonary embolus. With regard to the lower limb venous circulation I am assuming that the operation in June 2013 was associated with minimal or no period of bed rest and mobilisation and therefore the factors leading to the lower limb deep vein thrombosis would minimally apply it at all. The incidence of a pulmonary embolus altera procedure such as endoscopic repair of a shoulder joint labrum is exceedingly low. In his report dated 15 January 2014, Professor Goodman made the following comments with respect to any connection between the steroid injection received by Mr Rogers on 8 October 2013 and the development of an embolus:It is not clear to me why Mr Rogers underwent a steroid injection or by whom, whether it was done under ultrasound or x-ray guidance. This information would be invaluable, especially if it is suggested that the pulmonary embolus is a complication of the steroid injection into the right shoulder area, presumably by means of a local deep vein thrombosis. This potential but unlikely series of events would justify the carrying out of duplex venous studies of the right upper limb including axillary and subclavian veins. If there had been a deep vein thrombosis initiated as a result of the complication of the steroid injection, there may well be residual evidence in the veins to be examined by duplex scanning. In his report dated 15 January 2014, Professor Goodman noted the “possibility” that Mr Rogers suffered from a “pre-existing underlying tendency to thrombophilia” (i.e. deep vein thrombosis). In a letter from Dr Paul Kruger, Haematology Registrar, RPH, to Dr Geoffrey Bloor, dated 16 January 2014, Dr Kruger stated:…..Three months after this he had a corticosteroid injection in the shoulder as well. The day after the corticosteroid injection, John developed chest tightness and shortness of breath and was found to have a pulmonary embolus on a CTPA scan.…….John has not had a pulmonary embolus before, and he has had a left arm deep vein thrombosis before in the context of an intravenous cannula and this was treated with Clexane a few years ago.……….My impression is that John’s PE is likely to be related to his shoulder surgery which was quite recent before the PE. Our recommendation today is that he has at least six months of anticoagulation, taking him to approximately April 2014, but we should also check his thrombophilia screen to see if there are any other prothrombotic tendencies in his blood. [Emphasis added]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Having reviewed the content of Mr Edwards’ 15 August 2014 report, on 24 April 2015, Linfox’s solicitors wrote to Mr Rogers’ solicitors, advising them that:The respondent will be contending that liability should not have been accepted under s 14 of the SRC Act for a right superior and postero-superior labral tear. In making this contention, the respondent relies on Telstra Corporation v Hannaford [2006] FCAFC 87. [Emphasis added] On 20 May 2015, a directions hearing took place, at the request of the parties, before Deputy President Hotop. It is unfortunate that the issue of jurisdiction (and the Telstra v Hannaford argument) was not dealt with by Deputy President Hotop at this directions hearing. On 10 June 2015 (five days before hearing), Linfox’s solicitors advised Mr Rogers’ solicitors that it had abandoned the argument that Mr Rogers was no longer incapacitated as from 20 December 2013.[3] That is, the original basis of the Right Shoulder Condition Determination (namely that Mr Rogers was fit for suitable employment duties) would no longer be defended by Linfox and that in No. 2014/0170 Linfox would henceforth instead seek to rely on the decision of the Full Federal Court in Telstra v Hannaford (2006) 151 FCR 253 (Telstra v Hannaford), to argue that liability should never have been accepted by Linfox under s 14 of the SRC Act for Mr Rogers’ “right superior and postero-superior labral tear”. In contrast Mr Rogers’ position is that Telstra v Hannaford has no application in this case.[4][3] This was repeated in opening by counsel for Linfox at the first day of the hearing on 15 June 2015.[4] There no longer being a dispute that Mr Rogers is incapacitated, most of the medical evidence in the T-documents, filed by Linfox in relation to No. 2014/0170, is now irrelevant. In short, in Telstra v Hannaford, the Full Federal Court held that the Tribunal could revisit a Comcare decision accepting liability where the later decision under review by the Tribunal was dependent upon that acceptance of liability. That is, Telstra v Hannaford is authority for the proposition that the Tribunal is not inhibited from making findings of fact inconsistent with findings in earlier proceedings provided the facts in the earlier matter relate to the matters being considered in the current claim. Briefly, the facts in Telstra v Hannaford are as follows:· Mr Hannaford was a Telstra employee who had been engaged in the installation of cabling in swampy area in the area of Yamba in New South Wales, where mosquitos were prevalent;· On 3rd May 2002, Mr Hannaford lodged a claim for compensation;· On 8 May 2002, a determination was made under s 14 of the SRC Act whereby Telstra accepted liability because the then available medical opinion was that Mr Hannaford was suffering from Ross River Fever. Thereafter, payments were made to Mr Hannaford pursuant to both s 16 and s 19 of the SRC Act;· In July 2003, Mr Hannaford lodged a claim for permanent impairment compensation pursuant to s 24 and s 27 of the SRC Act;· Further medical testing revealed that whatever illness had afflicted Mr Hannaford in 2002, it was not Ross River Fever;· Telstra's position in the Tribunal hearing which followed was that this evidence, even though it was inconsistent with the earlier acceptance of liability in the s 14 determination, should be utilised by the Tribunal in assessing his claim for permanent impairment. That approach was accepted by the Tribunal;· On appeal to a single judge of the Federal Court, that approach was rejected; and· Telstra’s appeal to the Full Federal Court was upheld.