John Holland Pty Ltd v The Minister for Works

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   JOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD -v- THE MINISTER FOR WORKS [2021] WASC 312

CORAM:   HILL J

HEARD:   28 & 29 JULY 2021

DELIVERED          :   14 SEPTEMBER 2021

FILE NO/S:   CIV 3025 of 2019

BETWEEN:   JOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

THE MINISTER FOR WORKS

Defendant

(BY ORIGINAL ACTION)

THE MINISTER FOR WORKS

Plaintiff by Counterclaim

AND

JOHN HOLLAND PTY LTD

First Defendant by Counterclaim

CIMIC GROUP LTD

Second Defendant by Counterclaim

JOHN HOLLAND HOLDINGS PTY LTD

Third Party

(BY COUNTERCLAIM)


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Pleadings - Application for further and better particulars of statement of claim - Proposal for common data set - Appropriate orders to be made - Turns on own facts

Practice and procedure - Pleadings - Application for further and better particulars of defence - Whether particulars sought of defence contended by defendant - Whether particulars required or whether matter will be addressed by other case management orders - Appropriate orders to be made - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA) O 20 r 8, 13, 14, 19

Result:

Application by John Holland allowed in part
Application by State allowed in part
Applications otherwise dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Original Action

Counsel:

Plaintiff : M Dempsey SC, D Miller SC, W C J Zappia & T J Porter
Defendant : M G Roberts QC, J Taylor, E M Heenan, K A T Pederson

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (Perth)
Defendant : Herbert Smith Freehills

Counterclaim

Counsel:

Plaintiff by Counterclaim : M G Roberts QC, J Taylor SC,
E M Heenan, K A T Pederson
First Defendant by Counterclaim : M Dempsey SC, D Miller SC,
W C J Zappia & T J Porter
Second Defendant by Counterclaim : No appearance
Third Party : M Dempsey SC, D Miller SC,
W C J Zappia & Mr T J Porter

Solicitors:

Plaintiff by Counterclaim : Herbert Smith Freehills
First Defendant by Counterclaim : HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (Perth)
Second Defendant by Counterclaim : DLA Piper Australia - Perth
Third Party : HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (Perth)

Cases referred to in decision:

Alcoa of Australia Ltd v Apache Energy Ltd [No 3] [2013] WASC 334

Attorney General of Western Australia v President of the Legislative Council of Western Australia [2020] WASC 399

Barclay Mowlem Construction Ltd v Dampier Port Authority [2006] WASC 281; (2006) 33 WAR 82

Black Box Control Pty Ltd v Terravision Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 219

Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd v Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Ltd [2017] QSC 085

CMA Assets Pty Ltd v John Holland Pty Ltd [No 6] [2015] WASC 217

Darbyshire v Leigh [1896] 1 QB 554

Dare v Pulham [1982] HCA 70; (1982) 148 CLR 658

Green v Wilden Pty Ltd [2005] WASC 83

National Australia Bank Ltd v Rowe [2018] WASC 330

Pinson v Lloyds and National Provincial Foreign Bank Ltd [1941] 2 KB 72

Rowe v National Australia Bank Ltd [2019]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Holland Pty Ltd v The Minister for Works and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WASC 312
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

John Holland Pty Ltd (John Holland) commenced proceedings against the Minister for Works (State) in which it claims over $180 million in damages and the State has counterclaimed for over $17 million. Both parties have filed voluminous pleadings and particulars. The State has applied for further and better particulars of John Holland's statement of claim and John Holland has applied for further and better particulars of the State's defence and counterclaim. The State contends that the provision of information sought by John Holland's request for particulars can be addressed by case management orders that have been or will be made, including orders requiring the parties to file expert evidence and lay evidence on the issues on which each bears the onus of proof. In contrast, John Holland contends it requires further particulars of the State's defence so it can understand the case it has to meet and that without proper particulars, it will not be aware of the State's case until expert evidence is filed in February 2022, less than 8 months prior to the proposed commencement of the trial. The parties have agreed the trial of this matter should commence in or about October 2022 and dates from mid October 2022 have been reserved for the hearing of the proceedings. The court determined that the State should provide further answers to requests 2, 49, 91, 92, 93, 95, 123 and 124. The court also determined that if the State contends, as a matter of fact, that at the relevant times the current program needed to be updated to reflect particular events, the State should file a document identifying these events well prior to the filing of expert evidence. The court determined that the parties should file their critical path analysis well prior to the filing of their expert evidence in chief and that John Holland's application should otherwise be dismissed. The court determined that John Holland's proposal to supply a common data set to address the requests of the State did not sufficiently address the particulars that have been requested and that the State's application for particulars should otherwise be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

John Holland Pty Ltd (John Holland) entered into a contract with the Minister for Works (State) on 5 July 2011 to manage the design and delivery of a new children's hospital, Perth Children's Hospital (PCH), to replace the aging Princess Margaret Hospital. In December 2012, the parties entered into an amended contract under which John Holland agreed to design and construct PCH for a fixed lump sum payment. The contract was to be completed by 30 June 2015, but Practical Completion occurred in April 2017, with the hospital opening in stages from May 2018 and fully operational in June 2018. John Holland commenced proceedings against the State in November 2019, seeking declarations and payment of more than $180 million. The State denies liability for this amount and has brought a counterclaim seeking more than $17 million for liquidated damages and damages for alleged defects. Both parties have filed extensive pleadings, with John Holland's statement of claim and particulars totaling 384 pages and 1,200 pages, respectively, and the State's defence and counterclaim totaling 969 pages.

The case has proceeded through several stages, with both John Holland and the State filing applications for further and better particulars of each other's pleadings. John Holland's application seeks clarification on numerous aspects of the State's defence, including delay analysis, design compliance, and particulars of Australian standards. The State's application requests further particulars of John Holland's statement of claim, focusing on quantum and the contractual basis of its costs claims. The case management process has involved discussions on the adequacy of the pleadings, the role of expert evidence, and the timing of the exchange of particulars and expert reports.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the State should provide further answers to requests 2, 49, 91, 92, 93, 95, 123, and 124.
2. Whether the State should file a document identifying events that, if any, the current program needed to be updated to reflect.
3. Whether the parties should file their critical path analysis prior to the filing of expert evidence in chief.
4. Whether John Holland's proposal to supply a common data set adequately addresses the requests of the State.
5. Whether the State's application for particulars should otherwise be dismissed.

Held
1. The State should provide further answers to requests 2, 49, 91, 92, 93, 95, 123, and 124.
2. If the State contends, as a matter of fact, that at the relevant times the current program needed to be updated to reflect particular events, the State should file a document identifying these events. This should occur well prior to the filing of expert evidence.
3. The parties should file their critical path analysis well prior to the filing of their expert evidence in chief. The court's preliminary view is that this should occur in November 2021, but it will hear from the parties before making formal orders in this regard.
4. John Holland's application should otherwise be dismissed.
5. John Holland's proposal to supply a common data set to address the requests of the State does not sufficiently address the particulars that have been requested. The court will hear from the parties as to what orders should be made to give effect to these reasons.
6. The State's application for particulars should otherwise be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This case involved a dispute between John Holland Pty Ltd and the Minister for Works regarding the construction of the Perth Children's Hospital (PCH). Both parties had filed extensive pleadings and particulars, leading to applications for further and better particulars. The court examined the applications under the obligations of parties in respect of pleadings and the purpose of particulars. The court considered the obligations of a party in relation to pleadings, the purpose of particulars, and the requirement for a sufficiently clear statement of the opponent's case to enable a fair opportunity to meet it. The court also assessed the adequacy of the particulars in accordance with case management principles and what other orders will be made to define the issues and appraise the parties of the case they have to meet at trial.

The court found that while the proper conduct of this litigation would be substantially assisted if both parties clearly identified the issues in dispute and specified what facts are and are not in dispute, a party cannot be required to provide particulars of a case it does not advance. The court concluded that many of the paragraphs which are the subject of requests for particulars do not require further particularisation. Regarding the State's contention that the assessment of any entitlement to an extension of time is to be done prospectively, retrospectively, or a combination of these, the court held that this is a matter of proper construction of the Contract and not for expert evidence. The court also found that if the State contends, as a matter of fact, that at the relevant times the current program needed to be updated to reflect particular events, the State should file a document identifying these events well prior to the filing of expert evidence.

The court considered the requests for particulars of the State's case in response to John Holland's claims for an extension of time. The court found that the descriptions provided by the State were at a high level of generality and did not set out the material facts on which they were based. The court concluded that it will be necessary for the State to provide proper particulars of the concurrent delays so that John Holland is not taken by surprise.

Regarding the requests for particulars of design compliance, the court found that the State's defence was sufficiently clear to put John Holland on notice of the case it has to meet at trial. The court declined to order the State to provide the further particulars requested in these cases.

The court also considered the requests for particulars of Australian standards and miscellaneous requests. The court found that the State should provide particulars of what its case is in relation to the defects well prior to the filing and service of its evidence. The court also found that the State should provide answers to requests 123 and 124. The court will hear from the parties as to the timing of the provision of these answers before making formal orders.

The court considered the State's application for further and better particulars of John Holland's statement of claim. The court found that John Holland's proposal to address these requests for particulars through a 'common data set' was insufficient. The court concluded that the most efficient and cost-effective manner in which these matters can be addressed is for the provision of a document or documents which sets out the amounts claimed and the basis for the calculation. The court will hear from the parties on two matters: the timing of delivery of this information and what form this information should take.

The court found that John Holland's claim is sufficiently clear to put the State on notice of the claim it has to meet at trial. The court did not consider John Holland should be required to provide further particulars in answer to requests 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10.

The court considered the miscellaneous requests and found that further particulars should not be ordered at this stage. If, after the delivery of expert evidence, further particulars are not provided, the court will consider a renewed application at that stage.

For these reasons, the court allowed each of the applications in part and will hear from the parties as to the orders that should be made to give effect to these reasons and as to the costs of the application.