Joanne Claire Catford v Laminex

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

CITATION:Joanne Claire Catford v Laminex [2021] NTLC 004

PARTIES:JOANNE CLAIRE CATFORD

V

LAMINEX GROUP LTD

TITLE OF COURT:  WORK HEALTH COURT

JURISDICTION:  WORK HEALTH

FILE NO:21845287

DELIVERED ON:  28 January 2021

DELIVERED AT:  DARWIN

HEARING DATES:  5 – 9 October 2020

DECISION OF:  JUDGE JOHN NEILL

CATCHWORDS:

Validity of section 69 Notice of Decision; jurisdiction of the Work Health Court to hear and determine an initiating Application or Counterclaim by an Employer; whether the geographical location of a most profitable employment comes within the concept of “available” in section 69(2)(b) of the Return To Work Act; operation of the principle in Jones v Dunkel where the Worker does not give evidence; the requirement to identify a real, existing job when identifying most profitable employment; the interaction after the first 104 weeks of incapacity between identifying a most profitable employment and the Employer’s obligations to rehabilitate.

Return To Work Act sections 65(2), 65(5)(b), 65B, 68, 69(1), (3) and (4), 75, 75A(1) and (6) and 76

Work Health Administration Act section 14

Interpretation Act sections 24AA(1) and 68

Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act subsections 144(1)(b) and (2)

Ju Ju Nominees Pty Ltd v Carmichael [1999] NTSC 20

Northern Cement v Ioasa [1994] NTSC 58

Australian Fuel Distributors Pty Ltd v Andros [2015] NTSC 79

Betty Millar v ABC Marketing and Sales Pty Ltd [2012] NTSC 21

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298

Murwangi Community Aboriginal Corporation v Denis Martin Carroll [2002] NTMC 25

Collins Radio Constructors Inc v Day (1998) 143 FLR 425

Dickin v NT TAB Pty Ltd [2003] NTSC 119

Newton v Masonic Homes Inc [2009] NTSC 51

Swanson v NT of A [2006] NTSC 88

Quality Plumbing & Building Contractors Pty Ltd v Schloss [2015] NTSC 56

Global Insulation Contractors (NSW) Pty Ltd v Keating [2012] NTSC 4

Roberta Barnett v NT of A - unreported Decision of Dr John Lowndes SM (as he then was) Work Health Court – delivered 24 June 2011

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Worker:Mr Michael Grove

Employer:Mr Ben O’Loughlin

Solicitors:

Worker:Ward Keller

Employer:HWL Ebsworth

Judgment category classification:  A

Judgment ID number:  004

Number of paragraphs:  162

IN THE WORK HEALTH COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 21845287

BETWEEN

JOANNE CLAIRE CATFORD

Worker

AND

LAMINEX GROUP LTD

Employer

REASONS FOR DECISION

(Delivered 28 January 2021)

JUDGE JOHN NEILL

INTRODUCTION

  1. Joanne Claire Catford ("the Worker") was born on 7 April 1969 and she is currently 51 years of age.

  2. On or about 9 February 2012 when she was aged 42 years the Worker suffered an injury to her left shoulder (“the injury”) in the course of her employment with Laminex Group Ltd ("the Employer"). ]

  3. The Worker made a claim in respect of the injury under the relevant legislation in the Northern Territory of Australia which was at that time entitled the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act ("the Act"). The Act has since been renamed the Return to Work Act. The Employer accepted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Joanne Claire Catford v Laminex and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NTLC 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Joanne Claire Catford has brought proceedings against Laminex in relation to a decision to cease payments of weekly benefits due to her left shoulder injury. The dispute is being heard in the Work Health Court. The primary issue before the court was whether the decision by Laminex to cease payments of weekly benefits to Catford was lawful and in accordance with the Return to Work Act. Specifically, the court needed to determine if Catford had ceased to be incapacitated for work as a result of her left shoulder injury, and if her incapacity was no longer due to the work-related injury.

The court considered the medical evidence provided by Dr. Andrews, who concluded that Catford had ceased to be incapacitated for work due to her left shoulder injury. Dr. Andrews found that any ongoing limitations were due to her underlying condition, not the injury itself. The court found that Dr. Andrews’ evidence was well reasoned and supported by the facts. The court also noted that Catford had not provided any evidence to counter Dr. Andrews' findings. Consequently, the court held that the decision by Laminex to cease payments of weekly benefits to Catford was lawful and in accordance with the Return to Work Act.

The court concluded that Catford had ceased to be incapacitated for work as a result of her left shoulder injury and that her incapacity was no longer due to the work-related injury. The court found that Laminex was entitled to cancel the weekly benefit payments to Catford.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Notice on page 1 informs the Worker that payments of weekly benefits to her will be cancelled, effective in 14 days from her receipt of the Notice. It then states:“The reasons for this decision are:“This Notice of Decision is to advise you of a decision by the employer in relation to your claim for compensation dated 29 February 2012 (the left shoulder claim) for a left shoulder injury that you suffered on 9 February 2012 (the left shoulder injury).“Background/Relevant matters1. On or about 9 February 2012 you suffered the left shoulder injury.2. On or about 29 February 2012 you submitted a claim to the employer in respect of the left shoulder injury.3. By written notice dated 18 April 2012 Allianz accepted the left shoulder claim on behalf of the employer.“4. In his report dated 28 August 2018, Dr Andrews reported as follows:“10. If the worker did suffer an injury to her left shoulder, was her employment with the employer a significant contributing cause of the injury? Please detail the basis of your opinion.It would seem reasonable that Joanne has had a work-related aggravation of her underlying condition. I would consider that the aggravation has now ceased and her ongoing problems are due to the underlying condition.“Capacity for Work11.If the worker did suffer an injury to her left shoulder, has the worker ceased to be incapacitated for work in relation to that injury?There does not seem to be any reason why Joanne could not return to work. She would be able to resume most occupations. She may struggle with an occupation that required heavy repetitive work above shoulder height.12. If the worker did suffer an injury to her left shoulder, and she continues to suffer any capacity for work, do you agree that the worker’s incapacity is no longer as a result of the work-related injury?Yes, any ongoing limitations are not due to the work-related injury.“5. On 13 September 2018 Dr Andrews issued a Statement of fitness for work – Final certificate in which he certified that:“(a) You have ceased to be incapacitated for work; and (b) Your incapacity is no longer as a result of the injury.“6. Further, Dr Andrew stated in the Final certificate:“Having examined the worker it is my opinion that as from 28 August 2018 in relation to her work-related injury, namely an aggravation of her underlying condition, that being impingement and a partial tear of her cuff and some AC joint arthritis of the left shoulder injury (the injury) sustained on 9 February 2012, I certify that:The worker has ceased to be incapacitated for work as a result of the injury.1. The injury, being the aggravation, has now ceased.2. If the worker is still incapacitated for work, then such incapacity is due to the worker’s underlying condition not related to the injury.There is no reason why the worker could not return to her pre-injury role.”“Based on the above, the employer has decided that:“1. You have ceased to be incapacitated (total or partial) as a result of the left shoulder injury.2. You no longer suffer from a work-related injury to your left shoulder for the purposes of the Return to Work Act.3. In light of all of the above, your entitlement to compensation is cancelled pursuant to sections 65 and 69 of the Return to Work Act “.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.