Australian Fuel Distributors Pty Ltd v Andros

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

Australian Fuel Distributors Pty Ltd v Andros [2015] NTSC 79

PARTIES:AUSTRALIAN FUEL DISTRIBUTORS PTY LTD

v

ANDROS, Tracey Ann

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE TERRITORY EXERCISING APPELLATE JURISDICTION

FILE NO:LA 2 of 2015 (21239424)

DELIVERED:  7 December 2015

HEARING DATES:  15 May 2015

JUDGMENT OF:  BLOKLAND J

APPEAL FROM:  WORK HEALTH COURT

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL – Work Health Court –Workers’ compensation – Cancellation of compensation per s 69 of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act – Whether onus of proof falls on worker or employer – Employer bears onus to prove the contents of the Notice of Decision – Whether error in finding the Notice of Decision asserted that the worker had ceased to be incapacitated at all as opposed to totally incapacitated

APPEAL – Work Health Court –Workers’ compensation –Whether decision contrary to agreement between parties about how case would proceed – Whether concession made by counsel for the worker – Scant evidence of any concession – Timing and nature of concession – Whether burden of proof disposed of by concession - If concession made, ample opportunity to deal with any prejudice

APPEAL – Work Health Court –Workers’ compensation – Whether onus of proof falls on worker or employer – Counterclaim of employer – Employer bears onus to prove matters pleaded in the counterclaim

Work Health Court Rules, r 3.04

Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act, ss 3, 65(2), 68, 69, 110A(2), 116(1)

AAT King's Tours Pty Ltd v Hughes (1994) 4 NTLR 185;Bruce Cooper v NT Link Pty Ltd [2012] NTMC 012; Candy v GIO General Limited [2013] NSWSC 810; Disability Services of Central Australia v Regan (1998) 8 NTLR 73; Drabsch v Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd (Unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales Equity Division, 16 October 1996); Ju Ju Nominees Pty Ltd v Carmichael (1999) 9 NTLR 1; McAllister v Kormilda College NTMC 9 July 2003; Newton v Masonic Inc t/as Tiwi Gardens Nursing Homes [2009] NTSC 51; Normandy Mining Pty Ltd v Horner [2000] NTSC 79; Northern Cement Pty Ltd v Ioasa [1994] NTSC 58; The Nominal Defendant v Gabriel (2007) 71 NSWLR 150, referred to.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant:W Roper

Respondent:  K Sibley

Solicitors:

Appellant:Hunt and Hunt Lawyers

Respondent:  Withnalls Lawyers

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:  BLO 1511

Number of pages:  56

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Australian Fuel Distributors Pty Ltd v Andros [2015] NTSC 79

No. 21239424

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN FUEL DISTRIBUTORS PTY LTD

Appellant

AND:

TRACEY ANN ANDROS

Respondent

CORAM:     BLOKLAND J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 7 December 2015)

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal brought by Australian Fuel Distributors Pty Ltd (the appellant employer) following proceedings in the Work Health Court.  The principal hearing took place on 18-20 March 2014.  Two sets of Reasons for Decision were delivered by the Work Health Court.  The first deals with difficulties the learned Chief Magistrate perceived shortly after…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Fuel Distributors Pty Ltd v Andros and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NTSC 79
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Australian Fuel Distributors Pty Ltd v Andros, the dispute centered around the employer's decision to cancel the worker's compensation benefits under section 69 of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act. The employer sought to challenge the court's decision to reinstate the worker's compensation benefits, arguing that the court had erred in its interpretation of the onus of proof and in finding that the Notice of Decision asserted that the worker had ceased to be incapacitated at all rather than totally incapacitated. Additionally, the employer contended that the court erred in finding that the employer bore the onus of proof, and that any concession made by the worker's counsel did not shift the burden of proof or dispose of the employer's counterclaim.

The primary legal issues the court had to decide were whether the employer bore the onus of proof to establish that the worker had ceased to be totally incapacitated for work, and whether the court had erred in finding that the Notice of Decision asserted that the worker had ceased to be incapacitated at all. The court also had to determine whether any concession made by the worker's counsel affected the burden of proof or prejudiced the employer in relation to the employer's counterclaim. The employer argued that the certificate, the covering letter, and all other materials were not inconsistent with its case, namely that all the employer had to prove was that there was no longer total incapacity.

The court found that the employer bore the onus of proving the contents of the Notice of Decision. The court found no error in the lower court's finding that the Notice of Decision asserted that the worker had ceased to be incapacitated at all. The court also found that the concession made by the worker's counsel did not shift the burden of proof or dispose of the employer's counterclaim. The court found that there was ample opportunity to deal with any prejudice the employer may have suffered as a result of the concession. The court found that the employer had not discharged its onus of proving that the worker had ceased to be totally incapacitated for work.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal be dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 20 February 2014, Dr Hogan certified the worker fit for light duties.[48] The Employer’s Decision to Cancel Benefits and the Section 69(3) Certificate The consultant physician, Dr Stevenson assessed the worker on 31 August 2012 and provided a s 69(3) Certificate. The form of the s 69(3) Certificate provides for two tick boxes.[49] The form states: “Please select and complete as appropriate”. Dr Stevenson ticked the first box which reads: “Ms Andros has ceased to be incapacitated for work as a result of that injury”. Next to the second tick box it is stated: “Ms Andros has recovered from the injury and has the capacity to carry out her pre-injury duties”. That box was not ticked. The appellant employer submitted it would have been open to the Work Health Court to find that this was certification of the cessation of any capacity for work had there been no concessions before and during the hearing to the effect the employer bore the onus of proving that the worker had ceased to be totally incapacitated for work. In the event the employer discharged that burden, on the employer’s case, the worker assumed the burden of establishing any partial incapacity for work. Dr Stevenson’s report of 13 September 2012[50] recorded the description of pain given by the worker to him. Under the heading “head/neck” his report states “on formal examination she had a full but slow range of movement of the neck achieving slow but full rotation to the right and left and grimaced fairly dramatically as if in pain. When the conversation moved on to issues away from the neck the grimaces disappeared”. Under the heading “Upper Limbs/Shoulder Girdles” the report states “there was a similar pattern in the examination of the upper limb. She had in fact a full range of all movement complaining of pain at the extremity, particularly on the left and grimacing emphatically. I could not identify any objective painful arc”.[51] Dr Stevenson found the work injury was a non-specific minor soft tissue strain which was long resolved.[52] In answer to the question as to recommended treatment for the work injury, his report states “there is no ongoing requirement for treatment. She can resume her usual work. To work or not is her own economic choice”. Dr Stevenson concluded “she is fully fit and is no longer incapacitated by her injury”. [53] The Notice of Decision of 18 September 2012[54] was accompanied inter alia, by a covering letter from the insurer advising the worker that her “entitlement to weekly compensation is to be cancelled in accordance with s 69 of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act”.[55] The Notice of Decision states “[y]ou had ceased to be incapacitated for work as a result of your work injury 17 November 2011”. The appellant employer argues the certificate, the covering letter and all other materials are not inconsistent with its case, namely that all the employer had to prove was that there was no longer total incapacity.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.