JM Kelly (Project Builders) Pty Ltd v Toga Development No 31 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

[2006] QSC 365

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CIVIL JURISDICTION

ROBIN A/J

No BS3651 of 2006

J M KELLY (PROJECT BUILDERS) PTY LTD (ACN 010 280 412) Plaintiff

and

TOGA DEVELOPMENT NO 31 PTY LTD
(ACN 103 796 854)
Defendant

BRISBANE

..DATE 03/11/2006

ORDER

CATCHWORDS:  Building contract - superintendent's certificate of payment requiring payment by contractor (builder) to principal (owner) - interlocutory injunction sought by contractor to prevent principal calling upon "performance undertaking" provided by an insurer as security - certificate alleged to be defective - injunction refused.

HIS HONOUR:  This is an application by the plaintiff for an injunction restraining the defendant until trial or earlier order from making any demand on QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited to convert two identified bonds, both dated 16 July 2004, into money.  Those bonds are for amounts of
$1.25 million or thereabouts each. 

They represent a security to the defendant, which engaged the plaintiff to construct a large development at Burleigh Heads, for the due performance of the builder's obligations.  There are two of them because half of the security was a longer term arrangement to cover the maintenance period, the other half a shorter term arrangement to last until 14 days after practical completion, a stage which is reasonably close.

The defendant's counsel indicates that its intention is not to convert both bonds into cash in their entirety, but to make a demand in respect of one of them only - and presumably the one with the more limited future - in an amount slightly in excess of $600,000, representing an amount which the superintendent under the building contract has certified ought to be paid by the builder, the plaintiff, to the defendant. 

I hope I am correct in understanding that, in substantial part, that sum is attributable to delay on the part of the builder as assessed by the superintendent. 

Is that right?

MR INATEY:  I don't think it can be put quite as - it's just an amount certified, I think, your Honour.

MR DUNNING:  The way I think that it could accurately be stated is without the delay assessed by the certifier, a negative certificate couldn't have issued at that stage.

HIS HONOUR:  Do you agree with that, Mr Inatey?

MR INATEY:  Would your Honour just excuse me a minute?  Again, I don't think we can put it quite as broadly as that.

HIS HONOUR:  All right.  Well, if you put it your way, this will all be on the record.

MR INATEY:  Liquidated damages forms a component part which led to the negative certificate.

HIS HONOUR:  That's the idea I was attempting to convey.

MR INATEY:  Yes, I don't think it can be said that without it, it would not have happened because there's been an ongoing certification process.

HIS HONOUR:  All right.

MR DUNNING:  Your Honour, if it assists, Mr Murphy's second affidavit, page 72 has a graph of the deduction for liquidated damages which, I gather, is not factually controversial.  And if you go to 43A, you'll…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JM Kelly (Project Builders) Pty Ltd v Toga Development No 31... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] QSC 365
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

JM Kelly (Project Builders) Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, sought an interlocutory injunction against Toga Development No 31 Pty Ltd, the defendant, to prevent the defendant from demanding payment from QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited to convert two performance bonds into cash. The plaintiff alleged that the superintendent's certificate of payment requiring payment by the plaintiff to the defendant was defective. The primary legal issue was whether the Court should grant an interlocutory injunction preventing the defendant from calling upon the performance undertaking provided by QBE Insurance. The court examined whether the certificate of payment was vitiated in some way and whether it was necessary to depart from the well-established approach that pending the ultimate adjudication of matters bearing upon payments between contracting parties, the certificates should be accorded the effect which the contractual arrangements give them. The court found that provisional as they may be, payments have to be made. Therefore, the plaintiff's application for an interlocutory injunction failed. The court dismissed the application with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

JM Kelly (Project Builders) Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, was engaged by Toga Development No 31 Pty Ltd, the defendant, to construct a large development at Burleigh Heads. The contract included a superintendent's certificate of payment mechanism. Certificate 43, dated September 11, 2006, certified that the plaintiff owed the defendant $601,541.09. This amount was corrected by certificate 43A, dated October 2, 2006, to confirm the actual sum payable by the plaintiff to the defendant. The plaintiff sought an interlocutory injunction to prevent the defendant from demanding payment from QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, the provider of a performance bond. The injunction was sought on the basis that the payment certificates were defective. The plaintiff contended that the superintendent had not acted independently or fairly, and that the certificates were flawed due to errors in calculations and application of GST.

This case involved an interlocutory application by the plaintiff, JM Kelly (Project Builders) Pty Ltd, seeking an injunction to restrain the defendant, Toga Development No 31 Pty Ltd, from making any demand on QBE Insurance to convert the performance bond into cash. The matter was heard by His Honour Judge Robin A/J in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The plaintiff argued that the payment certificates issued by the superintendent were defective and should not be honoured. The defendant maintained that the certificates were valid and enforceable under the contract. The plaintiff relied on authorities such as Wood Hall Limited v The Pipeline Authority and Rejan Constructions Pty Ltd v Manningham Medical Centre Pty Ltd. The defendant cited Re Concrete Constructions Group Pty Ltd as relevant authority.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should grant an interlocutory injunction to prevent the defendant from demanding payment from QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited under the performance bond.
2. Whether the payment certificates issued by the superintendent are defective and should not be enforced.
3. Whether there are any grounds to question the independence and impartiality of the superintendent in issuing the payment certificates.

Held
1. The court refused to grant an interlocutory injunction to prevent the defendant from demanding payment from QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited under the performance bond.
2. The court found that the payment certificates issued by the superintendent were not defective and should be enforced.
3. The court did not find any grounds to question the independence and impartiality of the superintendent in issuing the payment certificates.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The plaintiff sought an interlocutory injunction to prevent the defendant from calling upon a performance bond provided by QBE Insurance. The plaintiff argued that the payment certificates issued by the superintendent were defective and that the superintendent had failed to act independently. The court considered the legal principles surrounding interlocutory injunctions and the enforceability of payment certificates in building contracts. The court relied on the authority of Wood Hall Limited v The Pipeline Authority and Re Concrete Constructions Group Pty Ltd, which established that payment certificates are potent instruments under building contracts and that interim payments are provisional pending a final certificate. The court also noted that there was a dispute mechanism in the contract for resolving disputes regarding certificates. Despite the plaintiff's arguments, the court found that the certificates should be enforced as per the contractual provisions and the authorities cited. The court also found that there were no grounds to question the independence of the superintendent, as there was no evidence of fraud or illegality. The court concluded that the plaintiff's application for an injunction failed and dismissed it with costs.