JKB Holdings Pty Ltd v de la Vega (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: JKB Holdings Pty Ltd v de la Vega (No 5) [2012] NSWSC 1238
Hearing dates:28 September 2012
Decision date: 28 September 2012
Jurisdiction:Equity Division
Before: Rein J
Decision:

1. Direct that the amount of $712,003 be paid out by the Registry to the first and third plaintiffs on Wednesday 3 October 2012 on the basis that $262,003 of this is to be paid into a controlled money account.

2. The plaintiffs' costs are not to include the costs of the third plaintiff's affidavit, nor half the costs of the second plaintiff's affidavit of 18 September 2011.

3. The plaintiffs to pay the costs of the defendants in responding to the third plaintiff's affidavit and the paragraphs of the second plaintiff's affidavit which were not read, which costs are to be offset against the costs otherwise payable to the plaintiffs.

Catchwords:

PROCEDURE - costs - offers of compromise under the UCPR - where offer contains term that defendants are to pay the plaintiffs' costs of proceedings as agreed or assessed - offer not exclusive of costs and therefore inconsistent with the UCPR

PROCEDURE - costs - offer of compromise under the UCPR - where offer did not state that it would be relied on for indemnity costs - where offer not capable of acceptance in absence of formal deed - offer not in accordance with the UCPR and cannot be relied on for indemnity costs

PROCEDURE - costs - Calderbank offers - where offer is not expressed to be Calderbank - where basis of calculation of offer not explained - where offer only open for seven days - offer cannot be relied on as Calderbank offer and in any event not established that it was unreasonable not to accept the offer

PROCEDURE - costs - conduct of parties - where party abandoned claim at the commencement of hearing - where party not successful on a point - insufficient to warrant order for indemnity costs

PROCEDURE - costs - apportionment of costs - extensive affidavits not relied on at hearing - plaintiff not entitled to recover costs of preparing those affidavits or portions not read

PROCEDURE - money paid into court by defendants - balance after payment out of judgment sum - whether balance should be released to defendants pending assessment of or agreement on costs - where there is no evidence that defendants unable to pay their own lawyers or other creditors - balance should remain in court
Legislation Cited: Practice Note SC Gen 16
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005
Cases Cited: Colgate-Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Ltd [1993] FCA 536
Cretazzo v Lombardi (1975) 13 SASR 4
Dean v Stockland Property Management Pty Limited [2010] NSWCA 66
Elite Protective Personnel Pty Ltd v Salmon [2007] NSWCA 322
Frisbo Holdings Pty Ltd v Austin Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] NSWSC 298
In the matter of Cheal Industries Pty Limited - Fitzpatrick and Cheal [2012] NSWSC 932
James v Surf Road…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JKB Holdings Pty Ltd v de la Vega (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWSC 1238
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of JKB Holdings Pty Ltd v de la Vega (No 5) involves a dispute between the plaintiff, JKB Holdings Pty Ltd, and the defendants, de la Vega. The primary focus of the case was the calculation of a judgment sum, which was previously determined in an earlier judgment. The matter came before the court for a final determination of the amount owed, and the subsequent allocation of costs. The court had to address several legal issues, including the interpretation of offers of compromise under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR), the conditions under which indemnity costs could be awarded, and the appropriate apportionment of costs between the parties.

The court examined whether certain offers made by the defendants complied with the UCPR and could be considered for indemnity costs. The court found that the offers were inconsistent with the UCPR as they did not exclude all costs and were not expressed to be Calderbank offers. The court also considered whether the plaintiff was entitled to indemnity costs due to the defendants' conduct, such as abandoning a claim at the commencement of the hearing. The court concluded that the defendants' conduct did not warrant an order for indemnity costs. Additionally, the court deliberated on the apportionment of costs, specifically whether the plaintiff could recover the costs of preparing extensive affidavits that were not relied upon at the hearing. The court held that the plaintiff was not entitled to recover those costs.

The court's reasoning and outcome were based on a detailed analysis of the UCPR, relevant case law, and the specific circumstances of the case. The court concluded that the defendants' offers of compromise did not comply with the UCPR and therefore could not be considered for indemnity costs. The court also determined that the plaintiff was not entitled to indemnity costs due to the defendants' conduct. Regarding the apportionment of costs, the court ruled that the plaintiff could not recover the costs of preparing affidavits that were not used in the proceedings. The court ultimately directed the parties to provide further calculations and submissions, leading to an agreed judgment amount of $712,003.

The final orders of the court included the determination of the judgment sum and the directions for further submissions and calculations. The court also instructed the parties to provide additional information and calculations to facilitate the final resolution of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I handed down my reasons for judgment on 7 September 2012 in JKB Holdings Pty Ltd v de la Vega (No 4) [2012] NSWSC 1177 ("the principal judgment") but was not able then to enter judgment for a particular amount due to the need for calculations to be undertaken of interest. I directed the parties to provide their calculations to each other and to provide the Court with submissions on: The parties provided written submissions and today I have heard oral submissions from Mr M Steele of counsel on behalf of the plaintiffs and Mr S Y Reuben of counsel on behalf of the defendants. The terms used in these reasons are those used in the principal judgment, which will need to be read in conjunction with these reasons. The plaintiff has calculated an amount of $738,792: see Annexure A to the plaintiffs' submissions on calculations ("PSCC"). The defendants calculate the amount as either: The principal area of dispute in relation to the calculation arises from the difficulty that: The $75,100 cannot be treated as going towards the First, Second and Third Loans if it is to be used to repay the August $52,000 Loan and the interest on it, as I indicated in my principal judgment it should be. On the other hand, there is a period of time when the de la Vegas are in effect in credit on the August $52,000 Loan which is attracting interest. I think that the only fair way to deal with this is to treat the $75,100 and the $8000 as payments towards interest on the first three loans until the amounts were called on to offset the $52,000 loan and the interest on it. It follows that the de la Vegas should have an offset for interest on the $75,100 and the $8000 at the contractual rate of interest of 17.5 per cent for 12 months and 20 per cent thereafter until the $52,000 was paid. I indicated to the parties this morning also that JKB could not recover for the $8000 on the March $75,000 which it had previously allocated to the JKB loans. Further, it was accepted that the interest on the small loans should be calculated for the later period in accordance with Practice Note SC Gen 16 and not the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 ("UCPR"). When these matters were taken into account, the agreed judgment amount for JKB was $690,369, and the agreed amount for Mrs Schwede's small loans was $38,974, a total of $712,003. The plaintiff relies on several offers made, namely: This offer contained the term: The question of whether the approach taken in Old v McInnes is correct in the light of other decisions of the Court of Appeal, see Vieira v O'Shea (No 2) [2012] NSWCA 121 and Dean v Stockland Property Management Pty Limited [2010] NSWCA 66 ("Dean v Stockland"), and the judgment at first instance of Garling J of Rail Corporation of New South Wales v Vero Insurance Company (No 2) [2012] NSWSC 926, was canvassed in Ziliotto v Dr Hakim (No 2) [2012] NSWSC 1079 by Davies J very recently. Another of the cases considered was a decision of Ward J in In the matter of Cheal Industries Pty Limited - Fitzpatrick and Cheal [2012] NSWSC 932 ("Cheal"), in which her Honour, having undertaken her own analysis of the earlier decisions, regarded herself as bound by the decision in Old v McInnes. A decision not cited to her Honour in Cheal was the Court of Appeal's decision in Vieira v O'Shea (No.2), a decision of Basten and Meagher JJA and Handley AJA, in which it was noted that the appellant had conceded that the offer made did not comply with the UCPR because it was not "exclusive of costs". It was said at [7]:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established