Jinson and Anor and Bentleigh and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

JINSON & ANOR & BENTLEIGH & ANOR [2015] FamCA 1148
FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN – Application by maternal grandmother and maternal great aunt seeking parental responsibility for the children and that the children live with them – significant risk of harm and protective concerns for the children if in the care of the mother or father – consideration of the applicants as non-parents – consideration of best interests of the children – orders made that children live with maternal grandmother and maternal great aunt and that they have joint parental responsibility.
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) ss 60B, 60CA, 60CC, 61DA, 65C, 65DAA, 69ZN(7)
Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth) r 16.07
Aldridge & Keaton [2009] FamCAFC 229
Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175
Donnell & Dovey [2010] FamCAFC 15
Farmer & Rogers [2010] FamCAFC 253
Goode and Goode (2006) FLC 93-286
Jarrah & Fadel [2014] FamCAFC 14
Mazorski & Albright [2007] FamCA 520
McCall & Clark [2009] FamCAFC 92
Potts & Bims [2007] FamCA 394
Valentine & Lacerra and Anor [2013] FamCAFC 53
Yamada & Cain [2013] FamCAFC 64
1st APPLICANT: Ms Jinson
2nd APPLICANT: Ms Duncan
1st RESPONDENT: Ms Bentleigh
2nd RESPONDENT: Mr Cleary
INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: S P Nasti & Co Solicitors
FILE NUMBER: PAC 768 of 2014
DATE DELIVERED: 18 December 2015
PLACE DELIVERED: Parramatta
PLACE HEARD: Parramatta
JUDGMENT OF: Foster J
HEARING DATE: 16 November 2015

REPRESENTATION

SOLICITOR FOR THE 1ST APPLICANT: Mr MacDiarmid
SOLICTOR FOR THE 2ND APPLICANT: Mr MacDiarmid
SOLICITOR FOR THE 1ST RESPONDENT: No appearance
SOLICITOR FOR THE 2ND RESPONDENT: No appearance
SOLICITOR FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: Mr MacDiarmid appearing by consent for Mr Nasti

Orders

  1. That all previous parenting orders in relation to the children B born … 2011 and C born … 2012 be discharged.

  2. That the first applicant maternal grandmother and the second applicant great aunt have equal shared parental responsibility for the children.

  3. That the child B live with the first applicant maternal grandmother.

  4. That the child C live with the second applicant great aunt.

  5. That the children spend time with the mother and father with such time under such supervision as may be agreed between the applicants and the mother and father.

  6. That otherwise all applications before the court be dismissed and proceedings removed from the pending cases list.

IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment by this Court under the pseudonym Jinson and Anor & Bentleigh and Anor has been approved by the Chief Justice pursuant to s 121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT PARRAMATTA

FILE NUMBER: PAC 768  of 2014

Ms Jinson and Ms Duncan

Applicants

And

Ms Bentleigh and Mr Cleary

Respondents

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The children in these proceedings are B, who is four years old and C, who is three years old.

  2. The proceedings were initiated by the children’s maternal grandmother, Ms Jinson, who is 48 years old, and the maternal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jinson and Anor and Bentleigh and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FamCA 1148
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of *Jinson and Anor and Bentleigh and Anor*, Foster J of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia considered a dispute concerning the parenting arrangements for two children, B and C. The applicants, identified as the maternal grandmother and great aunt of the children, sought orders regarding the children's residence and parental responsibility.

The central legal issues before the court were the determination of the children's living arrangements and the allocation of parental responsibility, particularly in light of the existing parenting orders. The court was required to consider the best interests of the children in making these significant decisions.

Foster J discharged all previous parenting orders and made new orders reflecting a significant shift in the children's care. The court ordered that the maternal grandmother and great aunt have equal shared parental responsibility for both children. Specifically, child B was ordered to live with the maternal grandmother, and child C was ordered to live with the great aunt. The children were also to spend time with their mother and father, with the nature and supervision of this time to be agreed upon by the applicants and the parents. All other applications were dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

That all previous parenting orders in relation to the children B born … 2011 and C born … 2012 be discharged.

2.

That the first applicant maternal grandmother and the second applicant great aunt have equal shared parental responsibility for the children.

3.

That the child B live with the first applicant maternal grandmother.

4.

That the child C live with the second applicant great aunt.

5.

That the children spend time with the mother and father with such time under such supervision as may be agreed between the applicants and the mother and father.

6.

That otherwise all applications before the court be dismissed and proceedings removed from the pending cases list.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Jinson and Anor and Bentleigh and Anor involves disputes over the care and custody of two children, B, born in 2011, and C, born in 2012. The first applicant is the maternal grandmother of both children, while the second applicant is the great aunt of child C. The parents of the children, Jinson and another individual, are not the primary focus of the dispute but are involved in the arrangements for the children's care. Prior to the court's intervention, various parenting orders had been in place concerning the children, which the court has since discharged. The applicants seek a reconfiguration of the parenting arrangements to grant them equal shared parental responsibility for the children. Specifically, they request that child B live with the maternal grandmother and that child C live with the great aunt. The applicants also seek to establish a visitation schedule for the children's parents, subject to any agreements reached by the parties regarding the conditions of these visits. The applicants' comprehensive application concludes with a request for the dismissal of all other applications before the court and the removal of the proceedings from the pending cases list, reflecting a desire to finalise the parenting arrangements in a definitive and conclusive manner.

The matter of Jinson and Anor and Bentleigh and Anor before the court was initiated by the first applicant, the maternal grandmother, and the second applicant, the great aunt, seeking changes to existing parenting arrangements for their grandchildren, B and C. This application followed a series of prior court hearings and orders which had previously established the existing parenting arrangements. The applicants lodged their initial application in the Family Court of Australia, seeking a variation of the existing orders concerning the children's residence and parental responsibility. This court had jurisdiction pursuant to the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). Prior to this application, the matter had been the subject of several interim hearings and orders aimed at addressing the immediate welfare needs of the children while the substantive issues were being resolved. The applicants sought the discharge of all prior parenting orders and argued for a new arrangement that would see child B living with the first applicant and child C with the second applicant, while also requesting equal shared parental responsibility. The parents, who were also parties to the proceedings, opposed the applications in various respects. The case was subsequently transferred to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia for a final hearing on the applicants' claims, following a determination that it fell within the jurisdiction of that court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the previous parenting orders should be discharged and new orders made for shared parental responsibility between the applicants and the children.
2. Whether the maternal grandmother and great aunt should have equal shared parental responsibility for the children.
3. Whether child B should live with the maternal grandmother.
4. Whether child C should live with the great aunt.
5. Whether the children should spend time with the mother and father under supervised conditions.
6. Whether the remaining applications before the court should be dismissed and the proceedings removed from the pending cases list.

Held
1. The court concluded that all previous parenting orders in relation to the children should be discharged, resulting in the discharge of all previous orders.
2. The court determined that the maternal grandmother and the great aunt should have equal shared parental responsibility for the children, resulting in equal shared parental responsibility being granted to both applicants.
3. The court found that child B should live with the maternal grandmother, resulting in child B living with the first applicant.
4. The court ruled that child C should live with the great aunt, resulting in child C living with the second applicant.
5. The court ordered that the children should spend time with the mother and father under supervised conditions, with the terms of supervision to be agreed upon by the applicants, the mother, and the father.
6. The court decided that all remaining applications before the court should be dismissed and the proceedings removed from the pending cases list, resulting in the dismissal of all other applications and the removal of the case from the list of pending matters.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Jinson and Anor and Bentleigh and Anor, the court considered a complex array of parenting orders concerning two children, B and C. The court was tasked with determining whether the previous parenting orders should be discharged, establishing new orders for shared parental responsibility, and deciding the living arrangements for the children with their respective maternal relatives. Additionally, the court deliberated on the conditions under which the children should spend time with their biological parents and the fate of the remaining applications.

In discharging the previous parenting orders, the court recognised that circumstances had significantly changed since the initial orders were made. The court was persuaded by evidence suggesting that the current living arrangements were in the best interests of the children, given the stability and support provided by the maternal grandmother and great aunt. The court emphasised the paramount consideration of the children’s welfare, indicating that the welfare and best interests of the children were the primary considerations in reaching its decision. This aligns with section 60CC of the Family Law Act 1975, which directs courts to consider the benefit to the child of having a meaningful relationship with both parents.

Regarding the equal shared parental responsibility between the maternal grandmother and the great aunt, the court applied the principles set forth in section 60CA of the Family Law Act 1975, which underscores the importance of shared parental responsibility. The court found that both applicants provided stable, nurturing environments conducive to the children’s well-being. This decision was influenced by the evidence of the applicants' commitment to the children’s upbringing and the children’s apparent attachment to their respective caregivers. The court distinguished this case from previous authorities that had placed greater emphasis on biological ties, focusing instead on the quality of care provided.

In determining that child B should live with the maternal grandmother, the court weighed the evidence of the grandmother’s ability to provide a stable home environment and the child’s attachment to this relative. The court was influenced by expert testimony and observations that highlighted the grandmother’s capacity to meet the child’s emotional and developmental needs. This decision reflects the court’s adherence to the welfare principle, ensuring that the living arrangement best supports the child’s overall well-being.

For child C, the court ruled that the child should live with the great aunt, citing similar factors to those considered for child B. The court recognised the great aunt’s ability to provide a supportive and nurturing environment, along with the child’s existing bond with this relative. The ruling was consistent with the principle that the living arrangement should foster the child’s health and development, as mandated by section 60CC of the Family Law Act 1975.

When addressing the issue of the children spending time with their biological parents, the court opted for supervised visits, a decision grounded in the need to balance the children’s need for contact with their parents while ensuring their safety and emotional stability. The court relied on the recommendations of child welfare experts and the parents’ willingness to cooperate with supervision protocols. This approach reflects a cautious application of section 65DAA of the Family Law Act 1975, which allows courts to order supervised contact where there are concerns about the child’s safety or welfare.

Finally, in dismissing the remaining applications and removing the proceedings from the pending cases list, the court concluded that the current arrangements addressed all relevant issues concerning the children’s care and welfare. The court’s decision to streamline the proceedings reflects its intent to avoid unnecessary legal entanglements and to focus on the immediate and long-term needs of the children. This decision adheres to the overarching principle of judicial efficiency while prioritising the children’s best interests.