Jetstar Airways Pty Ltd v Neeteson-Lemkes

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

[2014] FWCFB 8683

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.604 - Appeal of decisions
Jetstar Airways Pty Limited
v
Monique Neeteson-Lemkes
(C2013/5863)
VICE PRESIDENT HATCHER
SENIOR DEPUTY PRESIDENT DRAKE
COMMISSIONER RIORDAN SYDNEY, 24 DECEMBER 2014

Appeal against decision [2013] FWC 5840 of Commissioner McKenna at Sydney on 16

August 2013 in matter number U2013/27.

1

[1] In a decision issued on 13 December 2013 (Appeal Decision), this Full Bench

2  3

quashed a decision and order made on 16 August 2013 which reinstated Ms Monique

Neeteson-Lemkes to her former employment as a flight attendant with Jetstar Airways Pty

Limited (Jetstar). In the Appeal Decision, we proceeded to re-determine Ms Neeteson-

Lemkes’s application for an unfair dismissal remedy. It was concluded that her dismissal was

harsh, unjust and unreasonable. However we did not proceed to deal with the question of

remedy (in circumstances where Ms Neeteson-Lemkes sought the primary remedy of

reinstatement) because we considered that before we could do so, it would be necessary for us

to have before us additional expert medical evidence concerning Ms Neeteson-Lemkes’s

capacity to resume duties as a flight attendant. We also expressed a concern that we had not

received any information or submissions concerning another issue identified in the Appeal

4

Decision. Directions were subsequently made to allow further evidence to be filed

concerning these matters, including specific directions to facilitate the provision of a report by

an agreed independent forensic psychiatrist. These directions were made on the basis that Ms

Neeteson-Lemkes maintained her claim for a reinstatement order.

[2]        A hearing before us for the purpose of receiving the additional evidence filed pursuant

to those directions and any further submission which the parties wished to make occurred on

17 July 2014. That hearing was adjourned before it was completed because it emerged that a

defect in the instructions given for the preparation of the agreed independent psychiatrist’s

report meant that a matter of significance had not been considered and dealt with. This made

it necessary for a further independent psychiatric report to be obtained.
[2014] FWCFB 8683

[3]        Before this could be done, there was a change of position on the part of Ms Neeteson-

Lemkes. On 22 August 2014 Ms Neeteson-Lemkes informed the Commission that she no

longer sought the remedy of reinstatement, and instead sought compensation under s.392 of

the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act). In the light of this, directions were made for the filing of

written submissions in relation to compensation. We formed the view that the issue of

compensation could be adequately determined without the need for the parties to make oral

submissions, and the parties consented to the appeal proceedings being finalised without the

need for a further hearing. Accordingly, pursuant to s.607(1) of the Act, the issue of

compensation will be determined on the basis of the parties written submissions.

[4]        Section 390(3) of the Act provides that the Commission must not order the payment of

compensation as an unfair dismissal remedy to a person unless…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jetstar Airways Pty Ltd v Neeteson-Lemkes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FWCFB 8683
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Fair Work Commission Full Bench heard an appeal by Jetstar Airways Pty Limited against a decision by Commissioner McKenna to reinstate Monique Neeteson-Lemkes to her former employment as a flight attendant. In the initial decision, the Commissioner had found that Ms Neeteson-Lemkes' dismissal was harsh, unjust, and unreasonable. The Full Bench, however, quashed the reinstatement order and ordered that the matter be re-determined. The primary legal issue before the Full Bench was whether Ms Neeteson-Lemkes was entitled to compensation for her unfair dismissal, rather than reinstatement, and if so, how much compensation should be awarded.

The Full Bench found that Ms Neeteson-Lemkes' dismissal was unfair because she was not given a proper opportunity to respond to the medical reports that formed the basis of her dismissal. The evidence demonstrated that had she been given this opportunity, it was likely Jetstar would have reconsidered its position and not dismissed her. The Full Bench further found that Ms Neeteson-Lemkes had suffered pecuniary loss as a result of her dismissal, as she had been unable to return to work as a flight attendant and had been underemployed or unemployed since the dismissal. The Full Bench calculated the compensation amount by taking into account the lost remuneration, other earnings, and a reduction for mitigation efforts. The Full Bench concluded that Jetstar should pay Ms Neeteson-Lemkes $36,298.00 as compensation for her unfair dismissal, an amount that was below the statutory compensation cap.

The Full Bench ordered Jetstar to pay Ms Neeteson-Lemkes $36,298.00 as compensation for her unfair dismissal within 21 days of the decision. The Full Bench considered that this amount was appropriate in all the circumstances of the case, taking into account the various factors outlined in the Fair Work Act 2009. The Full Bench did not consider it necessary to order payment by instalments or to make any adjustments for viability, length of service, or misconduct. The Full Bench's decision provides guidance on the assessment of compensation in unfair dismissal cases and the importance of considering all relevant factors when determining an appropriate amount.