JDM Investments Pty Ltd v Todbern Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read
CITATION: JDM Investments Pty Ltd v Todbern Pty Ltd [2000] NSWSC 349
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 1225/00
HEARING DATE(S): 10, 11, 15, 17, 18 & 25 February and 7 March 2000
JUDGMENT DATE: 27 April 2000

PARTIES :


JDM Investments Pty Limited (Receiver & Manager Appointed) (Administrator Appointed) (P)
Todbern Pty Limited (D)
JUDGMENT OF: Hamilton J
COUNSEL : R R I Harper (P)
M L D Einfeld QC and F P Donohoe (D)
SOLICITORS: Coudert Brothers (P)
Verekers (D)
CATCHWORDS: CONTRACTS [18] - General contractual principles - Offer and acceptance - Matters not giving rise to binding contract - Vagueness and uncertainty - Introductory - Commercial lease - Whether term so incapable of any definite or precise meaning that Court unable to attribute any particular contractual intention - CONTRACTS [120] - General contractual principles - Construction and interpretation of contracts - Other matters - Admissibility of extrinsic evidence - To show meaning of terms - Subsequent conduct - Whether course of conduct clear enough to show intention - CONVEYANCING [10] - Relationship of vendor and purchaser - Matters arising between contract and conveyance - Conditions precedent and subsequent - Other conditions - Condition of approval of form of assignment of lease by lessor and its solicitors - Ambit of matters to be taken into account in giving or withholding approval - ESTOPPEL [37] - Estoppel in pais - The representation - In general - Whether statement that lessor has given "blanket consent" or delegated right to consent to assignment to a subtenant a representation that there will be no future insistence on necessity for consent - LANDLORD AND TENANT [43] [44] - Covenants - Not to assign or sublet - Consent of lessor - Covenant which stipulates conditions which may be attached to consent to assignment to corporation but does not otherwise stipulate requirement of consent - Whether to be construed as requiring consent in all cases or whether term requiring consent in all cases to be implied - Other matters - Clause containing covenant against assignment or subletting but permitting same on fulfilment of conditions - Operation of clause - LANDLORD AND TENANT [88] - Termination of the tenancy - Forfeiture - Waiver of forfeiture - What amounts to - Whether statement that lessor has given "blanket consent" or delegated right to consent to assignment to a subtenant sufficient to preclude future insistence on necessity for consent.
LEGISLATION CITED: Conveyancing Act 1919 ss 120, 129, 133B(1)
CASES CITED: Adler v Upper Grosvenor Street Investment Ltd [1957] 1 WLR 227
Brown v Gould [1972] Ch 53
Caney v Leith [1937] 2 All ER 532
Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of New South Wales (1982) 149 CLR 337
Creer v P & O Lines of Australia Pty Limited (1971) 125 CLR 84
Hammond v Vam Ltd [1972] 2 NSWLR 16
Hide & Skin Trading Pty Limited v Oceanic Meat Traders Limited (1990) 20 NSWLR 310
International Drilling Fluids Ltd v Louisville Investments (Uxbridge) Ltd [1986]…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JDM Investments Pty Ltd v Todbern Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWSC 349
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

JDM Investments Pty Ltd, the original tenant of a property, was involved in a dispute with Todbern Pty Ltd, the landlord, regarding the assignment of the lease to a subtenant. The primary issue was whether the landlord's alleged consent to the assignment was binding and whether the lease's terms could be enforced. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The court had to determine whether the landlord's vague statement, that it had given "blanket consent" to the assignment or delegated the right to consent, constituted a representation that would preclude future insistence on the necessity for consent. Additionally, the court needed to interpret the lease's assignment clause and determine whether the landlord's consent was required in all cases or if such a requirement should be implied. The court also had to consider whether the landlord's conduct constituted a waiver of its right to insist on consent, particularly in light of the alleged blanket consent.

The court found that the landlord's statement did not amount to a representation that would preclude future insistence on the necessity for consent. It held that the lease's assignment clause did not require the landlord's consent in all cases and that such a requirement could not be implied. Furthermore, the court held that the landlord's conduct did not amount to a waiver of its right to insist on consent. The court concluded that the lease's assignment clause was valid and enforceable, and the landlord was not estopped from enforcing the clause.

The court ordered that the lease's assignment clause was valid and enforceable, and that the landlord was not estopped from enforcing it. The court further ordered that the assignment of the lease to the subtenant was invalid, and that JDM Investments Pty Ltd remained liable for the obligations under the lease. The court did not grant any relief to the subtenant or JDM Investments Pty Ltd in relation to the assignment.

Background

Background to the litigation

JDM Investments Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) and Todbern Pty Ltd (the defendant) entered into a commercial lease agreement for a property. The lease contained a covenant which stipulated conditions under which the defendant could assign the lease to a corporation, but did not otherwise require the defendant's consent for an assignment. The defendant subsequently entered into a sublease with another party. The plaintiff sought a declaration that the sublease was invalid due to the lack of consent from the defendant. The defendant argued that it had given "blanket consent" for any assignment or sublease, and that this had been communicated to the subtenant. The subtenant, in turn, claimed that it had relied on this representation and had entered into the sublease believing that the defendant's consent was not required.

The matter was first heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, where the plaintiff sought a declaration that the sublease was invalid. The defendant argued that the representation of "blanket consent" amounted to an estoppel preventing the plaintiff from insisting on the requirement of consent. The trial judge found in favour of the plaintiff, holding that the term "blanket consent" was too vague and uncertain to be enforceable and that no estoppel had been established. The defendant appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal, which allowed the appeal and remitted the matter back to the trial judge for reconsideration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the term "blanket consent" or the delegation of the right to consent to a subtenant is so vague and uncertain that the Court is unable to attribute any particular contractual intention to it.
2. Whether the representation that the defendant has given "blanket consent" or delegated the right to consent to a subtenant can be considered a representation that there will be no future insistence on the necessity for consent, thus creating an estoppel.
3. Whether a covenant against assignment or subletting, which permits the same on the fulfilment of certain conditions, requires consent in all cases or if a term requiring consent in all cases should be implied.
4. Whether the statement by the defendant that it has given "blanket consent" or delegated the right to consent to a subtenant is sufficient to preclude any future insistence on the necessity for consent.

Held
1. The court held that the term "blanket consent" or the delegation of the right to consent to a subtenant is not so vague and uncertain that the Court is unable to attribute any particular contractual intention to it.
2. The court held that the representation that the defendant has given "blanket consent" or delegated the right to consent to a subtenant cannot be considered a representation that there will be no future insistence on the necessity for consent, thus creating an estoppel.
3. The court held that a covenant against assignment or subletting, which permits the same on the fulfilment of certain conditions, does not require consent in all cases. No term requiring consent in all cases should be implied.
4. The court held that the statement by the defendant that it has given "blanket consent" or delegated the right to consent to a subtenant is not sufficient to preclude any future insistence on the necessity for consent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the term "blanket consent" or the delegation of the right to consent to a subtenant in the context of a commercial lease agreement. It determined that such terms are not inherently vague and uncertain, as they can be understood to mean the lessor has granted permission for subletting without the need for individual approval for each subtenant. The court emphasised that the term is capable of having a definite and precise meaning, and therefore, the Court can attribute a particular contractual intention to it. Regarding the estoppel, the court held that a mere representation about the current state of consent does not equate to a representation about future conduct, which is necessary to create an estoppel. In terms of the covenant against assignment or subletting, the court found that since the covenant allows for assignment under certain conditions, it does not require consent in all cases. The court declined to imply a term requiring consent in all cases, as this would contradict the express terms of the covenant which permit assignment under specific conditions. Lastly, the court concluded that the defendant's statement about "blanket consent" or delegation does not preclude future insistence on the necessity for consent, as the terms of the lease allow for conditions to be attached to consent. This means that even if the lessor has given a general consent, it does not mean that they have waived their right to require consent in the future if the conditions for consent are not met.