Jango v Northern Territory of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Jango v Northern Territory of Australia [2003] FCA 1230

NATIVE TITLE – Application seeking orders for a regime for “male gender restricted evidence” and “female gender restricted evidence” – sufficient evidence to warrant taking cultural and customary concerns into account, pursuant to s 82(2) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) – whether other parties would be prejudiced “unduly” by orders sought

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), ss 17, 50
Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), ss 50(2), 61(1), 82
Native Title Amendment Act 1998 (Cth)

Wandarang, Alawa, Marr & Ngalakan Peoples v Northern Territory of Australia (2000) 104 FCR 380 cited.
Western Australia v Ward (1997) 76 FCR 492 applied.
Sampi v Western Australia [2001] FCA 620 cited.

JOHNNY JANGO & ORS v NORTHERN TERRITORY & ORS
DG 6023 of 1998

SACKVILLE J
YULARA
31 OCTOBER 2003


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NORTHERN TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

DG 6023 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

JOHNNY JANGO
APPLICANT

AND:

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA
FIRST RESPONDENT

GPT MANAGEMENT LIMITED
SECOND RESPONDENT

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
THIRD RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

SACKVILLE J

DATE OF ORDER:

31 OCTOBER 2003

WHERE MADE:

YULARA

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Orders 3, 4 and 5 are to apply to male gender restricted evidence.

2.“Male gender restricted evidence” means such information relating to Aboriginal law and custom as may be identified, recorded in written form or given in oral evidence at the hearings to take place on 3, 4 and 5 November 2003 in accordance with the Annotated Hearing Schedule and Planning Notes dated 28 October 2003, which information may not be disseminated to:

(a)women;

(b)uninitiated men;

(c)non Aboriginal men; or

(d)children.

3.The following people only may be present at the hearing when any male gender restricted evidence is given as oral evidence or may read any male gender restricted evidence or any transcript thereof:

(a)any male party;

(b)any male expert engaged by a party for the purpose of providing advice about such matters;

(c)any male counsel, male solicitor or necessary male staff of a party; and

(d)the Judge and those male staff as directed by the Judge.

4.Male gender restricted evidence must not be divulged to any person not present at the hearing other than:

(a)male parties;

(b)male experts engaged by a party for the purpose of providing advice about such matters;

(c)male counsel, male solicitors or necessary male staff of a party; and

(d)a Judge and those male staff of a Judge as directed by the Judge.

5.   Male gender restricted evidence:

(a)shall be recorded and transcribed by a man;

(b)shall, along with any audio and computer records of the evidence, be kept separate from the general transcript and shall be printed on coloured paper;

(c)shall have a covering sheet marked:

“‘Gender Restricted Evidence’ – This transcript records evidence and submissions in relation to matters of Aboriginal law and custom which by Order of the Court must not be viewed by any person other than:

(i)      any male party

(ii)any male expert engaged by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jango v Northern Territory of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 1230
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Jango v Northern Territory of Australia, the applicants, who are Aboriginal claimants, sought permission from the court to give evidence in a gender-restricted manner during their land claim hearings. The applicants wished to present evidence that was considered sacred and could not be shared with people outside of specific gender groups due to cultural sensitivities. The Northern Territory of Australia, as the respondent, did not oppose the applicants' request but sought clarification on the appropriate protocols for handling such evidence. The court was required to determine the appropriate measures to ensure the protection and confidentiality of the gender-restricted evidence, while also considering the legal rights of all parties involved.

The court acknowledged the importance of respecting the cultural practices of the Aboriginal claimants and recognised that the evidence in question contained sensitive information that should not be disclosed to certain individuals. The court outlined specific orders to govern the presentation and handling of gender-restricted evidence during the hearings. These orders included defining the scope of male and female gender-restricted evidence, specifying who could be present during the evidence presentation, and detailing the procedures for recording, transcribing, and storing the evidence. The court also emphasised the importance of adhering to a protocol for the secure handling of gender-restricted evidence and ordered that all records of such evidence be destroyed upon the conclusion of the proceedings.

Following the court's consideration of the matter, several orders were made to govern the presentation and handling of gender-restricted evidence during the land claim hearings. These orders included defining the scope of male and female gender-restricted evidence, specifying who could be present during the evidence presentation, and detailing the procedures for recording, transcribing, and storing the evidence. The court also emphasised the importance of adhering to a protocol for the secure handling of gender-restricted evidence and ordered that all records of such evidence be destroyed upon the conclusion of the proceedings. The respondent was granted liberty to apply for modifications to the orders if necessary.

In summary, the court in Jango v Northern Territory of Australia granted the applicants' request to present gender-restricted evidence during their land claim hearings, while also implementing measures to ensure the protection and confidentiality of such evidence. The court's orders outlined specific protocols for handling gender-restricted evidence, including restrictions on who could be present during the evidence presentation and procedures for recording, transcribing, and storing the evidence. The court also emphasised the importance of adhering to a protocol for the secure handling of gender-restricted evidence and ordered that all records of such evidence be destroyed upon the conclusion of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Orders 3, 4 and 5 are to apply to male gender restricted evidence.

2. “Male gender restricted evidence” means such information relating to Aboriginal law and custom as may be identified, recorded in written form or given in oral evidence at the hearings to take place on 3, 4 and 5 November 2003 in accordance with the Annotated Hearing Schedule and Planning Notes dated 28 October 2003, which information may not be disseminated to:

(a) women;

(b) uninitiated men;

(c) non Aboriginal men; or

(d) children.

3. The following people only may be present at the hearing when any male gender restricted evidence is given as oral evidence or may read any male gender restricted evidence or any transcript thereof:

(a) any male party;

(b) any male expert engaged by a party for the purpose of providing advice about such matters;

(c) any male counsel, male solicitor or necessary male staff of a party; and

(d) the Judge and those male staff as directed by the Judge.

4. Male gender restricted evidence must not be divulged to any person not present at the hearing other than:

(a) male parties;

(b) male experts engaged by a party for the purpose of providing advice about such matters;

(c) male counsel, male solicitors or necessary male staff of a party; and

(d) a Judge and those male staff of a Judge as directed by the Judge.

5. Male gender restricted evidence:

(a) shall be recorded and transcribed by a man;

(b) shall, along with any audio and computer records of the evidence, be kept separate from the general transcript and shall be printed on coloured paper;

(c) shall have a covering sheet marked:

“‘Gender Restricted Evidence’ – This transcript records evidence and submissions in relation to matters of Aboriginal law and custom which by Order of the Court must not be viewed by any person other than:

(i) any male party

(ii) any male expert engaged by a party for the purpose of providing advice about such matters;

(iii) any male counsel, male solicitor or necessary male staff of a party; and

(iv) the Judge and those male staff as directed by the Judge.”

6. Orders 8, 9 and 10 are to apply to female gender restricted evidence.

7. “Female gender restricted evidence” means such information relating to Aboriginal law and custom as may be identified, recorded in written form or given in oral evidence at the hearing to take place on 3, 4 and 5 November 2003 in accordance with the Annotated Hearing Schedule and Planning Notes dated 28 October 2003, which information may not be disseminated to:

(a) men;

(b) young women;

(c) non Aboriginal women; or

(d) children.

8. The following people only may be present at the hearing when any female gender restricted evidence is given as oral evidence or may read any female gender restricted evidence or any transcript thereof:

(a) any female party;

(b) any female expert engaged by a party for the purpose of providing advice about such matters;

(c) any female counsel, female solicitor or necessary female staff of a party; and

(d) the Judge and those female staff as directed by the Judge.

9. Female gender restricted evidence must not be divulged to any person not present at the hearing other than:

(a) female parties;

(b) female experts engaged by a party for the purpose of providing advice about such matters;

(c) female counsel, female solicitors or necessary female staff of a party; and

(d) a Judge and those female staff as directed by the Judge.

10. Female gender restricted evidence:

(a) shall be recorded and transcribed by a woman;

(b) shall, along with any audio and computer records of the evidence, be kept separate from the general transcript and shall be printed on coloured paper;

(c) shall have a covering sheet marked:

“‘Gender Restricted Evidence’ – This transcript records evidence and submissions in relation to matters of Aboriginal law and custom which by Order of the Court must not be viewed by any person other than:

(i) any female party

(ii) any female expert engaged by a party for the purpose of providing advice about such matters;

(iii) any female counsel, male solicitor or necessary male staff of a party; and

(iv) the Judge and those female staff as directed by the Judge.”

11. Any restricted gender evidence given at the hearings to take place on 3, 4 and 5 November 2003 shall be subject to the Protocol referred to in paragraph 15 of the Judgment.

12. At the conclusion of the proceedings, including any appeal, all gender restricted transcript or other records of such transcript including computer disk or tapes, shall be delivered up by the parties to the solicitors for the applicants, for destruction.

13. The Commonwealth have liberty to apply on 72 hours notice to modify the terms of these orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The motion also proposes orders in relation to “gender sensitive evidence”, defined to mean:“information relating to Aboriginal law and custom as may be identified, recorded in written form or given in oral evidence which may not normally be discussed in mixed gender Aboriginal groups”.In the course of argument, it became clear that the category of “gender sensitive evidence” was not intended to include male gender restricted evidence or female gender restricted evidence. Once again, there was agreement between the applicants and the Commonwealth that there was no need to address the orders appropriate to “gender sensitive evidence”, since none of the evidence to be adduced on 3-5 November 2003 is likely to fall within that category.THE PROPOSED GENDER RESTRICTED EVIDENCE At a directions hearing held on 7 August 2003, I made an order that on or before 12 September 2003, the applicants file descriptive statements of any restricted evidence to be led on site during the first tranche of hearings. Unfortunately, the applicants have not complied with that direction. Accordingly, the only information presently available as to the nature of the evidence to be called on site is that contained in the Hearing Schedule. According to the Hearing Schedule, some of the evidence to be given is unrestricted – that is, the applicants do not suggest that it is either gender restricted evidence or gender sensitive evidence. There is no issue that the respondents’ legal representatives are entitled to be present when the unrestricted evidence is given and that there should be no restrictions on access to the transcript of that evidence. The gender restricted evidence to be given on site is described as follows:Monday 3 November 2003 Location: MantarurrNellie ARMUNTA, Nellie PATTERSON and Dora Haggie WALKABOUT will give female gender restricted evidence about the Kungka Kutjarra Tjukurrpa and how its path of travel connects Mantarurr with the Yulara block. A part of the Kungka Kutjarra Tjukurrpa will be re-enacted within the Mantarurr complex. Nellie ARMUNTA, Nellie PATTERSON and Dora Haggie WALKABOUT will give female gender restricted evidence at the sacred site Manguri about other aspects of the Kungka Kutjarra Tjukurrpa.Location: Site near Ngaanatjarra CollegeDescriptive Statement of Evidence: Female gender restricted inma to be performed. This inma is a part of the Kungka Kutjarra Tjukurrpa narrative which connects the female applicants to the Yulara Township block.Tuesday, 4 November 2003 Location: Sacred sites between Kata Tjurta and AmpiyarraDescriptive Statement of Evidence: Men’s gender restricted evidence of the connection of the Yulara Township block to a wider area owned by the applicants will be given at the following site locations:·52 J 0680817, 7203377. Evidence will address the spiritual link between Kata Tjurta sites further East to be visited immediately afterwards in the direction of Yulara. Evidence will be led in the vicinity of the site ID 716 in Appendix 7.5 (Restricted). We then travel a short distance to a waterhole;·52 J 0683917, 7205017 (Yulara Kurku Waterhole). This is Site ID 1639 in Appendix 7.5 (Restricted). Evidence will be led from claimants about the rock hole and its spiritual significance linking Kata Tjurta with the claim area.·52 J 0690147, 7204539 (Yulara Purlka Waterhole). [Male gender restricted evidence] will be led from the claimants about the rock hole and its spiritual significance linking Kata Tjurta with the claim area.Location: Yulara Purlka Outstation and WaterholeDescriptive Statement of Evidence: Evidence of the connection of the Yulara Township block to a wider area owned by the applicants. Evidence of the establishment and occupation of the outstation…. There will also be evidence regarding the persons buried nearby.Location: Point on a men’s Tjukurrpa track within the claim area just past AmpiyarraDescriptive Statement of Evidence: Male gender restricted evidence of the connection of the Yulara Township block to a wider area owned by the applicants. At the following location:·52 J 0695371, 7215879. Reggie Uluru will explain the reasons for the closure of the track leading into the area.Wednesday, 5 November Location: Katartitja sacred site within Connellan airport2003 boundary within the Yulara Township. Descriptive Statement of Evidence: Female gender restricted evidence is to be given by Nellie ARMUNTA and Nellie PATTERSON about the Kungka Kutjarra Tjukurrpa that passes through that sacred site. Dora Haggie WALKABOUT will re-enact parts of the Kungka Kutjarra Tjukurrpa as it travels through the site. The evidence will show the connection between the Yulara Township block and surrounding land.Location: Uluru (Warayuki)Descriptive Statement of Evidence: Male gender restricted evidence of the connection of the Yulara Township block to a wider area owned by the applicants. The men will gather at the road and be lead into the site. An explanation of its importance will be given in the cave.After leaving the cave evidence will be lead at a site nearby regarding piercing of the nasal septum. The evidence will be given by the above named men. [The Hearing Schedule nominates seven men, subject to their availability on the day.]AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE APPLICANTS AND THE TERRITORY

Decision

Reasons for decision

SACKVILLE J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: SACKVILLE J