[2014] FWC 1860 |
FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
James Hutchinson
v
Monash Health
(U2013/9060)
COMMISSIONER RYAN | MELBOURNE, 21 MARCH 2014 |
Application for relief from unfair dismissal - valid reason.
[1] Mr Hutchinson was employed by Monash Health as a Security Officer. His employment commenced on 7 June 2010 and ended on 16 April 2013 when he was dismissed for serious misconduct.
[2] Mr Hutchinson filed an application for an unfair dismissal remedy on 1 May 2013. Monash Health raised a jurisdictional objection which was heard by DP Smith on 2 September 2013 with a decision given on 22 October 2013. The substantive application was heard on 6 and 7 March 2014 with Mr Hutchinson being represented by Mr Champion of counsel and with Monash Health being represented by Mr Rinaldi of counsel. A decision granting permission to both parties to be represented by counsel was given on 3 March 2014 [[2014] FWC 1489].
[3] Each of the preliminary matters required to be determined by s.396 before merits can be considered were the subject of decision given in transcript.
[4] The alleged serious misconduct was that Mr Hutchinson “did utilize excessive and unnecessary force when restraining a female patient” who had assaulted a doctor in a corridor near the ambulance arrival area of the Dandenong Hospital. The alleged serious misconduct was recorded by a CCTV located in the area. The CCTV record is without sound.
[5] The entire incident of Mr Hutchinson approaching the patient and attempting to restrain her as she assaults a doctor and the alleged use by Mr Hutchinson of excessive and unnecessary force on the patient takes no more than 3 seconds. These few seconds as well as the couple of minutes before were extensively examined by witness for both parties. Monash Health had produced a version of the CCTV footage which showed the critical time period at half normal speed. Even then this slowed down version of events was examined part-second by part-second by both sides.
[6] A neutral description of events as recorded by CCTV is as follows.
[7] Two ambulance paramedics have a patient on an ambulance trolley in a corridor near the emergency department. The patient is sitting on the trolley with her legs dangling at the side of the trolley. One paramedic is standing next to the head end of the ambulance trolley holding a mobile set of steps in place next to the trolley to enable the patient to step down off the trolley. The metal steps have a handrail on one side only and this is being held by the paramedic. The second paramedic is standing at the side of the ambulance trolley next to the set of metal steps.
[8] The consensus of the evidence was that the patient was loud and somewhat verbally aggressive. The patient engaged verbally with hospital staff who came near the patient. The paramedics change position as they also appear to be talking to the patient.
[9]
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read James Hutchinson v Monash Health and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] FWC 1860
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether Monash Health had a valid reason for terminating Hutchinson's employment and whether the dismissal was procedurally fair. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether the dismissal was for genuine operational reasons or if it was due to an invalid reason, such as bullying or discrimination.
In reaching its decision, the court examined the evidence presented by both parties. The court found that Monash Health did have a valid reason for terminating Hutchinson's employment, which was based on performance issues. The court also determined that the dismissal was procedurally fair, as Hutchinson was provided with multiple opportunities to improve his performance and was given adequate notice of the impending termination. Consequently, the court dismissed Hutchinson's application for relief from unfair dismissal. The final orders reflect this outcome, upholding the termination of Hutchinson's employment by Monash Health.