Jakeman v. Hawkins

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[2006] QSC 289

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CIVIL JURISDICTION

WILSON J

No BS1527 of 2004

MITCHELL FRANK JAKEMAN Plaintiff

and

DAVID CHARLES HAWKINS Defendant

BRISBANE

..DATE 25/09/2006

JUDGMENT

HER HONOUR:  There are two applications before the Court: (a) an application by the plaintiff to dispense with the defendant's signature on the request for trial date; and (b) an application by the defendant to join defendants to the counter-claim and for leave to file and serve a further amended defence and counter-claim.  It was common ground that the defendant's application is the only impediment to the proceeding's being ready for trial and so that application was heard first.

Mr Couper QC appeared for the plaintiff, Mitchell Frank Jakeman, and for the proposed defendants to the counter-claim, John Martin Speedy, Barry Lee Jakeman and Varsity Apartments Pty Ltd ACN 095 290 252 ("the second company").  Mr Hackett appeared for the defendant, David Charles Hawkins.

The plaintiff, the defendant, Speedy and B.L. Jakeman entered into a joint venture to acquire, develop and sell certain land ("the original agreement").  Varsity (Qld) Pty Ltd ACN 096 778 559 ("the first company") was the corporate vehicle for the joint venture.  The shares in the first company were held equally by the joint venturers either personally or through companies controlled by them.  The first company entered into a contract to purchase the land.   The plaintiff has sued the defendant for moneys owing pursuant to the original agreement. 

The defendant alleges that the original agreement was varied and that pursuant to the agreement as varied ("the new agreement"):

(a) the defendant transferred his shares in the first company to the plaintiff to be held on trust for the defendant;
(b) the plaintiff as trustee was obliged to preserve, maintain and maximise the value of the shares;
(c) the plaintiff would deduct any money owing by the defendant to the plaintiff pursuant to the original agreement from the money or value the plaintiff received from holding or dealing with the shares in accordance with the joint venture; and
(d) any surplus money or value received or held by the plaintiff from holding or dealing with the shares would be paid or assigned by the plaintiff to the defendant.

By the proposed counter-claim, the defendant alleges that:

(a) the plaintiff, Speedy, B.L. Jakeman and the first company owed him fiduciary duties;
(b) in breach of those fiduciary duties, the plaintiff, Speedy and B.L. Jakeman, caused the first company to be released from the contract to purchase the land and caused the new company (in which the shareholders were the plaintiff, Speedy, B.L. Jakeman and one, Pongrass, through companies controlled by them, but the defendant was not a shareholder) to enter into a contract to purchase the land, to complete the new contract, and to develop the land;
(c) in consequence of the breaches of fiduciary duties, the defendant suffered loss measurable by the diminution in the value of his shareholding in the first company at the time of the new…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jakeman v. Hawkins and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] QSC 289
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Jakeman v. Hawkins was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. Mitchell Frank Jakeman, the plaintiff, sought to enforce a joint venture agreement with David Charles Hawkins, the defendant. The plaintiff sought damages for moneys owing under the agreement, while the defendant counterclaimed alleging breaches of fiduciary duties by the plaintiff and others. The court was required to decide on two applications: the plaintiff's application to dispense with the defendant's signature on the request for a trial date, and the defendant's application to join additional defendants to his counterclaim and to file an amended defence and counterclaim.

The court found that the defendant's application to join additional defendants and amend his counterclaim was the only impediment to the proceeding being ready for trial. The court considered the legal principles regarding shareholders' ability to claim damages for a company's losses. The court held that the defendant's proposed amended counterclaim must fail as the loss claimed was the company's loss, and not recoverable by the defendant who was the beneficial owner of shares in that company. The court concluded that the defendant's claim was effectively one of fraud on a minority, and as such, it was the company's claim and not the defendant's. The court dismissed the defendant's application and granted the plaintiff's application to dispense with the defendant's signature on the request for a trial date. The court ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs of and incidental to both applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established