IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S191 of 2013
B e t w e e n -
SAYED AKBAR JAFFARIE
Plaintiff
and
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF SECURITY
First Defendant
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
Second Defendant
MIGRATION REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Third Defendant
BELL J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
FROM CANBERRA BY VIDEO LINK TO SYDNEY
ON WEDNESDAY, 4 MARCH 2015, AT 10.52 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR S.E.J. PRINCE: If the Court pleases, your Honour, I appear with my learned friend, DR S.A. BOGAN, for the plaintiff in that matter. (instructed by SBA Lawyers)
MR N.J. WILLIAMS, SC: May it please the Court, I appear with MS A.M. MITCHELMORE for the first and second defendants. (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)
MR PRINCE: There are two competing sets of orders, your Honour.
HER HONOUR: Yes. Would you just bear with me one moment, Mr Prince? I have two files in front of me ‑ ‑ ‑
MR PRINCE: Yes, your Honour.
HER HONOUR: ‑ ‑ ‑ and I am just trying to turn up the papers in relation to this argument. Yes, thank you.
MR PRINCE: Thank you, your Honour.
HER HONOUR: Yes.
MR PRINCE: There are two competing sets of orders which are sought. The first and second defendants seek to strike out the proceedings, presumably in a summary way, at this directions hearing.
HER HONOUR: Yes. Mr Prince, I think properly what I have before me is the summons filed by the first and second defendants.
MR PRINCE: Yes. The Registry indicated to my instructing solicitor, your Honour, that we did not need a summons for directions because the matter would be coming back on for directions.
HER HONOUR: Yes, yes. Are the parties content for you to address first?
MR PRINCE: I certainly am.
MR WILLIAMS: For our part, yes, your Honour.
HER HONOUR: Yes, very well, Mr Prince.
MR PRINCE: Thank you, your Honour. The orders that are sought by the plaintiff are set out at page 3 of the submissions of the plaintiff. Does your Honour have that?
HER HONOUR: Yes, I do. Mr Prince, the issue that you seek to agitate in relation to the three decisions that were not the subject of the remitter is the issue that was determined by the Federal Court, is it not?
MR PRINCE: No, your Honour, it is not, but different considerations apply. Your Honour may recall from the written submissions that were filed on behalf of the plaintiff that there was a drip‑feed of information from the respondents, notwithstanding that there was an agreed statement of facts when the matter was remitted by this Court ‑ ‑ ‑
HER HONOUR: Yes.
MR PRINCE: ‑ ‑ ‑ and notwithstanding that there was an agreed statement of facts, the Minister then filed a considerable number of affidavits ‑ ‑ ‑
HER HONOUR: Yes.
MR PRINCE: ‑ ‑ ‑which, by varying degrees at varying times as…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Jaffarie v Director General of Security & Ors and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] HCATrans 46
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the applicant's claim for compensation was barred by the operation of section 70(1) of the ASIO Act. This provision states that no civil or criminal proceedings shall be brought against ASIO or its officers for any act done or omitted to be done in the exercise of their powers or the discharge of their duties under the Act, unless the Attorney-General has certified that the act or omission was not done in good faith. The Court was required to determine the scope and effect of this immunity provision in the context of the applicant's allegations of unlawful conduct.
Bell J reasoned that section 70(1) of the ASIO Act provides a broad immunity to ASIO and its officers for actions taken in the exercise of their powers or discharge of their duties, provided those actions were done in good faith. The Court found that the applicant's claim, as pleaded, did not allege that the conduct of ASIO officers was not done in good faith. Consequently, the immunity provision applied, and the proceedings were barred. The Court emphasised that the purpose of section 70(1) is to protect ASIO officers from liability for actions taken in the course of their sensitive and often difficult duties, thereby ensuring the effective functioning of national security operations.
The Court ordered that the application be dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The proceedings in Jaffarie v Director General of Security & Ors were initiated by the plaintiff, Sayed Akbar Jaffarie, through an application for order to show cause filed on 10 October 2013. Jaffarie sought declaratory and other relief regarding several decisions made by the defendants: the first defendant, the Director General of Security, made a security assessment on 17 June 2013; the second defendant, the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, cancelled Jaffarie's Subclass 309 Partner (Provisional) visa on 19 June 2013, refused his application for a Partner (Migrant) (Class BC) Subclass 100 (Spouse) visa on 25 June 2013, and refused his application for a Bridging E (Class WE) visa on 25 September 2013; and the third defendant, the Migration Review Tribunal, affirmed the cancellation of the provisional partner visa on 26 August 2013. Initially, the High Court remitted the challenges to the security assessment and the bridging visa refusal to the Federal Court of Australia on 14 November 2013, with the rest of the proceeding stood over pending the outcome of those proceedings. The Full Court of the Federal Court dismissed the remitted challenges on 18 August 2014. Following this, the first and second defendants applied for orders dismissing the part of the matter not remitted to the Federal Court and sought costs. Jaffarie opposed these orders and sought leave to file an amended application for an order to show cause concerning the decisions not subject to the remitter. The plaintiff argued that he was unaware that the Minister had cancelled his visa based on an adverse security assessment without having access to all relevant material, and that the decisions were unconstitutional as they involved extra-judicial deprivation of liberty. The defendants opposed the leave, arguing that the plaintiff's claims of procedural unfairness and constitutional infirmity were not arguable. The High Court declined to grant leave to amend the application, finding that the plaintiff's contentions were not arguable in light of the Federal Court's previous determinations and the statutory scheme requiring the Minister to cancel the visa upon an adverse security assessment. The Court dismissed the part of the matter not remitted to the Federal Court and ordered Jaffarie to pay the first and second defendants' costs of the proceeding.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiff's visa cancellation and resulting incarceration were subject to procedural fairness requirements under the Migration Regulations.
2. Whether the Minister's decision to cancel the plaintiff's visa, based on an ASIO security assessment, involved an exercise of judicial power contrary to Chapter III of the Constitution.
3. Whether the regulation mandating visa cancellation upon an ASIO security assessment is invalid as it allows for automatic deprivation of liberty without charge or trial.
Held
1. Whether the plaintiff's visa cancellation and resulting incarceration were subject to procedural fairness requirements under the Migration Regulations: The court held that the plaintiff's argument regarding a denial of procedural fairness was not arguable because the Minister did not have a discretion to cancel the visa upon an adverse security assessment by ASIO. The regulation required the Minister to cancel the visa, leaving no room for procedural fairness considerations.
2. Whether the Minister's decision to cancel the plaintiff's visa, based on an ASIO security assessment, involved an exercise of judicial power contrary to Chapter III of the Constitution: The court held that the plaintiff's argument regarding the usurpation of judicial power by the Minister's decision to cancel the visa was not arguable. The adverse security assessment by ASIO did not involve the exercise of judicial power, and the Minister's decision to cancel the visa was a mandatory one based on the assessment.
3. Whether the regulation mandating visa cancellation upon an ASIO security assessment is invalid as it allows for automatic deprivation of liberty without charge or trial: The court held that the plaintiff's argument regarding the constitutional infirmity of the regulation was not arguable. The regulation was valid as it was consistent with the statutory scheme and did not involve the exercise of judicial power. The court referred to the decision in Australian Communications and Media Authority v Today FM to support its conclusion.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court considered the plaintiff's arguments regarding the procedural fairness and constitutionality of decisions made under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and the Migration Regulations 1994. The plaintiff argued that the Minister's decision to cancel his visa, based on an adverse security assessment by the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO), was subject to procedural fairness requirements and involved an exercise of judicial power contrary to Chapter III of the Constitution.
The court rejected the plaintiff's argument that he was denied procedural fairness because the Minister made the decision to cancel his visa without providing him with the full reasons. The court held that the Minister was not required to cancel the visa immediately upon receiving the adverse security assessment and was under no obligation to provide the plaintiff with the full reasons before doing so. The court relied on regulation 2.43(2)(a)(iii) of the Migration Regulations, which mandates the cancellation of a visa when the visa holder has been assessed by ASIO to be a risk to security. The plaintiff's argument that the regulation allows for automatic deprivation of liberty without charge or trial was also dismissed.
The court held that the Minister's decision to cancel the visa was not an exercise of judicial power because it did not involve the determination of guilt or the imposition of punishment. The court referred to the Full Federal Court's decision in Jaffarie v Director General of Security (2014) 313 ALR 593, which rejected a similar argument. The High Court further supported its decision by citing Australian Communications and Media Authority v Today FM (Sydney) Pty Ltd [2015] HCA 7, which reinforced that the making of an adverse security assessment by ASIO did not involve the exercise of judicial power.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Minister's decision to cancel a visa based on an adverse security assessment by ASIO does not require the exercise of procedural fairness or involve the exercise of judicial power. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by clarifying that the mandatory nature of the cancellation under the Migration Regulations does not negate the absence of judicial power in the decision-making process.