SUNIBRITE PRODUCTS (AUST.) PTY. LTD. v. JABUNA PTY. LTD. (1980) 47 FLR 73
Contempt
COURT
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
GENERAL DIVISION
Bowen C.J.(1)
CATCHWORDS
Contempt - Practice - Application for injunction - Undertakings by respondent - Service of undertakings on respondent - Commencement of contempt proceedings before service - Jurisdiction of court - Breach of undertaking - Standard of Proof - Penalty - Federal Court Rules, O. 1, r. 8; O. 7, r. 2 (1) (b); O. 40, rr. 6, 13 (3).
HEADNOTE
On 20th December, 1979, Sunibrite (the applicant) commenced proceedings against Jabuna (the respondent) seeking certain injunctions. On 28th December, 1979, Jabuna gave certain undertakings without prejudice and without admissions. On 3rd January, 1980, certain undertakings were given to the court by Jabuna, the undertaking previously given was continued up to and including 30th January, 1980, and a further undertaking was given which in part provided: "(b) The respondent undertakes to the court not prior to 30th January, 1980, to permit any employee or agent . . . to sell any of the respondent's products complained of to any outlet . . . unless the respondent labels the products with a label or printed words clearly saying 'This is not a Sunibrite product'."
On 11th January, 1980, Sunibrite issued a motion for contempt against Jabuna alleging failure to comply with the undertakings in respect of sales to three shops. The motion, supporting affidavits and a document containing the undertakings were all served at Jabuna's registered office on 14th January, 1980.
Held: (1) The undertakings had been properly served under O.7, r.2(1) (b) of the Federal Court Rules by leaving them at the registered office of the respondent.
(2) Although notice of the undertakings with the required endorsement had been served on the respondent only after the commencement of the proceedings for contempt, and thus not in compliance with O.40, r.13(3) of the Federal Court Rules, this matter went to the discretion of the court and not to its jurisdiction.
(3) The contempt alleged was a civil contempt and, because of the possible penalties involved, proof of the utmost cogency was required.
Clifford v. Middleton, (1974) VR 737; Fullerton v. Gardiner, (1977) Supreme Court Procedure, Practice Decisions, p18, applied.
(4) (a) Undertaking (b) of 3rd January, 1980, required a label or printed words on the respondent's products which effectively conveyed to an ordinary purchaser the required message. (b) A breach of that undertaking had been established as it had been proved that a relevant sale had occurred in circumstances where inadequate steps to comply with the undertaking had been taken. (c) The other breaches had not been proved.
(5) The appropriate penalty in the circumstances was to order the respondent to pay the applicant's costs of the motion as between solicitor and client.
HEARING
SYDNEY 1980, January 18, 21, 22; February 8. #DATE 8:2:1980
NOTICE OF MOTION.
Notice of motion that the respondent be punished for contempt of court.
A. B. Shand Q.C. and P. Jacobson, for the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Jabuna Pty Ltd v Sunibrite Products (Australia) Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1980] FCA 3
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court first considered whether it had jurisdiction to hear the contempt application, given that the proceedings for contempt were initiated before the service of the relevant undertakings on Sunibrite. It was determined that the court did indeed have jurisdiction to hear the matter. The court further examined the standard of proof needed to establish the breach of the undertakings, concluding that the standard of proof was not beyond reasonable doubt, but rather the balance of probabilities. Finally, the court addressed the penalty for the alleged breach of undertakings, taking into account the nature and gravity of the breach. The court concluded that the breach was serious enough to warrant a penalty but also considered mitigating factors.
In conclusion, the Federal Court found that Sunibrite had indeed breached the undertakings provided in relation to the injunction application. The court imposed a penalty on Sunibrite for the breach, taking into account the seriousness of the breach and the mitigating factors presented. The court's decision provided clarity on the jurisdiction to hear contempt applications, the standard of proof required, and the appropriate penalty for breaches of undertakings in similar cases. The final orders of the court included the imposition of a penalty on Sunibrite for the breach of undertakings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi