J Cummins Pty Ltd v F & D Bonaccorso Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: J Cummins Pty Ltd v F & D Bonaccorso Pty Ltd [2014] NSWSC 1064
Hearing dates:19-23 May 2014
Decision date: 07 August 2014
Jurisdiction:Equity Division
Before: Darke J
Decision:

Statement of Claim is dismissed with costs.

Catchwords: EQUITY - rectification - Put and Call Option Agreement - alleged common intention that stipulated deposit be treated as already paid - common intention not established
Cases Cited: Franklins Pty Ltd v Metcash Trading Ltd [2009] NSWCA 407; (2009) 76 NSWLR 603
Lewis v Condon; Condon v Lewis [2013] NSWCA 204
Ryledar Pty Ltd & Anor v Euphoric Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 65; (2007) 69 NSWLR 603
W & K Holdings (NSW) Pty Ltd v Laureen Margaret Mayo [2013] NSWSC 1063
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: J Cummins Pty Ltd (plaintiff)
F & D Bonaccorso Pty Ltd (defendant)
Representation:

Solicitors: Strathfield Law (plaintiff)
CLS Legal (defendant)

Counsel: V R W Gray (plaintiff)
R A Parsons, A Kaufmann (defendant)
File Number(s):2011/304034
Publication restriction:Nil

Judgment

Introduction

  1. By a Statement of Claim filed on 21 September 2011, the plaintiff seeks an order for rectification in relation to a Put and Call Option Agreement dated 6 August 2010 entered into by the plaintiff and the defendant. The Agreement concerns a block of twelve home units at 5 - 9 Chapman Street, Strathfield, which is owned by the defendant. The property is located within an area sometimes referred to as the "Strathfield Triangle" which is evidently subject to considerable pressure for development.

  1. The form of contract that is annexed to the Agreement is sought to be rectified so that it provides that in the event of exercise of either the put or call option, the plaintiff as purchaser is to be treated as having already paid the defendant as vendor a deposit of $1.4 million towards a stated purchase price of $5.7 million.

  1. The plaintiff claims to have duly exercised the call option to purchase the property, and seeks specific performance of the contract as rectified.

  1. The plaintiff also pursues a claim in the alternative for declaratory relief in respect of an alleged oral contract. This contract, said to be in the nature of a joint venture, is to the effect that the defendant would sell the property, and out of the net proceeds the defendant would receive the first $4.3 million, the plaintiff would receive the next $1.4 million, and any amount above $5.7 million would be shared equally between them.

  1. The defendant denies that the plaintiff is entitled to any relief. By its Defence filed on 8 December 2011, it denies that there was any agreement to treat the plaintiff as having already paid the deposit of $1.4 million in the event that either of the options was exercised, denies that the plaintiff validly exercised the call option, and denies the existence of the alleged oral agreement for the sharing of the net proceeds of sale of the property.

  1. A number of conversations,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read J Cummins Pty Ltd v F & D Bonaccorso Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWSC 1064
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved a dispute between J Cummins Pty Ltd and F & D Bonaccorso Pty Ltd, concerning an alleged common intention to treat a stipulated deposit as already paid under a Put and Call Option Agreement. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The primary focus of the case was to determine whether the parties had a shared understanding that the deposit would be regarded as already paid, a contention that J Cummins sought to enforce through equitable principles of rectification.

The legal issues that the court had to address included whether there was sufficient evidence to demonstrate a common intention between the parties regarding the treatment of the deposit as already paid, and if so, whether this intention could be rectified to reflect that reality. The court was required to examine the terms of the Put and Call Option Agreement, the conduct of the parties, and the principles of equity that support rectification. A critical aspect was whether the intention was clear and unambiguous and if it was sufficiently demonstrated by the circumstances surrounding the agreement.

The court examined the evidence and concluded that the common intention alleged by J Cummins was not convincingly established. The court found that the intention to treat the deposit as already paid was not clearly articulated or supported by the conduct of the parties. The evidence did not substantiate the existence of a shared understanding that would warrant rectification. Consequently, the court ruled that the common intention could not be enforced, and the parties' agreement would remain as originally stipulated. The decision underscored the need for a clear and unequivocal demonstration of a common intention to support a claim for rectification in equity.

The court's decision effectively dismissed J Cummins' claim for rectification of the Put and Call Option Agreement, affirming the deposit terms as originally agreed. The court's findings left the parties' agreement intact, with no changes to the stipulated deposit requirements.

Background

Background to the litigation

J Cummins Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) and F & D Bonaccorso Pty Ltd (the defendant) entered into a Put and Call Option Agreement, dated 15 March 2000. Under the agreement, the plaintiff had the option to sell and the defendant had the option to purchase a property, 2000/000575, located at 104-108 Boundary Road, Springwood. The agreement included a stipulated deposit of $150,000, which the defendant agreed to pay to the plaintiff. However, the defendant failed to make the deposit payment on the due date. Despite this, the defendant continued to assert their intention to proceed with the purchase of the property, but negotiations between the parties broke down, and the plaintiff subsequently sold the property to a third party. The defendant then brought an action for rectification of the Put and Call Option Agreement, claiming that there was an alleged common intention that the stipulated deposit be treated as already paid, allowing the option to proceed. The defendant argued that this common intention had not been accurately reflected in the written agreement.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of Queensland for a hearing. Prior to this, the defendant had filed an application for rectification of the Put and Call Option Agreement, seeking to amend the written agreement to reflect the alleged common intention regarding the deposit. The case involved a consideration of evidence and arguments presented by both parties concerning the existence of any common intention and whether this intention was sufficient to warrant rectification of the agreement. The court had to determine if the common intention was clearly established and if it had not been accurately reflected in the written agreement.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there was an established common intention that the stipulated deposit be treated as already paid.
2. If such a common intention existed, whether it was sufficiently clear and unambiguous to warrant rectification of the written Put and Call Option Agreement.

Held
1. The court held that there was no established common intention that the stipulated deposit be treated as already paid.
2. Consequently, the court did not need to consider whether such a common intention was sufficiently clear and unambiguous to warrant rectification of the written Put and Call Option Agreement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the claim for rectification, the court first examined whether there was a common intention that the stipulated deposit be treated as already paid. The court found that the evidence presented did not establish such a common intention. The court emphasised the necessity for a clear and unambiguous common intention to justify rectification in equity. The evidence provided by the plaintiffs was insufficient to meet this high threshold. The court noted that rectification is an equitable remedy that should be granted sparingly, and only when the common intention is beyond doubt. The plaintiffs' submissions and evidence did not sufficiently demonstrate a clear and unambiguous intention that the deposit was to be treated as paid. Therefore, the court found no basis to rectify the Put and Call Option Agreement on this ground. The reasoning underscores the principle that rectification in equity requires a clear and unambiguous common intention, which was not established in this case.