Ishwari Munswamy and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

[2014] AATA 757

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/3270, 5629, 2013/2153

Re

Ishwari Munswamy

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member
Dr W Isles, Member

Date

20 October 2014

Place

Sydney

The decisions under review are affirmed.

....................[sgd]....................................................

Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – employee of licensed corporation – injury in 2008 – liability to pay compensation for injury to lumbar spine accepted – subsequent decision of no present entitlement to compensation for medical expenses and incapacity affirmed by consent – present proceedings involve review of three decisions – determination of no present entitlement to compensation for medical expenses and incapacity in relation to accepted aggravation of constitutional degenerative changes in lumbar spine – denial of liability to pay compensation for new claim of aggravation of constitutional degenerative changes in lumbar spine – denial of liability to pay compensation for psychological injury due to alleged bullying and harassment – decisions under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 5A, 5B, 6, 14, 16, 19

CASES

Comcare v Mooi (1996) 69 FCR 439

Re Munswamy and Australian Postal Corporation [2009] AATA 982

Watts v Rake (1960) 108 CLR 158

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member
Dr W Isles, Member

20 October 2014

SUMMARY

  1. Ms Munswamy is 44 years old, and has been working as a driver/mail sorter with the Australian Postal Corporation (Australia Post) since 1999. Ms Munswamy told us that on 30 January 2008, she lifted a parcel from the ground to load it into her van when she felt a sharp pain in her lower back. She indicated that the pain was in the lumbar sacral region, midline, and that she had pain in her legs, and could not walk. Liability to pay compensation was accepted for acute mechanical low back pain. Ms Munswamy had time off, an MRI in February 2008, various Rehabilitation Programs, and a graduated return to work.

  2. In 2009 Ms Munswamy applied to the Tribunal for review of three decisions made by Australia Post. A hearing was conducted in 2009 and a decision made by the Tribunal: Re Munswamy and Australian Postal Corporation [2009] AATA 982. The two main issues at that hearing were Australia Post’s decision dated 13 March 2009 to suspend Ms Munswamy’s rights to compensation because she had not undertaken a Rehabilitation Program which was affirmed, and a decision dated 2 February 2009 deeming the Applicant fit to work six hours a day, five days a week, also affirmed.

  3. There was a further application (2010/2992) to the Tribunal which was settled by consent in April 2011. The Tribunal’s consent decision affirmed Australia Post’s decision that there was no present entitlement to the payment of compensation from 22 April 2010 for the injury of 30 January 2008.

  4. There are now three applications before the Tribunal. Ms Munswamy is the Applicant in each, and the Australian Postal Corporation (Australia Post) is the Respondent.

  5. Matter 2012/3270 concerns an application Ms…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ishwari Munswamy and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 757
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ishwari Munswamy, an employee of the Australian Postal Corporation, commenced proceedings against her employer regarding compensation for various injuries and conditions. The primary dispute centred on the acceptance of her lumbar spine injury from 2008, followed by a series of decisions concerning her entitlement to compensation for medical expenses and incapacity. The current litigation focused on the affirmation of three decisions: the denial of present entitlement to compensation for medical expenses and incapacity related to the aggravation of constitutional degenerative changes in her lumbar spine, the denial of liability to pay compensation for a new claim of aggravation of these degenerative changes, and the denial of liability to pay compensation for a psychological injury due to alleged bullying and harassment. The matter was before the court for review of these decisions.

The court was required to determine whether the decisions made by the Australian Postal Corporation were correct. Specifically, it needed to assess the validity of the determinations that Ms Munswamy did not have a present entitlement to compensation for medical expenses and incapacity related to the aggravation of her lumbar spine condition, that there was no liability to compensate for the new claim of aggravation of the lumbar spine condition, and that there was no compensable psychological injury due to the alleged bullying and harassment. The court's role was to review the evidence and legal arguments presented by both parties and decide whether the decisions were reasonable and supported by the law.

The court found that the decisions under review were affirmed, concluding that Ms Munswamy did not suffer from a psychiatric injury resulting from the alleged bullying. Consequently, the court held that she had not suffered a compensable injury due to the bullying. The court found no basis to overturn the decisions regarding her lumbar spine condition or the psychological injury claim. The reasoning centred on the evidence presented and the legal standards applicable to compensation claims in such circumstances.

The final orders of the court were that the decisions under review were affirmed, and there was no power to make an order for costs. The court did not find any grounds to alter the determinations made by the Australian Postal Corporation regarding Ms Munswamy's compensation claims.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ishwari Munswamy, an employee of the Australian Postal Corporation, sustained an injury to her lumbar spine in 2008. Liability to pay compensation for this injury was accepted by the corporation. Subsequently, a decision was made that there was no present entitlement to compensation for medical expenses and incapacity related to the injury, a decision which was affirmed by consent. This case involves the review of three specific decisions. The first decision under review determined that there was no present entitlement to compensation for medical expenses and incapacity in relation to the accepted aggravation of constitutional degenerative changes in Ms Munswamy's lumbar spine. The second decision denied the corporation's liability to pay compensation for a new claim concerning the aggravation of these degenerative changes. The third decision denied the corporation's liability to pay compensation for a psychological injury due to alleged bullying and harassment that Ms Munswamy claimed took place in October 2012.

The matter came before the court for a review of the decisions made by the relevant tribunal regarding Ms Munswamy's claims for compensation. The tribunal had previously assessed Ms Munswamy's claims for medical expenses and incapacity due to the aggravation of her lumbar spine injury, and her new claim for aggravation of the degenerative changes in her lumbar spine. Additionally, the tribunal assessed her claim for psychological injury resulting from alleged bullying and harassment in October 2012. The tribunal's decisions to deny compensation for these claims were the subject of the present review proceedings. The tribunal's findings were based on evidence and arguments presented by both parties, including medical reports, witness statements, and other relevant documentation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

We are satisfied that Ms Munswamy does not suffer from a psychiatric injury, and accordingly that Ms Munswamy has not suffered a compensable injury as a result of the bullying she claims took place in October 2012.DECISION The decisions under review are affirmed. There is no power to make an order for costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the first issue concerning Ms Munswamy's entitlement to compensation for medical expenses and incapacity related to the aggravation of her lumbar spine condition. The court noted that there was no present entitlement to compensation for medical expenses and incapacity in relation to the accepted aggravation of the lumbar spine condition. The court's decision affirmed the prior determination that Ms Munswamy did not have a present entitlement to compensation for this aspect of her condition.

Regarding the second issue, the court found that the corporation was not liable to pay compensation for the new claim of aggravation of the lumbar spine condition. The court considered the evidence and concluded that there was no basis to hold the corporation liable for compensation in relation to this new claim.

Lastly, the court assessed Ms Munswamy's claim for compensation due to a psychological injury resulting from alleged bullying and harassment in October 2012. The court found that Ms Munswamy did not suffer from a psychiatric injury and therefore had not suffered a compensable injury as a result of the bullying she claimed took place. The court's decision affirmed the denial of liability to pay compensation for this psychological injury.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an employee of a licensed corporation is not entitled to compensation for medical expenses and incapacity related to the aggravation of a pre-existing condition if there is no present entitlement to such compensation. Additionally, the corporation is not liable to pay compensation for a new claim of aggravation of a pre-existing condition, and an employee is not entitled to compensation for a psychological injury if there is no psychiatric injury resulting from the claimed events.