Isaacs v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Isaacs v Commissioner of Taxation [2006] FCAFC 105

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – review of decision of Commissioner to disallow objection decision – whether Tribunal had jurisdiction to hear review

TAXATION – employee share schemes – Commissioner has discretion to extend time for election that benefit under scheme is to be treated as assessable income in the year of income in which the benefit is conferred, rather than year it is realised – whether Tribunal can exercise that discretion when reviewing objection decision

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), ss 25, 27, 28, 43, 44
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 139B, 139C, 139CB, 139CC, 139E
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) ss 14ZL, 14ZU, 14ZW, 14ZY, 14ZZ, 14ZZA, 14ZZK, 161, 166, 170, 173, 174, 175A

Batagol v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1963) 109 CLR 243 referred to
Commonwealth Bank Officers Superannuation Corporation Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2005) 148 FCR 427 referred to
FJ Bloemen Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) (1981) 147 CLR 360 referred to
Henderson v Commissioner of Taxation (1970) 119 CLR 612 referred to

PHILLIP ISAACS v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

NSD2174 OF 2005

EMMETT, SIOPIS & RARES JJ
30 JUNE 2006
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD2174 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

PHILLIP ISAACS
APPLICANT

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

EMMETT, SIOPIS & RARES JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

30 JUNE 2006

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The appeal be dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD2174 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

PHILLIP ISAACS
APPLICANT

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

EMMETT, SIOPIS & RARES JJ

DATE:

30 JUNE 2006

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This appeal concerns the exercise by the respondent, the Commissioner of Taxation (‘the Commissioner’), of the discretion conferred by s 139E of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (‘the Assessment Act’). Under that provision, the Commissioner may allow a taxpayer further time within which to make an election that the benefit under an employee share scheme is to be treated as assessable income in the year of income in which the benefit is conferred, rather than the year of income during which the benefit is realised.  The specific question is whether that discretion can be exercised by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) in the course of a review by the Tribunal of an objection decision under Part IVC of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) (‘the Administration Act’).

    RELEVANT LEGISLATIVE PROVISIONS

  2. The question raised in the appeal concerns provisions of the Assessment Act, the Administration Act and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (‘the Tribunal Act’). It is convenient to describe briefly the relevant provisions of each of those enactments.

    EMPLOYEE SHARE SCHEMES

  3. Division 13A of the Assessment Act, which consists of ss 139 to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Isaacs v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCAFC 105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Isaacs v Commissioner of Taxation is a case in which the appellant, Phillip John Isaacs, contested a decision made by the Commissioner of Taxation regarding the taxation of a share option granted to him by his employer, Cytyc Australia Pty Ltd. The case was appealed to the Federal Court of Australia from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The primary issue for the court was whether the Commissioner had the authority to deny the taxpayer's request to make a late election under section 139E of the Assessment Act to be taxed on the share option at the time of grant rather than at the cessation time.

The court examined the relevant statutory provisions, including sections 14ZU, 14ZW, 14ZY, 14ZZ, 14ZZA, and 14ZZK of the Administration Act, as well as sections 139B, 139CC, and 139E of the Assessment Act. It determined that the Commissioner had the discretion to deny a request for a late election under section 139E, and that the taxpayer's appeal was therefore without merit. The court found that the Commissioner's decision to deny the taxpayer's request to make a late election was reasonable and in accordance with the law.

The court dismissed the appeal and upheld the Commissioner's decision. The court did not grant the taxpayer's request to amend his tax return for the 1998 tax year to include the additional income amount under the employee share acquisition scheme, nor did it remit the tax shortfall penalty and the general interest charge. The court held that the Commissioner was not required to allow the taxpayer further time to lodge the election, and that the taxpayer's request for an amended assessment was therefore denied.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Under s 44(1) of the Tribunal Act, a party to a proceeding before the Tribunal may appeal to the Federal Court of Australia, on a question of law, from any decision of the Tribunal in that proceeding. By s 44(3), the Federal Court is given jurisdiction to hear and determine appeals instituted in accordance with s 44(1). THE FACTS CONCERNING THE TAXPAYER The appellant, Mr Phillip John Isaacs (‘the Taxpayer’), commenced employment as managing director of Cytyc Australia Pty Ltd (‘the Employer’) on 4 March 1998. The Employer is a wholly owned subsidiary of Cytyc Corporation, a United States entity (‘the Corporation’). On 1 May 1998, the Taxpayer was granted an option to buy 50,000 shares of the Corporation for a total option price of $US737,500 (‘the Option’). The Option was to be exercisable for the number of shares in the Corporation set out below after the dates set out below:12,500 1 May 199912,500 1 May 200012,500 1 May 200112,500 1 May 2002The Option was to expire on 1 May 2008. The Option was a right acquired by the Taxpayer under an employee share scheme. The Taxpayer was formally notified of the grant of the Option by notice from the Corporation dated 5 June 1998. The Taxpayer received the notification under cover of a memorandum from the Corporation suggesting that he consult his personal financial or tax adviser to learn how the Options would be treated for tax purposes in Australia. The Taxpayer lodged a return in respect of the year ended 30 June 1998 (‘the 1998 Tax Year’). On 4 May 1999, the Commissioner issued a notice of assessment to the Taxpayer stating that his taxable income for the 1998 Tax Year was $214,482 and that the tax payable on that taxable income was $91,408.07. Since no election had been made under s 139E of the Assessment Act in respect of the benefit under the Option, the amount of the discount in relation to the Option was not included in the taxable income of the Taxpayer for the 1998 Tax Year. On 18 May 2001, the Taxpayer wrote to the Commissioner stating that the Taxpayer wished to make an election under s 139E in respect of the Option. The letter relevantly said:‘…no action has been taken by the Taxpayer to exercise his options.Based on the valuation tables set out in Division 13A, the effect of making the election to be taxed at grant is that an additional amount of $209,802 should be included in the Taxpayer’s assessable income for the year ended 30 June 1998… We now request an amended assessment be issued for the year ended 30 June 1998 to include this amount.We request that no penalty be imposed in relation to this election given the complexity of the relevant legislation. Please find enclosed a cheque for the additional amount of tax of $101,753.97 for the year ended 30 June 1998.…’A form of election dated 18 May 2001 was enclosed with the letter. The Commissioner replied by letter of 11 September 2001, relevantly saying:‘QUESTIONS AT ISSUE:-Whether the Commissioner will allow the Taxpayer further time to lodge an election under s 139E of the [Assessment Act] in respect of the options granted to the Taxpayer by his employer under an employee share acquisition scheme during the year ended 30 June 1998?-Whether the Taxpayer’s tax return for the year ended 30 June 1998 will be amended to include the additional income amount under the employee share acquisition scheme?-Whether the tax short fall penalty and the general interest charge will be imposed?……the Taxpayer’s request for making a late election is denied.The amount of discount calculated in accordance with either [s 139CC(3) or s 139CC(4) of the Assessment Act] will therefore need to be included in your client’s assessable income in the year of income in which the cessation time occurs [s 139B(3)]. In view of this decision, it is not necessary to consider the imposition or remission of the tax shortfall penalty and the general interest charge.…’

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 14ZU of the Administration Act provides that a person making a taxation objection must lodge it with the Commissioner within the period set out in s 14ZW. Section 14ZW(1)(aa)(ii) relevantly provides that the person must lodge the taxation objection with the Commissioner within four years after notice of the assessment concerned is given to the person. Section 14ZY(1) provides that, if the taxation objection has been lodged with the Commissioner within the required period, the Commissioner must decide whether to allow it, wholly or in part, or disallow it. Such a decision is called an objection decision. The Commissioner is required to cause written notice of an objection decision to be served on the relevant person. Section 14ZZ(a)(i) of the Administration Act relevantly provides that, if the person is dissatisfied with the Commissioner’s objection decision, the person may apply to the Tribunal for review of the decision. Under s 14ZZA, the Tribunal Act applies in relation to the review of objection decisions, subject to the modifications set out in Division 4 of Part IVC of the Administration Act. Under s 14ZZK, on an application for review of an objection decision, the applicant is, unless the Tribunal orders otherwise, limited to the grounds stated in the objection to which the objection decision relates. Further, the applicant has the burden of proving that the assessment is excessive. REVIEW BY THE TRIBUNAL Section 25(1) of the Tribunal Act provides that an enactment may provide that an application may be made to the Tribunal for review of a decision made in the exercise of powers conferred by that enactment. Section 25(4) provides that the Tribunal is to have power to review any decision in respect of which application is made to it under any enactment. By the operation of s 14ZZC of the Administration Act, an application to the Tribunal for a review of an objection decision must set out a statement of the reasons for the application and must be lodged with the Tribunal within 60 days after the person making the application is served with notice of the objection decision. Section 27(1) of the Tribunal Act provides that, where an enactment provides that an application may be made to the Tribunal for a review of a decision, the application may be made by or on behalf of any person whose interests are affected by the decision. However, s 27 does not apply in relation to an objection decision. Thus, standing to apply to the Tribunal in respect of an objection decision is determined by s 14ZZ of the Administration Act. Section 28 of the Tribunal Act provides that, if a person makes a decision in respect of which an application might be made to the Tribunal for a review, any person who is entitled to apply to the Tribunal for a review of the decision may request a statement in writing, setting out, inter alia, the reasons for the decision. However, s 28 does not apply in relation to an objection decision. Once again, entitlement to reasons for an objection decision is regulated by the Administration Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

If it is, the discount is the amount or value of the consideration received by the taxpayer for the disposal, reduced by the amount or value of any consideration paid or given by the taxpayer as consideration for the acquisition of the right plus the amount or value of any consideration paid or given to exercise that right (‘the Relevant Consideration’). If it is not, the discount is the market value of the right, or the share acquired as a result of the exercise of the right, at the cessation time, reduced by the Relevant Consideration. Market value is determined in accordance with Subdivision F of Division 3A. For present purposes, it is not necessary to examine the details of the provisions for determining market value. Under s 139B(3), the discount is to be included in the taxpayer’s assessable income of the year of income in which the cessation time occurs. Under s 139CB(1), the cessation time for a right is the earliest of the following: the time when the taxpayer disposes of the right, other than by exercising it; the time when the employment in respect of which the right was acquired ceases, and if the right is exercised, the time when the right is exercised; or·if there is a restriction or condition in relation to the exercise, the time when the restriction or condition ceases to have effect. However, s 139B(2) provides that, if a taxpayer makes an election under s 139E covering a right acquired under an employee share scheme, the discount is to be included in the taxpayer’s assessable income of the year of income in which the right was acquired. Section 139E(1) provides that a taxpayer may make such an election, which covers each right acquired in that year by the taxpayer. Under s 139E(2), such an election must be in writing and must be made before the taxpayer lodges his or her return of income for the year of income in which the right was acquired, or within such further time as the Commissioner allows. That last phrase is critical for this appeal. ASSESSMENTS, OBJECTIONS AND REVIEW OF OBJECTIONS Under s 161(1) of the Assessment Act, every person is required to give to the Commissioner a return for each year of income. Under s 166, the Commissioner is to make an assessment in respect of each year of income, from returns and any other information in his possession, of the amount of the taxable income of a taxpayer and the tax payable thereon. Section 170(1) provides that the Commissioner may, subject to the provisions of that section, amend any assessment at any time, by making such alterations or additions as the Commissioner thinks necessary. Under s 173, every amended assessment is to be an assessment for all purposes of the Assessment Act. Under s 174(1) of the Assessment Act, the Commissioner must serve notice of any assessment made, as soon as convenient, after the assessment has been made. Under s 175A(1), a taxpayer who is dissatisfied with an assessment made in relation to that taxpayer may object against the assessment in the manner set out in Part IVC of the Administration Act.