Iron Ore Resources Pty Ltd v Argyle Iron Ore Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

CITATION:   IRON ORE RESOURCES PTY LTD -v- ARGYLE IRON ORE PTY LTD [2009] WASC 20

CORAM:   NEWNES J

HEARD:   29 JANUARY 2009

DELIVERED          :   11 FEBRUARY 2009

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1049 of 2009

BETWEEN:   IRON ORE RESOURCES PTY LTD (ACN 121 046 197)

First Plaintiff

ROYALTY ADMINISTRATION COMPANY PTY LTD (ACN 108 786 778)
Second Plaintiff

AND

ARGYLE IRON ORE PTY LTD (ACN 106 440 564)
Defendant

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Injunction - Undertaking as to damages - Plaintiff a trustee - Plaintiff has no assets in its own right - Whether injunction should be conditional upon beneficiary giving undertaking as to damages - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Continuation of injunction conditional upon beneficiary giving undertaking as to damages

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Plaintiff                  :     Mr J C Vaughan

Second Plaintiff             :     Mr J C Vaughan

Defendant:     Mr S Penglis

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff                  :     Deacons

Second Plaintiff             :     Deacons

Defendant:     Freehills

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Air Express Ltd v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd (1981) 146 CLR 249

Allen v Jambo Holdings Ltd [1980] 2 All ER 502

Bell Wholesale Co Pty Ltd v Gates Export Corporation (No 2) (1984) 2 FCR 1

BPM Pty Ltd v HPM Pty Ltd (1996) 131 FLR 339

Custom Credit Corporation Ltd v Whitehall Holdings Pty Ltd (Unreported, WASC, Library No 920231, 7 April 1992)

Lagarna Pty Ltd v Bridge Wholesale Acceptance Corporation (Australia) Ltd [1995] 1 VR 150

Laundry Coin‑Wash Nominees Pty Ltd v Dunlop Olympic Ltd (1985) ATPR 40‑584

  1. NEWNES J:  On 9 January 2009, an urgent interim injunction was granted on the application of the plaintiffs restraining the defendant from transferring certain tenements to Kimberley Metals Group Pty Ltd (Kimberley Metals) pursuant to an agreement dated 19 December 2008 made between the defendant and Kimberley Metals.  The injunction was expressed to operate until 4.00 pm on 14 January 2009.

  2. On 14 January 2009, the injunction was extended until further order.  The trial of the action has since been set down for three days commencing on 3 March 2009.

  3. When the injunction was first granted, the first plaintiff gave an undertaking as to damages in the usual form.  On 14 January 2009, counsel for the defendant raised the adequacy of the value of the first plaintiff's undertaking but the matter was not pursued at that time on the basis that the parties would confer to see if it could be resolved between them.  It has turned out that the parties have been unable to reach agreement and the defendant now seeks an order that the injunction be discharged unless such an undertaking is also given by Battle Mountain Pty Ltd (Battle Mountain), for whom the first plaintiff holds its shares in the defendant in trust.

The background

  1. It is necessary in order to explain the basis of the application to describe briefly the issues in the action.  In that connection, I should say that I…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Iron Ore Resources Pty Ltd v Argyle Iron Ore Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] WASC 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Iron Ore Resources Pty Ltd, as trustee of the Battle Mountain Iron Ore Trust, brought an action against Argyle Iron Ore Pty Ltd seeking an injunction to restrain the defendant from engaging in certain activities. The plaintiff, having no assets in its own right, relied on its right of indemnity against the trust property. The defendant argued that an injunction should only be granted if the plaintiff's beneficiary, Battle Mountain, provided an undertaking as to damages. The case reached the court, which was tasked with determining whether the plaintiff's lack of assets in its own right necessitated an undertaking from the beneficiary as a condition for the injunction.

The central legal issue was whether, given the plaintiff's status as a trustee with no assets in its own right, an undertaking as to damages from the beneficiary was required to satisfy the court that the plaintiff could meet any potential damages award if the injunction were ultimately breached. The court examined the principles governing security for costs and whether analogous reasoning could apply to the provision of an undertaking as to damages in the context of injunctive relief. It considered the nature of the trust, the terms of the loan agreement, and the potential for the trust's assets to be accessed to meet any damages award.

The court concluded that the plaintiff's current undertaking as to damages was insufficient given the precarious nature of the loan agreement and the ease with which it could be terminated. The court held that the loan agreement did not provide reliable assurance that the undertaking would hold value post-trial. The court also noted the lack of a satisfactory explanation from the plaintiff as to why Battle Mountain had not provided an undertaking. Consequently, the court ruled that the injunction should be conditional upon Battle Mountain providing an undertaking as to damages. This decision was based on the need to ensure that the plaintiff could meet any potential damages award, thus protecting the defendant from the risk of an unenforcable judgment.

The court ordered that the continuation of the injunction would be conditional upon the beneficiary, Battle Mountain, giving an undertaking as to damages. This decision ensures that the defendant is protected against the risk of an unenforceably small damages award and maintains the integrity of the court's orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Continuation of injunction conditional upon beneficiary giving undertaking as to damages

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It seems to me that some guidance can also be gained from the position in relation to security for costs. It is well established in relation to security for costs that where a corporate plaintiff does not have adequate assets to meet an order for costs if such an order is made against it at trial, those who stand behind the company and who stand to benefit from the litigation may be required to come out from behind the corporate shield and make funds of their own available to provide security for costs if the action is not to be stayed: Bell Wholesale Co Pty Ltd v Gates Export Corporation (No 2) (1984) 2 FCR 1; BPM Pty Ltd v HPM Pty Ltd (1996) 131 FLR 339. Similarly, where the only tangible assets of a plaintiff are held in trust, so that its only asset is its right of indemnity against the trust property, it may be required to establish that recourse to that property will be available to meet an order for costs. In that connection, the court must bear in mind the difficulties which a successful defendant would face in attempting to execute in respect of an order for costs. Where the court is not satisfied that such recourse is available, the trustee will be treated as having no available assets and the beneficiaries may be required to make funds of their own available to provide security for costs if the action is not to be stayed: Laundry Coin‑Wash Nominees Pty Ltd v Dunlop Olympic Ltd (1985) ATPR 40‑584; Lagarna Pty Ltd v Bridge Wholesale Acceptance Corporation (Australia) Ltd [1995] 1 VR 150. The first plaintiff has declined to procure an undertaking as to damages by Battle Mountain and, as appears from a letter from the first plaintiff's solicitors to the defendant's solicitors of 28 January 2009, Battle Mountain itself resists giving such an undertaking. Indeed, the latter is evident from the measures which Battle Mountain has put in place in an endeavour to placate the defendant. (I would observe in passing that in the course of argument counsel for the first plaintiff was unable to explain why Battle Mountain had gone to those lengths when it would appear that much the simpler course would have been to provide an undertaking as to damages.) It is contended that those measures (by way of the loan agreement and the direction of 28 January 2009) are sufficient to overcome any reasonable complaint by the defendant as to the value of the first plaintiff's undertaking and that no basis has been made out to require an undertaking from Battle Mountain. I do not accept that contention. In my view, the loan agreement does not provide any real assurance that, if it is called upon by the defendant after trial, the current undertaking as to damages will have any greater value then than it has now. The loan agreement effectively exists at the will of Battle Mountain. Under the terms of the loan agreement, it expires if the first plaintiff's appointment as trustee is terminated. Upon the termination of the loan agreement, the first plaintiff must repay the balance of the loan funds outstanding (save any funds which have already been paid to the defendant under the undertaking as to damages). Battle Mountain has the power to terminate the first plaintiff's appointment as trustee at any time and the nature of the trust is such that there would appear to be no practical impediment to it doing so. In addition, the loan terminates on 30 June 2009, regardless of whether the defendant then has an unquantified entitlement to damages under the undertaking as to damages. It is also the case, as the defendant submitted, that the first plaintiff and Battle Mountain could by agreement terminate or amend the loan agreement at any time.