Ipswich Netball Association Inc v Netball Queensland Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Ipswich Netball Association Inc v Netball Queensland Limited [2021] QSC 348

PARTIES:

IPSWICH NETBALL ASSOCIATION INC
ABN 86 148 152 575

(applicant)

v
NETBALL QUEENSLAND LIMITED
ACN 612 079 179

(respondent)

FILE NO:

SC No 8635 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

17 December 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATES:

2 and 3 September 2021

Further submissions on 10 and 17 September 2021

JUDGE:

Wilson J

ORDERS:

1.   Declarations that:

(a)     the decisions of the respondent made on 6 October 2020, 1 February 2021 and 15 March 2021 (referred to in paragraph 4 of this judgment) were not authorised and are invalid; and

(b) the respondent’s “Policy Number – 001 – Affiliation and Membership Policy” purports to vary class rights of Member Associations without complying with section 264B(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and is invalid to the extent that it refers to and requires the affiliation of Member Associations.

2.   Order that the respondent reinstate the applicant’s rights and privileges as a Member Association of the respondent.

3.   The question of costs is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

CATCHWORDS:

CORPORATIONS – CONSTITUTION AND REPLACEABLE RULES – GENERALLY – where the applicant was a member of the respondent – where the respondent decided not to affiliate or re-affiliate the applicant – where the respondent’s constitution did not require or create a process for affiliation – where the respondent’s Affiliation and Membership Policy created a process of affiliation – whether affiliation and membership were synonymous – whether the decisions were authorised by the respondent’s constitution or Affiliation and Membership Policy

CORPORATIONS – CONSTITUTION AND REPLACEABLE RULES – LEGAL CAPACITY AND RELATIONS WITH OUTSIDERS – POWERS – where the applicant was a member of the respondent – where the respondent decided not to affiliate or re-affiliate the applicant – where the decisions were not authorised by the respondent’s constitution or policies – whether sections 124 and 125 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) authorised the decisions

CORPORATIONS – MEMBERSHIP, RIGHTS AND REMEDIES – MEMBERS’ REMEDIES AND INTERNAL DISPUTES – OTHER ACTIONS OR REMEDIES – where the respondent’s constitution created a class of Member Associations – where the respondent’s Affiliation and Membership Policy created a separate status of affiliated Member Associations with different rights – whether the Affiliation and Membership Policy constituted an impermissible variation of class rights under sections 246B and 246C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 140, s 124, s 125, s 246B(2), s 246C

ANZ Executors & Trustees Company Limited v Qintex Australia Limited [1991] 2 Qd R 360, cited
Darvall v North Sydney Brick & Tile Co Ltd (No 4) (1988) 14 ACLR 474, cited
Hillig v Darkinjung Pty Ltd (2006) 201 FLR 148, approved

Rolled Steel Products (Holdings) Ltd v British Steel Corp & Ors [1986] 1 Ch 246, cited

COUNSEL:

H Blattman for the applicant
S Monks for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Neumann &…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ipswich Netball Association Inc v Netball Queensland Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 348
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Ipswich Netball Association Inc brought an action against Netball Queensland Limited, seeking relief regarding the decisions of the respondent to not affiliate or re-affiliate the applicant. The case involved the interpretation of the respondent's constitution and the Affiliation and Membership Policy, and whether these decisions were authorised and valid. The respondent's constitution did not explicitly define or provide a process for affiliation. Instead, the Affiliation and Membership Policy outlined a process for affiliation. The applicant argued that affiliation and membership were not synonymous, and that the decisions were not authorised by either the constitution or the policy. Additionally, the applicant contended that the Affiliation and Membership Policy constituted an impermissible variation of class rights under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

The Court examined the respondent's constitution and the Affiliation and Membership Policy to determine whether the decisions were authorised. The Court found that the constitution did not provide a process for or a definition of "affiliation." The term "Affiliated Member" appeared twice in the constitution but was not defined, and the Court concluded that the use of the terms "affiliation" and "Affiliated Member" supported the interpretation that affiliation did not relate to a Member Association being affiliated with the respondent. Instead, these terms referred to the registration or affiliation of an Individual Member or an Affiliated Member with a Member Association. The Court also found that the Affiliation and Membership Policy did not provide a valid process for the decisions made by the respondent. The Court held that the decisions were not authorised by either the constitution or the policy and, therefore, were invalid.

The Court declared that the decisions made by the respondent on 6 October 2020, 1 February 2021, and 15 March 2021 were not authorised and invalid. The Court also declared that the Affiliation and Membership Policy varied class rights of Member Associations without complying with the Corporations Act and was invalid to the extent it referred to and required the affiliation of Member Associations. The Court ordered the respondent to reinstate the applicant's rights and privileges as a Member Association of the respondent. The question of costs was adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Declarations that:

(a) the decisions of the respondent made on 6 October 2020, 1 February 2021 and 15 March 2021 (referred to in paragraph 4 of this judgment) were not authorised and are invalid; and

(b) the respondent’s “Policy Number – 001 – Affiliation and Membership Policy” purports to vary class rights of Member Associations without complying with section 264B(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and is invalid to the extent that it refers to and requires the affiliation of Member Associations.

2. Order that the respondent reinstate the applicant’s rights and privileges as a Member Association of the respondent.

3. The question of costs is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Ipswich Netball Association Inc (the applicant) and Netball Queensland Limited (the respondent) have a contentious relationship stemming from a series of events that began in late 2019. The applicant, a member of the respondent, was accused by the respondent of engaging in activities that were damaging to the reputation of netball and the respondent itself. These activities included a campaign against the former Chair, Chief Executive Officer, and the Board of the respondent, the cancellation of netball participation opportunities without reasonable efforts to collaborate on alternative solutions, refusal to engage with the respondent's management or Board, a proactive campaign to discredit the respondent using various media outlets, and discrediting the respondent with various stakeholders. Following these events, the respondent decided not to affiliate or re-affiliate the applicant, decisions which the applicant now challenges.

This case came before the court following an application by the Ipswich Netball Association Inc for judicial review of decisions made by Netball Queensland Limited. The applicant sought declarations regarding the validity of certain decisions and orders to reinstate its rights and privileges. The court reviewed the matter, examining the constitution and policies of the respondent, the process by which the decisions were made, and the powers of the respondent to make such decisions. The court also considered the impact of the decisions on the applicant's rights and privileges as a Member Association of the respondent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The minutes do not identify the source of the board’s power to not renew the applicant’s affiliation. The second decision The second decision was made at a board meeting on 1 February 2021. On this occasion, the board was provided with a paper outlining the applicant’s conduct, the relevant provisions of the Constitution, options for dealing with the applicant’s conduct and recommendations. The executive summary to the board paper stated: “The conduct of the Ipswich Netball Association (INA) Management Committee, particularly over the last 12 months, has been very damaging to the brand and reputation of Netball Queensland (NQ) and netball as a sport.The public and private campaign against NQ, NQ Directors and NQ staff contravenes NQ's values driven culture and the values articulated in our Strategic Plan (collaborative, brave, authentic, inclusive and innovative) which all rely on a backbone of trust.The decision, actions and behaviours in question include:(a)a deliberate and ongoing campaign to discredit the former NQ Chair, CEO and the NQ Board; (b)cancellation of opportunities for netball participation (competitions and events) without reasonable efforts to collaborate on alternative solutions; (c)refusal to meet with or engage with NQ management or Board to discuss issues and attempt conciliation and/or resolution; (d)a proactive campaign to use various media outlets to discredit NQ and publish inaccurate information; and (e)a proactive and extensive campaign to discredit NQ with various stakeholders including Netball Australia, the Queensland State Government and QSport.” The board paper then set out the details of what it described as the applicant’s discrediting campaign, lack of participation, refusal to engage and media leaks. The board paper stated that consideration had been given as to whether the applicant had breached membership obligations under the Constitution. It set out the following clauses for ease of reference: “Clause 5 MembershipUnder clause 5.3 of the Netball Queensland Constitution, each Member Association will:(iii)at all times act for an on behalf of the interest of the Company, the Members and Netball(viii)act in good faith and loyalty to maintain and enhance the Company and netball, its standard quality and reputation for the collective and mutual benefit of the Members and Netball;(ix)at all times operate with and promote mutual trust and confidence between the Company and the Members, promote economic and sporting success, strength and stability of each other and work cooperatively with each other in the pursuit of the Objects(xi)not do or permit to be done any act or thing which might adversely affect or derogate from the standards, quality and reputation of netball and its maintenance and developmentClause 6 Cessation of MembershipUnder clause 6.1 (e) if a member no longer meets the requirements for membership under clause 5 they ceases to be a member.Clause 7 Grievances and Discipline of MembersAll Members are subject to NQ's jurisdiction. The Directors in their sole discretion may refer an allegation (which in the opinion of the Directors is not vexatious, trifling or frivolous) by a complainant (including a Director or a Member) that a Member has:(i)breached, failed, refused or neglected to comply with a provision of this Constitution, the Policies or any other resolution or determination of the Directors or any duly authorised committee; or(ii)acted in a manner unbecoming of a Member or prejudicial to the Objects and interests of the Company or Netball, or both; or(iii)prejudiced the Company or Netball or brought the Company or Netball or themself into disrepute; for investigation or determination either under the procedures set down in the Policies or by such other procedure and/or persons as the Directors consider appropriate. During investigatory or disciplinary proceedings under clause 7, a respondent may not participate in Netball, pending the determination of such proceedings (including any available appeal) unless the Directors decide continued participation is appropriate having regard to the matter at hand. The Directors may include in any Policy or Policies a final right of appeal to an independent body outside the control of the Netball.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Constitution does not provide a process for, or definition of, “affiliation” to the respondent. The term “Affiliated Member” appears twice in the Constitution but is not defined. It appears first in the definition of registration in clause 1.1(u), which provides:“Registration means the registration or affiliation of an Individual Member or an Affiliated Member with a Member Association, such registration being in the form of a signed application form, and in the case of Individual Members, their consent to membership of the Company as required by clause 5.2. Registered has a corresponding meaning.” The definition of Registration is relevant to clause 5.3(c)(x), which stipulates that each Member Association will:“[M]aintain a database of all clubs, officials and members Registered with it in accordance with the Policies and provide a copy to the Company upon request from time to time by the Directors in such means as may be required;” In my view, use of the terms “affiliation” and “Affiliated Member” in the definition of Registration and, in turn, the use of the defined term “Registered” in clause 5.3(c)(x), supports an interpretation that affiliation in the Constitution does not relate to a Member Association being affiliated with the respondent. Rather, the terms “affiliation” and “Affiliated Member” refer to the registration or affiliation of an Individual Member or an Affiliated Member with a Member Association. Clause 12.3 then distinguishes between a Member Association and an Affiliated Member in setting out who is eligible to hold office as a director. “12.3 Eligibility(a)For the period from the date of this Constitution a person who:(i)is an employee of the Company, a Member Association or an Affiliated Member; or(ii)holds an Official Position with a Member Association or an Affiliated Member; or (iii)was a Director of the Company and clause 12.8 applies,(each a disqualifying position) may not hold office as a Director.” I note that by referring to a Member Association “or” an Affiliated Member, the Constitution treats these as distinct concepts. The Policy, affiliation and membership Clause 19.1 states that the directors may, from time to time, make policies. Clause 19.2 specifies that a policy is subject to the Constitution, must be consistent with the Constitution and, when in force, is binding on all members and has the same effect as a provision of the Constitution. There were two relevant versions of the Policy before the Court. The first is version 9, which came into force on 10 February 2020. Version 11 would have applied at the time of the first and second decisions, but the respondent has not adduced either version 10 or 11 into evidence. The applicant proceeded on the assumption that version 9 of the Policy was materially similar to version 11 and the respondent did not dispute such an assumption. The second relevant version of the Policy is version 14, which came into effect on 26 February 2021. It was applicable at the time of the third decision.