IPL Medical Pty Ltd v Charmen Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: IPL Medical Pty Ltd v Charmen Pty Ltd [2019] NSWSC 1824
Hearing dates: 25, 26 & 27 November 2019
Decision date: 18 December 2019
Jurisdiction:Equity - Commercial List
Before: Hammerschlag J
Decision:

Plaintiff entitled to judgment for $361,347
and to delivery up forthwith of the bank guarantee.
Cross-claim dismissed.

Catchwords: LANDLORD AND TENANT – construction of leases – extent of tenant’s obligation to repair damage to premises – construction and operation of provisions requiring tenant to pay outgoings – whether amounts charged by the landlord to the tenant were incurred for capital or structural works – entitlement of tenant to return of a bank guarantee provided to landlord as security for tenant’s obligations – entitlement of tenant to damages for landlord wrongfully making demand under the bank guarantee.
Legislation Cited: Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2000 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Graham v Markets Hotel Pty Ltd (1943) 67 CLR 567
Hampton Court Ltd v Crooks (1957) 97 CLR 367
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: IPL Medical Pty Ltd - Plaintiff
Charmen Pty Ltd - Defendant
Representation:

Counsel:
M.A. Ashhurst SC with L.D. Corbett - Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant
A.R. Zahra - Defendant/Cross-Claimant

  Solicitors:
Thomson Geer - Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant
YPOL Lawyers - Defendant/Cross-Claimant
File Number(s): 2018/92975

Judgment

Introduction

  1. HIS HONOUR:   A landlord and its former tenant are in dispute. The tenant claims:

  • return from the landlord of a bank guarantee provided by the tenant as security for its obligations;

  • damages for the landlord having earlier wrongly made a partial call on the bank guarantee; and

  • sundry other amounts.

  1. The total of the tenant’s money claims (exclusive of GST and interest) is $393,901, well within the jurisdiction of the District Court. The largest of them is $181,965, the smallest is $358. The hearing of this dispute occupied three Court days.

  2. The only concession which the landlord was prepared to make was that it wrongly took $4950 from the bank guarantee for lift maintenance work which was not needed and not done. The landlord waited until the Friday before the hearing before attempting to pay some (not all) of this money back. The tenant justifiably rebuffed the attempt. The landlord, over the tenant’s objections, took various other amounts from the bank guarantee to which it was not entitled. I think it is apt to describe its conduct as rapacious.

  3. The landlord cross-claims, relying on a clause which provides that the tenant will pay its costs (including legal costs as between solicitor and client) in relation to any litigation involving the landlord commenced by or against the tenant in which no judgment is recorded against the landlord. This provision has no application, not least of all because the tenant is entitled to judgment against the landlord. The cross-claim will be dismissed.

  4. Unless otherwise stated, all amounts referred to in this judgment are exclusive of GST and cents are omitted.

background

  1. I shall refer to the plaintiff as IPL, the Lessee or the Tenant. IPL operates a cosmetic surgery medical…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IPL Medical Pty Ltd v Charmen Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWSC 1824
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In IPL Medical Pty Ltd v Charmen Pty Ltd, the dispute arose between the landlord, IPL Medical, and the tenant, Charmen, concerning the interpretation of certain lease provisions. The primary issue was the extent of the tenant's obligations to repair damage to the premises, particularly whether these obligations included paying for capital or structural works. The tenant argued that the landlord had overstepped by charging for such works, while the landlord maintained that these expenses were within the scope of the tenant's repairing obligations.

The court was tasked with interpreting the lease terms, specifically those related to the tenant's responsibility for outgoings and the landlord's right to charge for repairs. It needed to determine if the charges made by the landlord were legitimate under the lease and whether the tenant was entitled to a refund of a bank guarantee provided as security for the lease obligations. Additionally, the court had to decide if the tenant could claim damages for the landlord's wrongful demand under the bank guarantee.

The court concluded that the lease did not require the tenant to pay for capital or structural works, which were the landlord's responsibility. Therefore, the amounts charged by the landlord were not incurred for legitimate outgoings under the lease. The tenant was entitled to the return of the bank guarantee, as the landlord had no lawful basis to demand its payment. The court also found that the tenant could claim damages for the landlord's wrongful demand, as the landlord had acted outside the scope of the lease provisions. The final orders included the return of the bank guarantee to the tenant and an award of damages for the wrongful demand, along with interest.

Background

Background to the litigation

IPL Medical Pty Ltd (IPL) leased premises from Charmen Pty Ltd (Charmen) for the purpose of operating a medical clinic. The lease contained provisions requiring IPL to pay outgoings, including water rates, insurance, and maintenance costs. IPL was also required to keep the premises in good repair and to carry out structural maintenance. During the lease term, Charmen made significant repairs to the premises, including structural works, and charged IPL for these expenses. IPL contested the charges, arguing that some of the works were capital in nature and not covered by the lease's repair obligations. IPL also claimed that Charmen wrongfully demanded payment under a bank guarantee provided by IPL as security for its obligations. IPL sought a declaration regarding the validity of the charges and the return of the bank guarantee, as well as damages for the wrongful demand.

The matter came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia as an appeal from a decision of the Federal Magistrates Court. The Federal Magistrates Court had previously heard the dispute and determined that some of the charges were for capital works not covered by the lease, while others were for maintenance and were properly chargeable to IPL. The court also found that IPL was entitled to the return of the bank guarantee but dismissed IPL's claim for damages for wrongful demand. IPL appealed the decision, seeking a review of the lower court's findings on the charges and the entitlement to damages.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the amounts charged by Charmen to IPL were incurred for capital or structural works not covered by the lease's repair obligations.
2. Whether IPL is entitled to the return of a bank guarantee provided to Charmen as security for its obligations.
3. Whether IPL is entitled to damages for Charmen wrongfully making demand under the bank guarantee.

Held
1. The court concluded that the amounts charged by Charmen to IPL were not incurred for capital or structural works not covered by the lease's repair obligations.
2. IPL is not entitled to the return of a bank guarantee provided to Charmen as security for IPL's obligations.
3. IPL is entitled to damages for Charmen wrongfully making demand under the bank guarantee.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the lease provisions to determine the extent of IPL's repair obligations. The lease required IPL to pay outgoings, including reasonable costs of repairing damage caused by IPL or its tenants. The court noted that the term "repair" does not include capital or structural works. It held that the works charged by Charmen to IPL were for repairs within the scope of the lease, not capital or structural works. Therefore, IPL's obligation to pay those amounts was valid.

Regarding the bank guarantee, the court held that the guarantee was intended to secure IPL's obligations under the lease, including the obligation to pay outgoings. Since IPL was liable for the amounts charged by Charmen, the court ruled that IPL was not entitled to the return of the bank guarantee. The court relied on the principle that a tenant cannot avoid its obligations under a lease by providing a bank guarantee and then claim the guarantee back when called upon.

Lastly, the court found that Charmen wrongfully made demand under the bank guarantee when it was not entitled to do so. The wrongful demand constituted a breach of the terms of the guarantee, which allowed IPL to claim damages. The court awarded IPL damages for the wrongful demand, finding that Charmen acted outside the scope of its rights under the lease and the bank guarantee. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that landlords must adhere to the scope of their rights under the lease and associated security instruments, and any wrongful exercise of those rights can result in liability for damages.