Invast Financial Services Pty Ltd v Pseven International DWC LLC
Link copied
CaseCopied
48 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Invast Financial Services Pty Ltd v Pseven International DWC LLC [2022] FCA 861
File number:
NSD 903 of 2020
Judgment of:
YATES J
Date of judgment:
22 July 2022
Catchwords:
CORPORATIONS – alleged contraventions of s 12DA(1) of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (the ASIC Act), s 18(1) of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), and the Australian Consumer Law (NSW) (ACL(NSW)) – contracts for differences entered into between the first respondent and the applicant – whether a contract for differences is a “financial product” for the purposes of s 12BAA(1) of the ASIC Act – whether s 12DA(1) of the ASIC Act is engaged – whether s 18(1) of the ACL(NSW) applies – whether the operation of s 18(1) of the ACL is excluded by s 131A of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
CONSUMER LAW – representations that funds would be, and had been, transferred by the first respondent to the applicant in satisfaction of a margin call made, and of other obligations assumed, in respect of contracts for differences entered into between the applicant and the first respondent – whether the making of the representations constituted conduct in trade or commerce that was misleading or deceptive – whether loss or damage was suffered by the making of the representations
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for summary judgment against the second respondent pursuant to s 31A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – application for default judgment against the second respondent pursuant to r 5.23(2)(b) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – application for summary judgment granted
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether the second respondent is liable as a principal contravener or as a person involved in the alleged contraventions – discussion of relevant principles
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Invast Financial Services Pty Ltd v Pseven International DWC... and more:
The applicant, Invast Financial Services Pty Ltd, sought summary judgment against Pseven International DWC LLC and another party regarding alleged contraventions of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth), the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), and the Australian Consumer Law (NSW). The dispute centred on contracts for differences (CFDs) between the applicant and the first respondent, where the applicant claimed that the first respondent failed to meet margin calls and other financial obligations. The applicant alleged that the second respondent made misleading or deceptive representations that these obligations would be met, causing the applicant to suffer loss. The court was required to determine whether CFDs are considered "financial products" under the ASIC Act, if the ASIC Act's s 12DA(1) applied, whether the ACL applied, and if the operation of the ACL was excluded by s 131A of the Competition and Consumer Act.
The court found that CFDs are indeed financial products under s 12BAA(1) of the ASIC Act, and that s 12DA(1) was engaged. Regarding the ACL, the court held that the representations made by the second respondent constituted conduct in trade or commerce that was misleading or deceptive, and that the applicant suffered loss as a result. The court also found that the second respondent was involved in the contraventions as he made the representations on behalf of the first respondent, acting as the controlling mind and the sole point of contact. The court granted the application for summary judgment against the second respondent, who had defaulted in filing a defence and providing evidence. The court referred questions regarding the amount of damages, interest on damages, and costs to a Registrar for inquiry and report.
The court ordered that the proceeding be listed for further hearing after the receipt of the Registrar's report. The court's decision addressed the legal issues concerning the nature of CFDs, the applicability of relevant legislation, and the involvement of the second respondent in the alleged contraventions.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Pursuant to s 54A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), the following questions be referred to a Registrar of the Court for inquiry and report as a referee:
(a) the amount of damages to which the applicant is entitled as against the second respondent for the loss which the Court has found was suffered by the applicant because of the first respondent’s contraventions of s 18(1) of the Australian Consumer Law (Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) and the second respondent’s involvement in those contraventions;
(b) the interest to which the applicant is entitled on such damages under s 51A of the Act; and
(c) the costs to which the applicant is entitled on a lump sum basis.
2. The inquiry be conducted in any way the referee thinks fit.
3. The proceeding be listed for further hearing on a date to be fixed after receipt of the referee’s report.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Here, the applicant relies on the second respondent’s default in failing to file a defence and his evidence, and in failing to appear at the hearing of the present application and the case management hearing that was listed at the same time. BACKGROUND The applicant’s claim concerns alleged contraventions of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (the ASIC Act), the Australian Consumer Law (the ACL) (Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (the Competition and Consumer Act), and the Australian Consumer Law (NSW) (the ACL(NSW)) (through operation of s 28 of the Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) (the Fair Trading Act)) by the first respondent and the second respondent in relation to representations that a margin call and other financial obligations would be met in respect of contracts for differences (CFDs) entered into between the applicant and the first respondent. A CFD is a contract between two parties by which one party owes the other party the difference between the current value of an asset and its value at the time the contract was made. A share CFD tracks the price of an underlying share. The applicant issued a Product Disclosure Statement (the PDS) in 2013 which describes a CFD in these terms: A contract for differences (CFD) is a contract with Invast to exchange the difference between the opening and closing values of a trading instrument, multiplied by the number of CFDs in the contract. CFDs can be contracts with an individual equity, Stock Index, bond, interest rate, inflation rate, commodity or currency pair as the underlying market.Invast generally bases the prices of the CFDs you trade with us on the prices of the Underlying Assets to which the CFDs relate. Our prices are generally based on the Underlying mid-market price and we apply a Spread having regard to factors such as the depth and liquidity in the market for the Underlying Asset.CFDs are Derivative products which allow you to make a profit or loss from fluctuations in the price of an Underlying Security or trading instrument, without actually owning the Security or instrument. To trade CFDs you must enter into a contract with Invast to exchange the difference between the opening value and closing value of the CFD, which is referenced to an Underlying Security or trading instrument. CFDs allow you to speculate on the rise or fall in the price of the Underlying Security or trading instrument.CFDs are traded on margin which allows you to receive the commercial benefits of trading in the Underlying Security or trading instrument while avoiding many of the costs of purchasing the Underlying Security or trading instrument. The potential gain (or loss) from CFDs is the net position of your opening position less your closing position (after taking into account notional dividend payments, commissions, interest and other payments). In describing how a CFD works, the PDS states: When you enter into a CFD contract with Invast, the amount of profit or loss made on the CFD will be dependent upon, amongst other things such as commissions, interest payments and dividends, the difference between the price of the Underlying Security or trading instrument when the CFD is opened (entered into) and the price of the Underlying Security or trading instrument when the CFD is closed. Accordingly, as the price of the Underlying Security or trading instrument increases, the derived price of the corresponding CFD will also increase to reflect the movement of the Underlying. Similarly, a fall in the price of the Underlying Security or trading instrument will have a negative effect on the price of a CFD.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The second respondent made the representations. He also made the representations on behalf of the first respondent. In this regard, he was the controlling mind of the first respondent and the person through whom the first respondent acted. The second respondent was, therefore, a person involved in the first respondent’s contraventions.THE EVIDENCE Apart from the admitted allegations of fact in the statement of claim, the applicant also relies on the evidence provided through the following affidavits, which were read at the hearing:·Affidavit of Eun Ji Shin made 25 February 2022;·Affidavit of Simon James McGahan made 28 February 2022;·Affidavit of Peter Stewart Bickerton made 28 February 2022;·Affidavit of Christopher Thomas Barnes made 28 February 2022;·Affidavit of Gavin White made 28 February 2022;·Affidavit of Brendon John Miller made 4 May 2022;·Affidavit of Brendon John Miller made 30 May 2022. The evidence before the Court was subsequently supplemented by an affidavit of service made by Anushka Pokharel on 21 June 2022. Independently of the admissions taken to have been made, the evidence referred to in [38] above establishes the pleaded facts I have summarised. It also establishes the following additional facts. From 2017 to 2019, the first respondent traded with the applicant regularly. The sizes of the trades were significant. The first respondent was sent margin call notifications on seven occasions between 2017 and 2018. On each occasion, the amount required to be paid by the first respondent was a six-figure sum in USD. The largest sum was USD 380,774. The smallest sum was USD 137,870. On each occasion, the margin call was attended to appropriately by the first respondent reducing its positions. At all times, the second respondent was the only point of contact for the first respondent, and he was the only person authorised to provide instructions to the applicant. When, on previous occasions, the first respondent paid money to the applicant, the second respondent sent a copy of the proof of payment by email. The applicant’s trade with the first respondent in relation to the CFDs was a Direct Market Access CFD trade. Under this methodology, the pricing of stocks that the applicant offers to the client is direct from the official exchange live price feeds, reflecting exact, live pricing of the relevant stocks on the exchange. The applicant instantaneously hedges each client trade with its prime broker, who also instantaneously hedges the applicant’s trade on the relevant exchange. This is intended to mirror the experience of a client trading the physical stocks on the underlying exchange. In 2019, the applicant’s prime broker was Deutsche Bank. The applicant’s trades with Deutsche Bank were the institutional equivalent of a CFD. This is called a DMA equity swap in which Deutsche Bank committed to hedging all the applicant’s swap trades by executing them in the physical equities market stock exchange. When the first respondent initiated the trade with the applicant described above, the relationship was principal-to-principal. The applicant concurrently initiated a trade with Deutsche Bank, again on a principal-to-principal basis.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Establishing a contravention of s 18(1) of the ACL does not involve proof of any mental element. However, in order to establish the liability of a person said to have been involved in the contravention, it is necessary for the moving party to establish that the person was intentionally involved in the principal’s contravention and had knowledge of the essential matters that make up the contravention, whether or not that person also knew that those matters were a contravention: Yorke v Lucas [1985] HCA 65; 158 CLR 661.SUMMARY JUDGMENT Section 31A(1) of the Act permits the Court to give judgment in favour of an applicant where it is satisfied that the respondent has no reasonable prospect of successfully defending the proceeding. In Spencer v Commonwealth of Australia [2010] HCA 28; 241 CLR 118, Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel, and Bell JJ remarked (at [58]):58 How then should the expression “no reasonable prospect” be understood? No paraphrase of the expression can be adopted as a sufficient explanation of its operation, let alone definition of its content. Nor can the expression usefully be understood by the creation of some antinomy intended to capture most or all of the cases in which it cannot be said that there is “no reasonable prospect”. The judicial creation of a lexicon of words or phrases intended to capture the operation of a particular statutory phrase like “no reasonable prospect” is to be avoided. Consideration of the difficulties that bedevilled the proviso to common form criminal appeal statutes, as a result of judicial glossing of the relevant statutory expression, provides the clearest example of the dangers that attend any such attempt. Plainly, s 31A calls for the exercise of a practical judgment on the question posed by the provision. However, as Reeves J observed in Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Cassimatis [2013] FCA 641; 220 FCR 256 at [46], each application for summary judgment must be determined according to its particular circumstances, including the stage at which the proceeding has reached. In this present case, the stage has been reached where the second respondent has been ordered to file a defence and the parties have been ordered to file their evidence. The second respondent has not advanced a defence to the allegations in the statement of claim or any evidence, let alone any evidence which, if it were to be admitted at a final hearing, would contradict the applicant’s claim against him. Having regard to the admissions taken to have been made, and the uncontradicted evidence which has been adduced in the present application, I am satisfied that:(a)The first representation and the second representation were made through the instrumentality of the second respondent.(b)When the second respondent made the first representation and the second representation, he was acting as and for the first respondent. Therefore, the first respondent made the representations.(c)The first representation was false at the time it was made. I infer that the second respondent had no intention of causing the first respondent to send, and therefore the first respondent had no intention of sending, USD 1,500,000 to the applicant at that time or in the immediate future. The second respondent knew the falsity of the first representation. The making of this representation was conduct, in trade or commerce, that was misleading or deceptive. (d)In order to reach the finding in (c), it is not necessary to rely on the fact that the first representation was a representation with respect to a future matter. However, for completeness, I accept that it was a representation with respect to a future matter for the purposes of s 4 of the ACL, and that the first respondent, acting through the second respondent, had no reasonable grounds for making that representation.(e)The second representation was false at the time it was made. I rely on the finding in (c). In addition, I find that the second respondent did not cause the first respondent to send, and therefore the first respondent did not send, USD 1,500,000 by wire transfer to the applicant’s bank account. Once again, the second respondent knew the falsity of the second representation. The making of the second representation was conduct, in trade or commerce, that was misleading or deceptive.(f)In order to reach the finding in (e), it is not necessary to rely on the fact that aspects of the second representation were representations with respect to future matters—namely, that the funds would be processed, settled, and received in the applicant’s bank account for its credit. However, for completeness, I accept that these aspects were representations with respect to future matters for the purposes of s 4 of the ACL, and that the first respondent, acting through the second respondent, had no reasonable grounds for making those representations.(g)The conduct referred to in (c) and (e) contravened s 18(1) of the ACL.(h)The applicant suffered loss by reason of the contraventions referred to in (g).(i)The second respondent was involved in the contraventions referred to in (g) within the meaning of s 236(1) of the ACL. He made the representations as and for the first respondent with, as I have found, actual knowledge of their falsity.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In considering whether a CFD is a "financial product" for the purposes of s 12BAA(1) of the ASIC Act, the court examined the definition of "financial product" and the nature of CFDs. The court concluded that CFDs do not fit within the definition of a "financial product" as they do not involve a "contract, arrangement or understanding" that gives a person a financial right or obligation. The court further noted that CFDs are derivative products that allow for speculation on the price movements of underlying assets without the need to own those assets. This distinction led the court to find that CFDs are not financial products under the ASIC Act.
Regarding s 12DA(1) of the ASIC Act, the court considered whether the representations made by the second respondent on behalf of the first respondent engaged the provision. The court determined that s 12DA(1) was not applicable because it specifically pertains to certain misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to financial products, and as established, CFDs are not financial products.
The court addressed the applicability of s 18(1) of the ACL(NSW) and found that the representations made were indeed conduct in trade or commerce that was misleading or deceptive. The court noted that the second respondent made the representations with actual knowledge of their falsity, which is a critical element for establishing misleading or deceptive conduct under the ACL. The court also found that the applicant suffered loss or damage as a direct result of these misleading representations, thereby satisfying another element of the s 18(1) contravention.
The court further examined whether s 131A of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) excluded the operation of s 18(1) of the ACL. The court concluded that there was no exclusion applicable, meaning the ACL provisions remained in effect and the misleading representations were subject to the law's prohibition.
Lastly, the court determined the second respondent's liability, finding that he was involved in the contraventions as a person who made the representations on behalf of the first respondent. The court relied on the principle that for liability to attach, the person must have been intentionally involved in the contravention and have knowledge of the essential matters that constitute the contravention. The second respondent, as the controlling mind and point of contact, met these criteria, leading to his liability as a person involved in the contraventions.
The ratio of this decision is that CFDs are not "financial products" under s 12BAA(1) of the ASIC Act, and misleading or deceptive conduct in trade or commerce, even when made on behalf of another party, can result in liability under s 18(1) of the ACL(NSW) if the person involved had knowledge of the falsity of the representations.