IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Intuit Inc. [2020] APO 23
Patent Application: 2017201962
Title:Identifying Business Type Using Public Information
Patent Applicant: Intuit Inc.
Delegate: M. G. Kraefft
Decision Date: 20 May 2020
Hearing Date: Written submissions filed on 29 November 2019
Catchwords: PATENTS – section 45 – examiner’s objection – whether invention is a manner of manufacture – configuring business management application – identifying business type of user from data from online social network to generate configuration setting of business management application – abstract idea – alleged invention not a manner of manufacture – application refused.
Representation: Patent attorney for the applicant: Davies Collison Cave
IP AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE
Patent Application: 2017201962
Title:Identifying Business Type Using Public Information
Patent Applicant: Intuit Inc.
Date of Decision: 20 May 2020
DECISION
The claims of the application, as proposed to be amended, do not define a manner of manufacture.
Moreover, there is nothing of substance in the body of the specification from which valid claims could be drafted to overcome this finding.
The application is refused.
REASONS FOR DECISION
BACKGROUND
Intuit Inc. (“the applicant”) filed patent application 2017201962 on 23 March 2017. The application is a divisional application based on application 2013393324. That application has lapsed. The latter application in turn is based on two overseas applications. The earlier of those is an Indian patent application filed on 1 July 2013 (“the priority date”).
The present application has been subjected to three examination reports. In those reports, the examiner has maintained an objection that the claims of the application, including claims as proposed to be amended, do not define a manner of manufacture.
The applicant subsequently requested to be heard.
While the final date for acceptance of the application was 18 June 2019, patent sub-regulation 13.4(1)(g) may be available to extend the time for gaining acceptance to 3 months from the date of the present decision.
SPECIFICATION
The alleged invention relates to business management applications. Such applications may include accounting software, personnel software, payroll software, financial software, contract management software, amongst other things. In general, business management applications manage the financial aspects of a business entity.
The specification acknowledges that business management applications are typically user configurable. For example, one or more configuration settings of a business management application (“BMA”) may be determined based on user provided inputs, such as business name, business type, geographic location, language, culture related business processes, etc.
The specification, as presently proposed to be amended, ends with 18 claims. Claims 1, 7 and 13 are independent claims. These claims read as follows:-
1.A method for configuring a business management application (BMA) for managing financial aspects of a business entity, comprising:
obtaining a business name of an unconfigured user of the BMA using a computer processor that accesses a data entry field, wherein the unconfigured user is associated with the business entity, and wherein the BMA is a software as a service (SaaS) accessed by multiple users on a subscription basis;
retrieving,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Intuit Inc. and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] APO 23
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue the court needed to resolve was whether the invention described in the patent application was a manner of manufacture under section 45 of the relevant legislation. The court had to determine if the process of identifying a user's business type from social network data and using that information to configure a business management application qualified as a physical process or a series of operations that met the statutory requirements. The court also needed to consider whether the claimed invention was an abstract idea, which is not patentable.
The court found that the process in question did not amount to a manner of manufacture as it lacked a physical transformation or application of a series of operations to a particular subject matter. The court held that the process of identifying business type and generating configuration settings was primarily informational and did not involve a physical change or application. Additionally, the court concluded that the invention was an abstract idea, as it did not provide a concrete application or result beyond the informational process. As a result, the patent application was refused.
Background
Background to the litigation
The application process involved Intuit Inc. submitting the patent application to the relevant patent office. The examiner reviewed the application and raised an objection, asserting that the claimed invention was not a manner of manufacture. Intuit Inc. responded to the examiner's objection by providing arguments and evidence to support the patentability of the invention. However, the examiner remained unconvinced, leading to the refusal of the patent application.
The matter came before the court as an appeal against the decision of the patent examiner. The applicant, Intuit Inc., had initially submitted a patent application for a business management application that identifies the user's business type from online social network data to generate a configuration setting. The patent examiner refused the application, contending that the invention was an abstract idea and not a manner of manufacture. Intuit Inc. appealed the examiner's decision, seeking a review of the refusal. The court was required to determine the validity of the examiner's objection and the appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the invention constitutes a manner of manufacture under section 45 of the relevant legislation.
2. Whether the invention is an abstract idea or a concrete application or process.
3. Whether the examiner's objection to the patent application was justified.
Held
1. The court concluded that the invention does not constitute a manner of manufacture under section 45 of the relevant legislation.
2. The court held that the invention was an abstract idea rather than a concrete application or process.
3. The court found that the examiner's objection to the patent application was justified and upheld the refusal of the application.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the invention in question, which involved configuring a business management application by identifying the business type of a user from data obtained from an online social network to generate a configuration setting for the business management application. The primary issue was whether this invention constituted a manner of manufacture under section 45 of the relevant legislation. The court applied the principle that a manner of manufacture must involve a physical process or transformation of materials to produce a tangible product. In this case, the court found that the invention primarily involved an abstract idea or process rather than a physical manufacturing process. The court relied on previous case law that distinguishes between abstract ideas and concrete applications or processes. The court further held that the invention did not involve a physical transformation or production of a tangible product, but rather an abstract process of data analysis and application configuration. Consequently, the invention did not satisfy the criteria for a manner of manufacture. The court also addressed the second issue regarding whether the invention was an abstract idea or a concrete application or process. The court found that the invention primarily involved an abstract process of data analysis and application configuration, without a tangible physical component. This conclusion was based on the nature of the invention and the lack of any physical transformation or production process. Finally, the court considered the examiner's objection to the patent application. The court found that the examiner's objection was justified because the invention did not meet the statutory criteria for patentability under section 45. The court confirmed that the invention was an abstract idea and not a manner of manufacture, aligning with the examiner's objection. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an invention must involve a physical process or transformation of materials to produce a tangible product to be considered a manner of manufacture under section 45 of the relevant legislation. The court distinguished this case from prior authority that upheld the patentability of inventions involving concrete applications or processes with tangible outcomes. This decision reinforces the requirement for patentable subject matter to involve a physical manufacturing process rather than an abstract idea or process.