Insurance Australia Ltd t/as NRMA v Sear

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read
DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: Insurance Australia Ltd t/as NRMA v Sear [2022] NSWPICMP 15
CLAIMANT: Gillian Sear
INSURER:

Insurance Australia Ltd t/as NRMA

REVIEW Panel: Principal Member John Harris
Dr Drew Dixon
Dr Geoffrey Stubbs
DATE OF DECISION: 8 February 2022
CATCHWORDS: 

MOTOR ACCIDENTS- The claimant was involved in a motor accident in 2013 and underwent cervical spine surgery in 2016 and lumbar spine surgery in 2017; the medical disputes related to whether the surgical procedures were reasonable and necessary and whether they were caused by the motor accident and the assessment of permanent impairment; Held - discussion of the insurer’s refusal to narrow the issues and whether such a position was inconsistent with the concept of a new assessment by a Review Panel under the MAC Act; Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Rutland considered; expert evidence of biomechanical engineer considered relevant but not determinative; the acceptance or rejection of his evidence in other cases not relevant; Edwards v Noble applied; factual findings made that lumbar spine injured in the motor accident, but the cervical spine was not injured; the claimant admitted that neck symptoms only arose after two weeks, and other histories suggested that it was much longer; Panel did not accept that the delay in onset of symptoms together with the absence of treatment established injury to the cervical spine; finding made that the motor accident materially contributed to the need for surgical treatment of the lumbar spine; AAI Ltd v Phillips applied; surgical treatment held to be reasonable and necessary in the circumstances; claimant’s submission that a rejection that the surgery was reasonable and necessary is a finding of medical malpractice rejected; considerations given to factors discussed in Diab v NRMA; acceptance that the treatment was a last resort and conservative treatment had failed; the surgical treatment, whilst extensive, was appropriate and accepted medical procedures; claimant’s evidence that she had a positive outcome accepted and consideration given to the patient/doctor relationship which was unlike a pure medicolegal opinion; findings made that subsequent motor accident was a temporary exacerbation that resolved; assessment of impairment based on multilevel lumbar surgery assessed at 20% impairment as surgery found to be causatively related to the motor accident. 

STATEMENT OF REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE REVIEW PANEL IN RELATION TO A MEDICAL ASSESSMENT

Medical Assessment – Permanent Impairment

WHETHER THE DEGREE OF PERMANENT IMPAIRMENT OF THE INJURED PERSON AS A RESULT OF THE INJURY CAUSED BY THE MOTOR ACCIDENT IS GREATER THAN 10%

THE ASSESSMENT MADE BY THE REVIEW PANEL UNDER SECTION 63(4) IS AS FOLLOWS: 

The Panel revokes the certificate dated 1 July 2021 and issues a new certificate determining that the following injuries caused by the motor accident give rise to a whole person impairment which, in total, is GREATER THAN 10%:

·        Lumbar spine – soft tissue injury and aggravation of degenerative changes

·        Scarring as a result of lumbar spine surgery.

Medical Assessment – Treatment and Care

Review Panel Assessment of Treatment and Care and  

Replacement

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Insurance Australia Ltd t/as NRMA v Sear and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWPICMP 15
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Insurance Australia Ltd trading as NRMA versus Sear, the primary dispute before the Court was the assessment of medical treatment and permanent impairment following a motor accident. The Court of Appeal was required to determine the validity of surgical procedures performed on the claimant, the causation of those procedures by the motor accident, and the appropriate assessment of permanent impairment. The case involved a motor accident in 2013, with subsequent cervical and lumbar spine surgeries in 2016 and 2017 respectively. The insurer contested the reasonableness and necessity of the surgeries and their causal link to the accident, as well as the assessment of impairment.

The legal issues centred on whether the insurer's refusal to narrow the scope of disputes was consistent with the statutory framework for new assessments under the Motor Accident Claims Act. The court also had to assess the relevance and weight of expert evidence, particularly from a biomechanical engineer, in determining the causation and reasonableness of the surgeries. The court examined whether the delay in onset of symptoms negated the injury causation and if the surgical treatments were appropriate and necessary given the failure of conservative treatments. Finally, the court had to decide on the extent of permanent impairment based on the multilevel lumbar surgery.

The Court found that the motor accident did not cause injury to the cervical spine, but did materially contribute to the need for lumbar spine surgery. The court rejected the insurer's refusal to narrow the issues as inconsistent with the statutory requirement for a new assessment. Expert evidence from the biomechanical engineer was considered relevant but not determinative. The court found the surgical treatment to be reasonable and necessary, noting that the claimant's positive outcome and the nature of the patient/doctor relationship provided valuable insights. The court also concluded that the subsequent motor accident was a temporary exacerbation that resolved. Based on these findings, the impairment assessment was made at 20%, considering the lumbar surgery to be causatively related to the motor accident.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established