Instate Esidential Pty Ltd v Regency Pty Ltd & Manthorpe

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

INSTATE ESIDENTIAL PTY LTD v REGENCY PTY LTD & MANTHORPE

[2022] SADC 55

Judgment of her Honour Judge Deuter  

6 May 2022

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - DISCHARGE, BREACH AND DEFENCES TO ACTION FOR BREACH

GUARANTEE AND INDEMNITY - CONTRACT OF GUARANTEE - CONSTRUCTION AND EFFECT - EXTENT OF LIABILITY AND OTHER MATTERS

The Applicant became the South Australian Master Franchisee of the GJ Gardner Homes building franchises in South Australia by purchasing the business 23 February 2015.

At the time of purchasing the SA Master Franchise the First Respondent, Regency Pty Ltd was a relatively new GJ Gardner Homes franchisee pursuant to a franchise agreement entered into with the previous master franchisee on 22 September 2014 (the franchise agreement).  The Second Respondent was the sole shareholder and director of the First Respondent.  With his wife, the Second Respondent executed a Deed of Guarantee and Indemnity that jointly and severally guaranteed the liabilities of the First Respondent.  The deed was signed at the same time as the franchise agreement and was an annexure to it.

There was no Deed of Assignment or Novation of the franchise agreement signed by the Respondents upon the Applicant becoming the SA Master Franchisee.  The Respondents were aware that the SA Master Franchisee had been transferred to the Applicant, and thereafter worked with the Applicant to establish and operate its GJ Gardner Homes franchise in the southern areas of Adelaide.  The First Respondent initially met its obligations under the franchise agreement, including paying franchise fees relative to each building contract it entered into.

In April 2018 the Applicant became aware that the First Respondent was performing building and construction work outside of the franchise agreement and in breach of that agreement.  No franchise fees had been paid to the Applicant in relation to this building work.  At a meeting on 8 May 2018, the Applicant indicated that there was no alternative to the franchise being terminated, and made a without prejudice offer to the Respondents of mutual termination on terms.  The franchise agreement was terminated on 8 May 2018, the terms and affect of that termination are in dispute.

The Applicant claims payment by the respondents of all unpaid franchise fees on the building contracts entered into by the First Respondent in breach of the franchise agreement, in addition to termination and penalty fees, for the balance of the term of the franchise agreement.

The First Respondent went into liquidation on 18 February 2021, and as a result the Applicant seeks to recover the First Respondent's liability to them from the Second Respondent pursuant to the guarantee provided as part of the franchise agreement.

Issues:

Was the franchise agreement assigned or novated to the Applicant?

Did the Respondents breach the franchise agreement?

Is the First Respondent liable to the Applicant under the franchise agreement?

Is the Second Respondent personally liable on the guarantee for the amounts claimed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Instate Esidential Pty Ltd v Regency Pty Ltd & Manthorpe and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SADC 55
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Instate Esidential Pty Ltd v Regency Pty Ltd & Manthorpe, the primary concern was the liability of Regency Pty Ltd (the First Respondent) and its sole shareholder and director, the Second Respondent (Manthorpe), under a franchise agreement and a deed of guarantee and indemnity with respect to unpaid franchise fees and other costs following the transfer of the South Australian Master Franchisee of the GJ Gardner Homes building franchises. The dispute arose when the Applicant, Instate Esidential Pty Ltd, became the new South Australian Master Franchisee on 23 February 2015 and subsequently discovered that Regency Pty Ltd was performing building and construction work outside of the franchise agreement and in breach of it. The Applicant sought to recover the outstanding franchise fees and other charges from the Respondents.

The court was required to determine several key issues: whether the franchise agreement was assigned or novated to the Applicant upon the transfer of the franchise, whether the Respondents had breached the franchise agreement, whether the First Respondent was liable to the Applicant for the unpaid fees and other charges, and whether the Second Respondent was personally liable under the guarantee for the amounts claimed by the Applicant against the First Respondent. The court had to interpret the terms of the franchise agreement and the deed of guarantee and indemnity, and assess whether the mutual termination of the franchise agreement on 8 May 2018 was lawful and effective.

The court found that the franchise agreement was novated by implication to the Applicant on 23 February 2015, transferring all obligations and benefits of the agreement to the Applicant. The Respondents had breached the franchise agreement by performing building work outside of the agreement and failing to pay franchise fees in relation to these contracts. The franchise agreement was legally terminated on 8 May 2018, either by mutual agreement or due to the Applicant's reasonable grounds to terminate without notice. The First Respondent was liable for the unpaid franchise fees and other charges, and the Second Respondent was liable for these amounts under the terms of the deed of guarantee and indemnity. The deed of guarantee and indemnity was also novated to the Applicant, continuing to bind the Second Respondent.

In conclusion, the court entered judgment in favour of the Applicant against the Second Respondent in the amount of $252,487.43. The court further directed that the parties be heard on the question of interest and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held:

1. The franchise agreement was novated by implication to the Applicant from 23 February 2015. From that date the obligations and benefits of the franchise agreement passed to the Applicant.

2. The Respondents breached the franchise agreement by entering into, and performing building contracts outside of the franchise agreement and in competition with GJ Gardner Homes. The First Respondent breached the franchise agreement by not paying franchise fees in relation to these building contracts.

3. The franchise agreement was legally terminated on 8 May 2018. This was a mutual termination agreed by the Second Respondent on behalf of the First Respondent.

4. Alternatively the Applicant had good reason to terminate the franchise agreement without notice as a result of the Respondents acting fraudulently in connection with the operation of the GJ Gardner Homes franchise.

5. The First Respondent failed to meet the terms of the agreed mutual termination, and failed to pay any franchise fees in relation to its breaches of the franchise agreement.

6. The First Respondent was indebted to the Applicant under the franchise agreement in the amount claimed of $252,487.43.

7. On the express terms of the Deed of Guarantee the Second Respondent is liable for the amounts claimed by the Applicant.

8. The Deed of Guarantee was assigned to the Applicant as part of the totality of the business transaction whereby the Applicant became the SA Master Franchisee. The Deed of Guarantee continues to bind the Second Respondent.

9. Judgment for the Applicant against the Second Respondent in the sum of $252,487.43.

10. The parties are to be heard on the question of interest and costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.