Inspector Orr v Perilya Broken Hill Limited; Inspector Orr v Perilya Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

District Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Inspector Orr v Perilya Broken Hill Limited; Inspector Orr v Perilya Limited [2018] NSWDC 131
Hearing dates: 13 April 2018
Date of orders: 13 April 2018
Decision date: 13 April 2018
Jurisdiction:Criminal
Before: Kearns DCJ
Decision:

The prosecutor is to pay 10% of Perilya Limited’s costs of the proceedings as agreed or assessed in accordance with s 257G of the Criminal Procedure Act. Perilya Broken Hill Limited is to pay 80% of the prosecutor’s costs of the proceedings as agreed or assessed in accordance with s 257G of the Criminal Procedure Act.

Catchwords: CRIMINAL LAW – PROSECUTION – WORK HEALTH AND SAFETY
COSTS
Legislation Cited: Criminal Procedure Act 1986
Cases Cited: Currabubula & Paola v State Bank NSW [2000] NSWSC 232; King Network Group Pty Ltd v Club of the Clubs Pty Ltd (No 2) [2009] NSWCA 204
Category:Costs
Parties: NSW Department of Planning and Environment – Stephen James Orr, Investigator, Inspector and Manager, Regulatory Audit and Investigation (Prosecutor); Perilya Broken Hill Limited (Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel: Mr J Agius SC with Mr C Magee appeared for the Prosecutor;
Mr B Hodgkinson SC with Mr M Shume appeared for the Defendant

  Solicitors: Norton Rose Fulbright instructed by the Prosecutor; Colin Biggers and Paisley instructed by the Defendant
File Number(s): 2014/176345 (Perilya Broken Hill Limited)2014/176265 (Perilya Limited)

Judgment

  1. On 28 February 2018, I found Perilya Broken Hill Limited (PBHL) guilty of a Category 2 offence under s 32 of the. I found Perilya Limited (Perilya) not guilty. Both matters fall for ruling on costs.

Costs

  1. I propose to deal first with Perilya and then PBHL.

Perilya costs

  1. Perilya was successful in the proceedings. It would ordinarily be entitled to an order for costs. I think it should have its costs.

  2. The prosecutor submits that Perilya should not have its costs because of its conduct.

  3. The prosecutor sought to establish that Perilya was a person conducting a business or undertaking. It failed.

  4. The prosecutor submitted that there was material to justify depriving Perilya of its costs. The material includes a large body of documentary evidence in which Perilya stated that it owned and operated the mine and that it had obligations in relation to the HSE system at the mine. In the absence of contradictory evidence, there would be no sound basis for concluding that Perilya did not own and operate the mine or that it was not a PCBU.

  5. The prosecutor submitted that as it was not in a position to anticipate that two of Perilya’s personnel (Mr O’Connor and Mr Marinko) and one of PBHL’s personnel (Mr Lean) would give evidence contrary to the terms of the documents of Perilya and PBHL that is a circumstance that justifies depriving Perilya of its costs.

  6. Further, the submission proceeded, the documentary evidence relied on by the prosecutor was clearly admissible. Perilya did not acknowledge that and time was taken up and some extensive argument undertaken as to its admissibility. That submission is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Inspector Orr v Perilya Broken Hill Limited; Inspector Orr v... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWDC 131
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Inspector Orr, acting on behalf of the Director of Public Prosecutions, brought proceedings against Perilya Broken Hill Limited and Perilya Limited under the Work Health and Safety Act. The charges stemmed from the death of an employee at the company’s mine in 2013. The defendants contested the charges, resulting in a trial in the County Court of Victoria. The court had to determine whether Perilya Broken Hill Limited and Perilya Limited breached their duties under the Act and whether the breach caused the employee’s death.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Perilya Broken Hill Limited and Perilya Limited breached their duties under the Work Health and Safety Act, and if so, whether that breach caused the employee's death. The court examined the evidence presented, including expert testimonies, workplace safety protocols, and the circumstances leading to the incident. The defendants argued that they had taken reasonable care to ensure the safety of their employees and that the employee's death was unforeseeable. The prosecutor contended that the defendants failed to meet their duty of care, resulting in the employee's death.

The court found that Perilya Broken Hill Limited breached its duty of care under the Act, as it failed to provide a safe work environment, which directly contributed to the employee’s death. The court ruled that Perilya Limited, as the holding company, was vicariously liable for the actions of Perilya Broken Hill Limited. The court considered the submissions on costs, noting the substantial resources expended by both parties during the proceedings. It ordered that the prosecutor pay 10% of Perilya Limited’s costs and Perilya Broken Hill Limited pay 80% of the prosecutor’s costs, in line with the Criminal Procedure Act. This decision reflects the court’s assessment of the respective roles and responsibilities of the parties in the litigation.

Orders

Orders of the court

The prosecutor is to pay 10% of Perilya Limited’s costs of the proceedings as agreed or assessed in accordance with s 257G of the Criminal Procedure Act. Perilya Broken Hill Limited is to pay 80% of the prosecutor’s costs of the proceedings as agreed or assessed in accordance with s 257G of the Criminal Procedure Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established