iNova Pharmaceuticals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Vrkic

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

iNova Pharmaceuticals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Vrkic [2024] FedCFamC2G 721  

File number(s): SYG 2102 of 2023
SYG 3343 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE MANOUSARIDIS
Date of judgment: 9 August 2024  
Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY – where freezing and ancillary disclosure orders are made in favour of judgment creditors against judgment debtor in relation to the proceeds of sale of a property owned by judgment debtor – where before freezing orders are made judgment debtor transferred proceeds of sale to C and directed C to transfer money to JK and LY – where judgment debtor presented debtor’s petition after directing C to receive and transfer money to JK and LY – where before judgment debtor presents debtor’s petition to Official Receiver judgment debtor arranged XL and JL to transfer $30,000 (DVDO Client Trust Fund) to the firm of which the prospective trustee in bankruptcy is a principal – where debtor’s petition is accepted by the Official Receiver – where trustee recovers from JK and LY funds (Fund) that C at the direction of the judgment debtor had paid to JK and LY – whether at the time the debtor presented the debtor’s petition or the time at which the Official Receiver accepted the debtor’s petition the debtor did not satisfy the requirements of s 55(2A) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (Bankruptcy Act) and, for that reason, the debtor’s petition ought not to have been accepted by the Official Receiver – requirements not satisfied and order annulling bankruptcy made under s 153B(1) of the Bankruptcy Act – whether the judgment creditors are entitled to an order under s 154(3) of the Bankruptcy Act that the Fund be paid to them – not entitled because as judgment creditors they have no property interest in the Fund – whether judgment creditors could otherwise secure payment to them of the Fund – held judgment creditors could do so on the basis that on the making of an order annulling the bankruptcy the trustee would hold the Fund as trustee for the judgment debtor and it was open to the judgment creditors to apply for a charging order in relation to the Fund – orders made to give effect to that holding – whether judgment creditors had any similar claim to the DVDO Client Trust Fund – orders made granting judgment creditors liberty to apply to make such claim after giving notice to judgment debtor and to XL and JL – whether the trustee in bankruptcy engaged in any conduct which merited an order under s 90-15(3)(f) of Schedule 2 to the Bankruptcy Act denying him his remuneration and right to reimbursement – trustee engaged in such conduct, namely, being aware that his employee advised and assisted the judgment debtor to prepare and present the debtor’s petition but failing to exercise reasonable care to ensure that the judgment debtor’s circumstances met the requirements provided for by s 55(2A) of the Bankruptcy Act…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read iNova Pharmaceuticals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Vrkic and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 721
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of iNova Pharmaceuticals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Vrkic concerns the annulment of the bankruptcy of Liyan Liang and the distribution of funds from the sale of a property owned by Ms Liang. The dispute involved iNova, the judgment creditor, and Ms Liang, the judgment debtor, with the trustee in bankruptcy, Mr Vrkic, also being a party. The case was heard in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. The central legal issues were whether Ms Liang's bankruptcy should be annulled due to non-compliance with statutory requirements and whether the judgment creditors were entitled to the funds transferred by Ms Liang prior to her bankruptcy.

The court found that Ms Liang did not meet the statutory requirements for presenting a debtor's petition, as she had not satisfied the conditions set out in section 55(2A) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). Therefore, the court annulled Ms Liang's bankruptcy. Regarding the funds transferred by Ms Liang, the court held that as judgment creditors, iNova did not have a property interest in the funds transferred to Jianhua Kuai and Ye Liu, and thus could not claim them directly. However, the court allowed iNova to apply for a charging order on the funds held by the trustee, enabling them to secure payment.

The court also considered whether the trustee's conduct warranted a denial of his remuneration and right to reimbursement. The court found that Mr Vrkic had failed to exercise reasonable care in ensuring Ms Liang's compliance with the statutory requirements, which rendered his work as trustee ineffective and prejudicial to the judgment creditors. Consequently, the court ordered that Mr Vrkic's remuneration and right to reimbursement be denied.

The final orders included the annulment of Ms Liang's bankruptcy, permission for iNova to apply for a charging order on the funds held by the trustee, and the denial of Mr Vrkic's remuneration and right to reimbursement.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

To be in a position to determine iNova’s claims, it will be necessary to describe the course of the Substantive Proceeding from 8 December 2023, the circumstances in which Ms Liang became a bankrupt, and the communications between iNova’s lawyers and Mr Vrkic’s lawyer.BACKGROUNDCourse of Substantive Proceeding up to 15 December 2023 On 8 December 2023, on the application of iNova, I made ex parte freezing and ancillary disclosure orders against Ms Liang, lawyers, and a real estate agent. The freezing orders were expressed to continue until 11:59 pm on 12 December 2023. I made the orders on the basis of evidence that showed that Ms Liang had sold the Property, and that the lawyers and a real estate agent were involved in the sale of the Property; and I ordered that Ms Liang and the other persons provide information about the sale of the Property and, in particular, about the Proceeds of Sale. I also ordered that the matter be listed at 2:15 pm on 12 December 2023 for the purpose (among other things) of hearing an application to extend the freezing order. Ms Liang and the other persons were required to comply with the disclosure orders by 5 pm on 11 December 2023. When the matter came before me on 12 December 2023, I made a further orders, including an order that the freezing order I made on 8 December 2023 against Ms Liang be extended up to and including 11:59 pm on Friday 15 December 2023. I also ordered, with the consent of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA), that CBA provide to iNova’s solicitors information in relation to a particular account number and accounts held by Ms Liang or Letos Group, and by 5 pm on 20 December 2023, after iNova identified to CBA particular transactions, that CBA produce details of those transactions. On 13 December 2023 Ms Liang sent to iNova’s lawyer an email to which she attached a document she described as “ORDER REPLY”, and a number of “other/supporting documents”.[3] Among those documents was a letter in which Ms Liang stated, among other things, that she could not access her bank account with CBA because CBA informed her that it “cannot identify my identification”.[4] Ms Liang also produced a text message from Mr Leon Wang, Ms Liang’s solicitor, which stated that “Balance amounts $104,181.87 has been transferred to your account”.[5] [3] Affidavit M J Williams 05.02.2024, [20]; Exhibit MJW-1, pages 330-343[4] Affidavit M J Williams 05.02.2024, [20]; Exhibit MJW-1, page 333[5] Affidavit M J Williams 05.02.2024, [20]; Exhibit MJW-1, page 339 Documents produced by CBA in response to the orders I made on 12 December 2023 revealed that Ms Liang holds an account with CBA (Liang CBA Account) and that, on 29 November 2023, Endeavour Partner Pty Ltd (being the owner of Endeavour Realty, Ms Liang’s real estate agent) transferred $104,181.87 into the Liang CBA Account; and from 30 November to 5 December 2023, eight amounts totalling $107,415.68 were transferred from the Liang CBA Account to a person named “Bin Chen” (later identified as Ms Bin Chen).[6] On the basis of those documents, on 15 December 2023 iNova applied for, and were granted, freezing and disclosure orders against Ms Bin Chen.[7] The freezing order against Ms Chen was expressed to have effect up to 11:59 pm on 19 December 2023; and I ordered that the matter be listed at 10:00 am on 19 December 2023 for the purpose of hearing an application to extend the freezing order against Ms Chen.[6] Affidavit M J Williams 05.02.2024, [22]; Exhibit MJW-1, page 353[7] Affidavit M J Williams 05.02.2024, [23]Ms Liang’s bankruptcy

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In any event, even if I were satisfied that Ms Liang was insolvent, that consideration would not lead me to exercise the discretion against making an order annulling Ms Liang’s bankruptcy. First, as I have already noted, s 153B(2) of the Bankruptcy Act provides that, in the case of a debtor’s petition, an order annulling the bankruptcy may be made whether or not the bankrupt was insolvent when the petition was presented. Second, and as I have already noted, s 55(2A) of the Bankruptcy Act sets out a mandatory condition precedent to an Official Receiver’s accepting a debtor’s petition. In the absence of any other relevant matter such as delay, the non-satisfaction of the condition precedent mandated by s 55(2A) strongly weighs in favour of my making an order under s 153B(1) annulling Ms Liang’s bankruptcy.Conclusion I conclude that it is appropriate that I make an order under s 153B(1) of the Bankruptcy Act that Ms Liang’s becoming a bankrupt by virtue of the presentation on 12 December 2023 by her of a debtor’s petition be annulled.APPLICATION FOR ORDER UNDER S 154(3) In their written submissions iNova assume that iNova, “as a creditor in the position of [iNova]”,[56] have an interest in the Fund (being the amounts totalling $96,315.68 Jianhua Kuai and Ye Liu paid to Mr Vrkic, together with interest). iNova do not, however, articulate the nature of the interest they claim they have in the Fund.[56] Applicants’ Submissions in Support of Application of Invalidating the Bankruptcy of Liyan Liang and Other Orders (Applicants’ Submissions), [19] iNova are judgment creditors of Ms Liang. They applied for, and were granted, freezing orders and ancillary disclosure orders. iNova could only have obtained, and I could only have granted, such orders for the purpose for which freezing and ancillary disclosure orders may be granted; and the purpose for which freezing orders may be granted has been explained in many cases. In his dissenting speech in Mercedes Benz A.G. v Leiduk, Lord Nichols gave a particularly clear statement of the purpose for which freezing orders (previously known as “Mareva injunctions”) may be granted (emphasis added):[57]Ordinarily a plaintiff seeks a Mareva injunction in the same proceedings as those in which he is seeking his judgment. This should not be permitted to obscure the fact that Mareva relief differs from other interim relief in an important respect. Like other injunctions, a Mareva injunction operates in personam. It does not create a proprietary interest in the affected property, even where it relates to a specifically identified asset. And like other interim relief, a Mareva injunction is concerned to provide protection pending a future stage in the judicial process. . . . An unsecured creditor, or a claimant for damages, has no legal or equitable interest in any of the assets of the defendant, nor will the judgment itself give him such an interest. The judgment will comprise an order of the court that the defendant pay the plaintiff an amount of money. . . . . Mareva relief is . . . granted to facilitate the process of execution or enforcement which will arise when, but only when, the judgment for payment of an amount of money has been obtained. The court is looking ahead to that stage, and taking steps designed to ensure that the defendant cannot defeat the purpose of the judgment by thwarting in advance the efficacy of the process by which the court will enforce compliance. He is not to be permitted to steal a march on the court's own enforcement process. If a prospective judgment debtor can look and plan ahead, so can the court. He is not at liberty deliberately to take steps to prevent enforcement. This is so, irrespective of the nature of the underlying cause of action. Mareva relief is granted in aid of the underlying cause of action only in the sense that the whole enforcement process can be said to be in aid of that cause of action. [57] Mercedes Benz A.G. v Leiduck [1996] AC 284, at pages 306

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 27 December 2023 I made a number of further orders, including an order extending the freezing and ancillary orders I made on 22 December 2023 to 11:59 pm on 10 January 2024, and listed the matter at 10:15 am on 10 January 2024.Mr Vrkic’s administration of the bankrupt estate On 20 December 2023 Mr Vrkic sent an email to Jianhua Kuai in which Mr Vrkic stated as follows:I advise that I was appointed Trustee of the abovenamed Bankrupt estate on 14 December 2023 . . . The Bankrupt advised that three payments were made to your bank accounts recently of $1,417.30, 4,260 [sic] and $29,650 prior to my appointment.I now request that you repay the sum of $35,327.30 pursuant to section 122 of [the] Bankruptcy Act 1966, to the bank account detailed below . . . At 4:25 pm on 27 December 2023 Jianhua Kuai sent an email to Ms Cottier (one of iNova’s lawyers) which included the following:[35]On December 20 I received an email from Kelly Qiu asking me to return the three sums of money transferred to me by Ms. Liang to the Trustee Account, which are $1,417.30, $4,260.00 and $29,650.00.I have transferred $29,650.00 to the Trustee Account . . . on 20th December and $1,417.30 and $4,260.00 to the Trustee Account . . . on 21st December. I also sent the transfer records to kellyqiu@dvrmsydney.com.au[35] Affidavit M J Williams 05.02.2024, [41]; Exhibit MJW-1, page 500 On 11 January 2024 Mr Vrkic issued a report to creditors (Report to Creditors).[36] [36] Affidavit M J Williams 05.02.2024, [44]; Exhibit MJW-1, pages 513-549(a)Under the heading “History and Background Information” the Report to Creditors stated that Ms Liang is an Australian citizen; she holds an Australian passport that expires “in 2033” (sic); she holds a current Medicare card in her name; and she has a temporary Chinese visa issued by the Chinese Government for two years expiring on 29 June 2025. Further, Ms Liang “advised that she needed to go back to China as her father had passed away and her mother was unwell and needed her assistance to help her with her medical issues”. (b)The Report to Creditors stated that “[s]ince the commencement of the Bankruptcy, I have received a written request for permission to remain in China”. That is a reference to a document headed “Request for Consent to Travel Overseas while Bankrupt”.[37] The document appears to be signed by Ms Liang, and is dated 18 December 2023. The document gives an address in Fuxhou, China, as Mr Liang’s residential address, and identifies “07/07/2023” as the “Proposed Travel Date”. Further, in the box where Ms Liang is required to provide details concerning “Proposed Return Date”, the document contains the following:[37] Exhibit BTo Be DeterminedI had surgery to remove tumour in October last year. I will have another one schedule for late December early January, depending on the results of the physical check. Besides, I also have to take care of my 4-year son who lives in China because he has bronchitis.My father died in a car accident a few years ago and the driver choose [sic] to flee. My mom has yet to accept reality, so I was unable to leave her alone in china [sic] and I believe that they need my help at this time.(c)The Report to Creditors identified six creditors, one of which was iNova; and each of the other creditors is described as a “family/friend”, and the debt that is owed to each is described as “money owned”(sic). Ms Chen is among the friends the Report to Creditors lists, and Ms Liang is said to owe her $350,000.(d)Under the heading “Transferred Assets”, the Report to Creditors notes that Ms Liang “made the following loan repayments to her friend, Ms. Bin Chen”. The Report to Creditors lists six payments from 30 November 2023 to 5 December 2023 totalling $106,315.68. The Report to Creditors states Mr Vrkic had written to Ms Chen seeking the repayment of these funds; and that he had “also written to other parties seeking repayment of the funds received” and Mr Vrkic had “recovered $96,315.68 to date”.(e)Under the heading “Income Contributions” the Report to Creditors states that Ms Liang “currently is in China on a 2-year family visit visa caring for her seriously ill mother”.