iNova Pharmaceuticals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Letos Group Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

iNova Pharmaceuticals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Letos Group Pty Ltd (No 4) [2024] FedCFamC2G 1307  

File number(s): SYG 3343 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE MANOUSARIDIS
Date of judgment: 29 November 2024
Catchwords: INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY - Costs – applications by applicants and by non-parties for costs in relation to applications the applicants made for freezing and ancillary disclosure orders.    
Legislation:

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) s 214

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 7.38(1)

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 rr 1.06(2), 22.02(2)(a), 22.09

Cases cited:

Bell Lawyers Pty Ltd v Pentelow (2019) 269 CLR 333

Buckland v Watts [1970] 1 Q.B. 27

CIQ17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (No 2) [2020] FCCA 3467

Elders Trustee and Executor Company Ltd; Estate of Howard v Estate of Herbert (1996) 132 FLR 24

France v Siekaup (No 4) [2021] NSWSC 963

iNova Pharmaceuticals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Letos Group Pty Ltd (No 3) [2023] FedCFamC2G 801

iNova Pharmaceuticals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Vrkic [2024] FedCFamC2G 721

Kazar (Liquidator) v Kargarian; In the Matter of Frontier Architects Pty Ltd (In Liq) [2011] FCAFC 136

Project Development Co. Ltd S.A. v K.M.K. Securities Ltd [[1983] 1 All ER 465

Project Development Co. Ltd S.A. v K.M.K. Securities Ltd [1982] 1 WLR 1470

Sebastian v Strongwall International Ltd (Deregistered) (No 2) [2011] FCA 1105

With v O’Flanagan [193] Ch.575

Division: General
Number of paragraphs: 84
Date of last submission/s: 27 November 2024
Date of hearing: 20 November 2024
Place: Sydney
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr C McMeniman
Solicitor for the Applicants: Gilbert + Tobin
Counsel for the First Interested Person: Mr N Kabilafkas
Solicitor for the First Interested Person: GWH & Associates
Counsel for the Fourth Interested Person: Mr D H Southwood
Solicitor for the Fourth Interested Person: AHD Lawyers

ORDERS

SYG 3343 of 2019

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

INOVA PHARMACEUTICALS (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD ACN 617 871 539
First Applicant

INOVA PHARMACEUTICALS (SINGAPORE) PTE. LIMITED UEN 200617543H
Second Applicant

AND:

LETOS GROUP PTY LTD ACN 623 106 561

Fourth Respondent

LIYAN LIANG

Fifth Respondent

GWH & ASSOCIATES
First Interested Person


MARTIN KACHUN TSE
Fourth Interested Person and other Interested Persons and Respondents named in the Schedule

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE MANOUSARIDIS

DATE OF ORDER:

29 NOVEMBER 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The fifth respondent pay the applicants’ costs of and incidental to the applications for freezing and ancillary disclosure orders the applicants made on 8, 15, and 22 December 2023.

2.Mr Martin Tse and GWH & Associates (GWH) pay the applicants’ costs of including Mr Martin Tse and GWH as respondents to the application the applicants made on 8 December 2023 for freezing and ancillary disclosure orders, such costs to be set in the amount of $3,000.

3.The applications Mr Martin Tse and GWH made that the applicants pay…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read iNova Pharmaceuticals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Letos Group Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 1307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves iNova Pharmaceuticals (Australia) Pty Ltd, a pharmaceutical company, and Letos Group Pty Ltd, another company, with the proceedings pertaining to intellectual property disputes. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate orders for costs in relation to applications made by iNova for freezing and ancillary disclosure orders. The legal issues included whether iNova was entitled to costs for the applications made for freezing and ancillary disclosure orders and whether any non-parties were entitled to costs for their involvement in the proceedings. The court had to assess the necessity and proportionality of the applications and the conduct of all parties involved.

The court considered the circumstances leading to iNova's applications for freezing and ancillary disclosure orders, including the timing and content of communications between the parties. It examined the reasons behind the applications, the conduct of the parties in responding to these applications, and the relevance and proportionality of the orders sought. The court also took into account the settlement offer made by Ms Liang, which was influenced by the pending enforcement actions. Ultimately, the court determined that iNova was not entitled to costs for the freezing and ancillary disclosure applications, as they were not necessary or proportionate. The court found that the applications were made in response to suspicious activities and were part of iNova's efforts to enforce its judgment. The court further held that the non-parties were not entitled to costs for their involvement in the proceedings.

The court made orders that iNova and Letos Group pay their own costs of the applications for freezing and ancillary disclosure orders, and that non-parties were not to be awarded costs. The court emphasized the importance of ensuring that any costs orders made were just and equitable, considering the overall conduct of the parties and the nature of the applications made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In these reasons for judgment I consider what order as to costs, if any, I should make. To be in a position to determine the claims for costs, it will be necessary to set out in some detail the events that led to iNova deciding to apply for freezing and ancillary disclosure orders on 8 December 2023.BACKGROUND On 16 December 2022 I granted summary judgment on causes of action iNova advanced against Letos Group and Ms Liang, and default judgment on causes of action iNova advanced against other respondents. I also ordered that the proceeding be listed at 9.30 am on 23 February 2023 to hear submissions on damages and costs. The hearing date on damages and costs was later changed to 1 March 2023. At the hearing on that date, iNova adduced evidence and heard submissions on damages and costs. On 1 September 2023 I delivered reasons for judgment on the basis of which I made orders, including orders that Letos Group and Ms Liang pay amounts for compensation, interest, and costs totalling $274,953.89.[2][2] iNova Pharmaceuticals (Australia) Pty Ltd v Letos Group Pty Ltd (No 3) [2023] FedCFamC2G 801 In the meantime, at around 4.15 pm on 26 June 2023, Mr Williams, the solicitor for iNova, became aware that a property of which Ms Liang was the registered proprietor (Waitara Property) had been listed for sale. Mr Williams immediately instructed Ms Smith, a lawyer acting under Mr Williams’ supervision, to telephone Mr Leon Wang of “Endeavour Realty”, being the real estate agent acting on the sale of the Waitara Property. “Endeavour Realty” is a business name owned by DPJ. Mr Wang informed Ms Smith that Ms Liang had instructed him on the sale of the Waitara Property. Ms Smith informed Mr Wang that iNova was anticipating a judgment from this Court against Ms Liang and, in all of the circumstances, iNova required Mr Wang provide an undertaking that the Waitara Property will not be sold without arrangements being made to account to iNova.[3] Mr Wang texted to Ms Smith his email address, and the email address of “Icy Fan Conveyancing” (IFC), being the trading name of Ms Jinhgua Fan.[4][3] Affidavit M J Williams 08.12.2023, [20][4] Affidavit M J Williams 08.12.2023, [21]; exhibit MJW-15, pages 43-45 At 10:44 am on 27 June 2023, Ms Smith sent an email to Mr Wang and to Ms Fan attaching a letter addressed to them.[5] The letter provided background to the claims iNova made in this proceeding against Ms Liang, noting that judgment on the question of damages and costs had been reserved. Ms Smith stated that the timing of the sale of the Waitara Property was highly suspicious, and that the “inescapable inference is that the sale of the Property was intended to defeat iNova’s monetary recovery”. Ms Smith made the following demand:In the circumstances, we are instructed to require Mr Wang as the real estate agent for the property (on his own behalf and on behalf of his agency, Endeavour Realty) and Jinghua Fan t/as Icy Fan Conveyancing as the lawyers acting for Ms Liang on the sale of the Property, to undertake to iNova that the Property will not be sold without iNova’s consent.This undertaking is required by 5pm today, Tuesday 27 June 2023.[5] Affidavit M J Williams 08.12.2023, [22]; exhibit MJW-15, page 46

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 8 September 2023, after I delivered my reasons for judgment on the basis of which I ordered that Ms Liang and Letos Group pay compensation, interest, and costs totalling $274,953.89 (Judgment), Mr Tse sent an email to Ms Smith.[15] Mr Tse said he was instructed that, in full settlement of iNova’s claims against her, Ms Liang offered to enable iNova or their nominees to sell the Waitara Property, and for iNova to keep the net proceeds of sale, which Ms Liang estimated would be $100,000. Mr Tse further stated that even if iNova did not accept the offer, Ms Liang would be “happy to assist your clients in selling the property and using the sales proceeds to pay down the judgment, including seriously considering and obtaining advice about any consent for grant and registration of any writ”. [15] Affidavit M J Williams 08.12.2023, [36]; exhibit MJW-15, page 230 By email sent to Mr Tse at 10:39 am on 11 October 2023, Ms Smith attached the terms on which iNova were prepared not to take further enforcement action against Ms Liang. iNova proposed that Ms Liang agree that she sell the Waitara Property on the basis of market appraisals by two real estate agents, and that Ms Liang agree that, on completion of the sale of the Waitara Property, the proceeds of sale be used to pay down the Judgment. According to a signed but unsworn form of affidavit made by Ms Fan (JF statement) (the conveyancer acting for Ms Liang), on 14 October 2023 IFC received an email from the sales agent, Endeavour Realty, advising that contracts for sale of the Waitara Property had been exchanged, and attaching the contract for sale.[16][16] Exhibit MJW-17, page 2111 On 18 October 2023 Mr Tse responded to Ms Smith’s email of 11 October 2023. Mr Tse said the selling agent informed Mr Tse “yesterday” that Ms Liang received an offer to purchase the Waitara Property for $630,000; and Mr Tse attached a sales advice issued by “Endeavour Realty”.[17] Mr Tse said he was instructed to making a counter offer that iNova agree to the sale of the Waitara Property for $630,000, and that, in full settlement of all their claims against Ms Liang and Letos Group, Ms Liang will agree “to direct all the sales proceeds of the Waitara Property to be paid to iNova after deduction of all necessary costs incurred in [the] course of sale”. Mr Tse said the offer was open for acceptance for 14 days expiring on 1 November 2023.[17] Affidavit M J Williams 08.12.2023, [41]; exhibit MJW-15, page 241 At 5.34 pm on 18 October 2023 Ms Smith sent an email to Mr Tse in which she asked Mr Tse to confirm that no contracts have been exchanged on the Waitara Property.[18] Ms Smith then noted that no market appraisal had been provided, and iNova held serious concerns that $630,000 was substantially below its market value. Mr Tse did not immediately respond to Ms Smith’s request that Mr Tse confirm that no contracts for sale of the Waitara Property had been entered into. The inference is available to be drawn that, in response to Ms Smith’s email, Mr Tse made enquiries about whether contracts had been entered into in relation to the Waitara Property, and, on making those enquiries, Mr Tse became aware that contracts had in fact been exchanged. That inference is based on two things. The first is the JF statement, in which it is stated that on 19 October 2023 Mr Tse sent to IFC an email advising that the sale could not proceed without GWH’s consent, and that “[n]egotiation for the settlement of this legal proceeding were [sic] conducted”.[19] The second is that Mr Tse drafted a mutual deed of rescission in relation to the contract that had been made,[20] and the deed of rescission was signed on 25 October 2023.[21][18] Affidavit M J Williams 08.12.2023, [41]; exhibit MJW-15, page 247[19] MJW-17, page 2111[20] MJW-17, page 1666[21] MJW-17, page 778

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established