Independent Portable Buildings Pty Ltd v Modular Building Systems Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Independent Portable Buildings Pty Limited v Modular Building Systems Pty Limited [2011] FCA 511

Citation: Independent Portable Buildings Pty Limited v Modular Building Systems Pty Limited [2011] FCA 511
Parties: INDEPENDENT PORTABLE BUILDINGS PTY LIMITED v MODULAR BUILDING SYSTEMS PTY LIMITED
File number: NSD 70 of 2011
Judge: ROBERTSON J
Date of judgment: 19 May 2011
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – set aside statutory demand – genuine dispute about the existence of a debt – defect in demand – Corporations Act ss 456G, 456H, 459J
Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 459G, 459H, 459J
Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 r 2.2(3)
Cases cited: Baa Baa Black Cow Pty Limited v CAFGA Livestock Pty Limited [2010] FCA 1191
Construction Management Services Pty Ltd v Bidnia Group Pty Ltd [2008] NSWSC 1152
Edge Technology Pty Ltd v Lite-On Technology Corporation (2000) 156 FLR 181
Graywinter Properties Pty Ltd v Gas & Fuel Corporation Superannuation Fund (1996) 70 FCR 452
John Holland Construction and Engineering Pty Ltd v Kilpatrick Green Pty Ltd (1994) 14 ACSR 250
LSI Australia Pty Ltd v LSI Holdings Ltd (2007) 25 ACLC 1,602; [2007] NSWSC 1406
Macleay Nominees Pty Ltd v Belle Property East Pty Ltd [2001] NSWSC 743
Solarite v York [2002] NSWSC 411
Spencer Constructions Pty Ltd v G & M Aldridge Pty Ltd (1997) 76 FCR 452
Date of hearing: 11 May 2011
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 113
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr A Harding
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Priority Business Lawyers
Counsel for the Defendant: Mr A Spencer
Solicitor for the Defendant: Gillis Delaney Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 70 of 2011

BETWEEN:

INDEPENDENT PORTABLE BUILDINGS PTY LIMITED
Plaintiff

AND:

MODULAR BUILDING SYSTEMS PTY LIMITED
Defendant

JUDGE:

ROBERTSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

19 MAY 2011

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The defendant’s demand dated 22 December 2010 and served on the plaintiff on 11 January 2011 is set aside.  

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 70 of 2011

BETWEEN:

INDEPENDENT PORTABLE BUILDINGS PTY LIMITED
Plaintiff

AND:

MODULAR BUILDING SYSTEMS PTY LIMITED
Defendant

JUDGE:

ROBERTSON J

DATE:

19 MAY 2011

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. Independent Portable Buildings Pty Limited (“IPB”) applies to the Court for an order setting aside the statutory demand served on it by Modular Building Systems Pty Limited (“MBS”). The demand was made under s 459E of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“the Act”). The application by IPB is made under s 459G(1) of the Act.

  2. IPB is a builder and supplier of portable buildings to the mining and construction sectors.  IPB contracted with a mine operator, “Gujarat NRE”, for the supply and installation of a washroom for a colliery at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Independent Portable Buildings Pty Ltd v Modular Building Sy... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 511
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Independent Portable Buildings Pty Ltd (IPB) brought an application to set aside a statutory demand issued by Modular Building Systems Pty Ltd (MBS). The application was heard and determined by Justice Gilmour of the Federal Court of Australia. The statutory demand required IPB to pay MBS the amount of $178,790.26, citing two tax invoices as the basis for the debt. IPB contended that there was a genuine dispute regarding the debt due to defects in the work performed by MBS, which IPB argued entitled it to offset the amount owed against the costs of rectifying those defects.

The central legal issue was whether IPB had a genuine dispute about the existence or amount of the debt claimed by MBS, which would entitle IPB to seek to set aside the statutory demand under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). In particular, IPB argued that the defects identified in the work performed by MBS constituted a breach of contract that justified a reduction in the amount owed. The court needed to determine if the defects alleged by IPB were sufficient to establish a genuine dispute.

Justice Gilmour found that IPB had established a genuine dispute regarding the amount of the debt claimed by MBS. The court accepted IPB's evidence that MBS had not performed the work in accordance with the contract specifications, resulting in defects that IPB was entitled to have rectified at MBS's expense. Given that the defects were material and remained unresolved, the court concluded that IPB had demonstrated a genuine dispute about the debt. Consequently, the statutory demand was set aside.

As a result, the court ordered that the statutory demand issued by MBS on 22 December 2010 and served on IPB on 11 January 2011 be set aside. This determination allowed IPB to avoid the immediate payment of the amount claimed by MBS and to pursue its claim for rectification of the defects and offsetting the costs against the debt.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The defendant’s demand dated 22 December 2010 and served on the plaintiff on 11 January 2011 is set aside.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

No evidence was called by MBS.The facts The statutory demand states, in effect, that IPB owes MBS the amount of $178,790.26, being the amount of the debt described in the Schedule. The Schedule refers to two tax invoices: No 100478 dated 9 August 2010 in the amount of $577,450.50 and No 100499 dated 31 August 2010 in the amount of $63,300.16. The Schedule also refers to payments received in the sum of $461,960.40 and states a total balance outstanding as $178,790.26. The same tax invoices and amounts are referred to in the affidavit accompanying the statutory demand, sworn by Mr Glenn Smith on 22 December 2010. In that affidavit Mr Smith states that the debt is due because IPB has failed to pay outstanding moneys due under the two tax invoices. Mr Smith states that he believes that there is no genuine dispute about the existence or the amount of the debt. Mr Nalder, in his affidavit, refers to MBS’ demand as a “purported Creditor’s Statutory Demand”. He states that there is a genuine dispute as to the debt claimed in the demand. As I read his affidavit he then goes on to identify the basis for that contention. At paragraph 13 of his affidavit, Mr Nalder states that IPB:contends, and it is the fact, that MBS failed to undertake the Works in accordance with the terms of the Contract and otherwise in a satisfactory and workmanlike manner [“the Defects”], in that:a.The floor of the shower area of the washroom has not been constructed with a 1:10 gradient as specified in the Building Specifications;b.The disabled toilet in the washroom has not been constructed in accordance with the Building Code of Australia as specified in the Purchase Order; c.The windows in the washroom have not been constructed as sliding windows as specified in the Building Specification;d.The electrical fuse box in the washroom has burnt out. In paragraph 15, Mr Nalder says that a number of issues have already been addressed but the issues relating to the Defects remain outstanding. He refers then to some 260 pages of print outs of emails and states:Despite these exchanges the Defects remain unaddressed. He next refers to a report IPB obtained from Grant McGrath of Building Code Professionals dated 20 May 2010. A copy of that report is in evidence. Mr Nalder then refers in his affidavit to a second report, also in evidence, from Camile Haddad of Metropolitan Building Approvals dated 15 November 2010 dealing with whether an occupancy certificate may be issued in respect of the washroom. Lastly, Mr Nalder says that IPB denies any further liability to MBS: In particular, IPB contends that, as a result of the Defects, it is not liable for the full amount of the contract sum. IBP contends that the costs associated with rectifying the defects are to be offset against the contract sum. The terms of the contract were in evidence and Mr Spencer accepted, for the purposes of these proceedings, that the documents in evidence constituted the contract. I now set out the relevant parts of the contractual documents.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Although Mr Harding described ground (c) as the secondary thrust of his submissions, logically it arises first and I will consider it first.The Evidence The originating process filed on 1 February 2011 was supported by an affidavit sworn the same day by Robert James Nalder, the managing director of IPB. At the hearing on 11 May 2011 IPB sought leave under O 14 r 6 of the Federal Court Rules to rely on that affidavit notwithstanding some defects in form as to the deponent’s signature and as to the timing of the compliance certificate. Mr Spencer did not oppose that leave and I granted it. There were objections to two sentences of Mr Nalder’s affidavit. One of those sentences was not pressed and the other I rejected as inadmissible. Also tendered and admitted, without objection, was an exhibit (RN1) to Mr Nalder’s affidavit. This exhibit was largely made up of a substantial amount of email correspondence exchanged between IPB and MBS, some of it involving Gujarat NRE, between 23 September and 22 December 2010. I shall return to the detail of Mr Nalder’s evidence below. By leave, Mr Nalder gave some short supplementary oral evidence to identify the handwriting on the copy of the Metropolitan Building Approvals’ report which was part of the exhibit to his affidavit. He said, and I accept, that the handwriting and the handwritten ticks in the right hand columns were his. Mr Nalder was not cross-examined. An affidavit of Sandra Carniato sworn on 29 April 2011 was filed but not read. This was because there was no dispute between the parties at the hearing that the application by IPB had been made within the 21 days after the demand was served, that period being prescribed by s 459G(2). No evidence was called by MBS.The facts The statutory demand states, in effect, that IPB owes MBS the amount of $178,790.26, being the amount of the debt described in the Schedule. The Schedule refers to two tax invoices: No 100478 dated 9 August 2010 in the amount of $577,450.50 and No 100499 dated 31 August 2010 in the amount of $63,300.16. The Schedule also refers to payments received in the sum of $461,960.40 and states a total balance outstanding as $178,790.26. The same tax invoices and amounts are referred to in the affidavit accompanying the statutory demand, sworn by Mr Glenn Smith on 22 December 2010. In that affidavit Mr Smith states that the debt is due because IPB has failed to pay outstanding moneys due under the two tax invoices. Mr Smith states that he believes that there is no genuine dispute about the existence or the amount of the debt. Mr Nalder, in his affidavit, refers to MBS’ demand as a “purported Creditor’s Statutory Demand”. He states that there is a genuine dispute as to the debt claimed in the demand. As I read his affidavit he then goes on to identify the basis for that contention. At paragraph 13 of his affidavit, Mr Nalder states that IPB:contends, and it is the fact, that MBS failed to undertake the Works in accordance with the terms of the Contract and otherwise in a satisfactory and workmanlike manner [“the Defects”], in that:a.The floor of the shower area of the washroom has not been constructed with a 1:10 gradient as specified in the Building Specifications;b.The disabled toilet in the washroom has not been constructed in accordance with the Building Code of Australia as specified in the Purchase Order; c.The windows in the washroom have not been constructed as sliding windows as specified in the Building Specification;d.The electrical fuse box in the washroom has burnt out.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does IPB have a genuine dispute about the existence or the amount of the debt claimed in MBS' statutory demand?
2. Are the defects identified by IPB sufficient to justify setting aside the statutory demand under the Corporations Act?
3. Can IPB offset the costs of rectifying the defects against the debt claimed by MBS?

Held
1. The court concluded that IPB has a genuine dispute about the existence or the amount of the debt claimed in MBS' statutory demand.
2. The court found that the defects identified by IPB are sufficient to justify setting aside the statutory demand under the Corporations Act.
3. The court determined that IPB can offset the costs of rectifying the defects against the debt claimed by MBS.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering whether IPB had a genuine dispute about the existence or the amount of the debt claimed in MBS' statutory demand. The statutory demand referenced two tax invoices and claimed an outstanding balance of $178,790.26. However, IPB's affidavit, sworn by Mr Nalder, contended that MBS failed to undertake the works in a satisfactory manner, leading to several defects. The court accepted that IPB's contention of defects presented a genuine dispute about the existence and amount of the debt.

Next, the court examined whether the defects identified by IPB were sufficient to set aside the statutory demand under the Corporations Act. The court noted that under s 459J of the Corporations Act, a statutory demand can be set aside if the defendant has a genuine dispute about the existence or the amount of the debt. Mr Nalder's affidavit detailed several specific defects in the workmanship, supported by expert reports and extensive email correspondence. The court found that these defects were significant enough to justify setting aside the statutory demand.

Lastly, the court considered whether IPB could offset the costs of rectifying the defects against the debt claimed by MBS. The contractual documents were in evidence and the court acknowledged that the terms of the contract allowed for deductions in the event of defects. Mr Nalder argued, and the court accepted, that the costs associated with rectifying the defects should be deducted from the contract sum. The court concluded that IPB could indeed offset these costs against the debt claimed by MBS.

The ratio decidendi of the case is that where a genuine dispute exists regarding the existence or amount of a debt claimed in a statutory demand due to defects in the performance of contractual obligations, and these defects are substantiated by evidence, the statutory demand can be set aside. Additionally, the court recognized that contractual terms allowing for deductions for defects can be enforced.